1/55
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Why trade is political
Trade can expand markets, lower prices, encourage specialization, and increase consumer choice. Its gains are uneven: consumers and exporters may benefit while import-competing firms and workers lose. Comparative advantage concerns relative opportunity costs, not simply who produces most efficiently. Governments weigh efficiency against employment, development, security, health, and environmental goals.
From ITO to GATT to WTO
The proposed International Trade Organization was too ambitious for the political support available, particularly in the United States. GATT, signed in 1947 by 23 countries, offered a narrower, provisional agreement. Its limited institutional demands helped secure participation. Negotiating rounds reduced tariffs, but persistent protection in agriculture and textiles, growing non-tariff measures, and weak dispute settlement encouraged reform. The Uruguay Round (1986-1994) produced the WTO, which began operating in 1995. GATT goods rules continued within the WTO framework.
The Uruguay Round bargain
Developed countries sought stronger commitments on services and intellectual property; developing countries sought market access in agriculture and textiles. Linking these agendas enabled exchanges of concessions. The single undertaking made package bargaining possible, but also made agreement harder when members disagreed on important parts. Inclusion of an issue did not guarantee that all countries would gain equally.
The Uruguay Round bargain: Developed countries wanted
Services, intellectual property, Investment-related rules
The Uruguay Round bargain: Developing countries wanted
Agriculture, textiles, special and differential treatment
Most favored nation treatment (MFN)
compares foreign origins: an advantage for like products from one trading partner normally extends to other members, subject to recognized exceptions
MFN example
A lower border tariff for one foreign origin
National treatment (NT)
compares imported and like domestic products in internal taxation and regulation.
NT example
a higher internal tax on imports than on like domestic goods
MFN Rule
A lower tariff offered to one member must usually be offered to all
NT Rule
Do not use internal taxes or rules to disadvantage imports
What is a tariff
a tax on imports
What is a bound tariff
is an agreed ceiling, not necessarily the applied rate
Non-tariff measures
Licensing, standards, quotas, and regulatory requirements. Such measures can serve legitimate objectives while affecting trade
What did GATS address
Services, where barriers often concern permission to operate, ownership, or licensing.
What does TRIPS govern
intellectual-property standards. Deeper commitments therefore reach domestic policies, generating sovereignty debates.
Why did GATT's weakness help it survive?
inherent limitations and "provisional" status made it flexible enough to adapt to political, economic, and legal realities that a more rigid, formalized trade organization could not.
How does package bargaining facilitate agreement and create deadlock?
Even if some members were not fully satisfied with every item, the overall package could be acceptable enough to secure consensus, especially when the package was tied to broader political or economic goals. As rounds grew larger and more complex, the number of issues in a package increased, making it harder to identify and resolve disputes. This "package problem" was a key factor in the stagnation of the Doha Round, where members could not agree on a comprehensive package
Subsidies and Countervailing Measures (SCM): Red/Prohibited Subsidies
Subsidies tied to export performance or the use of domestic over imported goods (No proof of adverse trade effects required)
Subsidies and Countervailing Measures (SCM): Yellow/Actionable Subsidies
May be challenged if they cause adverse effects to another WTO member, such as targeted support that harms foreign competitors (not automatically prohibited)
Subsidies and Countervailing Measures (SCM): Green/Former Safe Harbor
Certain research, regional development, and environmental adaptation subsidies once qualified (Expired on Dec 31 1999)
Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures (SPS Agreement)
protect human, animal, or plant life or health; scientific justification and risk assessment matter. The salmon and hormone-treated-beef disputes illustrate scrutiny of regulatory design, not a prohibition on health protection.
What is Dumping
Exporting below normal value, usually the comparable home-market price—not merely selling cheaply.
What do anti-dumping duties require
dumping, injury, and causation
What do Countervailing duties address
s subsidized imports under their own legal requirements.
What is the highest authority in the WTO
The Ministerial Conference
What does the general council handle
ongoing work and also meets as the Dispute Settlement Body and Trade Policy Review Body
How do WTO members typically vote
by consensus
How are disputes handled
typically begin with consultations, followed when necessary by panels, report adoption, appeal where available, and implementation.
What is negative consensus
adoption unless members agree to reject a report, the losing party cannot simply veto it
Does the WTO have an independent sanctions force?
No.
What impacts the outcome of a WTO legal proceeding?
Litigation costs, expertise, administrative resources, and market size affect practical leverage
Doha Round
development agenda stalled over agriculture, competing priorities, and package agreement. Preferential trade agreements can promote liberalization and reform, but also divert trade and fragment rules
Why can a small country win legally but remain weak in enforcement?
A small WTO member can win a case legally because the WTO's dispute settlement system is designed to apply agreed trade rules impartially, regardless of a member's size or economic power. However, winning a ruling does not automatically mean enforcing it, because the system's enforcement relies on political and economic leverage, not just legal authority.
Distinguish anti-dumping duties, countervailing duties, and WTO-authorized retaliation
Anti‑dumping duties and countervailing duties are trade remedies targeting unfair pricing or government subsidies, while WTO‑authorized retaliation is a countermeasure against a WTO member's illegal or inconsistent trade measures.
Assess the WTO using both achievements and limitations, not an all-or-nothing judgment.
The WTO has achieved significant milestones such as lowering global tariffs, expanding membership, deepening trade integration, and strengthening dispute settlement, which have contributed to record trade growth, global value chain expansion, and poverty reduction
However, it also faces notable limitations, including stalled negotiations like the Doha Development Round, limited capacity to address modern trade issues such as digital commerce and environmental concerns, and uneven benefits that often favor developed economies
Overall, the WTO's record is mixed but substantial: it has been a cornerstone of multilateral trade liberalization and stability, yet its adaptability and inclusivity remain challenges that require reform to meet evolving global economic realities.
Defense of Patents
incentives for costly, risky research
Argument Against Patents
exclusive rights and prices can restrict access
What did TRIPS do?
linked minimum IP standards, including twenty-year patent terms, to WTO rules.
What is a compulsory license
Authorizes use without the patent holder's consent under conditions, including remuneration. It does not cancel every patent, transfer know-how, or confer marketing approval.
What is Parallel Importation
Concerns obtaining an authorized brand-name product from another market, subject to applicable rules—not authorizing generic production
Cipla
low-priced ARV offers made treating large numbers financially feasible; the chapter explicitly links this to donors considering support.
The 2001 Doha Declaration
Affirmed public-health flexibility, including members' rights to grant compulsory licenses and determine emergencies.
The August 2003 medicines decision
Addressed the cross-border supply problem where countries without sufficient manufacturing capacity still needed producers abroad
Differences between Doha Declaration and the wider Doha Round.
The former was a success while the later was a failure
What do Patents Need?
financing, suppliers, regulatory approval, procurement, distribution, and trained health workers
TRIPS-Plus Agreement
can impose stronger IP protection and constrain generic competition
What is Forum Shifting?
pursuing rules in institutions expected to offer more favourable outcomes
What other sources support access through financing and other initiatives, though their functions differ from WTO trade rulemaking and WHO health expertise?
PEPFAR, UNITAID, and the Global Fund
Brazil Negotiations with Merck
issued an efavirenz licence in 2007, initially imported generics, and later developed domestic production. Criticism and investment warnings were documented; comparable concrete retaliation was not established in our reviewed sources.
Rwanda Dependence
depended on overseas production and cooperation; deliveries in 2008-2009 managed that dependence rather than creating domestic capacity
Thailand and Abbott Contention
Faced Abbott's withdrawal of pending registrations for newer products, including a heat-stable HIV formulation—not withdrawal of all existing medicines.
Complications with COVID 19
Export restrictions, supply disruption, and vaccine nationalism complicated access.
June 2022 vaccine decision
narrower than the original waiver proposal, as it only waived patents on vaccines
Limitations on Patent Flexibility
cannot create technical expertise, inputs, manufacturing plants, or clinical delivery
What must be compared when evaluating access
legal authority, production capacity, financing, and bargaining power