Criminal Law - Non-fatal offences against the person

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/15

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

16 Terms

1
New cards

Malicious wounding/inflicting GBH (s.20): definition and actus reus

"Whosoever shall unlawfully and maliciously wound or inflict any grievous bodily harm upon any other person, either with or without any weapon or instrument shall be guilty of [an offence]"

Offences Against the Person Act 1861, s.20 [max 5 yrs]

Wound = puncture of the inner and outer skin accompanied by bleeding (Moriarty and Brooks (1834) 6 C&P 684; JCC v Eisenhower (1984) 78 Cr App R 48). Internal injuries are not wounds (but may be GBH).

Eisenhower: shot air gun pellet into C eyes. On appeal, COA said didn’t classify as wound

"The ‘wounding’ form of these offences should be reserved for those wounds considered to be really serious. However, it is appropriate to charge these offences when a wound is caused by a knife or other weapon, to reflect the seriousness." - CPA guidance

2
New cards

Inflicting GBH (s.20): definition and actus reus

GBH = really serious injury (DPP v Smith [1961] AC 290), including psychiatric injury (R v Ireland; R v Burstow).

"harm does not have to be either permanent or dangerous … ultimately, the assessment of harm done is a matter for the jury, applying contemporary social standards."

CPS Guidance citing Golding [2014] EWCA Crim 889

"Life-changing injuries should be charged as GBH. […] significant or sustained medical treatment (for instance, intensive care or a blood transfusion) may indicate GBH injuries, even if a full or relatively full recovery follows."

Golding - D had sexual relationship, gave her genital herpes. Conviction of s.20.

3
New cards

CPS guidance: R v Bollom [2003] EWCA Crim 2846

Takes account of the impact on a particular victim if vulnerable – R v Bollom [2003] EWCA Crim 2846.

^ 17 month old baby suffered from bruising and dropped at a party. Prosecution said injuries caused by D. s.18, s.20 and assault occasioning ABH s.47. chose most serious (s.18) D had argued conviction should've been overturned. Defence argued judge had created impression vulnerability of baby. COA agreed with view that when assessing, vulnerabilities of V may be considered.

Same as ABH, is that fair?

4
New cards

Inflicting definition:

While s. 47 uses ‘occasion’ and s. 18 uses the term ‘cause’, s.20 uses ‘inflict’. What implications, if any, does this have for the means by which V suffers the necessary harm?

R v Wilson [1983] 3 All ER 448: ‘inflict’ need not involve an assault/battery (contra R v Clarence (1888) 22 QBD 23) but does involve force ‘violently applied’ directly or indirectly.

Clarence - infected V with gnorrhea but didn’t inflict GBH. Battery necessary for GBH in s.20. as husband and wife, no breach as consent implied.

R v Ireland; R v Burstow [1997] 4 All ER 225 – ‘infliction’ of psychiatric harm – Clarence ‘does not assist’ (Lord Steyn); no real practical difference between ‘cause’ and ‘inflict’ (Lord Hope).

5
New cards

Reckless transmission of HIV can be ‘infliction’ - R v Dica [2004] 3 All ER 593

R v Dica [2004] 3 All ER 593 – reckless transmission of HIV can be ‘infliction’: Clarence would be decided differently today. See also Golding [2014] EWCA Crim 889 (transmission of genital herpes).

D learned he was HIV positive and started relations with 2 women. Both C had consented but D hadn't acted deliberately, reckless. Reckless transmission counted as infliction under s.20

6
New cards

Inflicting by falling: Brady [2006] EWCA Crim 2413

D was at a club and done loads of drugs and alcohol. Jumped into crowd, caused V GBH and left paraplegic. D argued it was an accident. Caused GBH; whether he had a guilty mind or reckless?

7
New cards

Malicious wounding/ inflicting GBH (s.20): mens rea

‘Maliciously’ means intention / recklessness as to injury (Cunningham [1957] QB 396: s.23 OAPA ‘malicious’ administration of noxious substance).

In s. 20:

"the word maliciously does import upon the part of the person … an awareness that his act may have the consequence of causing some physical harm to some other person … It is quite unnecessary that the accused should have foreseen that his unlawful act might cause physical harm of the gravity described in [section 20]

  • R v Mowatt [1968] 1 QB 421

Intending to frighten isn’t enough unless there was foresight to cause harm

8
New cards

Wounding/ causing GBH with intent (s.18): definition and actus reus

"Whosoever shall unlawfully and maliciously by any means whatsoever wound or cause any grievous bodily harm with intent to do some grievous bodily harm to any person, or with intent to resist or prevent the lawful apprehension or detainer of any person, shall be guilty of [an offence] and being convicted thereof shall be liable to [imprisonment for life]"

9
New cards

Offences Against the Person Act 1861, s.18

Requires wound or GBH, but ‘… cause by any means whatsoever’ avoids the problem that has had to be overcome with ‘inflict’.

10
New cards

Wounding/causing GBH with intent (s.18): mens rea

Requires either:

  • Intent to cause GBH (not merely to wound short of GBH – Taylor [2009] EWCA Crim 544) or

  • Intent to resist/prevent lawful apprehension or detainer of a person

Additionally, ‘maliciously’ imports intention / subjective recklessness as to wound/injury.

If D is charged with causing GBH with intent, ‘maliciously’ adds nothing; in all other cases it may be crucial (Morrison (1989) 89 Cr App R 17: maliciously causing GBH with intent to prevent arrest).

"Factors that may indicate specific intent [to cause GBH] include a repeated or planned attack, deliberate selection of a weapon or adaptation of an article to cause injury, such as breaking a glass before an attack, making prior threats or using an offensive weapon against, or kicking, the victim’s head. The gravity of the injury may be the same for section 20 or 18 although the gravity may indicate the intention of the defendant." - CPS Guidance

11
New cards

Morrison [1989] 89 Cr App R 17

police entered house to evade squatters. Police officer jumped through window after being grabbed. Officer had facial scaring. Malicious and unlawful wounding with intent to resist arrest. Judge said objective test of reckless, WRONG. Proper standard is subjective, D must have foreseen risk and still took risk anyway. Conviction quashed. S.18 difficult.

12
New cards

Reforming non-fatal offences:

1998 Home Office Consultation: Draft Bill to replace

  • S.18 with intentionally causing serious injury

  • S.20 with recklessly causing serious injury

  • S.47 with intentionally / recklessly causing injury

"the most obvious feature of the proposed offences is the absence of clutter; the expression is simple and direct, with actus reus linked to mens rea through nothing more than a causal connection. Mens rea corresponds to the actus reus, and the mens rea and actus reus are defined. It is difficult to imagine that this scheme of offences would give rise to the same number of appeals, confusions and complexities as does the current order" - Simester & Sullivan


13
New cards

Reforming non-fatal offences: Law Com Paper 361 (November 2015)

  • 3 principal offences based on causing injury/serious injury where the fault terms (intention, recklessness) correspond with AR, as per the Draft Bill of 1998.

  • No definitions of intention/recklessness.

  • Transmission of disease may be ‘injury’.

  • Non-physical injury must be recognised psychiatric injury.

  • Remodel battery as ‘physical assault’ and assault as ‘threatened assault’, making clear that non-consent is an element.

  • New offence of aggravated assault where D commits physical or threatened assault and causes minor injury (summary offence only, but with 12 months max).


14
New cards

Law Com Paper 361: areas of controversy

Most respondents, including the senior judges, supported the case for change (‘The legislation is out of date and in some areas obsolete’).

A minority, including the Bar Council and the Criminal Bar Association, thought that the OAPA’s legal meaning had largely been settled by decisions and that it worked well in practice.

The Law Commission’s riposte was that a statute ‘written in code’ which is accessible only to trained criminal lawyers fails in its function of informing the public what the law is.

15
New cards

Area of controversy: Constructive liability

15 respondents approved of the correspondence principle as a default setting for legislation.

A substantial minority (11), including the CPS, defended constructive liability

The new aggravated assault runs counter to the correspondence principle. Though most respondents were against it, the CPS thought it useful to cover some cases currently charged as s.47 that should only be triable summarily.

16
New cards

Areas of controversy: transmission of disease

The decision to incorporate Dica (which had not been decided when the 1998 Report was published) was not welcomed by HIV charities and a substantial body of medical opinion, on the ground that criminalization of reckless (as distinct from intentional) transmission of disease is unhelpful in terms of public health.

The Law Com identified many questions unanswered in Dica:

  • Must D know s/he is infected?

  • What about where D is having treatment that reduces risk of transmission – is it still ‘reckless’?

  • What level of awareness constitutes ‘informed’ consent by V?