1/44
Looks like no tags are added yet.
C.S. Lewis — The Abolition of Man
Written in 1943 during WWII.
Lewis argues that to be human is essentially to be nested within a moral framework.
This moral framework is called the Tao.
Tao = a term from Chinese philosophy that Lewis uses to refer to the moral law/objective moral framework.
Lewis connects morality and humanity: being human involves living according to a moral framework.
If humans abandon objective morality, they risk abandoning something essential to what makes us human.
What Is Nature?
Nature can be understood as the essence of something.
Nature = essence, quiddity, or “whatness.”
“Whatness” = what something fundamentally is.
Example: asking about the “nature of justice” means asking what justice really is.
Nature refers to reality itself, rather than simply people's opinions about reality.
Nature vs. Convention
Nature = what something really is or what is actually the case.
Convention = what people believe, agree upon, or establish.
The conventional view focuses on people's opinions or agreements.
Important question: If everyone agrees that something is a certain way, does that make it naturally/actually that way?
Nature as Given vs. Manufactured
Nature = something that is given rather than manufactured.
Natural = something that comes into being or develops naturally.
Artificial = something manufactured, fabricated, constructed, or deliberately made.
This distinction becomes important when discussing human beings and technology.
Etymology of Nature
Nature comes from Latin natura.
Natura comes from nasci = “to be born.”
Nature is therefore connected to birth, procreating, and begetting.
This emphasizes the idea of something coming into existence naturally.
Natural vs. Artificial
Natural = what develops or exists according to its own natural process.
Artificial = what has been manufactured, interfered with, or deliberately modified.
This distinction raises questions about human nature and transhumanism.
Example: If humans use technology to fundamentally modify human biology, are we changing human nature?
Moral Law and Natural Law
Moral law = principles about what is right and wrong.
Natural law = the idea that objective moral principles are grounded in human nature/the natural order.
Natural law is contrasted with conventional/positive law.
Positive law = laws created and established by human societies/governments.
Natural law = moral principles that are considered to exist independently of human-made laws.
Key distinction: natural law = morality grounded in nature; positive law = rules created by humans.’
C.S. LEWIS — THE ABOLITION OF MAN PT 2
Lewis wrote The Abolition of Man in 1943 during WWII.
Lewis is concerned with what happens to human beings when we try to control or conquer nature.
His larger concern is that when humans try to conquer nature, they may eventually try to conquer human nature itself.
LEWIS: NATURE AS THE GIVEN
Nature can be understood as what is “given” to us.
Given = what we receive as part of our existence rather than what we manufacture ourselves.
Lewis is concerned about humans rejecting what is naturally given about who we are.
If humans believe everything about themselves can be redesigned, they may begin trying to manufacture a new version of humanity.
LEWIS: NATURE AS THE “REAL” / ESSENCE
Nature can mean the real essence of something — what it actually is.
This connects to the idea of natural law.
Natural law = moral principles grounded in the nature of reality/human beings.
This is different from conventional or positive law, which is created by human beings.
Lewis connects this to the Tao.
LEWIS: THE TAO
Tao = the objective moral order/moral law.
Lewis uses the Tao to refer to a framework of objective moral values.
The Tao is not simply whatever an individual person happens to believe is right or wrong.
Lewis argues that human beings need this objective moral framework.
Morality is therefore connected to what it means to be human.
If humans reject objective moral values, they risk undermining something essential to humanity.
LEWIS: NATURE AS A COMPLETED FORM
Nature can be understood as what something becomes when it is mature or fully developed.
To understand what something is, we can look at what it naturally develops into.
Example: an acorn develops into an oak tree; its completed form helps reveal its nature.
This idea connects to Aristotle's theory of the final cause.
LEWIS: NATURE AS THE SUB-RATIONAL
Lewis also discusses nature as the more basic/sub-rational side of human beings.
This includes impulses, inclinations, and desires.
These parts of us do not necessarily operate through rational thought.
This connects to the animalistic side of human nature.
The challenge is how these impulses should relate to reason and morality.
LEWIS: MODERNITY AND THE CONQUEST OF NATURE
Lewis discusses the modern desire to conquer and control nature.
Modern science increasingly treats nature as something that can be understood, controlled, and manipulated.
Lewis's concern: if “nature” becomes something to be conquered, then human nature can also become something to be conquered.
Humans may begin trying to control and redesign themselves.
LEWIS: CONSEQUENCES OF CONQUERING HUMAN NATURE
Trying to control human nature can create an interior malaise and fragmentation within the individual.
Interior malaise = a sense that something is wrong or divided within the self.
Humans may suppress parts of themselves instead of accepting what is naturally given.
Humans may also try to control other people.
Therefore, the conquest of nature can become a problem of power and control over human beings.
Lewis's concern is not simply about controlling the external world; it is about what happens when humans turn this desire for control toward themselves and other people.
MODERN CONCEPT OF NATURE
The modern concept of nature increasingly views nature as something that can be measured, controlled, and manipulated.
Nature becomes a world of objects that can be studied scientifically.
Characteristics of this modern view:
Spatial and temporal = understood through space and time.
Cartesian “extension” = physical things are understood as objects that occupy space.
Quantity over quality = focus on what can be measured rather than what something is like or what value it has.
No inherent value = nature is treated as something neutral rather than something containing objective values.
Objects rather than consciousness = emphasis on physical objects rather than lived conscious experience.
THOMAS AQUINAS — THE THEORY OF HUMAN NATURE
AQUINAS' INTERPRETATION OF THE MEANING OF “NATURE”
a) Nature = the source of a living being's essence → “to be born,” birth
b) Nature = the principle of movement in a living being
c) Nature = the good or end of a living being's development and growth
d) Nature = the essence or quiddity of a thing → what something is
“The essence of any given thing is completed through its form
AQUINAS' THEORIES ON HUMAN NATURE
Questions 75–76 → features the soul's essence
Questions = main topic
Article = sub-topic
Objection
Response
Final thing he does
Questions 77–83 → the soul's capacities/powers:
Nutritive
- Governs unconscious biological functions like taking in nutrients, growing, and reproducing.
Shared by all living physical beings, including plants, animals, and humans.
Sensory
Enables an organism to perceive its physical environment through the five external senses and internal faculties like imagination and memory.
Includes sensory desires (appetites) that incline the organism toward pleasant things and away from harmful ones.
Locomotive
Gives an organism the physical capacity to move itself from place to place.
Driven by what the sensory powers perceive and desire, allowing animals and humans to pursue food or flee danger.
Operative
Refers broadly to any power or habit that produces an actual operation or action (used by Aquinas to describe how all powers function, or specifically in relation to "operative habits" like virtues and skills).
In this specific five-part list, it often corresponds to the Appetitive power, which drives an organism to act toward a perceived good or away from an evil.
Intellective (rational)
Exclusive to humans, this power operates without a physical organ to grasp universal truths, form abstract concepts, and reason.
Includes the will, which allows humans to freely choose the good understood by the intellect.
Questions 84–89 → the soul's operations
Primarily the intellective capacities
what is a human being, form, matter
WHAT IS A HUMAN BEING?
We need to focus on the form of the human being, not the matter, for the essence.
FORM
Form = principle of actuality
Actuality = an active existence, the act of existing
Greek: morphe
Latin: forma
“What brings something into existence is its form.”
Form = the principle of explanation.
Principle of intelligibility = the intellect proposes the form of that thing.
Actuality is always real.
MATTER
Matter = the principle of potentiality.
Potentiality = the possibility of change.
Pure matter/primary matter = akin to nothingness.
Matter = that from which something is made/composed.
Form and matter always go hand in hand.
You will never find them alone.
WHAT IS MATTER?
Aquinas doesn't answer this loaded question.
E = mc²
It is energy of some sort.
It is not something firm or something you can see.
Matter is mysterious.
THE SOURCE OF THE HUMAN BEING
THE SOURCE OF THE HUMAN BEING
We need to inquire into the source of the human being.
WHAT IS THE SOUL?
Soul = psyche, animo
The soul is the first principle of life.
It gives a living thing its very existence.
It gives a living thing its purpose/goal/end.
IS THE SOUL A BODY?
A body = a three-dimensional physical object.
A body takes up space.
Some bodies are living and some are non-living.
Non-living bodies:
Rocks
The earth
Living bodies:
Humans
Plants
We make a distinction between living and non-living bodies.
It cannot be the case that a body as a body is responsible for life because then all bodies would be alive.
“The soul is not a body.”
The soul qualifies the body in a certain way.
The soul informs the body.
The soul is the form of the body.
THE CHARACTERISTICS OF LIFE
Cognition
Intellect
Movement
Will
We know something is alive when it exercises cognition and movement.
Non-living things move by accident or externally.
Example: A table won't move unless you put a force on it.
Living things move from within.
Example: A plant grows up and moves towards the sun on its own.
KEY PROPOSITION — KNOW THIS BY HEART
“The soul is the form of the body.”
The soul = form.
The body = matter.
HYLEMORPHISM
Hylomorphism = Aquinas' doctrine of matter and form.
Composed of two words:
hule = matter
morphe = form
Doctrine of matter and form.
The soul and body (form and matter) are conjoined to constitute one thing absolutely.
Form precedes matter.
THE SOUL aquienes
The soul is the first principle of life.
The soul is the form of the body.
Hylomorphism = the doctrine of matter and form.
The soul is subsistent.
Subsistence = to exist in itself.
The soul has an independent activity: intellection (cognition and thought).
Therefore, the soul has an independent existence.
The intellect — the act of understanding — has no bodily organ.
THEORY OF ABSTRACTION
Cognition is always about the reception of forms from material/bodily objects.
Theory of abstraction = we abstract/remove the form from the matter.
Principle of “LIKE KNOWS LIKE”:
If the intellect were an organ or worked through an organ, it would not be able to know the forms of all material things.
Universal nature of concepts:
If the intellect were a physical organ, then it would only know particular essences and not universal essences.
ARGUMENT FROM THE SUBJECT OF INTELLECTUAL ACTIVITY
If an act of thinking happens, what justifies its thinking of a particular person?
This can only happen if the INTELLECTIVE PRINCIPLE is the FORM of the body.
This shows that the body plays an essential role in the execution of intellectual acts.
THE RATIONAL SOUL
The rational soul is the form of the body.
Reason permeates the entire body.
Example: phenomenon of neuroplasticity → the mind shapes the brain.
MEREOLOGY OF THE SOUL AND BODY
Mereology = the science of how wholes and parts relate to each other.
The whole is always greater than its parts.
The soul is the whole of the body.
The soul organizes the whole organism.
Contrast between a living thing and a machine:
Living thing = primarily a whole.
Machine = made of parts.
WHAT IS A FORM?
Two types of form:
A. SUBSTANTIAL FORM
The form of a substance.
It makes something exist.
Example: bronze statue → the physical material/metal, the actual bronze.
B. ACCIDENTAL FORM
A property or quality of a substance.
Example: bronze statue:
What is it shaped like?
What is it displaying?
What colour is it?
These are properties/qualities of the substance.
Thomas Aquinas: The methedolgy of the soul-body relationships
Aquinas states his doctrine:
The soul is whole in the whole body and whole in each part of the body
The whole is before the parts and the whole repulates the parts
The whole is irreducible to the parts
When a part of our body is removed from a living organism, it ceases to be what it substantially is
THEORIES OF HUMAN NATURE
A. MATERIALISTIC ACCOUNT OF HUMAN NATURE
The human being is nothing more than MATTER.
We are nothing more than a physical body.
Terms:
Materialism: all facts and reality consist entirely of matter, or are causally dependent on and reducible to physical processes
Physicalism: everything is physical or supervenes on the physical
Naturalism: that only natural laws and forces operate in the universe, rejecting supernatural entities like deities, ghosts,
WHAT IS MATTER?, WHY IS MATERIALISM INADEQUATE AS A METAPHYSICAL PRINCIPLE OF REALITY?, EXAMPLES OF SPIRITUAL / IMMATERIAL ACTS
WHAT IS MATTER?
Matter = Mater → “mother”
Question: What is an adequate definition of matter?
WHY IS MATERIALISM INADEQUATE AS A METAPHYSICAL PRINCIPLE OF REALITY?
PRINCIPLE OF VERIFICATIONISM
Every proposition that supports materialism is self-refuting.
EVIDENCE FOR IMMATERIAL / SPIRITUAL ACTS
There is evidence for immaterial/spiritual acts.
Robert Sokolowski: any act that transcends space, time, and matter.
One needs to have some understanding of what a material cause amounts to.
EXAMPLES OF SPIRITUAL / IMMATERIAL ACTS
Act of knowing = grasping universal concepts.
Sensations = qualia → first-person perceptual experiences.
Having purposes.
Acts of volition.
Intention.
2ND MODEL OF HUMAN NATURE — SUBSTANCE DUALISM
Substance dualism = there are 2 substances:
Immaterial: An immaterial, thinking thing that does not occupy physical space or have physical dimensions. It includes consciousness, thoughts, and the soul
Material: Material matter that occupies space, has mass and shape, and can be divided into parts. This includes the brain, body, and all external physical objects
Plato and Descartes agree with this model.
Personal identity: I am identical with my soul.
PROBLEMS WITH SUBSTANCE DUALISM
Cannot adequately address who I am / personal identity.
Our bodies do constitute our identity.
Cannot explain how the soul and body are connected.
THE CAPACITIES OF THE SOUL
THE 3 TYPES OF SOULS
VEGETATIVE SOUL — PLANT LIFE
Generative: The power of physical growth and development to reach full maturity.
Augmentative: The capacity to reproduce and pass life on to a new organism.
ANIMAL / SENSITIVE SOUL
Sensation: The capacity to perceive the world through the five external senses (sight, hearing, smell, taste, touch) and internal senses (like memory and imagination).
Locomotion → The ability to move through space toward things perceived as pleasant or helpful (like food) and away from things perceived as painful or harmful
RATIONAL SOUL
Intellect → our capacity to know the truth.
Human: Will → the capacity to freely choose and pursue what the intellect recognizes as genuinely good.
ESSENCE OF THE SOUL VS. CAPACITIES OF THE SOUL
Important: the capacities are NOT identical to the essence of the soul.
RATIONAL SOUL
The rational soul is the form of the body as a FIRST ACTUALITY.
It makes the body exist.
CAPACITIES
Capacities are a SECOND ACTUALITY.
Their actuality is due to an operation/activity → executing an act.
INTELLECT AND BODY
Question: How are the intellect and BODY related to each other with respect to intellectual activity?
THE INTELLECT IS AN IMMATERIAL CAPACITY
The intellect does not have a physical organ.
Independent operation implies independent existence.
Aquinas’ argument: the intellect cognizes universal concepts.
THE INTELLECT IS DEPENDENT ON THE BODY
The intellect is dependent on the body for the content of its thought.
THE CAPACITIES OF THE SOUL
SENSATION
EXTERNAL SENSES
External senses are distinguished by their power/capacity, NOT by their physical organ.
THE PROPER AND PER SE SENSIBLES
“Per se” = essential.
Each external sense has its own proper sensible:
Sight / vision → colour
Hearing → sound
Smell → smell / odour
Taste → savour / flavour
Touch → the tangible
Examples of touch:
Hot/cold
Wet/dry
Hard/soft
THE COMMON SENSIBLES
Sensible qualities that can be perceived by more than one sense:
Size
Shape
Number
Motion
Rest
These are incidental, not essential.
“Per accidens” sensible = incidental/accidental sensible.
The object itself:
Table
Chair
Dog
etc.
INTERIOR SENSES
COMMON SENSE (SYNTHETIC SENSE)
The common root and term of the external senses.
Allows us to discriminate one sense from another.
We can reflexively sense our sense perceptions.
Examples:
One sees that one is seeing.
One hears that one is hearing.
It receives sensations from the external senses.
IMAGINATION
A storehouse/repository of “images” (phantasms) derived from the common sense.
It retains images/phantasms and composes them.
It provides the intellect with phantasms from which concepts are formed.
ESTIMATIVE / COGITATIVE SENSE
A certain comparison of objects under a common nature/essence.
Estimative = found in non-human animals → instinct.
Cogitative = specifically human → “particular reason.”
MEMORY
Stores/retains INTENTIONS.
It cannot interpret intentions in terms of their “pastness.”
INTENTIONS
Intentions are perceived by the cogitative sense.
The cogitative sense receives intentions.
An object is being perceived as an object.
THE INTELLECT
Important principle: the intellect and the senses are DISTINCT.
The intellect always deals with UNIVERSAL CONCEPTS.
Examples:
Dog
Human being
Tree
CAPACITIES OF THE INTELLECT
Possible / potential intellect: To receive and become intelligible forms (capacity to know).
Active / agent intellect: To act upon the data of experience and abstract universal forms (cause of knowledge)
THEORETICAL VS. PRACTICAL INTELLECT
Theoretical intellect
Object = universal truth.
Practical intellect
Object = action.
INTELLECT VS. REASON
Intellect
A single apprehension of a truth.
Reason
A discursive process moving toward a conclusion.
Reason involves motion/movement toward a conclusion.
FREE CHOICE
Free choice pertains to the attainment of this universal goal of happiness.
Clarify the perceptual hierarchy
Explain the two intellect capacities