Exploring the Sharia Midterm

0.0(0)
Studied by 4 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/11

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

12 Terms

1
New cards
  1. What is Shari‘a? What is Fiqh?


Shari’a: the human attempt to understand God's will in a given time and place.

  • In concept it is the ideal of god’s will, and in practice it is the human attempt at figuring out what that is.

Fiqh: the method for determining god’s will.

  • Jurisprudence 

  • It is fixed and constant, so the coherence of Islamic law sits in fiqh not in shari’a

  • Fiqh produces Shari’a



2
New cards
  1. What is the “covenant of Alast” and why is it important in Islamic Jurisprudence?


Alast = “Am I not”



“And ˹remember˺ when your Lord brought forth from the loins of the children of Adam their descendants and had them testify regarding themselves. ˹Allah asked,˺ “Am I not your Lord?” They replied, “Yes, You are! We testify.” ˹He cautioned,˺ “Now you have no right to say on Judgment Day, ‘We were not aware of this.’” [Al-A'raf 7:172] 



This verse can both be understood as a primordial event between God and humanity, or a moment in each individual’s psyche. In this verse, God calls on all human beings to use their innate ability to sense God. Primitive human religious consciousness emerges from this moment, as people acknowledge that there is a God, and that he alone is superior, and humans are his servants. 



This assumption is the basis for the covenant between God and man: 



“ A covenanting Creator-Lord hands down to his creature-slave a body of commandments, of rules, that define the obligations that the creature incurs as a result of the covenant encounter. The law is the totality of specific terms that the creature must fulfill as a party to the covenant. The covenant is the bedrock of legal obligation and responsibility.” (Weiss, pg. 32) 



^ TLDR, this verse establishes a covenant between God and humanity. The covenant is the basis for human legal obligation to God. 




3
New cards

Define the Sunna and list two ways in which it may be ascertained.

  • The Sunna: the normative practice of the prophet (what he said or did).

    • It consists of hadith (tawathur) and communal practice 

  • Hadith, in order to be certain, has to be tawathur, which means that it has to come from multiple independent chains of transmission, starting at the prophet (many people had to have heard it or seen it from the prophet himself).

  • In the case of communal practice, it is things muslim have always done - generational transfer of knowledge. 


4
New cards
  1. How does Ijma work in Islamic Law?


When a judge is studying to come up with a ruling for a case and there is existing case law, if all the judges before him got to the same ruling in this case law, and reached a consensus, that is what is called Ijma. It makes the uncertain certain, closed to never be opened, in which case a judge would have to do taqleed/imitate.



5
New cards

What is the role of case law in Fiqh?

When a judge is studying to come up with a ruling for a case, case law can be helpful because it is a shorter road to a ruling. When there is existing case law, a judge can choose to do taqleed, as in imitate a previous ruling (for the same/similar case) if there was not a consensus, or choose to do ijtihad, which is the application of reason to the certain sources (quran/sunna). If there is consensus in the existing case law, what Islam calls Ijma, that ruling becomes law and has to be implemented; Ijma makes the uncertainty certain.

6
New cards
  1. Construct (a) an argument in favor of the use of analogy in jurisprudence and (b) an argument against the use of analogy.


Background: 



In order to use analogy (qiyas)  to 

  1. An original case (in Nass) 

  2. An original rule 

  3. A novel case

  4.  A feature common to both cases 

*you also need to determine a cause for the original case. 



The use of analogy: (Weiss, pg. 69) 

  • There are many situations which arise where there is no comparable case within the Nass. 

  • The textualism that has prevailed has adopted analogy, because 

    • it begins with rules found within the original text (it is practical) 

    • can stop short of generalization 

    • Textual Evidence: 

      • “Reflect, O you who have understanding” (find verse #) 

      • In Sunna, the prophet commends an early judge who uses discretion to determine the outcome of a case that is not specified in the Quran. 




The argument against using analogy (Rigorist) 

  • Human judgement is unnecessary, the text should cover everything! 

  • What the Nass doesn’t cover is “the product of unacceptable human innovation” 

  • Can give rise to generalizations and human (flawed) interpretation

  • The Quranic command to reflect is vague, and the Sunna has doubtful origin + made not direct reference to analogy (Weiss, 71) 

  • There are some different approaches to not using analogy: 

    • Say no to everything that isn’t in the Qur’an or Sunna: (_____) 

    • Say yes to everything that isn’t in the Qur’an or Sunna: (_____) 

    • Use Inductive Reasoning (Shi’a) 


7
New cards
  1. Offer a clear definition of Ijtihad. What are two ways/methods it is used in the derivation of law?


Ijtihad is the application of reason to the certain sources (quran/sunna).

Two methods to apply ijtihad: 

  1. Analogy: you have 2 cases, one for which the ruling is clearer, and you apply that case’s legal ruling to the other case. E.g., red wine from raw grapes is haram to consume because it intoxicates. Beer intoxicates; beer is haram to consume.

  2. Inductive reasoning: expanding a ruling; deducing where you can go from it; taking two rules and relating them somehow. E.g., you cannot say “uff” to your parents, and so you cannot beat them (because logically, beating them would be worse).


8
New cards
  1. What does it mean to say that Islamic Law is constructed on the twin pillars of Intentionalism and Textualism?


God communicates his will through text. This text must have intent; according to islamic law, this intent does not change. Sometimes we figure out the intent and sometimes we do not: god embedded meaning within language that does not change over time. 

9
New cards
  1. What is Ijma and how does it work in Islamic jurisprudence?


When a judge is studying to come up with a ruling for a case and there is existing case law, if all the judges before him got to the same ruling in this case law, and reached a consensus, that is what is called Ijma. It makes the uncertain certain, closed to never be opened, in which case a judge would have to do taqleed/imitate.



10
New cards

What is meant by a “certain text”? What principle is necessary for establishing a text as “certain”?

A certain text means “certainly from God.” This includes to Qur’an, which is the word of God transmitted through the Prophet Mohammad. Then the Sunna is the practice of the Prophet [why is it certainly from God]. These texts have been transmitted via Tawatur. In order for the texts to be assured as certain, there must be multiple, independent chains of transmission directly from the Prophet. 

11
New cards
  1. What does Mutahhari mean when he distinguishes between identical and equal rights?


Identical rights would mean that everyone has the same rights. Equal rights means that different people (men and women) have different rights dependent on their natural role and role in society. 

12
New cards

Construct legal arguments for (a) the permissibility of alcohol and (b) the prohibition of coffee.

In the Qur’an, wine made from raw grape juice (khamr) is specifically forbidden. 



The permissibility of alcohol



A rigorist view of the text might posit that though khamr is forbidden, other alcoholic drinks are not forbidden, and therefore may be consumed. The reason why khamr is forbidden may just as well be related to it’s color or the rawness of the grapes. 



The Prohibition of Coffee



Using analogy, we have: 



  1. The original case: Khamr is forbidden 

  2. An original rule: drinks that alter one's capacity are forbidden (intoxicate)

  3. A novel case: Coffee, a drink that alter’s one’s capacity (intoxicates) 

  4.  A feature common to both cases: both drinks intoxicate



Therefore both drinks are forbidden.