1/88
All the terms for the final exam in Dr. Keleher's NMSU Intro to Philosophy class (might be helpful for others too).
Logic
The branch of Philosophy concerned with identifying and evaluating arguments
Epistemology
The branch of Philosophy concerned with the scope and nature of knowledge
What can we know?
How can we know it?
Metaphysics
The branch of Philosophy concerned with questions of ultimate reality
Does God Exist?
Do ghosts exist?
Ethics
The area of Philosophy concerned with how we should/shouldn’t act
What is good/right and what isn’t?
Logical consistent
When all propositions are true at the same time
Logical inconsistent
When it is impossible for all propositions to be true at the same time.
Causally possible
It does not violate the laws of nature
Happens in real life
Logically possible
It doesn’t contain a contradiction
It can be imagined
Philosophical definitions
A set of necessary and sufficient conditions for a term/concept
Necessary condition
q is necessary for p if it is impossible for something to be p without q
Being a shape is necessary for being a triangle, it is impossible to be a triangle and not be a triangle
Sufficient condition
q is sufficient for p if it is impossible for something to be q and not p
Being a triangle is sufficient for being a shape, it is impossible to be a triangle and not be a shape.
Necessary and Sufficient condition
When something fits a 1-to-1 description of something else
Being a triangle is necessary and sufficient for being a shape with three sides
Deductive argument
Premises aim to support the conclusion.
Certainly true
Evaluated by validity and soundness
Valid argument
If all the premises are true, then the conclusion must also be true
Matter of form, not content
Modus ponens
If P, then Q. P, therefore Q.
Modus tollens
If P, then Q. Not Q, therefore not P.
Disjunctive syllogism
Junction
Either p or q. Not p, therefore q.
Hypothetical syllogism
Hypothetical
If p, then q. If q, then r. Therefore if p, then r.
Sound argument
A valid argument with all true premises
Inductive argument
Premises aim to provide some support for the conclusion
If the premises are true, the conclusion is likely to be true
Enumerative argument
Arguments from observations or generalizations
Argument by analogy
Because x and y are similar in certain respects, they must also be similar in others
Inference to the best explanation
Arguments that assert that a certain explanation is the best explanation
Ockham’s Razor
A is better than B if A is simpler than B
Principle of conservatism
A is better than B if A fits together better with my beliefs about the world
Allegory of the Cave
An allegory following Socrates and Glaucon about a man who was chained in a cave with others and only sees shadows in flames, that is his reality. He leaves the cave and is momentarily blinded by the light of the real world before his vision clears and he understands better what reality is.
Philosophy is the turning of the souls to the light
Camus Myth of Sysiphus
Human life is absurd and it is important to find personal meaning in daily endeavors
Sisyphus must be described as happy despite his punishment
Propositional knowledge
Knowledge - that
“I know that ____”
Knowledge - how
“I know how to ____”
Knowledge of acquaintance/experience
“I know Veronica”
“I know Mexico City”
Knowledge
Justified True Belief
Gettier cases
Cases in which justified true belief does not amount to knowledge
Often happens when someone’s claim is accidentally correct, they don’t actually know that it’s true
Skepticism
We cannot prove that our beliefs are true, so we can only have beliefs and not knowledge
Universal skepticism
We cannot claim knowledge about anything at all
Local skeptic
We cannot claim knowledge about certain subjects, or cannot trust certain sources of knowledge
Cartesian method of doubt
One doubts all his beliefs to identify the beliefs he actually thinks are true
Cogito ergo sum
I think, therefore I am
Descarte’s argument for why she exists
If you doubt, you think, if you think, you are. If you doubt, you exist.
Solipsism
You can only know the content of your own mind
Empiricism
Beliefs are best justified by our senses
Empirical evidence - observed
Truth by experience
Naive realism
The world is exactly how we perceive it
Indirect realism
The world doesn’t have all the properties we perceive
Our senses are liars
I.e. objects look like they have color, but they actually don’t
Idealism
To be is to be perceived
The physical world is just a manifestation of thoughts; reality is created by collective thinking
Problem of Induction
We cannot only justify claims empirically even if the events are similar to previous events we have experienced
i.e. This plane will fly, because it flew yesterday
Begging the question
Assuming the conclusion of an argument is true during the argument
Rationalism
Beliefs are best justified by reasoning
Logic and Mathematics
A priori
Prior justification
A justification that occurs only before consulting empirical evidence
A posteriori
Posterior/latter justification
A justification occurs only after consulting empirical evidence
Necessary Truth
It is true in every possible world
Contingent truth
It depends on the actual state of the world
Analytic truth
True by virtue of the meaning of the words in the sentence
“All bachelors are married”
Truth by definition
Synthetic truth
The words hold a proper relationship with the world
“Fred is a bachelor”
Anslem’s Ontological Argument
God is the greatest conceivable being
Reality is always greater than thoughts
If he only existed in the mind he would not be the greatest conceivable being
Therefore, God exists
Aquinas’ Five Ways
Nothing can move by itself without something greater
If nothing can exist without what came before it, there had to be one thing to start it all
If there once was nothing and everything came from something then there has to be a necessary cause
Some things are better than others so there must be a “best” standard by which everything follows
Humans act as an end to a means out of knowledge, but since natural things act toward an end there must be something commanding them to do so
Therefore, God exists
Pascal’s Wager
It is in your best interest to believe in God
Believing in God is low risk, high reward
Not believing in God is high risk, low reward
The Problem of Evil
If there is an AAA God, then Evil Cannot exist. Evil does exist, therefore an AAA God can’t.
Theodicies
AAA God(s) do exist, but there is no true evil (needless suffering)
Any suffering in existence exists for a reason
Fideism
Faith and reason are hostile toward each other and faith is a superior method of truth
Theist
Believes that there are good reasons an AAA God exists
Atheist
Believes that there are good reasons an AAA God does NOT exist
Agnostic
We cannot know whether or not an AAA God exists
Classical God
An All-Loving, All-Powerful, and All-Knowing being that created the universe
Arguments from Religious Experience
A posteriori argument
Personal experience justifies the belief of God
Cosmological arguments
A posteriori argument
Infer that there must be a necessary being
“The cosmos exists, therefore God must also exist”
Expected utility
Reasonable expected outcome of an action
Outcome’s utility (happiness/pleasure) multiplied by the probability of it happening
Moral intuition
Sense of right and wrong
Moral principles
Rules to help us classify right and wrong
Ethical Objectivism
There are at least some moral truths for all people at all times
Ethical Relativism
No moral truth exists
Ethical Subjectivism
Moral truth is in the eye of the beholder
“Eating meat is wrong for me”
Cultural Relativism
Moral truth should be determined by a person’s particular culture
Divine Command Theory
An action is morally right if God says so
Utalitarianism
An action is morally right if it maximizes the happiness of everyone affected
Quantitative utalitarianism
All pleasures and pains can be calculated
Qualitative Utalitarianism
Some pleasures and pains cannot be measured/calculated equally or at all
Hedonic Calculus
Calculation of hedons (pleasures) and dolors (pains)
Obligatory actions
Actions that are morally required
Supererogatory Actions
Above and beyond actions
It is morally obligated not to kick a puppy, but it’s praiseworthy if you additionally feed the puppy and pet it
Deontology
An action is morally right if the motive behind the action is right
Kant’s Duty Ethics - do not treat morality as an end
Good Will
Under Kant, the only thing that is naturally good without qualification
Categorical Imperative
Duty Ethics
Nicomachean Ethics
What is the best life for a human being and how does he come to live it?
Ergon Argument
The good of any thing lives in its purpose/function
If someone is naturally good at poetry, they should be a poet
Eudaimon Life (Good Life)
A life spent in accordance with virtue. Evaluate your circumstances and act accordingly with what you are good at/have access to
Virtuous person
Makes a habit of evaluating their circumstances and act in accordance with virtue
Continent person
Acts in accordance with virtue, but not as a habit and has to actively struggle to do the right thing
Incontinent Person
Knows what virtue requires, but does not act virtuously
Vicious person
Is mistaken about what is virtuous and always acts in extremes
Rachels Cultural Relativism
It is arrogant to discount other cultures beliefs, and there is no universal truth
Nussbaum’s List
A good life must have:
Life until a natural age
Bodily health
The ability to freely move
Senses, imagination, and thought
Emotions/attachments
Practical reason/moral intuition
Empathy, connections, and dignity
Relationships to other species
Play/Enjoyment
Control over one’s political and material environment