1/63
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what is the central aim of tikanga justice processes
restoring balance within relationships
define hara
transgression of tapu or a wrong causing imbalance, closest equivolent to a “crime”
Take → Utu → ea explained
take is the issue
utu is the reciprocal response to rebalance
ea that state of rebalance
two forms of mana
mana tuku iho → inherited
mana tangata → earned through actions
mana whenua → whakapapa connection
the 6 contrasts of english CJS and tikanga
Outward (tikanga) v inward looking (english): ECJS looks inward at the individual at a single moment, Tikanga looks outward at histories, whakapapa, connections
The person vs the behaviour: english law is a “guilt society” → punishing behaviour, tikanga is a “shame society” → how does behaviour reflect on the mana of the person, whanau, hapu, iwiw
collective vs indivudal responsibility
rebalance vs punishment: tikanga the aim is to restore balance, and ask what went awry for thhe person who caused harm and everyone around them, “systems review”
Omission-based vs action-based liability: Tikanga is almost entirely omission bassed → collective failute to prevent harm, there is no “accident”. → there is mana in admitting liability, but admission is the start of the process → in ECJS openness disadvantages maori (whakama example)
substance of wrongs: tikanga focus on reputation
summarise the key diferences between enlish and tikanga
Tolmie: the key diference is not what is wrongul. It is how liability is construed (collectively) and the pupose of the process (repair and rebalance, not punishment of an individual). Serious consequences, including death, were still possible
guilt society vs shame society
guilt: did behaviour happen, then punish
shame: effect on the mana of the collective, aimed at reintegration
why is tikanga liability omission based
collective failure to prevent harm, no offenderless harm, no offernderless crime, no accidents
Kohuru vs patu
kohuru involves treachery, no justification.
Patu is killing that may be justified
why was family violence serious
violation of tapu,
imbalance in whanau, hapu and iwi
leading to damage to whanaungatanga and whakapapa
what is “muru”
ritual stripping of goods, redress without bloodshed, normally it will be planned by collective agreement → better chance at achieving ea
what is pana
banishment, no necessarily permanent, with aroha. → placed under another communitys mana
why cant whakama be resolved alone
it is relational → others must end it, or it may become chronic and intergenerational overtime → can erupt in violence
what is Metges point on guilty pleas
maori treat whakama and confession as part of the punishment, and the courts misreading disadvantages them.
what is whakama
embarrassed, ashamed, humiliated, but without an attatched sense of blame
it is relational: loss of mana in the eyes of peers
cant be resolved alone
if left unresolved it becomes chronic and integeneration and can erupt in violence
what are 3 sanctions in tikanga
Muru
pana
whakama
what is the general response to Kohuru and family violence
Kohuru: death of perpetrator or a kin member, compensation (e.g transfer of land), or symbolic killing
Family violence: financial restitution, offender could be declared “dead”, ignored by everyone, this severs whanaungatanga → seen as a serious punishment
first maori trial
Maketu wharetotara → executed, maori jurors refused
what was the maori objection behind the 1844 ordinance
imprisonment degraded mana → they didnt belive theft was acceptable, they saw imprisonment as pointless under tikanga
key features of the 1844 ordinance (governor fitzroy)
chiefs approval for warrants
20 pound bond
4x valye for theft paid to victim
avoided imprisonment
later extended to assault → shows direction NZ could of gone
what did Governor Grey change
replaced the 1844 ordinance with resident magistrates (1846),
keeping fines, but removed chiefs approval
a result of pakeha complaints
what was s 71 of the 1852 consitution act (aboriginal districts)
Aboriginal districts → never implemented
allowed districts where maori custom would be maintained, unless repugnant to the general principles of humanity
not seen as radical at the time
europeans who breached tikanga in those districts would be accountable
idea of parallel system / hybrid
williams J on colonial v modern recognition of tikanga
colonial recognition was temporary and assimilationist;
modern recognition is permanent and transformative
what did waitangi tribunal say regarding maori soverignty in NZ
Rangatira did not cede sovereignty in 1840
Article 2 vs article 3 claims
Article 2: separate maori justice system and accomodation (maori never ceded sovereignty → waitangi tribunal 2014)
Article 3: equality and overrepresentation
Mason ratio
Crimes act ss 5 and 9 extinguish any customary criminal system → not a parallel system (mason rejection)
where is custom more amenable per mason
sentencing, not trial
Iti case ratio
Tikanga is relevant to assessing “reasonable”, but not determinative
important to get tikanga expertise, diferent world views see “reasonable” diferently → dont want to impose pakeha world view
Rudelle ratio
cultural context evidence in self defence, still rejected self defence in this case → brought in expert evidence on family violence → pressure of maori women to nurture and look after people (aroha and manaakitanga)
-
Courts can hear evidence of tikanga as it goes to issues of reasonableness to help educate the jury
So that the jury isnt just bringing there own life experience and bias to the way they view a fact scenario
is tikanga present in statute
largely absent
what are the tikanga statutory exceptions
Majori exception → Oranga Tamariki Act 1989 (mana tamaiti, family group conferences)
Minor exception → Sentencing Act ss 8 and 24A cover restoritave justice and 27 provides culturual reports
critique of s 27 sentencing act reports
they come after guilt, are not always funded or valued, and are not transformative
what is meant by “indiginous window dressing” - Tolmie
solutions-focused and marae courts that leave state law and the indivual focus in tact
the point is that Māori elements get added to the surface of existing Pākehā institutions while the underlying system stays the same. It's like decorating a shop window without changing what's sold inside.
what did the Ellis majoirites say
3:2 majority the appeal should continue post death
however a diferent majority 3:2 said tikanga was not material to the outcome
what was held to be “unanimous” in Ellis
Tikanga is recognised in the development of the common law where relevant, and in statute, discretions and public bodies
What are the limits on tikangas role
not where contrary to statute or binding precedent
Ellis process safegaurd
a wananga of experts produced a statement of tikanga, admitted by agreement
what are the steps under s 200 (Defendants → name suppression)
Threshold → 200(2)
Discretion
what are the steps under s 202 (name suppression)
Victim or connected person → s 202(1)
threshold 202(2)
then discretion
Extreme hardship vs undue hardship
extreme is very high and something “out of the ordinary”
Undue is lower: more than the inevitable hardship (parker)
what does “likely” mean regarding name suppression
A real and appreciable possibility
standard at the discretion stage
the balance must clearly favour suppression (D v Police)
R v A case brief
A had heart condition, “significant” risk of cardiac event given by doctor if publication. (use for identifying extreme harship)
B and C → relevant for whakama and mana discussion → the crown had offered no evidence, charges were dismissed, so threshold would have been met given this outcome, combined with “the inevitable and heightened whakama and loss of mana”.
First case recognising whakama and mana at the name suppression threshold
judge also commented on whakama at the discretion stage
R v R/ Parr outcome
Appellant found not guilty by insanity for killing his former partner, and his mother seperately years later on.
He had been released from mental health facility weeks before his mothers death → High PI in how the state agencies performed, risk he posed, and to V family.
appeal was on discretion stage only (undue harship for whanau as victims was made out) → did tikanga and the whanaus harship through whakama outweigh open justice, at least while he remained in a facility?
Appeal dismissed, overwhelming public justice favoured Open justice. The Tangihanga supports open and transparent justice process, what happened on the marae was consistent with open justice
what was the relevance of the Tikanga expert evidence at appeal regarding the discretion stage in R v R/Parr v R
Kohuru is discussed openy at the tangihanga to esnure transparency and restitution, and that happened at a marae
Tikanga expert evidene said publication beyond that context would “afflict extra uru on both whanau who are grieving… and coping with the whakama”
and said it would be “excessive punishment” and a “new level of utu” risking an “intergenerational quagmire of trauma”
Importance is that tikanga experts can be involved at this discretionary stage → whakama/mana effects potentially relevant
→ crown stated that Tikanga supports open and transparent justice process, and what happened on the marae was consistent with open justice → shows tikanga can cut both ways (it is not a shield)
also stated criminal law is codified, so tikanga does not have “unfretted rein”.
SC postscript of parr v R relevance?
tikangas affect on “public interest” at this discretionary stage in name suppresion is a question of general or public importance
Parr was an appropriate vehicle but tikanga was raised late
SC is inviting a future case where tikanga has real impact on outcome at this discretionary stage with regars to public interest
Mikaeres position on future directions
Tikanga is the law, incorporation keeps it subordinate
main risks of incorporation (future directions)
subordination
coloniality
bastardissation
use against maori
net widening through collective responsibility
Reforming options (future directions)
revived rearly colonial models: Aboriginal districts, native ordinance, resident magistrates
a parrallel system
a hybrid system
→ suggestion form Williams J “third law” - hybrid
Tikanga and name suppression PQ engine
identify the applicant and the provision: a D → s 200 (T,D), a victim or “connected person” (st peters college)→ s 202 (CP,T,D)
start from the presumption: open justice → SC in Erceg describes open justice as a principle of “constitutional importance” → maintains public confidence in CJS
Threshold stage: extreme hardship to D? or Undue harship to Victim or connected person?
tikanga arguments at threshold stage → whakama can elevate harship (metge), loss of mana, whakama relational = relevant to undue harship to victims
comparator cases for threshold: R v A (EH on likely health ground, whakama and mana would of met it for B and C). → Norman-Henry (health alone not enough, needs likely consequence → successufl chemotherapy dude)→ need tikanga expert, who can i ask about this
Discretion stage: even when threshold is met, the balance must “clearly favour” suppression (D v Police) → factors OJ, seriousness of offending, Public Interest, presumption of innocence, freedom of expression, V interests.
Tikanga can also inform discretion stage (Parr v R) → but cuts both ways → crown in this case successfully argued tikanga supports OJ
weigh the case specific merits
conclude on both stages
what is the relationship between tikanga maori and state criminal law today essay structure
parallell system → No (mason) , Te Tiriti article 2 still grounds the claim however
matter of fact → yes tikanga goes to reasonablness in defences and elements (iti, rudelle)
statute → tikanga is mostly absent from criminal statutes (exception of oranga tamariki act 1989 and sentencing act 2002)
institutional design → Rangatahi and matariki courts, Te Ao Marama, iwi panels, restorative justice (subject to “window dressing” critique)
value of the common law → Ellis (tikanga “has been and will continue to be” recognised where relevant) → tikanga also informs discretions such as name suppression
Normal-Henry v R relevance
impact on publication on a compromised immune system after a successful chemotherapy was not enough for EH
Risk must be serious and well evidenced like in A (doctor)
when tikaka arises in the exam what are the 3 key questions
what is the legal question → identify the offence, defence, statutory power or discretion
how is tikaka relevant → He poutama, explain the relationships, obligations and values engaged by the facts
what diference does it make → est the relevant tikaka via appropriate evidence
remember: recognition of tikaka does not itself establisha. defence, guarantee suppression or remove the courts jurisdiciton. → explain the legal route before reaching a result
key line for where tikaka arises
tikaka maori is a complete legal system, with its own principles, authority and responses to harm when tikaka arises
indiviudal accountability cf collective harm
state system: generally focuses on a individuals conduct, guilt and punishment
tikaka approach: places the person within histories, whakapapa and relationshiops, askin ghow conduct aggects the collevtive mana and balance → responsibility may arise from collectives failure to prevent harm, even without individual knowledge
detterence and accountability operate through those relationships, rather than only through punishment of teh individual
how can tikaka affect evidence and context
exam use → identify the precise element affected, explain what the evidence helps us understand and why it matters to the legal test
purpose: evidence about tikaka may help the court understand a persons relationships and obligations. → that understanding can affect the application of standards such as reasonableness
r v iti: tikaka may inform what amounts to “reasonable cause”
R v Rudelle: evidence about aroha, manaakitanga and relationships may explain cultural pressures to remain with or care for an abusive partner
tikaka in statutory provisions
oranga tamariki act 1989
sentencing act → s 8: requires consideration of personal,family, whanau , community and cultural backgrounds when sentencing → restoritave justice → enables information abu toffenders background and cimmunity to support or responses
Tikaka in express statutotry provisions
rangatahi and matariki processes, marae based diversion, restorative justice , te ao marama
note these remain state processes
tikaka in common law
tikaka may inform the development of legal principles and the exercise of powers (Ellis v R) → relevant to common law
e.g name suppression: act does not expressly mention tikaka, but evidence of mana, whakama, whanau and relationships still help est the nature and extent of hardship, and inform the later exercise of discretion
can tikaka displace the courts jurisdiction
ss 5 and 9 crimes act 1961 precluded a competing customary criminal jurisdiction (r v Mason)
structure for arguing tikaka should affect a legal decision (the ellis route)
Is tikaka relevant here
explain the connection to the legal issue → e.g whanau relationship may explain why publication causes harm beyond the D. Naming a conecept is insufficient wihtout explaining its effect.
how can tikaka operate with the governing law
identify the relevant provision, standard or discretion → explain whether tikaka infroms the facts. → remember to respect statute and binding precedent
How is the relevant tikaka established
identify the evidence or authority supporting the claimed principle and its application → appropriate expertise may be needed, especially where disputed (pukenga)
preserve tikakas integrity as an interconnected legal system, avoid picking and choosing
what diference does it make
explain its effect, weigh its significance along other factors
tokaka and other legal principles may support the same outcome or point diferent direction.
illustration→ ellis: whakapapa, mana and ea helped explain why an unresolved wrong could continue to affect descendents and the wider collective after death. → those interests considered alongside finalitt, practicality, possible miscarriage of jsutice and complananits itnterests
how and when should tikaka be considered
SC in Ellis unanimously recognised that tikaka can be relevant to common law development, legislation, directions and public body processes
its relationship with the common law develops case by case