1/113
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Democracy
political power exercised either directly or indirectly by the people.
Republicanism
indirect democracy that emphasizes separation of powers and representation through elected officials.
comes from Rome
Separation of powers
clear division of power among different branches of government
Direct Democracy
public participates in policy-making and governance
Indirect Democracy
public participates directly through its elected representatives.
Liberal democracy
promote participation, competition, and liberty and emphasizes individual freedom and civil rights.
considered a true democracy
Illiberal regimes
appear legitimate, but…
hold elections, but lack key elements or are rigged
Hybrid, electoral authoritarianism, semi-democratic regimes
Russia, Iran
Democratization
process by which a state transitions to a more democratic regime
Non-democratization
process of a state transitioning to a more non-democratic regime
Modernization Theory
As societies modernize economically…
they become better educated
old traditions of authority and hierarchy weaken
new values emerge (individualism, tolerance, gender equity)
middle class emerges and demands political inclusion
Why did the modernization theory fall out of favor?
There are modernized economies that are not democratic (China, Gulf states)
Old traditions can stay
What is the contribution of the modernization theory?
Health and economic growth are related to long-term democratic survival.
Elites and Democratization Theory
Concentration of wealth and power reduce the likelihood of democratic transitions
elites are more resistant to democracy if they fear losing wealth
a stronger middle class can predict a democratic transition
Elites could choose to support democracy if…
the transition allows them to keep their wealth (Chile and SA)
supporting democracy wins them international support (Taiwan)
Society and Democratization Theory
Public will be better able to push for democracy if civil society is strong
Civil Society
organizations outside of the state that help help people define and advance their own interests
When has civil society changed regimes?
1970s-90s: mass protests by civil society groups led to end of communism in Eastern Europe.
International Relations and Democratization Theory
International actors can play a direct/indirect role in promoting democracy.
state and nonstate actors can be democratic promoters
Allied Powers post-WWII, EU post-USSR, US in Iran and Afghanistan
Culture and Democratization Theory
Supporters say:
Western-style values are required for democracy
Individualism and secularism
Evidence: democracy first emerged in the West
Detractors say:
Democracy can emerge anywhere, but local culture will shape which values are prioritized
Evidence: every region/culture has democracy
Executive
branch that carries out the laws and policies of a state; policy-implementation
Executive roles can be combined or divided
Head of State: symbolizes and represents the people nationally and internationally
Head of Government: deals with everyday tasks of running the state; formulating and/or executing domestic policy
Legislature
makes laws
Types of legislatures
Bicameral: two houses
larger, more diverse
often related to federalism
Unicameral: one house
smaller, more homogenous states
more common in unitary state
Direct election
U.S., France, Germany, UK (house of commons)
Indirect election
France, Germany, U.S. pre-1917
Heredity/appointment
UK, other monarchies
Judiciary
maintains and upholds laws
Rule of Law
idea that everyone is equally subject to the law
necessary component of a liberal democracy
is why corruption is bad for democracy
Constitution/courts are at the core and dedicated to upholding the law
Constitutional Courts
highest judicial body in political system that decides whether laws violate the constitution
Judicial Review
mechanism by which courts can review the action of governments and overturn those that violate the constitution
power held by all constitutional courts
Types of Judicial Review
Concrete review and abstract review
Concrete Review
Courts can consider the constitutionality only when a specific court case triggers this.
U.S. Supreme Court
Pros: more info, balanced power
Cons: slow-moving, not always effective
Abstract Review
court may rule on legislation without a specific case; leaders can challenge even before a law is passed
Differences in Court Designs
Some constitutional courts are also the highest appellate court (Supreme Court), but not everywhere
Timing and tenure of judges varies
SC is on of few that has lifetime tenure
Germany has 12-year tenure with retirement at 68
Different legal traditions fuel other differences in judicial culture and court designs (ex. juries)
Parliamentary System
political system where the head of government is picked from, and subject to, the legislature
Prime Minister
Head of state may be elected or not
Most common type of system (UK, Canada, Germany, SK, Japan)
Logistics of parliamentary system
Head of government and legislature are the same branch
PM and cabinet are elected by legislature and part of it
PM requires the support of the legislature
can be easily removed
Vote of no confidence
Judiciaries can frequently be weaker in parliamentary systems
Vote of No Confidence
vote by legislature as to whether they still support the PM
Presidential System
political system in which the roles of head of state and government are combined
legislature has separate leadership structure
second most common type (US, Nigeria, Brazil)
Logistics of presidential system
Executive and legislature are separate branches
both directly elected
President is difficult to remove (has a mandate)
Separate authorities
legislature writes laws (shapes policy)
President implements or vetoes laws
Judiciaries are often stronger; act as moderators between other branches
Mandate
presidents campaign on certain policies and get elected to fulfill these policies (is why they are harder to remove)
Semi-Presidential System
both a directly elected president and a PM
very chaotic and common in non-democratic countries
In part due to separation of powers and lack of accountability via legislative action
Ex. France and Taiwan, Non-dem: Russia
Pros and Cons of Presidential System
Pros: direct election allows them to have a mandate
Cons: polarization and deadlock, hard to remove leaders, could be pathway to authoritarianism
Pros and Cons of Parliamentary System
Pros: more efficient, faster policy-making, all under one roof, near-automatic legislative majority
Cons: weak legislative oversight, weaker accountability
Pros and Cons of Semi-Presidential System
Pros: maybe best of both worlds (optimistically)
Cons: bad track record, less effective overall
Political Parties
Promotes…
political participation
easier following of government behavior (leads to accountability)
more efficient government and policy-making
Party systems are shaped by electoral systems
Electoral System
set of values that decide how votes are cast, counted, and translated into seats.
Constituency
everyone in a geographical area an official represents
countries differ in how many reps are elected from each district
District
the geographical bounds that we elect people to represent
Single-Member District (SMD)
electoral system with one seat per district
UK, US, former British colonies
Proportional Representation (PR)
political parties compete in multimember districts
voters choose between parties
seats in district are awarded proportionally according to the result of the vote
most common
SMD: First Past the Post (FTPT)
electoral system where individual candidates compete in SMD
plurality-based SMD
most votes wins
US, UK, Canada
Voters are less likely to vote for smaller parties
Tends to produce a two-party system
More candidate-centric
SMD: Majority-Based
where individual candidates compete in SMD but winner must win a majority
more representative than FTPT
often necessitates run-off elections
most common SMD system
ex. France
SMD: Ranked-Choice Voting
voters rank order candidates
with no majority, lowest-ranking candidate is eliminated; votes are distributed
keep going until a candidate receives majority
Multimember District System (MMDs)
electoral system with more than one seat elected from each district
distributions vary by country
vote for parties with slates of candidates
Usually require that parties need to pass an electoral threshold to win any seats
typically small; 3-5%
PR system outcomes
More party-centric; parties choose who fills their seats in parliament
PR voters more willing to vote for smaller parties, leads to more parties
Party discipline and ideology is more distinct.
Pros and Cons of Proportional Representation
Pros: more and smaller parties (representation, discipline and unity on ideology), women and minorities are better represented.
Cons: risk of fragmentation
Pros and Cons of Majority/Plurality Systems
Pros: fewer and larger parties (clear mandates, better accountability)
Cons: less representative, disproportional results
Risk of Election Rigging
Most common in FTPT systems; gerrymandering
Gerrymandering
drawing distinct boundaries to favor one party at the expense of other parties
common in US house elections
Mixed Electoral System
uses a combination of SMD and PR
Parallel voting (ex. Japan’s candidates come from different systems)
mixed member proportional
Forms of Direct Democracy
Referendum and Initiative
Referendum
national vote called by the government to address a specific proposal, often a change to constitution
Initiative
vote called by members of the public to address a specific proposal
Benefits of Direct democracy forms
Purest form of representation
Alternative as voters become disillusioned with institutions
Risks of Direct democracy forms
Too much power to an uninformed public (could lead to harmful policy)
Voter manipulation: could be used to advance a personal agenda for leaders
Variety of Rights and Liberties
Vary widely in their application across democracies
Why?
specificity of constitutional protections?
Actions by courts to defend parties and liberties
Cultural differences in ideas about the role of the state
What is undermining democracy?
Social Capital?
norms, traits, social networks, connection, isolation or socialization
Fatigue, social media division, confirmation bias, efficacy, economic factors, declining trust, destabilizing variables
Nondemocratic/authoritative regime
small group of people exercising power over the state without being responsible to the public
can still be wealthy, popular, advanced, and legitimate
Legitimacy
perception of authority being the rightful wielder of power in a setting
Charismatic legitimacy
the leader is appealing; typically doesn’t outlast that one leader
Rational-Legal Legitimacy
assigned by association with institutions granted legitimacy
Traditional Legitimacy
assigned by association with history and tradition
Totalitarianism
Extreme authoritarianism
deeply ideological
extremely transformative (often violently)
very high degree of control
Today’s DPRK, Stalinist Russia
NOT the same as authoritarianism
Elites and Nondemocracy Theory
The more concentrated power is, the more likely nondemocracy is
Resistant to sharing power
losing assets
losing freedom because of past actions
State is viewed as a tool to gain and maintain wealth
Resource Curse (Elites and Nondemocracy Theory)
theory in which the existence of natural resources in a given state is a barrier to modernization and democratization
state generates resources/wealth without taxation → less incentive to make economy better
Unequal development stunts society
Resources are not portable, so control of resources requires control of the state
Modernization Theory of Nondemocracy
Lack of it can reinforce non-democracy
less developed society = less democratic
urban, educated middle class demands democracy
increased inequality fuels polarization and anti-democratic politics
Modernization itself can be disruptive and lead to non-dem
urbanization transforms institutions and norms
tech can leave some behind
economy and job markets shift
social and gender values change
Non-democratic leaders then promise stability and order
Society Theory of Nondemocracy
Weak civil society → strengthen non-democracy
regime might act to absorb, monitor, or destroy individual organizations
Rarely, strong civil society could promote non-dem if they emphasize ethnic favoritism, xenophobia, racism, etc.
Hungary under Orban
Populism
Populism
view that is against elites at the top and that power should be given to the people
International Relations Theory of Nondemocracy
International acts influence regime type through…
foreign occupation
imperial legacy
backing non-dem forces
Ex. US in Venezuela
Culture Theory of Nondemocracy
One area of thought:
Democracy is a Western/Christian construct
Individualism/secularism don’t translate
Counterargument
every region has democracy
Culture shapes the form of democracy, not its presence or absence
Coercion
compelling individuals by threatening their lives or livelihoods
relies on use of fear to discourage opposition
killing, torturing, job loss, lawsuits, threats
Targeted or indiscriminate (targeted is more effective)
Often relies on surveillance
internal security/secret police
informants in general public
Tech allow states to increase surveillance
monitor and control email, SM, texts
video systems and biometric tech
Limits of Coercion
Can undermine legitimacy
May create widespread grievances
Costly to maintain
Some people have to benefit from the regime, or there would be no soldiers to carry out orders
Co-Optation
Process by which people outside an org are brought into a beneficial relationship with state.
provide benefits to key groups to gain support
make population dependent on state for certain rewards
two strategies
Strategy 1: Corporatism
replacing individual civil society orgs with state-funded and controlled variants
gives population the opportunity to organize while being under control
Ex. China’s “catholic” church, Cuba’s state-run labor union
Strategy 2: Clientelism
state co-opts the public by providing specific benefits in exchange for support
Rent-seeking
can decline into a kleptocracy
it is a matter of degree; how much of it is happening?
Rent-Seeking
political leaders essentially rent out parts of the state to supporters, who then control public goods
big jobs, industries
Kleptocracy
“rule by thief;” those in power seek to drain the state of assets and resources
Personality Cults
presents the leader as venerated; almost a religious operation
embody the spirit of the nation
wisdom and strength beyond the average person
Media, art, propaganda to reinforce this image
Stalin, Ayatollah, Putin, Xi Jinping, Kims
Which type of coercion is the most stable/reliable for the long-term?
Co-Optation
Personal and Monarchical Rule
Based off one leader; ancient; state and society are seen as possessions of the leader
Main control tools:
charismatic/tradition legitimacy
Patrimonialism
Saudis, DPRK, Bahrain, etc.
Patrimonialism
very similar to clientelism, where a formalized system of benefits for certain individuals props up the non-democracy
Military Rule
Rule by one or more military officials
often because of a coup
Follows period of unrest
leaders promise stability
Main tools of control
Coercion
Rational authority
Bureaucratic authoritarianism
Burueacratic Authoritarianism
bureaucracy and military believe that a technocratic leadership can solve the problems without relying on political participation
rational, objective, and technical expertise
One-Party Rule
Single party monopolizes everything
anyone else banned
no area is untouched
Main tools of control
Co-optation (corporatism and clientelism
China, Cuba
Theocracy
Rule by God
religion is the foundation of the regime
Religion-state ties are growing in non-dem and dem countries
Israel, India, Myanmar
Main tools of control
Traditional legitimacy
Corporatism
Illiberal Regimes (as a type of non-dem)
Institutions associated with democracy are in place, but weak or subverted.
Common features:
weak rule of law
execs have an overwhelming degree of power
election manipulation
few civil rights or individual freedoms
very common
Hungary, Nigeria, Colombia
Contentious Politics
collective struggle carried out to achieve a political goal
can be violent or non-violent
political violence is a subsection
Political Violence
violence outside of state control that is politically motivated
states should have a monopoly on violence
carried out by non-state actors
intent is to lead to policy or institutional change
Simple crime is not political violence
Political Violence Explanation: Institutions
They can make people feel marginalized, polarized, excluded
However, some institutions reduce violence by promoting inclusion
Quest for the “root source” of political violence (in order to eliminate it)
Political Violence Explanation: Ideational
Having to do with the idea or rationale behind the violence
Nationalism or religious ideas are common causes of political violence
ISIS, J6, Charlottesville
can inspire violence against outgroups
contextual
Radicals and reactionaries can lead to an increased likelihood in political violence.
Political Violence Explanations: Individuals
Individual experiences drive people to violence
emotion or rational calculations?