CLAS170 Midterm - In Class Essay Argument

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/10

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

My backbone and evidence for the prompt I chose.

11 Terms

1
New cards

Thesis

Within the Iliad and parts of the Odyssey, Homer used two parallel heroes to emphasize the deconstruction of kleos through Hector, the best of the Trojans, who was mourned for his good character instead of his heroic deeds, and Achilles, the best of the Greeks, who ultimately wished to abandon his well-earned glory for the chance of a normal life. 

2
New cards

Definition of Kleos

The reputation or legacy of a hero once they die, they live through the stories that people speak of them. Typically, it is earned by accomplishing great deeds as a renowned warrior, such as dying in battle (sets you apart from others).

3
New cards

Claim #1

Although they fought on opposite sides in the Trojan War, both Hector and Achilles sought the same kleos of military excellence.

4
New cards

Evidence for Claim #1 - Achilles

“‘... And we’ll want a good man/ For captain…./ …maybe you, son of Peleus, our most formidable hero/ To offer sacrifice and appease the Arch-Destroyer for us.’” (Illiad, 1.154-157)

“‘When every last Greek desperately misses Achilles,/ When Hector the man-killer swats you down like flies./ And you will eat your heart out/ Because you failed to honor/ the best Greek of all.’” (Iliad, 1.254-259)

“‘You may be a good man in a fight, Achilles/ And look like a god…’” (Illiad, 1.140-141)

“...Achilles, strong, swift, and godlike” (Illiad, 1.129)

“Rage:/ Sing, Goddess, Achilles’ rage,/ Black and murderous, that cost the Greeks/ Incalculable pain…/Begin with the clash between Agamemnon…/ and godlike Achilles.” (Illiad, 1.1-8)

5
New cards

Evidence for Claim #1 - Hector

“‘When every last Greek desperately misses Achilles,/ When Hector the man-killer swats you down like flies./ And you will eat your heart out/ Because you failed to honor/ the best Greek of all.’” (Iliad, 1.254-259)

“‘Yes, Andromache, I worry about all this myself/ But my shame before the Trojans and their wives,/ with their long robes trailing, would be too terrible, if I/ hung back from battle like a coward.’” (Illiad, 6.463-466)

“‘Deep in my heart I know too well/ There will come a day when Ilion will perish…/ All that pain is nothing to what I will feel/ For you, when some bronze-armored Greek/ Leads you away in tears, on your first day of slavery…./ And someone, seeing your crying, will say, ‘That is the wife of Hector, the best of all The Trojans when they fought around Ilion.’’” (Iliad, 6.470-485)

“‘Zeus and all gods: grant that my son/ Become, as I am, foremost among the Trojans/ Brave and strong, and ruling Ilion with might./ And may men say he is far better than his father/ When he returns from war, bearing bloody spoils,/ Having killed his man. And may his mother rejoice.’” (Iliad, 6.501-506)

6
New cards

Claim #2

Even though Hector died in battle, which was considered to be a great feat worthy of kleos, he was remembered for his kindness and the tragic fate of his wife, his infant son, and his country.

7
New cards

Evidence for Claim #2 - Andromache and infant son Astynax

“‘You have died young, Hector, and left me/ A widow in the halls. Our son is still an infant,/ Doomed when we bore him. I do not think/ He will ever reach manhood. No, this city/ Will topple and fall first…/ And children you guarded will go off soon/ In the hollow ships, and I will go with them./ And you, my son, you will either come with me/ And do menial labor for a cruel master,/ Or some Greek will lead you by the hand/ and throw you from the tower, a hideous death,/ Angry because Hector killed his brother,/ or his father, or his son.’” (Iliad, 24.777-790)

8
New cards

Evidence for Claim #2 - Helen

“‘Oh, Hector, you were the dearest to me by far/ Of all my husband’s brothers…/ This is now the twentieth year/ Since I went away and left my home,/ And I have never heard an unkind word from you./ If anyone in the house ever taunted me,/ Any of my husband’s brothers or sisters,/ Or his mother--my father-in-law was always kind--/ You would draw them aside and calm them/ With your gentle heart and gentle words./ And so I weep for you and for myself/ And my heart is heavy, because there is no one left/ In all wide Troy who will pity me/ or be my friend…’” (Iliad 24.815-826)

9
New cards

Claim #3

Achilles eventually achieved great kleos through his heroic deeds and untimely death in the Trojan War, but instead of rejoicing in it, he scorned his well-deserved fame and yearned for normalcy.

10
New cards

Evidence for Claim #3 - King Peleus, father of Achilles

“‘And what about Peleus? What have you heard?/ Is he still respected among the Myrmidons/ Or do they dishonor him in Phthia and Hellas,/ Crippled by old age in hand and foot?/ And I’m not there for him up in the sunlight/ With the strength I had in wide Troy once/ When I killed Ilion’s best and saved the army.” (Odyssey, 11.517-523)

“‘Now take Peleus…/ …He was the happiest/ And richest man on earth…/ But even to Peleus, the gods gave some evil:/ He would not leave offspring to succeed him in power,/ Just one child, all out of season. I can’t be with him/ To take care of him now that he’s old, since I’m far/ From my fatherland, squatting here in Troy,/ Tormenting you and your children.’” (Illiad, 24.575-585)


11
New cards

Evidence for Claim #3 - Valued his short-lived life after his untimely death

“‘Achilles, by far mightiest of the Achaeans,.../… But no man, Achilles,/ Has ever been as blessed as you, or ever will be./ While you were alive the army honored you/ Like a god, and now that you are here/ You rule the dead with might. You should not/ Lament your death at all, Achilles.’” (Odyssey, 11.498-508)

“‘Don’t try to sell me on death, Odysseus./ I’d rather be a hired hand back up on earth,/ Slaving away for some poor dirt farmer,/ Than lord it over all these withered dead…’” (Odyssey, 11.510-513)

  • could also use the other quote, he is the “one child, all out of season” that Peleus had