1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
In response to the holocaust what did Milgram do?
Conduct an investigation into extreme obedience
How many people did Milgram recruit and how?
40 American men via newspaper advert for a study on ‘memory’
What role was the 40 participants given?
The role of the ‘teacher’
Who were the participants introduced to?(delegates)
professor (in lab coat)
Learner
What was the learners role?
The learner was strapped to a to a chair in another room with electrodes attached
they then have to answer some questions
What was the role of the teacher?
The participant had to deliver electric shocks, that became more intense from 15-450 volts when the ‘learner’ answered incorrectly
What were the results of Milgrams test?
300 volts
300 volts
450 volts
100% to 300 volts
12.5% stopped at 300 volts
65% to full 450 volts
What are three situational variables that Milgram tested that effected obedience?+ results and why
proximity - professor gave instructions via phone. Dropped to 21%- no agentic state
Location - run-down office instead of Yake Uni. Dropped to 47.6% - lack of LOA
Uniform - professor wore ordinary clothes. Dropped to 20%- lack of LOA
STRENGTH
How does Milgram’s research support agentic state and LOA?
The experimenter accepts responsibility for any harm to the learner- the scientists in a lab coat has LOA in the location Yale university
= the manipulation of these variables supports that these factors influence obedience
WEAKNESS
How does Milgram’s research not support LOA and agentic state?(mention two people)
Milgram’s research is criticised for methodological flaws. The task using a shock generator lacks mundane realism, and the study of Yale university lacks ecological validity.
Orne & Holland (1968) said the task was so unusual that the participants figured out it was not real and put on demand characteristics.
WEAKNESS
What results show that agentic state and LOA are not the only factors that explain obedience?(and what two other factors likely play a role)
35% of people resisted to an authority figure, dispositional factors like authoritarian personality and locus of control likely play a role
STRENGTH
Milgram used standardised procedures why is this a good thing?
Standardised procedures such as pre-recordings of the learners response, led to high level of control and allowed the experiment to be replicated
WEAKNESS
What is an ethical problem with Milgram’s research?
What is a methological problem with Milgram’s research?
Ethically criticised for distress and deception
Lacked ecological validity/mundane realism
STRENGTH
How does Bickman support Milgram’s reach for LOA?
In a NYC field experiment, passers were asked to pay for a parking meter.
Obedience = 89% in uniform
Obedience = 33% in no uniforms