1/37
Looks like no tags are added yet.
If D is presence within the jurisdiction, does C need permission to serve the claim form on them?
Why?
So what rules apply?
No
(Claim is not being served outside of the jurisdiction!)
→ so usual rules apply that apply to domestic disputes
No permission is needed, serving outside the jurisdiction on a D where…
Otherwise…
D submits to / agrees to jurisdiction (other than by contract), OR
A Jurisdiction clause, (contract agreeS E&W) OR
Hague Convention applies
→ Seek permission from court via application!
If party needs to seek court permission to serve on D outside the jurisdiction - what 3 matters must they establish?
If these 3 matters are established then?
A ‘gateway’ /ground
Claim has reasonable prospects of sucess
E&W is the ‘proper place’ to bring the claim
→ court MAY grant permission for service outside the jurisdiction
These ‘gateways’/ grounds incl?
contract + tort claims (if reqs met)
D has domicile within E&W
Claim is for an injunction (& act to be restrained is w/in E&W)
Necessary/ proper party to the claim
Hague Convention - if this applies then jurisdiction…
Cannot be challenged!
Hague convention applies where?
There is a contractually agreed jurisdiction clause
+ can answer 6 Qs: (affirmatively)
Civil/ commercial matter?
Not an excluded matter?
The clause gives jurisdiction to a contracting state? I.e. E&W
Jurisdiction must be given exclusively?
The agreement is concluded/ documented/ evidenced in writing?
Is the agreement an asymmetric one?
Hague convention - excluded matters:
I.e. x3
consumers
Employment
Family
But irrespective of Hague Convention, parties can…
Purpose of The Hague convention?
what if other court is not one of the Hague convention contracting state?
Serve outside jurisdiction where have a jurisdiction clause agreed anyway + dont need court permission
The court specified must accept jurisdiction & other courts in convention cannot! = binding them
→ they are not bound, i.e. dont have to refuse!
Jurisdiction?
Choice of Law?
contract + tort claims (if reqs met)
D has domicile within E&W
Claim is for an injunction (& act to be restrained is w/in E&W)
Necessary/ proper party to the claim
What if you commence proceedings in a court which doesn’t have jurisdiction?
Court may refuse to determine
May face opposition from opponent
If English/ welsh court applies foreign law?
procedural matters?
Substantive matters?
Presumption?
E&W laws/ CPRs continue to apply
Foreign law applies
Presumed = foreign law is the same as English law, unless proven otherwise
HOW do you serve on D outside jurisdiction?
Comply with rules for service in a manner permitted by the target country
What if a contract does not contain a jurisdiction clause?
Look towards the common law rules!!
The common law rules
→ consider first? _ aka …
Companies?
Presence; is the defendant present within the jurisdiction
→ then if serve on them whilst present in the jurisdiction = court can have jurisdiction
Slightly different rules (check!!!!)
Also should check whether the D has…
& they must have
Does this mean they have ‘submitted’ to jurisdiction?
Nominated a solicitor to accept service of proceedings (aka w/in the jurisdiction)
& solicitor must have accepted to do so
No! (Haven’t even seen anything about proceedings yet!)
What type of application will application for permission to serve outside of the jurisdiction be?
A w/o notice one
need to do arguments for/ against etc.
Procedure for disputing the court’s jurisdiction,
The D must…
File an AOS
Tick the box on AOS to indicate the D intends to contest jurisdiction
Apply w/in 14 days after filing AOS, disputing the court’s jurisdictions + support with evidence e 5
Procedure - serving outside jurisdiction, where you don’t believe court permission is needed?
What does this do?
This is _
Also need…
So you cannot just…
File and serve (with the claim form) - an N510 (setting out the basis on which you believe the court has jurisdiction to hear the matter)
= mandatory
To serve translations of all the documents.
Follow the usual rules
Would relief from sanctions apply if fail to serve N510?
NO!!!
What should D do if they dispute jurisdiction?
avoid?
File AOS, and
Apply to court challenging the court’s jurisdiction
Avoid submitting to the jurisdiction!
Submitting to the jurisdiction includes?
Taking a step in the proceedings !
(Rome I)
Factors might argue; re having an arguable case falling w/in one of the jurisdictional gateways?
contract made in the jurisdiction
Governed by the law of E&W (in contract)
…. INSERT
Re demonstrating a reasonable prospect of success; this re?
equal to prospect of success needed to resist an application for summary judgment
Relatively low threshold
Not fanciful
Think elements: duty, breach, causation, loss
Factors re E&W being the proper place?
witnesses
Where contract formed/ breached
Where losses occurred
Where D resides
Applicable law
Etc.
Forum shopping?
Choosing betw multiple jurisdictions/ forums; most favourable one for your case
I.e. costs/ remedies/ funding/ disclosure/ speed/ enforcement
Steps to consider re choice of jurisdiction x4
Jurisdiction clause choosing E&W?
D nominated solicitors to accept service?
D present in jurisdiction to serve?
IF none above apply → make application for permission to serve CF outside jurisdiction
(Think: prof conduct; act in best interests of clients; may need to instruct solicitors in another jurisdiction, even if loss of revenue for firm)
Choice of law - (Rome I) - re?
X4 steps
(Contracts)
Parties choice of applicable law → this applies,
Contract relates to a specified case? → if yes, the articles apply
Country where the ‘characteristic performer’ has its habitual residence
Contract ‘manifestly more closely connected’ w another country
Parties choice of law
can be?
When can choice be made?
Express in contract/ implied (if demonstrated by circumstances)
At any time incl after dispute arisen!!
Specified cases/ types of contracts - what?
For contracts of… | Applicable law is that of… |
Sale of goods | Seller’s habitual residence
|
Provision of services | Service provider’s habitual residence
|
Contract relating to land | Where the land is situated
|
Distribution contract | Distributor’s habitual residence |
‘Habitual residence’
for a company is where?
For a natural person acting in the course of business is?
company → where its central administration is.
natural person acting in course of business → where their principal place of business is.
Where party required to effect characteristic performance has its habitual residence? aka…
Party doing something for payment, not the one just giving payment
BUT must consider where the contract is manifestly more connected with another country
threshold?
And if it is more connected, then…
high threshold!!!
Can override stage 2/3!! & apply the law of this more manifestly connected country
Rome I applies to?
Contracts entered into on/ after 17 dec 2009
Choice of law - (Rome II) - re?
X4
(Tort)
Parties VALIDLY chosen which law should apply? → applies
C and D habitually reside in the same country? → yes, that country
Country in which the damage occurs?
Tort ‘manifestly more closely connected’ w another country?
Rome II applies to?
Events giving rise to damage on/ after 10 Jan 2009
Rome II - 1. Parties choice
may be?
What if choice of law was entered into after the options event giving rise to damage?
If before the event; choice will only be effective if? X2
express/ implied (demonstrated by circs, w reasonable certainty)
Choice will be effective
If:
Both parties pursuing a commercial activity +
Freely negotiated it
Rome II - 3. Country in which the damage occurs? Ie.. where….
Injury sustained/ property damaged.