1/4
Looks like no tags are added yet.
S- research support
jin et al carried out SS in Korea a typically collectivist culture
They found results consistent with VI one and K with secure being the most common IR second and IA least common
therefore, this is a strength as it is consistent with their findings increasing reliability
however VI and K were criticise as only 5/32 studies were from collective cultures = research lacks population validity
L- uses bias method of assessment
SS classification system is based on American ideals and expectations on what a “healthy“ attachment should look like without considering cultural differences
E.g. lack of separation anxiety is seen as IA but in Germany seen as desirable as it represents independence and would be considered best or most healthy attachment
Limitation as based on culturally bias procedures decreasing validity
V+K acknowledge limitations of their study and suggested more data was needed from collective cultures to make valid conclusions
L - comparing countries are not cultures
Compared GB with Israel in Meta analysis within each country, there may be different subcultures each with unique ways of rearing children
Researchers noted a variance within countries was greater between countries
Therefore, stands to reason, they did collect data on subcultures with the countries they investigated rather than the whole nation
However bowlby claims global trends in attachment are due to innate drives rather than cultural experiences providing an alternate explanation for why secure attachments are the most common