1/55
Looks like no tags are added yet.
(1803) Marbury v. Madison (Background Summary)
William Marbury was appointed a justice of the peace by outgoing President John Adams, but Secretary of State James Madison refused to deliver his commission. Marbury asked the Supreme Court to order Madison to deliver it.
(1803) Marbury v. Madison (Question Before the Court)
Could the Supreme Court order Madison to deliver Marbury's commission, and did the Court have the constitutional authority to do so?
(1803) Marbury v. Madison (Constitutional Connection)
Article III of the Constitution; Judiciary Act of 1789; Supremacy Clause. Established judicial review, the power of courts to declare laws unconstitutional.
(1803) Marbury v. Madison (Opinion / Decision)
The Court ruled that Marbury was entitled to his commission, but the Supreme Court could not issue the requested order because the relevant part of the Judiciary Act of 1789 unconstitutionally expanded its original jurisdiction. Established judicial review.
(1819) McCulloch v. Maryland (Background Summary)
Congress created the Second Bank of the United States. Maryland tried to tax the bank, and bank cashier James McCulloch refused to pay the tax.
(1819) McCulloch v. Maryland (Question Before the Court)
Could Congress create a national bank even though the Constitution did not explicitly authorize one, and could Maryland tax that federal bank?
(1819) McCulloch v. Maryland (Constitutional Connection)
Necessary and Proper Clause (implied powers) and Supremacy Clause (federal law takes precedence over conflicting state law).
(1819) McCulloch v. Maryland (Opinion / Decision)
The Court upheld Congress's power to create the bank through implied powers and ruled that Maryland could not tax it. States cannot interfere with valid federal actions.
(1919) Schenck v. United States (Background Summary)
Charles Schenck distributed leaflets opposing the World War I draft and was convicted under the Espionage Act for attempting to obstruct military recruitment.
(1919) Schenck v. United States (Question Before the Court)
Did punishing Schenck for distributing anti-draft leaflets violate his First Amendment freedom of speech?
(1919) Schenck v. United States (Constitutional Connection)
First Amendment freedom of speech; limits on speech during wartime. The Court used the historical clear-and-present-danger test.
(1919) Schenck v. United States (Opinion / Decision)
The Court unanimously upheld Schenck's conviction, ruling that the speech in its wartime context could be punished under the clear-and-present-danger test. This historical test was later superseded by modern First Amendment standards.
(1954) Brown v. Board of Education (Background Summary)
Black students were required to attend segregated public schools separate from white students. Families challenged school segregation as unconstitutional.
(1954) Brown v. Board of Education (Question Before the Court)
Does racial segregation in public schools violate the Equal Protection Clause even if the schools are claimed to be equal in quality?
(1954) Brown v. Board of Education (Constitutional Connection)
Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause. Challenges the doctrine of racial segregation known as separate but equal.
(1954) Brown v. Board of Education (Opinion / Decision)
The Court unanimously ruled that racial segregation in public schools is unconstitutional because separate educational facilities are inherently unequal. Rejected Plessy v. Ferguson's separate-but-equal doctrine in public education.
(1962) Baker v. Carr (Background Summary)
Tennessee had not updated its legislative districts to reflect population changes for many years, leaving some voters in heavily populated areas underrepresented.
(1962) Baker v. Carr (Question Before the Court)
Could federal courts hear constitutional challenges to unequal state legislative districts, or was redistricting exclusively a political question?
(1962) Baker v. Carr (Constitutional Connection)
Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause; justiciability, meaning whether an issue can be decided by courts.
(1962) Baker v. Carr (Opinion / Decision)
The Court ruled that challenges to legislative apportionment could be heard in federal court. It paved the way for the one-person-one-vote principle established in later cases.
(1962) Engel v. Vitale (Background Summary)
New York public schools encouraged students to recite a state-written, nondenominational prayer. Some parents challenged the government-sponsored prayer.
(1962) Engel v. Vitale (Question Before the Court)
Does a government-written prayer in public schools violate the First Amendment even if participation is voluntary?
(1962) Engel v. Vitale (Constitutional Connection)
First Amendment Establishment Clause, which prohibits government establishment or sponsorship of religion; applied to states through the Fourteenth Amendment.
(1962) Engel v. Vitale (Opinion / Decision)
The Court ruled that government-sponsored prayer in public schools is unconstitutional, even if the prayer is nondenominational and voluntary.
(1963) Gideon v. Wainwright (Background Summary)
Clarence Gideon was charged with a felony in Florida and could not afford an attorney. The court refused to appoint one, and Gideon represented himself at trial.
(1963) Gideon v. Wainwright (Question Before the Court)
Does the Constitution require states to provide an attorney to defendants who cannot afford one in serious criminal cases?
(1963) Gideon v. Wainwright (Constitutional Connection)
Sixth Amendment right to counsel, applied to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment Due Process Clause (selective incorporation).
(1963) Gideon v. Wainwright (Opinion / Decision)
The Court unanimously ruled that states must provide attorneys to indigent defendants charged with serious crimes, including felonies. Gideon's conviction was overturned, and he received a new trial with counsel.
(1969) Tinker v. Des Moines (Background Summary)
Students wore black armbands to school to protest the Vietnam War. The school suspended them for violating its policy against the armbands.
(1969) Tinker v. Des Moines (Question Before the Court)
Did suspending students for wearing protest armbands violate their First Amendment rights?
(1969) Tinker v. Des Moines (Constitutional Connection)
First Amendment freedom of speech and symbolic speech, applied to public schools through the Fourteenth Amendment.
(1969) Tinker v. Des Moines (Opinion / Decision)
The Court ruled that the students' armbands were protected symbolic speech. Schools may restrict student expression when they can show it would materially and substantially disrupt school operations or interfere with others' rights.
(1971) New York Times v. United States (Background Summary)
The New York Times and Washington Post sought to publish the Pentagon Papers, classified documents concerning the history of U.S. involvement in Vietnam. The federal government tried to stop publication.
(1971) New York Times v. United States (Question Before the Court)
Could the federal government prevent newspapers from publishing classified documents by claiming national security concerns?
(1971) New York Times v. United States (Constitutional Connection)
First Amendment freedom of the press; prior restraint, meaning government censorship that prevents publication before it occurs.
(1971) New York Times v. United States (Opinion / Decision)
The Court ruled for the newspapers. The government had not met the heavy burden required to justify prior restraint of publication.
(1972) Wisconsin v. Yoder (Background Summary)
Amish parents refused to send their children to school beyond eighth grade because further formal education conflicted with their religious beliefs and way of life. Wisconsin prosecuted them under its compulsory-school-attendance law.
(1972) Wisconsin v. Yoder (Question Before the Court)
Did requiring Amish children to attend school beyond eighth grade violate their parents' religious freedom?
(1972) Wisconsin v. Yoder (Constitutional Connection)
First Amendment Free Exercise Clause, applied to states through the Fourteenth Amendment.
(1972) Wisconsin v. Yoder (Opinion / Decision)
The Court ruled that Wisconsin could not compel Amish children to attend school beyond eighth grade under these circumstances because it substantially burdened their sincerely held religious practices.
(1993) Shaw v. Reno (Background Summary)
North Carolina created a strangely shaped congressional district designed to increase Black representation. Voters challenged the district as an unconstitutional racial gerrymander.
(1993) Shaw v. Reno (Question Before the Court)
Can a congressional district drawn primarily on the basis of race violate the Equal Protection Clause?
(1993) Shaw v. Reno (Constitutional Connection)
Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause; racial gerrymandering and the use of race in redistricting.
(1993) Shaw v. Reno (Opinion / Decision)
The Court ruled that voters could bring an Equal Protection challenge. Districts in which race is the predominant factor in drawing boundaries are subject to strict scrutiny.
(1995) United States v. Lopez (Background Summary)
Alfonso Lopez, a high school student, carried a gun into school and was charged under a federal law banning guns in school zones.
(1995) United States v. Lopez (Question Before the Court)
Did Congress have authority under the Commerce Clause to prohibit gun possession near schools?
(1995) United States v. Lopez (Constitutional Connection)
Article I Commerce Clause; enumerated congressional powers and limits on federal authority.
(1995) United States v. Lopez (Opinion / Decision)
The Court ruled that Congress exceeded its Commerce Clause authority. Possessing a gun near a school was not sufficiently connected to interstate commerce to justify the federal law.
(2010) McDonald v. Chicago (Background Summary)
Chicago had strict restrictions on handgun possession. Residents challenged the city's rules after the Supreme Court had recognized an individual Second Amendment right to possess a firearm for self-defense in District of Columbia v. Heller.
(2010) McDonald v. Chicago (Question Before the Court)
Does the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms apply to state and local governments?
(2010) McDonald v. Chicago (Constitutional Connection)
Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms; Fourteenth Amendment Due Process Clause and selective incorporation.
(2010) McDonald v. Chicago (Opinion / Decision)
The Court ruled that the Second Amendment right recognized in Heller applies to state and local governments through the Fourteenth Amendment, limiting their ability to infringe that right.
(2010) Citizens United v. FEC (Background Summary)
Citizens United, a nonprofit organization, wanted to distribute a film critical of Hillary Clinton and advertise it close to the 2008 presidential primary. Federal campaign-finance law restricted certain corporate-funded election communications.
(2010) Citizens United v. FEC (Question Before the Court)
Could the government restrict independent political expenditures by corporations and unions under federal campaign-finance law?
(2010) Citizens United v. FEC (Constitutional Connection)
First Amendment freedom of speech, especially political speech; campaign-finance regulation and independent expenditures.
(2010) Citizens United v. FEC (Opinion / Decision)
The Court ruled that the government generally cannot prohibit corporations and unions from making independent political expenditures. The decision did not eliminate all campaign-finance rules or allow unlimited direct contributions to candidates