1/56
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Why when a co becomes insolvency, do Ds need to be very careful in how they act?
May be held personally liable to compensate co/ its creditors
→ if found guilty of fraudulent trading/ wrongful trading
Fraudulent trading can be brought by who?
Liquidator or administrator
Fraudulent trading can be brought against?
Any person,
Who is knowingly party to the carrying on of any business of the co,
With intent to defraud creditors/ for any fraudulent purpose.
What must be proven for a claim for fraudulent trading to succeed?
& this means?
Actual dishonesty
→ means FT claims are very rare = high standard of proof required to receive
There is a corresponding… for fraudulent trading
Criminal claim
Wrongful trading claims, may be brought by?
A liquidator, or administrator
Wrongful trading claim may be brought against?
Includes?
Any person who was a director at the relevant time
Incls de jure/ de facto/ non-executive/ shadow directors
Are there criminal proceedings for Wrongful Trading?
No
(But are for FT)
Fraudulent consequences v wrongful trading consequences - sanctions
criminal sanctions i.e. imprisonment!
Wrongful trading - requirements:
court must be satisfied that at some point before the commencement of the winding up/ insolvent administration, the director…
…
….
Knew/ ought to have concluded that there was no reasonable prospect that the co would avoid going into insolvent liquidation/ administration
Continued trading
+ that continued trading made the company’s position worse
Wrongful trading - insolvency test?
On balance sheet test only
(Assets are insuff for the payment of its debts)
Wrongful trading - defence - a director may be able to escape liability if they can satisfy the court that they took…
Every step w a view to minimising the potential loss to the CO’s creditors
Wrongful trading - what test does the court apply?
Elements?
Court will apply?
The reasonably diligent person test
OBJ: general knowledge/ skill/ experience expected of a person carrying out functions of D
+SUBJ: the actual knowledge/ skill/ experience of that partiuclar director ie.. if qualified accountant!!
The higher of the 2 standards
Wrongful trading - what practical steps can be taken to protect against any such claim?
holding freq meetings to review company’s financial position + voice concerns + minute this
Seek indep professional advice - financial + legal
Up to date financial info
Suggest reduction of costs
Don’t incur more credit
Wrongful trading - can a D escape liability by resigning?
Can only do so if….
No - this could be an act of WT!
→ only resign if constantly outvoted by other Ds & no way of persuading them
What happens to a person found liable of wrongful trading?
the loss?
can be ordered to make contribution of Co’s assets as the court thinks proper (the loss = the additional depletion from continuing to trade)
+ may also be disqualified (for up to 15 years)
Voidable transactions - who has the ability to challenge transactions here?
Liquidators + administrators
Voidable transactions - what transactions can be challenged - timeframe = this taken place within…
Statutory periods prior to insolvency
…
Voidable transactions aka…
Antecedent transactions
What is the aim of challenging voidable transactions? = to…
&thereby…
Restore the co to the same position it would have been in, had the transaction not take place
& thereby→ increase the funds available in the insolvent estate for the benefit of creditors
Voidable transactions; qs to ask / conditions
X4
Did the transaction involve a connected person/ associate?
Did it take place w/in the relevant time?
Was the co insolvent at the time of the transaction, or become insolvent as a result of the transaction?
Is there a presumption available which shifts the BOFP from liquidator/ administrator, to the other party?
Voidable transactions - who is the target of the proceedings?
The beneficiary of the transaction w the insolvent co
(Not the directors of the co responsible for entering into the transaction)
The 4 different types of voidable transactions
Transactions at an undervalue (TUV)
Transactions defrauding creditors (TDC)
Avoidance of floating charges
Preferences
Transactions at an undervalue?
within…
Provided the company…./…
Presumption?
2 years prior to the onset of insolvency
Company insolvent at the time of transaction/ became insolvent as a result of transaction
Insolvency presumed where transac took place w a connected person
TUV - what?
gift/ transaction for significantly less consideration than the co gave.
TUV
can be brought by?
Liquidator/ administrator
TUV - reqs x 3
Gift/ transaction
W/in relevant time (2 years from onset of insolvency)
Co was insolvent at time of transaction/ became insolvent as a result
TUV - what is the ‘onset of insolvency’?
…
TUV - defence
good faith
For purpose of carrying on business
Reasonable grounds for belief in benefit
TUV - remedies?
a common one?
Court can order as seems fit to restore position as if co had not entered into the transaction
→ pay amount of undervalue
TUV - remedies - what if sold on to bona fide 3rd party
Cannot then get back this property? (Unaware)
Key diffs TUV/ TDC
insolvency?
Time period restrictions?
Who can bring claim?
Difficulty/ ease of bringing?
TDC- co can be solvent
No time period restrictions
Other people can bring claim - not just liquidator/ administrator
But less common/ harder to bring → as need to prove intention to defraud
‘Co was insolvent’ - test?
cash flow/ balance sheet test
→ for TUV/ TDC/ avoidance of floating charges/ Preference
__- test only
→ wrongful/ fraudulent trading
Transactions defrauding creditors - TDCs
what?
Does co need to be insolvent?
transaction for an undervalue
+ intention to defraud creditors
No
TDCs - requirements
There has been a TUV
Intention/ purpose of TUV was to put assets beyond reach of credtiors/ otherwise prejudice their interests
TDCs - who can bring a claim?
administrators
Liquidators
Supervisors of …..
Victim (creditors)
TDCs - remedies?
anything court sees fit, to put in position but for the transaction
TDCs - time limit re transactions?
No
TDCs can be brought in respect of something any time in the past
Preference = aim is to prevent…
A creditor from obtaining an improper advantage
Preference - who can bring a claim?
liquidators
Administrators
Preference - requirements/ elements x5
Person is a creditor
Company allowed something to be done to put the creditor in a more advantageous position
Company is insolvent/ as a result
W/in relevant time
Desire to prefer the creditor
Preference - relevant time here? X2
w/in 6 months ending with the onset of insolvency
Or w/in 2 years (if connected person)
Preference - defence
Absence of a desire to prefer (subjective)
I.e. were just under commercial pressure!
Preference - remedies
Court order to restore position to pre-preference
Ie. Restoration order→ to get £ into pot to distribute to creditors
Preference
have to have a ?
Presumed
desire to prefer the creditor (can prevent lots of claims)
Presumed desire to prefer where connected person & then burden shifts to them to rebut the presumption
Note: preferences apply to _ as well as creditors
Guarantors
(I.e. guarantor of the debts, so in setting the debt they are in a better position in the event the co goes insolvent, than otherwise would have been in)
Avoidance of floating charges - who can bring this?
liquidator
Administrator
Avoidance of floating charges - is an application to court needed?
no!! (Unlike other voidable transactions)
Advoidance of floating chargers - requirements
Floating charge created w/in the relevant period
Co insolvent at time of creation/ made insolvent as a result of the charge
No consideration??
Avoidance of floating charges - relevant period here?
12 months
Or 2 years (if connected person)
Avoidance of floating charges - presumption?
Insolvency presumed if connected person
Avoidance of floating charges - defence
New money/ fresh consideration
Preference - remedies
Floating charge void (/invalid)
NOT the debt!! → this is still valid, i.e. will just be an unsecured creditor in respect of the debt & could still recover
Def of connected person under the insolvency act!! (Note this is different from under companies act!!)
Connected person, if:
is a director of the co,
Or an associate of a director
…COMPLETE
What could you be liable for generally failing to comply with director duties?
Incl for a …
Misfeasance
(TUV)
Individual bankruptcy - TUVs?
Where consideration provided?
Look back period?
Do they have to be insolvent?
Presumption?
Is a friend an associate?
Was sig. less than provided by the bankrupt.
w/in 5 years
Yes if after 2 years i.e. transferred 2-5 years ago then there is a req for insolvency at the time of the transfer?
Of insolvency where TUV w/ an associate
No
‘Associate’ meaning under insolvency act - incls…
Spouses, relatives,
trustees of a trust where the debtor is a beneficiary
Employers/ employees/ business partners of the debtor
A co under debtor’s control