1/95
CAMS @ NYU
Cost-benefit model of behavioral intervention
There are benefits and costs to intervening, and there are benefits and costs to not intervening
Benefits of intervening
Some benefits include:
Better social skills and communication
Better relationships
Reduced behavioral problems (e.g. aggression)
Saves money, especially long term
Behavioral problems are expensive: e.g. extra services, unemployment in the long-run
Costs of intervening
Some costs include:
Treatment/intervention requires money, time, and effort
IATROGENIC EFFECT
Stigmatizing, labeling
Takes away instruction or social time
Iatrogenic Effect
Opposite effect, usually negative, to treatment or intervention (cost of intervention)
Example of iatrogenic effect
People who underwent 9/11 crisis-response evidence-based PTSD treatment unexpectedly had WORSE ANXIETY levels compared to those that didn’t get the treatment
Benefit of not intervening
Allows child to problem-solve and find their own coping skills for themselves, making these solutions more likely to stick and help the child
Avoiding classifying something as a problem and treating when it is not a problem and could go away by itself through normal development
Costs of not intervening
Potential for long-term financial costs (e.g. unemployment or ending up in the juvenile system)
Behavior gets worse, or other disorders could develop (e.g. substance abuse)
Social isolation/rejection/etc. because of the continued “bad” behaviors
3 learning theories
Classical conditioning, operant conditioning, social learning
Why do we care about learning theories?
If we want to change behaviors, we must understand how these behaviors are learned
Modeling
Viewing a person doing an action in front of you AND getting reinforced for it, makes you more likely to do it too (just by viewing them)
A form of social learning
Vicarious learning
The process by which people learn by viewing others (e.g. modeling)
Latent learning
You can hold onto vicarious learning for a long time without being reinforced for the action yourself
E.g. mice can immediately navigate the maze when food is present because they latently learned the layout by roaming it for days before
Form of treatment via classical conditioning
Building positive associations
Explain the behavior of being a “Class Clown” through operant conditioning terms
Behavior: Being a class clown
Reinforcement: Other students laughing at your jokes
Punishment: Teacher scolding you
IMPORTANT: Although in this scenario there is both a punishment and a reinforcement, usually the social acceptance (reinforcement) is far more powerful than the common punishments teachers give - so behavior continues
Treating “Class Clown” using operant conditioning
The more effective treatment: Changing the reinforcement (making not doing the behavior more appealing)
Less effective treatment: Intensifying the punishment
Extinction (operant conditioning) in the classroom
When you don’t give “bad” behavior attention (doing NOTHING), it starts decreasing
Not a form of punishment because you are not giving or taking away anything - the student never had the attention to begin with
Examples of classical conditioning in the classroom
Aversion to hw/quizzes/tests
Teacher bias against particular students
When the teacher associates a particular student with continued bad behavior, just the mention/seeing the student might trigger a conditioned response of being aversive towards them
Performance anxiety
Examples of operant conditioning in the classroom
Positive reinforcement systems
Punishment systems
Being class clown (reinforcement from peers) or teacher’s pet (reinforcement from teachers)
Famous experiment that’s an example of social learning
Bandura’s Bobo doll experiment
Positive reinforcement
Giving something to increase behavior
E.g. Getting a sticker when you raise your hand
Negative reinforcement
Taking away something to increase behavior
E.g. Homework pass after being on time (taking away the responsibility of hw)
Positive punishment
Giving something undesirable to decrease behavior
E.g. Criticism or shouting when student interrupts
Negative punishment
Taking away something desirable to decrease behavior
E.g. Detention (because you are taking away free time); or a fine (removing money)
Idiographic Effect
People respond to punishment and reinforcement the same way, but different THINGS reinforce and punish different people
Giving marshmallows is reinforcing for someone that loves them, but punishing for someone that hates them
3 reasons why kids behave in a certain way
To get something (positive reinforcement)
To get out of something (negative reinforcement)
To self-regulate
Trying to reach optimal stimulation
Kids’ behaviors because they are overstimulated
Will attempt to calm down to reach optimal stimulation (ASD-like symptoms)
Kids’ behaviors because they are understimulated
Will attempt to seek more stimulation/hype themselves up (ADHD-like symptoms)
Yerkes-Dodson curve
Optimal performance is based on average stimulation
Reasoning for why kids behave in ways to try to self-regulate
ABC Model (what is it + what does it stand for)
A behavioral analysis model and tool that identifies these elements of behaviors:
A - Antecedents
B - Behavior
C - Consequences
What is an antecedent (A in ABC model)?
An event that precedes a behavior and influences that behavior
Antecedents don’t always have to be the cause, but all causes are antecedents
Types of antecedents (4 classifications)
Distal vs. proximal
Distal: Happened a long time ago
Proximal: Happened closer in time
Artificial vs. natural
Artificial: Imposed by someone with the intent of influencing you
Natural: Environment influenced your behavior someway, without the intention to influence you
What type of antecedent is “teacher instructing students to start activity” to the behavior “working on the activity”?
Proximal, artificial antecedent
What type of antecedent is “genetics” on the behavior “having ADHD”?
Distal, natural antecedent
What is a behavior (B in ABC model)?
Any observable motor or verbal action
Must be observable with regular senses, not e.g. scanning
E.g. Hitting peers
ABC model: What are the 5 dimensions behavior is assessed on?
Duration
Frequency
Intensity
Latency
Valence
Behavior assessment dimension: DURATION
How long does this behavior occur for?; Quantifiable
Behavior assessment dimension: FREQUENCY
How often does this behavior occur?; Quantifiable
Behavior assessment dimension: INTENSITY
How severe is this behavior?
Example: A high intensity tantrum is one with aggression, a low intensity tantrum is one with easily consolable crying
Behavior assessment dimension: LATENCY
The amount of time between the last proximal antecedent and the behavior; Quantifiable
Would we want a long or short latency for a favorable behavior (e.g. compliance)?
Short latency
An example of an antecedent for the behavior compliance is instruction. We want a short amount of time (latency) between instruction and compliance
Would we want a long or short latency for an unfavorable behavior (e.g. going off-task)?
Long latency
An example of an antecedent for the behavior “going off task” is "being instructed to start a task. We want a long latency between these two.
Behavior assessment dimension: VALENCE
How appropriate/acceptable is this behavior; Qualitative
What is a consequence (C in ABC model)?
An event that FOLLOWS a behavior and influences that SAME behavior in the future (increase or decrease of that behavior)
A consequence follows a behavior and is not caused by it because many things (consequences) can be a result of the same behavior
Classifications of consequences (2)
Natural or artificial
Types of consequences (3)
Reinforcement
Punishment
Extinction
Example of a consequence + why it classifies as a consequence (ABC model)
A consequence of robbing a bank (behavior) is going to prison (consequence)
Going to prison is a form of punishment; influences the behavior of robbing banks again in the future
Robbing a bank does not CAUSE causing to prison, it just follows the behavior, because another possible consequence to follow is getting away with it and being rich
Going to prison is an artificial consequence because the law intends to influence your behavior (discourage stealing)
Being rich is a natural consequence because it follows the behavior but is not intended to influence it
IDEA
Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act; a federal law that ensures things like IEP
FAPE
The requirement that every child gets a FREE, APPROPRIATE, PUBLIC, EDUCATION; as stated by IDEA
FAPE provides the requirement of what must be done; the MINimum for what should be done
What does an Appropriate education mean as part of FAPE?
Meets general standards
Child is assessed semi-annually
Goals are tracked
LRE: Least Restrictive Enviroment
Another IDEA policy, requires students to be as close to “normal education” as possible
Ensures students are not too restricted or segregated (the MAXimum of what can be done when it comes to special education)
What does an IEP (Individualized Education Plan) do?
Classify if a child has a disability and plan what sort of education they require to provide child with services/SPCED
IEP Process (3 steps)
1) Identify probable need and request an evaluation
2) Evaluate
3) Classify disability and plan
Examples of IEP evaluations to help determine what support is needed
IQ tests
Academic achievement tests
Speech evaluations
Attention and memory tests
How many disability classification options for an IEP?
13 labels/disabilities
Types of IEP supports/outcomes (3 categories) + examples
Placements
General education
ICT
Self-contained (SPCED only classes)
Services
Pull-out/Push-in
Aide
Speech/OT/PT
Accommodations/Modifications
BIP: Behavioral Intervention Plan
Testing accommodations
What are ICT classrooms and what are some problems with them?
An ICT classroom has 2 teachers (one GE, one SPCED) and a combination of special education and general education students (<50% SE students)
Some problems with ICT classes:
“Stowaways”: Kids without IEPs that are struggling are placed by the school in ICT classes as GenEd when they have higher needs too → SE kids percentage is an underestimation
GE students could feel burdened to help their SE peers
FBA: Functional Behavioral Analysis
An IEP federally mandates a student get an FBA if they have behavioral problems; an analysis for why these behaviors occur
BIP: Behavioral Intervention Plan
A result of an FBA; Specifies target behaviors and informs proper teacher/staff responses to them; Reduces or eliminates punishment to “bad” behavior
504
Under the ADA act (not IDEA); States the accommodations needed for the child to access education - NO SPCED
Pros and Cons of IEP
Pros:
Has goals that are tracked
Can provide expensive services
Federally mandated
Cons:
Hard to get; takes a long time
Label/stigma
Pros and Cons of FBA
Pros:
Mandated (because under an IEP)
Better than hunches because it deeply analyzes the behaviors
Cons:
Few people are trained to do them
There is no standard for how to do them
No standard results results in it being done pro forma (just done, but usually not well)
Pros and cons of 504
Pros:
Easy to get
No special education label
Cons:
No tracked goals
Does not provide expensive services/accommodations/etc.
What are continuous vs. categorical disorders + examples
Continuous disorders: Symptoms happen on a spectrum and you need to decide when on that spectrum to place the cut off for this disorder’s diagnosis
E.g. ADHD
Categorical disorders: You either have the disorder or you don’t; the distribution of people that have the disorder is bimodal (yes and no)
E.g. Diabetes
True or False: “ADHD is normally distributed”; Explain
True; Very few people have no ADHD symptoms, most people have some varying degree of ADHD symptoms like inattention or fidgetiness, and then a small percentage of people are beyond the cut-off placed and are diagnosed with ADHD
ADHD diagnostic criteria (5 things we consider)
Symptoms
Impairment
Setting
Age
Rule-out
Acronym: SISAR
Types of ADHD (3)
Inattentive
Hyperactive/Impulsive
Combined
Age cut-off - ADHD diagnosis criteria
ADHD symptoms must be/have been present at age 12 or earlier
ADHD Hyperactivity symptom examples (4)
Fidgety
Running/moving around a lot
Making noise or talks excessively
“Driven by a motor”
ADHD Impulsivity symptom examples (3)
Acting without thinking
Trouble waiting
Blurting out or interrupting
ADHD Inattention symptom examples (4)
Trouble concentrating
Distractible
Forgetful
Loses things
Setting - ADHD diagnosis criteria
Symptoms and impairment must be present in MORE THAN 1 major setting (e.g. school AND home)
Research-based treatment options for ADHD (3 options, ranked, with 1 being most effective)
1) A combination of stimulant medication and behavior therapy
90% of people with ADHD respond to stimulants + therapy
2) Stimulants
3) Behavior therapy
ADHD research: How does ADHD affect dopamine levels in the brain?
People with ADHD have LOWER dopamine levels in the prefrontal cortex (PFC) where it is responsible for things like impulse control and learning new things
Stimulants work by increasing dopamine in the PFC
ADHD research: What are some brain structure changes in ADHD brains?
Smaller brains
Less volume and structure differences particularly in PFC
ADHD research: How heritable is ADHD?
HIGHLY heritable (80% concordance rate with identical twins), but no single ADHD-gene found
2 types of Disruptive Behavior Disorders
Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD)
Conduct Disorder (CD)
Symptoms of oppositional defiant disorder (5)
Temper/anger
Argumentativeness
Defiance
Blaming interpersonal actions
Revenge, spitefulness
Origins of oppositional defiant disorder (3)
Difficult temperament when younger
Coercive interactions (e.g. with parent)
Ineffective discipline
Treatment of oppositional defiant disorder + when is the best time
MOST EFFECTIVE WHEN TREATMENT IS EARLY (2-8 years-old)
Treatments:
Parent training
School consultation
Medication for mood and aggression (if needed)
Conduct disorder symptoms (4) + intent
Symptoms:
Aggression
Serious violation of rules
Destruction of property
Deceitfulness/theft
Intent: Gain power or for entertainment (lack empathy/remorse)
Origins of conduct disorder (2)
Neurological differences in reward, punishment, and regulation
Don’t respond well to punishment
Need thrill-seeking behavior to feel reward
Trauma and comorbidities (e.g. abuse, neglect)
Treatment of conduct disorder (3)
Parent training
School consultation
Multi-systemic therapy (MST)
How do ODD and CD differ?
Conduct disorder is more severe than Oppositional defiant disorder. If ODD isn’t treated, it could turn into CD.
What is multi-systemic therapy (MST)?
All systems interacting with child (e.g. school, parents, juvenile system) support the child IN THE SAME WAY
It is effective, but not enough to invest in it because very expensive to coordinate
What is a risk of not treating conduct disorder?
Not treating conduct disorder in childhood results in a diagnosis of antisocial personality disorder 18+
Autism spectrum disorder symptoms
Social communication/interaction deficits
Rigidity
Restricted interests
Sensory sensitivity
Repetitive patterns of behavior
ASD origins (2)
Genetics: ASD is highly heritable
Neurologic differences: Local brain activity overwhelms more complex, higher-level connectivity
When does theory of mind develop typically and with ASD?
Typically at 2-3 years-old, much later for kids with ASD
Treatments for ASD
ABA: Applied Behavioral Analysis
Social interventions
Positive behavioral supports