1/32
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the ultimate goal of every contract?
Both parties fully perform their duties so they can walk away with no further liability
Unconditional vs. Conditional performance
Most duties are unconditional (must perform no matter what). Some are conditional — performance is required only if a specified condition occurs (common examples in real estate: financing contingency or “sale of current home” contingency).
What is tender of performance?
An unconditional offer by one party to perform their duties right now (“I am ready, willing, and able to perform”).
Complete performance
Doing exactly and fully everything the contract requires. This is the best way to be discharged from further obligations.
Substantial performance
Performing in good faith almost all the essential parts of the contract. Minor deviations remain. Common in construction. The party who substantially performed can still enforce the contract and demand payment; the other party may receive a small credit for the difference in value.
Jacob & Youngs v. Kent (1921)
Contractor used a slightly different (but nearly identical quality) brand of pipe than specified. Court held the contractor had substantially performed. Homeowner had to pay the remaining balance minus a small credit for the difference in pipe cost. Forcing demolition would have been commercially unreasonable.
Material breach vs. minor breach
Material breach = performance falls below the level of substantial performance (significant failure). Innocent party is excused from remaining duties and may sue for damages.
Any breach (even minor) allows a lawsuit for damages, but only a material breach lets the innocent party walk away completely.
“Time is of the essence” clause
Makes timely performance a condition of the contract. Missing the deadline becomes a material breach. Common in real estate contracts. If no deadline is stated, courts imply a “reasonable time.”
Discharge by full performance
The cleanest and preferred way parties are released from further duties.
Rescission (by agreement)
Both parties agree to cancel the contract. Easy if little performance has occurred. If one party has already performed substantially, the other must usually give new consideration to make the cancellation valid.
Novation
Parties agree to substitute a new person for one of the original parties. The original party is fully released from further liability.
Accord and Satisfaction
Parties agree to accept a different performance than originally required. “Accord” = the new agreement; “Satisfaction” = performing the new agreement.
Material alteration of the contract
One party unilaterally changes an important term without the other party’s consent → the other party is discharged by operation of law.
Statute of Limitations (Prescription in Louisiana)
Waiting too long to sue bars the claim. Louisiana examples: breach of contract (up to 10 years), promissory note (5 years), credit-card debt (3 years), personal injury/property damage (1 year).
Impossibility of performance
Performance becomes truly impossible (death or incapacity of a necessary party, destruction of the subject matter, or a change in law making the contract illegal). Both parties are discharged.
Commercial impracticability
Something beyond a party’s control makes performance extremely difficult or expensive (but not literally impossible). The duty is temporarily suspended and resumes once the problem is resolved.
Primary goal of contract damages
Make the innocent (non-breaching) party whole — put them in the same financial position they would have been in if the contract had been fully performed.
Requirements to recover damages
Losses must have been foreseeable at the time the contract was made, and the breach must be the proximate cause of the losses.
Compensatory damages
Cover direct losses and out-of-pocket costs caused by the breach. In goods contracts: difference between contract price and market/cover price (or lost profits if goods were never manufactured).
Consequential damages
Extra losses caused by special circumstances that the other party knew or should have known about when making the contract.
Example: A business tells a supplier it needs a machine by a certain date or it will lose customers. The supplier delivers late, causing the business to lose money.
Hadley v. Baxendale (1854)
Mill owners did not tell the carrier they had no spare crankshaft. Carrier delayed return of the shaft and the mill shut down. Court denied lost-profit damages because the special circumstances were never communicated. Rule: special circumstances must be disclosed in advance for consequential damages to be recoverable.
Punitive damages
Awarded to punish and deter extremely bad behavior. Hard to obtain. In Louisiana, generally require extremely outrageous conduct plus either a specific statute or a contractual provision allowing them (examples: child sexual abuse, drunk-driving wrongful death).
Nominal damages
Small amount ($1–$5,000) awarded when a legal wrong occurred but the plaintiff cannot prove actual financial loss. Recognizes that a right was violated.
Duty to mitigate damages
The injured party must take reasonable steps to reduce their own losses. Failure to mitigate reduces the damages award. Classic example: a wrongfully terminated employee must actively look for comparable work.
Liquidated (stipulated) damages
Parties agree in advance on the amount of damages for breach. Enforceable only if (1) actual damages were difficult to estimate at the time of contracting, and (2) the amount is a reasonable estimate (not a penalty). Common in construction (“$X per day for delay”).
Rescission + Restitution
Rescission cancels the contract; restitution requires both parties to return whatever money or property they already exchanged. Usually requires agreement or a court order based on a defense (fraud, duress, etc.).
Specific performance
Court orders the breaching party to actually perform the contract. Rarely granted. Most common for unique real estate. Generally not available for ordinary goods or personal-service contracts.
Reformation
Court corrects a clerical or mutual mistake in the written contract (example: wrong property description). Used only to fix mistakes, not to rewrite terms one party later dislikes.
Quasi-contract as a remedy
A court requires someone to pay for a benefit they received, even without a contract, to prevent them from unfairly benefiting for free.
Election of remedies
A party may plead alternative remedies but cannot obtain double recovery. Only one remedy is ultimately awarded.
Limitation-of-remedies clauses
Parties may agree to limit available remedies. Courts will not enforce clauses that try to eliminate liability for intentional breach, fraud, or illegal acts.
Home Solicitation (Cooling-Off) Rule
When a seller contacts a consumer at home (door-to-door, phone, etc.), the buyer has 72 hours to cancel the contract in writing. Notice only needs to be sent within 72 hours.
Hold-harmless and indemnification agreements
Hold-harmless: One party agrees to assume the liability of the other arising from performance of the contract.
Indemnification: One party agrees to pay the other party’s costs, losses, attorney fees, and judgments. Common in leases where the operator (e.g., oil company) protects the landowner.