1/66
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Resource Allocation Problem
The ethical and practical challenge of determining how to distribute scarce medical goods and services fairly across two primary levels: 1. Macro-allocation: Societal and governmental decisions regarding how total resources are divided between healthcare and other social needs, and how funds are divided among medical sectors. 2. Micro-allocation: Individual or clinical decisions determining which specific patients receive scarce treatments, such as donor organs, ICU beds, or exotic therapies.
positive rights
impose an active, corresponding moral or legal duty on others—such as individuals, institutions, or the state—to provide or facilitate the resources necessary to realize that claim (e.g., a right to healthcare, education, or basic sustenance).
negative rights
entitlement that others not perform certain actions or not be in certain states
rights/duties
if you have a right to do something, then you have a claim to it
SO: there exists some obligation/duty to provide you with it, or against preventing you from having or doing that thing
(ex. your right to life means others have an obligation not to unjustly kill you)
sources of rights
-Govt. / institutions
-God
-Just being human
funding of healthcare come from...
-from you privately (income)
-from you publicly (tax revenue)
Why is healthcare expensive
bc it is a scarce resource
Robert Nozick
Justice as protecting entitlements
(also called the libertarian view, held by john locke)
Main idea of Robert Nozick
no person or govt. has any right to a resource properly owned by any other. Thus, using taxes to pay for another's healthcare is the same as using that person i.e., taking their labor value and giving it away
(NO SHARING!)
implication of Robert Nozick's Idea
you may be selfish or cruel not to work to ensure the common good, but you are not acting unjustly by doing so. Healthcare is a privledge, not a right. No rights exists to use somebody else's resources to pay for another's healthcare
John Rawls
justice as fairness/equality
John Rawls Main idea
justice requires a fair distribution of resources, such that some members of a society do not disproportionately benefit without a net of benefit for all members
(SHARING!)
John Rawls Justification of idea
thought experiment: "original position" behind the "veil of ignorance"
John Rawls Thought Experiment
-you do not know anything about who you are or what you will do
-the rules you make will decide what is moral of immoral
-under these circumstances, people will ensure that all have equal access to the societal good
-A JUST SOCIETY WOULD LIKELY CONSIDER HEALTHCARE AS A HUMAN RIGHT
"The Allocation of Exotic Medical Lifesaving Therapy"
- by: Nicholas rescher
- criteria for allocation:
1. criteria of inclusion/exclusion: decides who the candidates for ELT are
2. criteria of selection: decides who actually gets the ELT
Rescher's Criteria
1. process must be simple, such that all parties understand
2. process must be plausible, and patently reasonable to all. For instance, you can't just get an ELT just bc your name is "Renaldo"
3. process must be rationally defensible, i.e it must be FAIR
Rescher's Process
1. constituency factor
2. progress of science factor
3. prospect of success factor
constituency factor
hospital can exlude a patient who is not a "client" in some relevant sense of that word
ex. even though i do like toys, I am not a child. So, even if I dress in som star wars pajamas, I still can't get treated at St. Jude's Children's Hospital
Progress of science factor
a hospital that specializes in an specific kind of ailment, i.e. type 2 diabetes can justly exclude patients who only have the first type
prospect of success factor
hospital can exclude those which won't be helped as much as others
Relative likelihood of success factor
as before, but now on an individual (not population or group basis
life expectancy factor
does the patient have a long life ahead
family role factor
is the person a mother or father or a loner
potential future contributions factor
will the patient be valuable to society
past services rendered factor
has the patient been valuable to society
"Should Alcoholics Compete Equally for Liver Transplantation?"
- by: Alvin H. Moss
ARESLD
alcohol- related end- stage liver disease (cause= alcohol use/abuse)
ESLD
end stage liver disease (cause = various, NOT ALCOHOL)
HCFA reccomendation
medicare should cover transplant surgery for those with alcoholic cirrhosis who are abstinent
Moss/ Siegler's proposal
patients with ARESLD SHOULD NOT compete equally
according to Moss/Siegler, is alcoholism a disease
yes
According to moss and siegler, should people with ARESLD be held responsible
yes
Why do we treat ARESLD patients differently than all the other patients whose behaviors put them at risk
bc resources are scarce
one reason to doubt moss and siegler
-alcoholism is the result of a free choice
-BUT: the disease results in a chemical dependency, a BIOLOGICAL need
-So: after that point, is the decision to drink a FREE CHOICE?
John Harris -> "The Value of life"
- tries to solve how to choose what patients gets the transplant (1. Anti ageist argument 2. Fair innings) ex. cancer kills 120,000, you can create a drug that would give everyone 6 more months, or one that would give 1,000 people 10 more years
ageism
prejudice based on age
anti-ageism argument assumption
-life has an absolute value to all those who value it
-20 yrs of life = 3 yrs of life = 4 weeks of life, etc. from the perspective of the patient
ageism premises
1. life is absolutely precious precious to all of those who wish to go on living
2. life is just as precious (if not more so) to those with less time to live, i.e. the terminally ill or elderly
conclusion: it would be a great injustice to deny someone in this condition the rest of their life
fair innings assumption
there is an amount of time which constitutes a reasonable life span or what is called a "fair innings" (harris says it is 70 yrs)
fair inning premises
1. before you reach a fair innings, you are entitled to reach it
2. once you reach a fair innings, you are living bonus time
Conclusion: after you reach a fair innings, you can fairly be denied treatment of resources in favor of younger patients
"a defense of abortion"
- by: Judis Jarvis Thomson
thomson's thought experiment
-attached to famous violinist
-Thomson argues that you have a right to defend yourself against the violinist, even if it kills him (you can unplug him)
extreme view
no exceptions for abortion, even in cases of rape of incest
(thomson calls this insane)
The Right to life thought experiment
-Henry Fonda could touch our heads to save your life, but does that mean he should/has to?
-Thomson says we do not have a right to force someone to save our life, even if they could
(we don't have a right to the bare minimum it takes to keep us alive)
Do fetuses have a right to their mother's bodies if the mother was raped
according to thomson, no bc the mother has not given the fetus a right to use her body
do fetuses have a right to their mother's bodies if the mother voluntarily engaged in sex
according to thomson, if precautions have been taken to keep them out of their mother's bodies then they do not have this right
Abortions which are NOT unjust killings (thomson)
-rape victim
-if mother will lose their life
-precautions were taken to prevent pregnancy
types of samaritans
-good samaritan: person does MORE than what is morally required
-minimally decent samaritan: person does what is morally decent to do, but NOT MORE
Thomson's conclusions about samaritans
1. we all ought to be at least minimally decent samaritans
2. law which would outlaw abortion would force women into doing much more than what is morally required of them (it would force them to be good samaritans)
Morally indecent abortions
1. Abortions of convenience
2. Late-term abortions
Michael Tooley -> "abortions and infanticide"
-Person vs human being (there's a difference!); he thinks that persons have a right to life, but being biologically human does not give you the right to life
What properties must something have in order to be a person according to tooley i.e. to have a serious right to life
self consciousness
What gives a person the right to life according to Tooley
the sense of self and personhood, not physical attributes (fetuses are not persons!)
What does Tooley say about killings babies or kittens
you can kill them, not that you should, but you cannot torture them (bc they can feel pain and therefore have an interest in not feeling pain)
Potential persons thought experiment
-a serum is created that can turn a cat into a person
-you do not have an obligation to turn cats into person
-scientist thinks he made a mistake so he makes a reversal serum
-is it wrong to reverse the process before they become a person
-You do not have an obligation to the fetus to turn into a person, and do not have to allow the fetus the become a person i.e. termination is allowed
John Finnis -> "abortion and healthcare ethics"
- if the unborn are human persons, the principles of justice and non-maleficence prohibit every abortion a.k.a every procedure that has the intention of killing the fetus
What constitutes a person according to Finnis
when a sperm penetrates an ovum, the resulting one cell organism which will become a human person, ALREADY IS ONE
When is the cutoff according to Finnis
There is no cutoff, its always a person
Doctrine of double effect
it is sometimes permissible to cause serious harm as a side effect of bringing about a good result, even though it would not be permissible to cause such a harm as a means to bringing about the same good end (ex. hysterectomy vs. abortion)
Finnis' two main ethical principles
healthcare providers should make all decisions based on:
1. non-maleficence; do no harm
2. justice; treats like cases alike
Is abortion ok in the case of rape according to Finnis
a rape victim may take medical precautions to prevent conception
BUT: once conception occurs, an abortion is not permissible (this is the extreme view thomson is attacking)
is abortion ok in the case of mother fetal conflict according to finnis
finnis evokes double effect, it is permissible that a fetus may die as an effect of saving a mother's life, where such life saving is the sole intention, not the direct killing of the fetus
"Why abortion is immoral" -> Don Marquis
- sets out an argument that shows abortion is, except in rare occasions, seriously immoral (rare occasions = medical conditions where fetus will be in pain or die soon, so their future will not be like ours)
Marquis argues that the focus should be on
what makes the killing of a person always wrong, not if the fetus is a person or not
what makes killing people wrong according to marquis
the loss of life harms the victim (deprives victim of a future)
Marquis basic argument
1. Depriving someone of a future like ours is morally impermissible
2. Abortion deprives someone of a future like ours
SO: ABORTION IS MORALLY IMPERMISSIBLE
what does marquis say about contraception
permitted; no subject has lost its future