Success of Authoritarian States

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/3

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

4 Terms

1
New cards

Establishing control - Hitler - Successes

  • Legal Revolution & One-Party Dictatorship (1933): Exploited the Reichstag Fire (Feb 1933) to pass the Reichstag Fire Decree (suspending civil liberties and arresting 4,000+ communists) and the Enabling Act (March 1933) (granting four years of dictatorial rule by decree); abolished trade unions (May 1933) and banned all opposition parties (July 1933 Law Against the Formation of Parties), establishing a legal one-party state within six months.

  • Subjugation of Traditional Elites & The Wehrmacht (1934): Eliminated internal SA radicals in the Night of the Long Knives (June 1934) (executing 85–200 leaders, including Ernst Röhm) to appease conservative elites and the military; upon President Hindenburg’s death (August 1934), merged the offices of Chancellor and President into FĂĽhrer (ratified by an 89.9% plebiscite) and bound the 100,000-man Wehrmacht to a personal oath of unconditional loyalty.

  • Gleichschaltung (Coordination) & Popular Consensus: Dissolved state parliaments (Jan 1934), centralized policing under Himmler’s SS/Gestapo, and absorbed civil society into Nazi organizations (DAF, Hitler Youth); combined economic recovery (cutting unemployment from 6.1 million to under 1.6 million by 1936) and foreign policy triumphs (1935 Saar Plebiscite, 90.8% vote) to secure genuine majority consent alongside terror.

  • Ian Kershaw & Karl Dietrich Bracher: Kershaw argues Hitler successfully established control through "working towards the FĂĽhrer" and the "Hitler Myth"—where elites and ordinary citizens voluntarily radicalized policies to win his favor, generating authentic popular consensus; Bracher counters that this apparent consensus was built upon a calculated "legal revolution" and swift coercive terror in 1933–1934 that destroyed pluralist institutions before organized resistance could form.


2
New cards

Establishing control - Hitler - Failures

  • Incomplete Gleichschaltung of the Churches & Traditional Institutions: Despite the 1933 Reichskonkordat and the state-backed Reich Church, Hitler failed to fully Nazify German Christianity; over 7,000 pastors joined Martin Niemöller’s Confessing Church, while Pope Pius XI’s 1937 encyclical Mit brennender Sorge (read from 11,000 Catholic pulpits) and Bishop Galen’s 1941 sermons forced the regime to officially halt the T4 Euthanasia Program (though it continued covertly).

  • Persistent Youth Non-Conformity & Working-Class Dissent: Even after making the Hitler Youth mandatory (8.8 million members by 1939), working-class Edelweiss Pirates (numbering several thousand across Rhineland cities) and middle-class Swing Kids actively rejected Nazi regimentation, while underground socialist/communist networks (Sopade) distributed millions of anti-Nazi leaflets and workers engaged in over 400 localized strikes between 1933 and 1937 over wage freezes and longer hours.

  • Polycratic Chaos & Elite/Military Conspiracy: Rather than creating a monolithic, efficient dictatorship, Hitler’s overlapping party-state agencies (SS, SA, Wehrmacht, Four-Year Plan) bred administrative paralysis and infighting; moreover, high-ranking military and conservative elites were never fully co-opted, plotting coups during the 1938 Oster Conspiracy and culminating in the July 20, 1944 Valkyrie Bomb Plot (where over 7,000 people were arrested and 4,980 executed).

  • Hans Mommsen & Martin Broszat: Mommsen argues Hitler was a "weak dictator" whose polycratic regime suffered from chronic structural chaos, administrative overlap, and an inability to completely eradicate traditional institutional autonomy; Broszat counters that this institutional rivalry actually accelerated radicalization—forcing competing Nazi agencies to outbid one another in implementing extreme policies rather than limiting Hitler's ultimate authority.


3
New cards

Establishing control - Mussolini - Successes

  • Legal Dictatorship & One-Party State (1923–1928): Secured a parliamentary majority via the 1923 Acerbo Law (winning 64.9% of the vote in April 1924 through Squadristi intimidation), survived the 1924 Matteotti Crisis by exploiting the opposition’s Aventine Secession, and passed the Leggi Fascistissime ("Most Fascist Laws," 1925–1926)—ruling by decree, banning rival parties/unions, and eliminating democratic elections via the 1928 Electoral Law (restricting voters to a single 400-candidate Fascist list).

  • Subjugation of Party Radicals & Elite Compromise: Neutralized militant Ras (provincial Fascist bosses) by purging over 150,000 party members in the late 1920s and subordinating the MVSN militia to state control; secured conservative acceptance by preserving King Victor Emmanuel III and signing the 1929 Lateran Treaty with Pope Pius XI (ending the Roman Question, granting Vatican sovereignty and 1.75 billion lire, and yielding a 98.3% "Yes" vote in the 1929 plebiscite).

  • Mass Consensus & Leisure Co-optation (1929–1936): Embedded Fascist influence in daily life through the ONB (Balilla, 7 million youth members by 1937) and OND (Dopolavoro, 4 million adult members), while achieving peak domestic popularity ("years of consensus") following the conquest of Abyssinia (May 1936), which defied League sanctions and sparked mass patriotic rallies across Italy.

  • Renzo De Felice & Emilio Gentile: De Felice argues Mussolini successfully established durable control by combining pragmatic compromises with traditional elites (Monarchy, Church, big business) and populist welfare, achieving genuine mass consensus by 1936; Gentile counters that this consensus was manufactured atop a totalitarian police state (OVRA, 10,000+ sent to confino) that systematically destroyed civil liberties and pluralist politics.


4
New cards

Establishing control - Mussolini - Failures

  • Incomplete Totalitarianism & Dual Power (Monarchy and Church): Unlike Hitler, Mussolini never merged the roles of Head of Government and Head of State—King Victor Emmanuel III retained supreme command of the armed forces and the constitutional power to dismiss him (which he exercised via the Grand Council of Fascism’s 19–7 vote on July 25, 1943); simultaneously, the 1929 Lateran Treaty left the Catholic Church and Catholic Action (Azione Cattolica, 1+ million members) independent, frequently clashing with Fascist youth groups over ideological primacy.

  • Administrative Incompetence & Trasformismo Corruption: Mussolini deliberately centralized power by holding up to seven cabinet ministries simultaneously (including Foreign Affairs, Interior, and War), creating chronic administrative bottlenecks; rather than creating a disciplined "New Fascist Man," the PNF absorbed over 2.6 million opportunistic members by 1939 ("tessera del pane" or "bread card" joiners), perpetuating traditional southern clientelism, corruption, and regional stagnation.

  • Superficial Cultural Penetration & Collapse of Consensus (1938–1943): Popular support eroded rapidly after the 1938 Racial Laws (which alienated both ordinary Italians and Pope Pius XI) and disastrous WWII defeats in Greece, North Africa, and the USSR; by March 1943, over 100,000 industrial workers staged crippling strikes in Turin and Milan—the largest open labor rebellion in Axis-occupied Europe—proving Fascist control lacked deep ideological roots.

  • Hannah Arendt & Denis Mack Smith: Arendt famously classified Mussolini’s Italy as a "non-totalitarian dictatorship" because surviving traditional institutions (the Monarchy, Church, and Army) fatally constrained Fascist control; Mack Smith adds that Mussolini’s theatrical vanity, poor administration, and reliance on sycophantic subordinates left the regime structurally hollow and unable to survive military crisis.