1/19
Vocabulary terms and definitions covering the Problem of Evil, Boethius's theodicy and compatibility thesis, and David Hume's critique and four sources of misery.
Boethius
An aristocratic Roman philosopher (c.475–c.526) appointed by King Theodoric to high office, later executed on false charges of treason and magic, who bridged classical thought and the Middle Ages with his translations of Aristotle and his work 'The Consolation of Philosophy'.
David Hume
A Scottish Enlightenment philosopher, historian, and empiricist (1711–1776) who challenged religious theodicy, notably in his posthumous work 'Dialogues concerning Natural Religion' (1779).
Theodicy
A theological or philosophical defense of divine goodness, justice, and power in the presence of evil and suffering.
Compatibility Thesis (Boethius)
The philosophical position holding that human free will is compatible with universal divine foreknowledge.
Riddle of Epicurus
An ancient philosophical dilemma recorded by Lactantius questioning why evil exists if God is both willing and able to remove it.
Omnipotence
The divine attribute of being all-powerful.
Omniscience
The divine attribute of being all-knowing.
Omnibenevolence
The divine attribute of being all-loving and willing good alone.
Inconsistent Tetrad
A set of four propositions in the problem of evil where at least one must be false: God is omnipotent; God is omniscient; God is omnibenevolent; Evil exists.
Deism
The philosophical view that a god or gods created the world but no longer interacts with it.
Theism
The philosophical view that a god or gods created and maintains a sustaining, personal relationship with the world.
Fate (Boethius)
The ordering and direction of the world resulting from natural processes.
Providence (Boethius)
God's continuous sustaining of and intervention in the natural world, directed toward rewarding the good, exercising virtue, and punishing or correcting the wicked.
Foreknowledge is Distinct from Cause
Boethius's resolution to the paradox of divine foreknowledge, arguing that things do not happen because they are foreseen, just as our seeing present things does not impose necessity upon them.
Hume's Architect Analogy
A thought experiment comparing the universe to an uncomfortable, ill-built palace: just as defects lead one to condemn the human architect, flaws in the world undermine belief in a wise, powerful, and benevolent Deity.
Hume's Four Sources of Misery
The four circumstances beyond human free will identified by David Hume as responsible for the ills of sensible creatures: pain and the struggle for survival, governance by general laws, limited powers and faculties, and the inaccurate workmanship of nature.
Pain and the Struggle for Survival (Hume)
Hume's first source of misery, noting that sensible creatures are driven to self-preservation by pain as well as pleasure, though pleasure or its diminution alone could have achieved the same purpose.
Governance by General Laws (Hume)
Hume's second source of misery, stating that the universe operates through fixed, uniform causes and effects rather than constant divine intervention to exterminate ill.
Limited Powers and Faculties (Hume)
Hume's third source of misery, pointing to the extreme frugality with which nature endows creatures with abilities, leaving humans prone to idleness rather than endowed with industry and vigor to prevent harm.
Inaccurate Workmanship of Nature (Hume)
Hume's fourth source of misery, describing the imperfect balance of natural forces—such as winds becoming hurricanes, rain being defective or excessive, and bodily humours failing—which cause disaster and disease.