1/46
Looks like no tags are added yet.
When is counselling required?
Counselling is an embedded component of genetic testing in many countries
Pre-test counselling
Giving results
Post-test counselling
What does counselling allow for?
Helps patients and families, interpret and adjust to the results and make best health and personal decisions
When are genetic tests done?
Genetic tests will only be performed when full consent has been given after a full discussion with a professional
What is the aim of counselling?
To enable informed consent, helping patient and family
Make choice about whether to be tested
Prepare for the test result
Adapt to the test result
Have had the opportunity to consider the options which may include not being tested and can prepare for the results and consequences
What are the precautions with BRCA1 testing?
Understand that genomic testing is different from other investigations related to cancer diagnosis and treatment
Optional and many not change prognosis
Might raise additional cancer related risks for her
Could confirm that her relatives have an increased risk of cancer
What are the BRCA1 features of the test timing?
Emotionally whilst she is going through chemotherapy and genetic
Would the identification of the mutation change the treatment options
What are the alternatives of BRCA1 genetic test?
Alternative of having blood stored and tested at a later date
Or if she dies with her family request
What does counselling tell you about negative results?
Understand what a negative result gene test would mean including the residual risk of inherited cancer
What are the different geneticm tests?
Single gene test
Multiple gene genomic test
Chromosomal tests
Other lab tests – biochemical/haematological
Test can confirm a genetic diagnosis but not testing the genome
Imaging – ultrasound / X-rays
Clinical examination - could confirm a diagnosis and still has genetic implications
How is explicit genetic testing different?
Even if a clinical diagnosis of a genetic condition has been made then confirming the results
Has an additional psychological impact on the family
Feel more definitive and highlights the genetic implications more starkly
How do the protocols differ for tests?
Diagnostic, predictive, carrier, prenatal, therapeutic
Primary aim is informed consent and mange the impact of the test result
The approach and contents varies considerably depending on the purpose of the test
Who has diagnostic testing?
Already exhibiting symptoms which may be compatible with a known genetic conditions or group
May or may not have a family history
What are the features of diagnostic considerations?
If a pathogenic variant is identified this confirms the diagnosis
Help guide clinical management
May have additional family implications such as BRCA1 which should be raised with the patient before the test
Most similar counselling to non-genetic diagnosis
Who has predictive testing?
Known family history and predicts the likelihood of developing symptoms in the future
Done on healthy or unaffected individual who is aware of a familial condition
Doesn't confirm a diagnosis but predicts a high likelihood that it will develop
What are the considerations for predictive testing?
May be no preventative or risk-reducing measures before the onset
Pre-test counselling is high importance and can be more than one appointment
Usually refers to highly/moderately penetrant gene mutations
Lower risk associations with common diseases are susceptibility testing
Increasingly unexpected findings with genomic testing
Greater pre-test counselling
Who has carrier testing?
Usually asymptomatic, potential risk to children
Heterozygous recessive or X-linked carriers
Known family history of condition or population screening
What are the precautions of carrier testing?
Increasing awareness of disease symptoms in heterozygous carriers
Have mild symptoms due to X-linked inactivation patterns
Counselling needs to address this in a balanced way
Counselling before carrier testing focuses on reproductive implications and options and for family planning
Could detect carrier status and incidental findings
Who has prenatal testing?
Screening tests offered in all pregnancies
Diagnostic, usually in presence of family history or known abnormality
NIPT may change this
What are the considerations with prenatal testing?
What choices the parents make in a positive diagnosis
If the testing is appropriate
Previous family history can use own experience where others might be less prepared
Using the stages to identify those at high risk in population screenings provides more time to consider options
NIPT needs to remain as an opt-in
Can be performed in preimplantation genetic diagnosis
Choices around genetic selection of embryos such as sex
What are the features of therapeutic testing?
Pharmacogenetic testing
Predict adverse drug reactions due to genetic variants
Guide treatment efficiency
Less likely to be genetic family implications
Counselling is more similar for usual medical investigations
What are there guidelines for?
Predictive testing
Testing children
Prenatal testing
How does harm impact the guidelines?
Include the potential harm if appropriate counselling isn't offered
Practice recommendations can help when explaining the rationale for the counselling
Allow flexibility so they don't see the barriers
How do children impact the guidelines
Predictive testing in children where there is no clear benefit from early testing
Can't test until the age of 18
Can discuss the testing and can have a clear plan for the future
What are the features of the database?
The approaches to consent and return of results doesn't have a consensus agreed
The debate can highlight key areas that require recommendations
What challenges did the database provide?
Challenge of taking consent for a test that can reveal multiple variants for future health
Counselling to prepare patients for the limitations and types of results that will be reported back
What are the features of predictive test counselling?
Usually more than one session
Established protocols – vary by condition
What are the Huntington’s guidelines?
Have sufficient time and support to decide to be tested and adapt to the result
Due to limited management options the majority decline testing
Pre-test counselling is provided to ensure the individual has time for the decision
The result also has to be given in person and continue with planned follow up support
How do other predictive tests work?
Differences for other conditions due to higher uptake and options for risk-reducing and treatment options
Cancer and long QT syndrome
What are the features of not testing children?
Rarely test for adult onset disorders where no medical benefit
Unless benefit for early access to screening, treatment or lifestyle changes
Doesn't include children not being included in the discussion – especially if a family member has it
What are the features of testing in children?
Presumption against carrier testing before mid-teens
Practical and ethical to support the child to make their own decision
Information given to parents could become outdated
What are the features of prenatal testing?
Personal views on termination of pregnancy
Both views have to be respected
Value of individuals with disability
Testing can't devalue the lives of individuals with disabilities
Tests should be presented as an option rather than a recommendation
Positive test may want a discussion of clinicals who have experience with the condition
What is meaningful consent?
Pre-test counselling
Documentation in case record
Completion of consent forms
Clinician responsibility indicated on laboratory request form
What are the features of the continuum of uptake
Choices influenced by the availability of treatment, alternatives to testing, salience, personal views
25% for Huntington's
Nearly 100% for serious life limiting conditions with treatment
Facilitate choice particularly for tests without clear health promotion benefits
What is the aim of consent?
Aim of informed consent is to make the choice about whether to be tested
What is the doctors/GC role in consent?
Should the patient make the decision alone, offering the test could be seen as promoting eugenic aims
When should it not be non-directive?
When there is the health promotion non-directive might not be appropriate
Shared-decision where the clinician is more involved
What needs to be considered in consent?
What extent does culture around individual choice impact
Carrier and predictive testing the individuals have to decide to be tested
What are the considerations for vulnerable adults?
Consent for vulnerable adults
Assessing capacity
Safeguarding
What are the features of capacity?
Other individuals may have lasting power of attorney for health and welfare decisions
Guidance still encourages efforts to involve the patient in discussions even if the decision is made by someone else
What are the features of safeguarding?
Could be someone pressuring them into something that they don't agree with, seek out the safeguarding team
What happens in pre-test counselling?
Information about the condition
Scope and limitations of testing
Reasons for testing
Alternative to testing
Potential impact
Planned result giving
What are the features of information about the condition?
Prior knowledge based on familial experience or skewed perspective
For panels it is easier to provide information
Microarrays or whole genome it isn't possible to list all the disorders, and anyone has a low chance of identification
More appropriate to give information in the context of the scope and limitations of testing
What are the features of scope and limitation?
Understand broadly that the test may provide information which confirms a genetic diagnosis or status
Understand the potential for uncertain results arising
Genomic testing may not reveal the underlying cause
What are the features of reason for testing?
Could be the opportunity for improved medical management
Patients motivations can be varied from removing uncertainty, clarify genetic risks to other family members, inform reproductive decisions and other life options including employment and relationships
What are the features of alternatives to testing?
To prevent obligation alternatives need to be discussed
Delay testing
Access health screening without testing
Continue pregnancy without prenatal tests
What are the features of potential impact?
Psychological
Relationships
How the result will impact the wider family
Even good news can be a challenge to adjust to
Practical: insurance, employment and activities
What are the features of planned results giving?
Agreed arrangements beforehand
How and when the results will be communicated
Could be based on the situation, location, choice and capacity
Some keep the date secret so time to absorb without others
Rehearse / planning of results