1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the problem of change?
The problem of change can be summed up in a simple question: “Why do things change?”
Briefly explain how the problem of change inaugurated Western philosophy.
The problem of change inaugurated Western philosophy by setting man on a quest to understand the world which is a teeming mass of change and motion.
What is the problem of motion?
The problem of motion is another name for the problem of change.
Briefly explain why orderliness is important to the problem of change.
Order is important to the problem of change because change is frequently tidy and organized, even though the world is so often prone to disorder.
Give your own examples) of motion or change that is not orderly.
Answers will vary. (Ex. A hurricane tears through a community.)
Give your own examples) of motion or change that is orderly.
Answers will vary (Ex. The seasons return each year and in the same order.)
What is "natural philosophy"?
"Natural philosophy" is the philosophy of nature or what we now call "science."
What was Thales' answer to the problem of change? How was this answer a step forward in answering the problem?
Thales answer to the problem of change was that everything is made of water.
His answer was a step forward in answering the problem because he put the problem of change on the table and gave the world a sample solution.
When did Thales live (very roughly)?
Thales lived circa 500s BC.
There are two main reason why Thales is important to Western philosophy.
What are they?
The two main ways in which Thales was important are: first, he set the agenda for Western philosophy with his attempt to explain why the world around us changes while maintaining so much order; and second, he was the first mathematician (the first person to try to systematically prove mathematical statements).
What was the Pythagorean motto? Explain what this motto means. (Hint: how did Morris Kline unpack the motto?)
The Pythagorean motto was "All is number." This motto has three underlying ideas: first, that the universe is ordered according to perfect mathematical laws, second, that divine reason is the orderer, and third, that human reason can discern the divine mathematical pattern.
When did Pythagoras live (very roughly)?
Pythagoras lived circa 500s BC.
What Pythagorean discovery led to the Pythagorean motto?
The Pythagorean discovery that led to the Pythagorean motto was the discovery that musical intervals could be represented by whole numbers. In other words, it was discovered that simple mathematics could describe something as seemingly nonmathematical as music.
What is the music of the spheres? Why were the Pythagoreans impressed by the connection between music and mathematics? Why do you think that we aren't usually impressed by this?
The Pythagoreans believed that the motion of the heavenly bodies (the sun, moon, planets, and stars) produced actual harmonic music which is called "the music of the spheres."
The Pythagoreans were impressed by the connection between music and mathematics because there is no apparent reason for the math to work out so nicely when it comes to music and the vibration of strings. I think that we aren't usually impressed by this because we are so used to using numbers to describe things—music, velocity, weight, density, etc.—we entirely expect the world to help us out like this.
When we say that mathematics applies to the world, what do we mean exactly?
(Hint: what two realms are similar?)
When we say that mathematics applies to the world, we mean that math, although it is nonphysical, can accurately describe the world, even though the world is physical.
What did Wigner say about the applicability of mathematics to the physical world? Why couldn't he make sense of why math "works"? How did Plato make sense of it?
Wigner said that "The miracle of the appropriateness of the language of mathematics for the formulation of the laws of physics is a wonderful gift which we neither understand nor deserve." In other words, he said we cannot understand why Math "works." He couldn't make sense of why math "works" because he was not aware that the universe was created by an intelligent de-signer, a God who is a mathematician. Plato made sense of the applicability of math by saying that the world is mathematical, and he believed that the world was mathematical because God made it that way.
What two important views did Plato inherit from the Pythagoreans?
The two important views that Plato inherited from the Pythagoreans were that the human soul is immortal, and that the physical world is fundamentally mathematical.
According to Plato, humans are divided into two very different kinds of things.
What are these two things?
According to Plato, humans are composed of two parts: a physical body and a nonphysical soul or mind.
Plato divided reality into two main realms. Explain.
Plato divided reality into two main realms: the physical realm and the non-physical realm. The physical part is just the ordinary universe we live in. The nonphysical part is a world of Ideas or Forms.
How do Plato's two "worlds" correspond to the two parts of humans?
The physical part of humans, the physical body, corresponds to the physical world, whereas the nonphysical part of humans, the soul or mind, corresponds to the nonphysical world.
What is "Plato's Heaven"?
"Plato's Heaven" is the mysterious, nonphysical "realm" or "world" where the Ideas or Forms exist.
What are Forms?
Forms are actual nonphysical objects that literally exist outside the physical world, independent of any minds. They are absolutely perfect, they exist eter-nally, and they never, ever change.
Explain how, according to Plato, the physical world is a mere copy. Be sure to give an example.
The physical world is a mere copy of the nonphysical world because the perfect blueprints for things in the world are found in the nonphysical world, and when these things are found in the world, they are never perfect, they can cease to exist, and they can change. For example, the perfect Idea of Circularity exists in Plato's Heaven, but circles in the world are never perfectly circular. (Examples may vary.)
What is Plato's answer for why the world is mathematical?
Plato's answer for why the world is mathematical is that God made it that way. Plato's "god" used the mathematical forms and so the world too is mathematical.
According to Plato, why was the study of mathematics important?
Plato believed that our souls are more important than our bodies. According to Plato it is important to take care of our souls, to purify them. For Plato, the soul is purified by becoming more like the Forms, more like the eternal, perfect Ideas that inhabit Plato's heaven. The way to do this, said Plato, is to study mathematics.
Explain how Plato's Republic is important in the history of the liberal arts.
What does this have to do with Pythagoras?
The education that Plato sketches in his book the Republic is where the West gets the notion of the liberal arts. There are seven liberal arts and four of them, the quadrivium (arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and music) were handed down to Plato by the Pythagoreans.
What is the "music of the spheres"?
The Pythagoreans believed that the motion of the heavenly bodies the sun, moon, planets, and stars) produced actual harmonic music which is called "the music of the spheres."
What was the homework that Plato assigned the Academy? Why is this assignment historically important?
For homework, Plato wanted the Academy to create a mathematical system that accurately described and predicted the motion of the heavens. This is historically important because it brings us back to the problem of change-this time the motion of the sun, moon, planets, and stars in all their bewildering meanderings. He wanted to tackle the problem of change in the physical world using mathematics.
How did Plato attack the problem of change? That is what was his version of the problem?
Plato's version of the problem dealt with the motion of the heavenly bodies, the physical world, and he believed the problem could be solved using mathe-matics. Whereas Thales tackled the problem of change by saying that everything is made of water, Plato attacked the problem by saying that everything can be described mathematically.
Why is Plato's problem of change so difficult to solve?
Plato's problem of change is so difficult to solve because he wanted to describe the motion of the sun, moon, stars, and planets (the entire cosmos) mathemati-cally. It is even more difficult to solve because the heavenly bodies don't really move in an orderly fashion.