1/15
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is cognitive dissonance theory?
Proposed by Leon Festingar in 1957. It is a broad abstract theory that attempts to explain how individuals deal with conflicting beliefs, values or attitudes. The theory is built on the idea that people naturally desire internal consistency and harmony, and when there is cognitive dissonance, individuals are motivated to relieve the pressure. Aka the reactions people have when ‘prophesy’ fails.
What are the origins of Cognitive Dissonance theory?
Appearing as a result of study of natural disasters, individuals noticed that anxiety justifying rumours around disasters occurring increased as a function of distance from the natural disasters. Festingar infiltrated Marion Keech’s group, who experimented with automatic writing ‘messages from Sananda’, who predicted the idea that a world-ending flood was coming. The day came, and the flood did not occur. Festingar observed the cognitive dissonance presented by followers/seekers.
What are conditions in which people might be more committed to a belief after being proven wrong?
What is cognition?
An element of knowledge that could be about an environment. Cognitions can be dissonant (where the opposite one follows from the other) , or consonant ( one cognition follows from the other)
How can dissonances be reduced?
BELIEF CONFIRMINATION PARADIGM
Describe the belief confirmation paradigm?
Induces a belief is highly resistant to change Information disconfirms belief, and info is difficult to discard Paradigm tests of dissonance is reduced by increasing social support & persuading others For example, participants are exposed to a problem like this
Then the individual's affirmative action attitude was measured in another scenario. They found that feminists who failed to solve problems judged the decision to hire men as less just and had a more positive attitude toward affirmative action.
Describe Batson’s study?
Teenagers were asked to sit on either side of a room depending on their belief in jesus They completed a measure of belief in Jesus as a son of God – they read an article that claimed that Jesus was a hoax. Measured belief in Jesus and articles. Only 24% of believers accepted the discomforting article as true. Non-doubting beliefs showed the greatest change in belief pre and post test. Reflects strengthening of initial belief as a result of challenges to that belief.
Describe Burris, Harmon-Jones, & Tarpley study?
Participants were exposed to a newspaper article that evoked dissonance.
Transcendence was measured before or after exposure to news articles and agitation was measured According to cognitive dissonance theory, those who had more transcendence before the article were more likely to have high agitation, compared to those who engaged with transcendence after the article. That is, transcendence DECREASED agitation - confirming the cognitive dissonance theory
Describe the study 2 in the Burris, Harmon-Jones, & Tarpley study?
exposed to a similar news article. And were exposed to no questionnaire, distractions questionnaire and religious affirmation questionnaires. Once again they found that the religiously affirming group after the exposure to the news article experienced less agitation, supporting the cognitive dissonance theory.
Describe Harmon-Jones, Harmon-Jones, & Denson (2020) study?
Measured support for Trump online, and had individuals exposed to news article about Trump's alleged sexual assaults OR a neutral article about space exploration Measured intention to share the following memes on their social media account, and measured how accurate they thought the info was. Those who supported trump & and the article were most likely to share the meme – supporting the strengthening of original belief and attempt to resolve the cognitive dissonance. .
DISSONANCE AFTER A DECISIONS PARADIGM
Describe free choice dissonance after the decision paradigm?
States that individuals after making a choice, will generate positive and negative cognitions between preferences between choices. Generally pos. aspects of chosen & neg. aspects of rejected are consonant cognitions neg. aspects of chosen & pos. aspects of rejected are dissonant cognitions easy decision = no change in ratings of chosen & rejected • difficult decision = change
What is effort justification?
Suffering for something can cause us to find it more desirable. The unpleasant effort is dissonant with our desire to do such. Dissonance should be greater the more unpleasant the activity, and therefore (according to the cognitive dissonance theory) exaggerating the attractiveness of the outcome can reduce the dissonance
Explain the study around effort justification?
Had women participate in sex discussion group and manipulated the difficulty of joining groups. Controls - just listened to the grp. Discussion Mild - read erotic words to experiments Severe - read erotic stories to the experimenters Those who found it more difficult to get INTO the group found that group discussion more interesting.
Explain the study around the induced compliance
Individuals are required to do a long boring task for a long time. A confederant informs the individuals that they actually need individuals to pretend the task is really interesting for the next individual. And individuals were paid 1 or 20 depending on their condition. They found that individuals who were paid a dollar found the boring task – more enjoyable.
Do other studies have also used a choice paradigm to induce dissonance?
Individuals were induced to have high or low dissonance using high or low choice manipulation. They found that - Low choice to engage in behaviour – many consonant cognitions, High choice to engage in behaviour – few consonant cognitions They found that commitment (generative cognition) to undergo an uncomfortable state can cause cognitive changes to reduce the dissonance . particularly when action is not externally justified.