1/43
Looks like no tags are added yet.
confirmation bias
names our fundamental tendency to seek and incorporate information that is consistent with our current beliefs and theories, while avoiding, not comprehending, or putting less weight on ideas that potentially disconfirm our naive conceptions
A physician believes a patient has COVID-19, so they focus entirely on the patient’s cough and fever while ignoring the patient’s severe right-lower quadrant abdominal pain, which points to appendicitis
in-group bias
pervasive pattern of favoring members of one’s own social, professional, or ideological group over those outside of it
a medical director rates applicants who graduated from their own program as more qualified than applicants from other universities with identical test scores and clinical evaluations
availability heuristic
illustrates our tendency to judge the relative number of instances or the probability of an event by the ease with which relevant instances are recalled or imagined
a doctor who treated a rare case of meningitis yesterday evaluates a new patient with a simple headache and immediately orders a spinal tap because of the memory of meningitis in their mind
anchoring
Stick to the initial presentation (or first piece of information presented) in the process of comprehension or problem solving, to the point of abandoning additional presentations that may be relevant
an emergency physician reads a triage note stating a patient’s blood pressure is high and focuses entirely on managing hypertension, ignoring other symptoms that indicate another condition
sunk cost
tendency to continue an endeavor, course of action, or investment simply because we have already invested time, effort or emotional energy into it
a researcher continues funding a $5 million drug trial that shows zero therapeutic benefit because they have already spent $4 million over three years and do not want it to “go to waste”
above average heuristic
Belief we are better than the average person in positive traits, and below average in negative traits
in a survey of 100 surgeons, 90% of them rate their surgical skill as being in the top 10% of their profession
Diagnostic creep
gradual widening of diagnostic criteria over time, expanding the list of symptoms, which lowers the threshold for what is classified as a disease, disorder, or abnormality
the diagnostic criteria for ADHD are revised to include not just hyperactivity and inattention, but also disorganization and procrastination broadening the total scope of symptoms
diagnostic expansion
Lowering the threshold for diagnostic symptoms
lowering the threshold for diagnosing hypertension from 140/90 to 130/80 classifies millions more people as having the disease
premature closure
failing to consider other possibilites once an initial diagnosis has been reached and sticking to that diagnosis
a clinician diagnoses a patient presenting with SOB as having asthma after asking 2 questions, failing to consider or test for PE
contradiction
one is true and one is false
the patient is alive and the patient is dead
incompatibility
cannot both be true at the same time, but both could be false or one could be true one could be false, leaves space for a third possible explanation
today is Tuesday, today is Wednesday
base rate neglect
focus specifically on case-by-case information, while completely ignoring or under-weighting the background statistical probability or base rate of an event occurring in the general population
test for a rare disease (1 in 10,000) has a 99% accuracy rate. Patient tests positive and assumes they have a 99% chance of having the disease without taking into account the extremely low base rate in the general population
satisficing
individual chooses the first option that meets a threshold of adequacy or satisfies minimum requirements, rather than investing the time and energy to find the optimal solution
Buying new hospital chairs, instead of researching for the best option, they buy the very first model that has basic comfort and is cheap
belief preserverence
tendency to cling to an initial belief, hypothesis, or conviction even after the initial evidence supporting it has been discredited
a person believes that ulcers are caused by stress, and even after medical studies proving H. pylori bacteria causes most ulcers they continue to insist stress is the only cause
survival rate
measures the percentage of people with a specific condition who remain alive for a specific length of time
expressing cancer outcomes at 90% 5-year survival rate sounds encouraging
mortality rate
measures the frequency of death in a total population over a given time period
10% 5-year mortality rate causes more anxiety
descriptive vs normative
descriptive- focus on empirical facts, observations, and what actually is
only 40% of adults get an annual flu vaccine each year (how things currently are)
normative- focus on values, standards, ethics, and what ought to be
all adults ought to get an annual flu vaccine to protect public health (how things should be)
sufficient, necessary, supportive conditions
sufficient- factor that if present guarantees the outcome would occur, however another alternative could also produce the same outcome
decapitation is sufficient to cause death (it alone guarantees outcome)
necessary- factor that must be present for an event to occur, A is required for B
having a functional liver is necessary to survive
supportive- accelerates the likelihood of an outcome occurring
regular exercise is a supportive condition for heart health (helps and contributes, but does not guarantee immunity)
declarative knowledge
facts, data, or information someone can consciously recall
knowledge that the heart has 4 chambers
procedural knowledge
knowledge of operations, procedures, strategies, or action rules
how to execute various strategies
knowing how to ride a bike
absolute vs relative risk
absolute- the actual, true probability or chance that an event will occur in a specific group of people over a given period of time
a medication reduces your individual risk of a stroke from 2% to 1%
relative- compares the risk in a specific group to the control
the same medication reduces your risk of stroke by 50% relative to the untreated group
lead time bias
makes a screening test or early intervention appear to prolong a patient’s life, even when it had no impact on the time of death
when disease is detected earlier, it shifts the starting point of the survival clock backwards changing the natural endpoint of the disease
a new screening test detects pancreatic cancer 3 years earlier than standard methods. Patient diagnosed via screening live 5 years after diagnosis, while unscreened patients live 2 years after diagnosis; however, both groups die at age 65 because the early detection did not change the ultimate outcome only lengthened perceived survival time
overdiagnosed bias
screening tests or overly sensitive diagnostic criteria identify abnormalities that look like disease under a scanner, but never would have cause symptoms, health problems, or death during the patient’s life if left undiscovered
routine prostate screening detects a benign tumor that would have never caused symptoms of harm during natural lifespan
cognitive vs affective empathy
cognitive- capacity to identify and comprehend another’s emotions or perspective
a physician logically understands that a patient is experiencing grief after a terminal diagnosis and can explain why they feel overwhelmed
affective- capacity to appropriately respond emotionally to another’s mental state, can take the form of sympathy or personal distress and anxiety in response to another’s suffering
a physician physically feels sadness and distress in their own body when witnessing a patient cry after receiving bad news
deductive vs inductive evaluation
deductive- if all premises are true than the conclusion must be true
5>3, 3>1, then 5>1
assume the premises are true, the sentences don’t have to be true under the assumption that the premises are true, then the conclusion must also be true
all mammals have lungs, a dolphin is a mammal, a dolphin has lungs
inductive- if the premises are true than the conclusion is probably or likely to be true
evern raven observed in the study has been black, research observed 10,000 across different continents, the next raven observed will likely be black
attribution bias
doctor arrives late to a clinic, and attributes it to severe traffic, but when a patient arrives late, the doctor assumes the patient is lazy and unmotivated
overestimate internal factors when judging someone else’s behavior, while attributing our own behavior by external factors
What are the 5 main sources of SES bias?
Sources
cultural stereotypes- links low SES to moral failings, lack of discipline, or non-compliance
biological/psychological misconceptions- flawed assumptions relate lower SES with biological or cognitive inferiority
Notions of responsibility- assuming that knowledge equals responsibility, thinking that giving a patient information will fulfill their needs or blaming them for health outcomes without accounting for whether they actually have the financial or structural resources
ignorance- lack of awareness regarding the systemic barriers faced by lower income individuals
risk taking- biased assumption that lower SES patients deliberately engage in risky behaviors
5 main consequences of SES bias
Tests- not done, delayed, not referred
Studies- lower SES populations are frequently omitted from research and deemed undesirable
differential care- base the quality of treatment on the patient’s SES and occupation
treatment- generic/defensive, protects the doctors or the hospital rather than tailoring treatment to patient’s individual needs
reduced trust- SES bias reduces the patient’s trust in the healthcare system
(patients of lower SES less likely to be perceived by the doctor as intelligent, independent, responsible, rational, or compliant. Causes delayed diagnostic testing, more generic medication prescriptions, and less referral to specialty care.
5 main sources of race/gender orientation bias
cultural stereotypes- linking racial or ethnically minioritized groups to negative generalizations such as pain exaggeration, drug-seeking behavior, or non-compliance
biological/psychological misconceptions- flawed assumptions that racial groups have fundamental biological differences (false beliefs about thicker skin or different pain thresholds)
notions of responsibility- assuming patients from racial minority groups are responsible for health disparities without accounting for systemic racism, language barriers, or environmental factors
ignorance- lack of awareness regarding implicit biases, historical medical mistreatments, and cultural competencies
risk taking- biased assumptions that specific racial or ethnic groups engage in higher risk health behaviors by default
5 main consequences of race/gender/sexual orientation bias
tests- critical diagnostic tests or pain assessments are not done or delayed
studies- minorities are underrepresented or omitted from clinical trials, leading to treatments optimized for dominant demographics
differential care- varying the speed or quality of care based on a patient’s background
treatment- generic/defensive- under-prescribing effective treatments or applying generic algorithms rather than individualized care
biases leads to decreased trust in medical system from those in minority groups
4 domains of medical errors, causes, prevalence, consequences, and examples
patient-physician interaction- inferior communication between the doctor and the patient
causes- mental state and temperament of physician influence judgement, emotional state of patient, relational disparities- cognitive (differences in attitude), epistemic (gaps in medical knowledge and expertise, social and external (inequities in power, status, class, or wealth)
prevalence- relational disparities and power imbalances exist across clinical encounters
consequences- impacts physician decision-making by disrupting clinical dialogue, prevents clear and effective communication, leads to increased risk of medical errors
doctor dismisses a patient’s reported medication side effects over the phone due to being in a bad mood or misunderstanding what the patient said, resulting in severe untreated toxicity
diagnostic error- patient’s health problem is not accurately identified and explained to the patient
causes- labeling and identifying of samples in the lab, wrong interpretation of x-rays, CT scans, and MRIs, lack of time for deep evaluation, education, overconfidence, common inferential mistakes and fallacies
prevalence- 42% of patients report having at least one misdiagnosis
consequences- delayed or withheld treatment, harm from unnecessary treatment, psychological and emotional stress
physician misdiagnoses a benign tumor as metastatic cancer leading to months of unnecessary and toxic treatment
hospitals- high risk of infection
causes- inadequate hygiene or sterile technique, leaving indwelling devices in patients for too long, hospital overcrowding
prevalence- 1 in 38 hospitalized patients has at least one hospital-acquired infection
consequences- increased mortality, prolonged hospital stays cause financial burden
hospital staff does not identify signs of dehydration and misses a central line infection which causes septic shock
defensive medicine- doctor orders unnecessary tests/procedures to reduce risk of medical malpractice lawsuit rather than acting in best benefit of patient
causes- fear of medical malpractice litigation and uncertainty
prevalence- estimated between 70-90% of physicians admit to practicing defensive medicine
consequences-unnecessary medical risks of procedures, overtesting increases healthcare costs, overreferral increases wait times
physician orders unnecessary invasive biopsies for harmless mass to avoid potential lawsuit, exposing patient to surgical risks
External, personal, and cognitive reasons for misdiagnosis
external- lack of time for deep evaluation, tests not available, background noise
personal- lack of education, overconfidence, inability to collaborate, burnout, fatigue, physician and patient state of mind or body
cognitive- common inferential mistakes and fallacies, heuristics and biases in assessment, ego-related misconceptions
What are the types of empathy? Why is the distinction important?
cognitive empathy- capacity to identify and comprehend another’s emotions or perspective
affective empathy- capacity to appropriately respond emotionally to another’s mental state, can take the form of sympathy or personal distress in response to another’s suffering
psycopathy- lack of affective empathy, strong cognitive empathy
autism- strong affective empathy but not cognitive, don’t understand what you’re going through
explains certain behaviors, could help improve burnout in caregivers
Waste, harm, and irrationality
waste
stents are often placed for stable angia- chest pain when heart does not get enough blood during exercise, in a trial patients given a placebo procedure, and compared to the placebo stents had no greater effect on angia pain, improvement in symptoms attributed to lifestyle changes
ordering routine chest x-rays, ECGs, or blood panels prior to low-risk, non-cardiac surgeries in asymptomatic patients- unnecessary costs and rarely alters treatment
harm
geriatric populations are frequently admitted for falls or delirium but are inappropriately taking many long-term medications or sedating drugs prescribed for previous minor stressor, failure to reevaluate prescription list causes harm to patient
contagious infections acquired during hospitalization such as central line associated bloodstream infections result from improper aseptic technique or inadequate hand hygiene
irrationality
shortcut taking- 4 y/o boy came to ER with chills and enlarged lymph nodes and diagnosed with fever without looking at vital signs, upon reassessment had a dangerous blood bacteria from overlooked apendicitis by taking a heuristic shortcut
prescribing broad-spectrum antibiotics for viral upper respiratory infections- driven by patient demand, time constraint, or “just-in-case” despite knowing they have 0 effect on viruses
What are the differences between mortality/survival rate and between relative/absolute risk? How can illiteracy about these concepts be used to mislead?
mortality vs survival rate- lead time bias
relative vs absolute risk- can convince people about a new drug/treatment
out of 1000 4 people have a heart attack without a drug
out of 1000 2 people have a heart attack with a drug
drug reduces risk by 50%
What biases exist in medical journal, medical pamphlet, and website reporting? Why do they matter?
publication bias- studies with positive, statistically significant, or novel findings are more likely to be published than those showing negative or non-significant results
funding- research sponsored by pharm companies more likely to yield conclusions favorable to the sponsor’s product
overrepresentation of white males- findings not generalizable
confirmation bias in citing other studies
framing bias- relative instead of absolute risk
selection bias- highlight benefits while omitting side effects or risks
baises mislead patients into believing certain studies/information, taking certain drugs or treatments
5 main consequences of defensive medicine
increased healthcare costs and financial waste- leads to billions in extra spending each year on unnecessary diagnostic imaging and redundant lab work
unnecessary physical harm and exposure to risk- exposes patients to medical risks such as radiation from scans, unnecessary invasive biopsies
over diagnosis and overtreatment- uncovers benign asymptomatic abnormalities that never would’ve caused harm
effects patient-physician relationship- approaches patient as a litigant instead of a collaborative relationship, reduces communication and trust
over-referral- causes longer wait times for those that actually need to see a specialist
List and explain 5 main causes of medical errors and offer remedies
inferior doctor-patient communication- shorter visit time causes ineffective communication- make sure physicians allocate enough time to consultation and promote clear communication strategies
misdiagnosis- causes overuse or misuse of treatment, enforce strict clinical guidelines to verify the necessity of a procedure, promote collaboration with other healthcare professionals for second opinions on diagnosis
medication errors- prescribing the wrong medication or dosage, enforce consultations with pharmacists to prescribe
Hospital stays → infection risk- enforce strict aseptic and sterile technique
defensive medicine → establish legislation that will protect physicians from liability if they can prove they adhered to evidence-based clinical practice guidelines
List and explain the types and sources of knowledge
declarative- facts
procedural- certain skills
sources
innate- born with
natural- live and learn
deliberate- comes from books and teaching
procedural innate- infant reflexes such as sucking and grabbing
declarative natural- avoiding things that are dangerous or harmful, fire is hot
natural procedural- throwing a ball
declarative deliberate- history
procedural deliberate- laboratory protocol
evaluating where are knowledge comes from and how it is structured can help to eliminate bias
What is metacognition? What are the main misconceptions regarding its nature? Explain the domains of metacognition
“thinking about thinking” ability to understand and control your own learning and thought processes.
metacognition- large host of higher-order abilities to think about our cognitive operations such as problem solving, learning, social interaction, comprehension, attention, and creativity
misconceptions- it is automatic and unchangeable, rather skills that can be learned and improved over time
metacognitive knowledge- awareness of our cognitive states (awareness of learning needs and current study readiness)
metacognitive monitoring- awareness of our performance (realizing you read without understanding, identifying repeating questions)
metacognitive control- refine or revise cognitive devices/level of engagement (changing a study technique to a new unknown topic)
List and evaluate the types of scientific studies
experimental- perform a specific intervention, do something to affect the nature or subjects and then measure some specific outcome
pros- replicable, isolate 1 variable, helps to show cause and effect
cons- may not represent real world experience, not always practical
observational- gather large amounts of data, compare different groups, reduces the risk of affecting the natural behavior of the system by minimizing intervention
pros- less ethical limitations, easy to see trends/patterns/correlations, minimize negative interventions, natural behavior
cons- takes a long time, no causations, uncontrollable variables
Prospective study- chooses subjects or objects and then observes their behavior into the future
pros- measure in real time, real patients
cons- hard to compare to other subjects, patient may subconsciously change their behavior knowing they are being watched
retrospective study- look back at events and outcomes that have already occurred to analyze relationship between past exposure and present outcomes
individual studies- in cases of extremely rare phenomenon, single standalone experiment
metaanalysis- combines multiple studies into a new statistical analysis
6 major differences between science and pseudoscience
falsifiability- science relies on testable hypotheses that can be proven false, whereas pseudoscience relies on unfalsifiable claims that cannot be tested or disproven
precision and measurement- science demands precise data and controlled observations, whereas pseudoscience relies on vague claims, errors in perception, or selective data mining
logically consistent arguments, definitions, conclusions, pseudoscience uses logic when convenient
replication- scientific findings must be replicable by independent research and subject to peer review, pseudoscience offers no review
predictive errors- scientific theories are updated or discarded when predictions fail, pseudoscience predictive failure is ignored and mistakes are rationalized
evidence vs emotions- science aims to convince through evidence and logical evaluation, pseudoscience incorporates emotional elements aimed at convincing
6 dangers of adopting pseudoscience
financial- pseudoscience promoters survive by selling questionable or useless products (horoscopes, crystals, palm reading)
harmful health decisions- patients may rely on unproven explanations that can delay or replace medical treatments
harms critical thinking- encourages belief based on pattern recognition and emotional appeal without concrete scientific evidence
misallocation of resources- time, money, scientific efforts wasted investigating claims that lack falsifiability
manipulation- emotional appeals lead to individuals being more susceptible to scams and misinformation
rejection of proven scientific knowledge- embracing pseudoscience fosters distractions in established scientific consensus
Why is scientific and critical reasoning important?
protects personal finances- no money going into useless products like horoscopes, crystals, palm reading
prevents harmful health decisions- rely on evidence based clinical medicine rather than unproven alternatives
strengthens decision making vs emotional appeal- evaluating concrete evidence versus relying on emotions and gut feeling
ensures efficient resource allocation- money going toward useful scientific studies
Protects against scams and misinformation
defends established science and truth
Helps us overcome inherent faults in thinking like implicit bias, inferential mistakes and fallacies
Encourages replicability and falsifiability- allows others to evalute, peer review, and improve