1/55
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Olmstead v. United states (1928) What happened??
Federal agents wiretapped suspected bootleggers without physically trespassing on their property
what is the main difference between Olmstead and Katz??
Olmstead focused on physical trespass; Katz recognized privacy protection without physical entry
Olmstead v. United states (1928) what did SCOTUS decide?
No, the court found no 4th amendment violation because agents did not physically trespass
The police attach a listening device to the outside of a public phone booth and record a person's private conversation without a warrant. They argue that no search occurred because they never entered the booth. Under Katz, what is the correct answer?
Police secretly use a government informant who is invited into a suspect's hotel room. The suspect voluntarily makes incriminating statements, and the informant reports them to police. Under Hoffa v. United States, which statement is correct?
Police receive an anonymous tip that drugs are inside a house. Without a warrant, they bring a trained drug-sniffing dog onto the front porch, and the dog alerts. Under Florida v. Jardines, what is the correct answer?
Olmstead v. United states (1928): what doctrine is assiociated with the case
Trespass doctrine: the court focused on physical intrusion into protected property
What case did Olmstead v. United States get overturned by
Katz v. United States (1967)
Katz v. United States (1967) what happened
The FBI recorded Katz’s private phone calls from a public telephone booth without a warrant
Katz v. United States (1967) whats the legal issue
can warrantless electronic surveillance violate the fourth amendment without physical entry
Katz v. United States (1967) what did SCOTUS decide
YES/recording Katz’s private calls violated the 4th amendment
Katz v. United States (1967) KEY RULE
4th amendment protects ppl not places; reasonable expectations of privacy matter
Kyllo v. United states (2001) what happened?
police used a thermal imager to detect heat patterns from a home suspected of growing marijuana
Kyllo v. United states (2001) legal issue??
warrantless use of thermal imaging of a home’s interior a fourth amendment search
Kyllo v. United states (2001) what did SCOTUS decide?
YES/// using technology not in a general public use to learn otherwise unknowable details inside a home was a search
Hoffa v. United States (1966): what happened??
Government informant Edward Partin reported Hoffa’s incriminating statements about alleged jury tampering
Hoffa v. United States (1966): LEGAL ISSUE??
Did using a secret informant to report Hoffa’s voluntary statements violate his consistutional rights?
Hoffa v. United States (1966): what did SCOTUS decide??
NO//constitutional violation under the circumstances; the court upheld Hoffa/s convictions
Hoffa v. United States (1966): why was the 4th amendment claim rejected?
Hoffa voluntarily spoke around Partin, misplaced trust in an informant was not an illegal search
Hoffa v. United States (1966): why was the 5th amendment claim rejected?
Hoffa/s statements were voluntary, not compelled self incrimination
Florida v. Jardines (2013) what happened?
police brought a drug-sniffing dog onto a home’s front porch to investigate suspected marijuana growing inside
Florida v. Jardines (2013) LEGAL ISSUE
Was bringing a drug dog onto a porch to investigate a home a fourth amendment search??
Florida v. Jardines (2013) what did SCOTUS decide?
YES// the dog sniff was a search because police physically intruded on protected curtilage to gather evidence
Florida v. Jardines (2013) CURTILAGE MEANS??
area immediately surrounding the home//such as front porch
Olmstead v United states (1928): LEGAL ISSUE
Did warrantless wiretapping without physical trespass violate the 4th amendment?
What happened in Powell v. Alabama?
Two Black men were charged with raping two white girls in 1931. They were not provided meaningful access to legal counsel during their trial.
What was the issue in Powell v. Alabama?
Did the defendants' lack of meaningful access to an attorney violate their right to due process?
What was SCOTUS Ruling in Powell v. Alabama?
YES// The Supreme Court held that the defendants were denied due process under the Fourteenth Amendment because they were not given a meaningful opportunity to obtain and consult with counsel.
Betts v. Brady (1942) What happen?//ISSUE??
An indigent defendant requested an appointed attorney, but Maryland denied his request because the state generally appointed counsel only in capital cases.
what was the SCOTUS ruling in Betts v. Brady?
NO/// The Supreme Court ruled that states were not constitutionally required to appoint an attorney for every indigent defendant charged with a noncapital crime.
What is the key takeaway from Betts v. Brady?
At the time, indigent defendants did not automatically have a constitutional right to appointed counsel in every state criminal case.
What case overturned Betts v. Brady?
Gideon v. Wainwright (1963).
What happened in Gideon v. Wainwright?
Clarence Gideon was charged with a felony in Florida. He requested an appointed attorney because he could not afford one, but Florida denied his request because the case was not a capital offense.
What was the holding in Gideon v. Wainwright?
Yes. The Supreme Court held that the Sixth Amendment right to counsel applies to state felony trials through the Fourteenth Amendment.
What is the key takeaway from Gideon v. Wainwright?
States must provide attorneys to indigent defendants charged with felonies who cannot afford legal representation.
What was the issue in Douglas v. California?
Whether an indigent defendant could be denied appointed counsel during their first appeal as a matter of right because they could not afford an attorney.
What was the holding in Douglas v. California?
The Supreme Court held that indigent defendants have a right to appointed counsel during their first appeal as a matter of right.
What is the key takeaway from Douglas v. California?
Indigent defendants cannot be denied legal representation during their first appeal as a matter of right simply because they cannot afford an attorney.
What was the issue in Argersinger v. Hamlin?
Whether an indigent defendant has the right to appointed counsel when charged with a misdemeanor offense that could result in imprisonment.
What was the holding in Argersinger v. Hamlin?
No person may be imprisoned for any offense, whether petty, misdemeanor, or felony, unless they were represented by counsel at trial or knowingly and intelligently waived that right.
What is the key takeaway from Argersinger v. Hamlin?
The right to appointed counsel applies when a defendant is actually sentenced to imprisonment.
What case later clarified the Argersinger rule?
Scott v. Illinois (1979).
What did Scott v. Illinois clarify?
The constitutional right to appointed counsel applies when an indigent defendant is actually sentenced to imprisonment, not merely when imprisonment is a possible punishment.
What was Ross v. Moffitt about?
An indigent defendant sought appointed counsel for further review of his criminal case, including discretionary review and postconviction proceedings.
What is a writ of habeas corpus?
A legal writ used to bring a prisoner before a court to determine whether their detention or imprisonment is lawful.
What was the issue in Ross v. Moffitt?
Whether an indigent defendant has a constitutional right to appointed counsel for discretionary appellate review after their first appeal as a matter of right.
What was the holding in Ross v. Moffitt?
No. The Supreme Court held that there is no automatic constitutional right to appointed counsel for discretionary appeals or petitions for certiorari.
What was the main issue in United States v. Cronic?
Whether an inexperienced attorney with only 25 days to prepare for a complex criminal trial, while the prosecution had prepared for over four years, constituted ineffective assistance of counsel.
What was the holding in United States v. Cronic?
The Supreme Court held that the circumstances alone did not establish ineffective assistance of counsel. The defendant had to identify specific errors or circumstances that undermined the fairness of the proceedings. Every experienced criminal defense attorney once tried their first criminal case.
What did Strickland v. Washington establish?
The Strickland Test, a two-prong test used to determine whether a defendant received ineffective assistance of counsel.
What are the two prongs of the Strickland Test?
Deficient Performance- defendant must show that the attorneys performance fell below objective standard of reasonableness
Prejudice- the outcome of the proceeding would have been different
What is the key takeaway from Strickland v. Washington?
An attorney making a mistake does not automatically mean ineffective assistance of counsel. The defendant must prove that the attorney's performance was deficient AND that it prejudiced the defense.
What was the issue in Faretta v. California?
Whether a criminal defendant has a constitutional right to represent themselves in court when they voluntarily and intelligently choose to do so.
What was the holding in Faretta v. California?
Yes. The Supreme Court held that the Sixth Amendment gives defendants the right to represent themselves if they voluntarily, knowingly, and intelligently waive their right to an attorney.
What does pro se mean?
Representing yourself in court without an attorney.
What must a defendant understand before representing themselves?
The defendant must voluntarily, knowingly, and intelligently choose to waive the right to an attorney and understand the dangers and disadvantages of self-representation.