1/67
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Norden v Blueport Enterprises Ltd
A lessor can be held responsible for a breach of quiet enjoyment if they are aware of problematic behavior by one tenant that impedes the rights of another, provided the lessor has sufficient control over the situation. This expands liability to include the actions of other lessees or third parties.
Non-derogation from grant
The principle that lessors must not prevent the fulfillment of the lease's intended purpose.
Mount Cook National Park Board v Mount Cook Motels Ltd
A case illustrating non-derogation from grant where the Board's actions made the lease's purpose unachievable.
General principle for non-residential leases
No general implied principle or contractual term that premises must be suitable for the purpose they were leased
Residential Tenancy Act (RTA)
Legislation providing statutory requirements for habitability in residential properties.
Obligations of the lessee
Pay rent
Tenant-like manner
Yielding up possession
Doctrine of waste
Obligation to pay rent law
Property Law Act
Obligation to act in a tenant-like manner law
Warren v Keene
Doctrine of waste (tort)
A legal concept where acts by the tenant decrease the value of the property.
Implied covenants
Covenants automatically included in leases under the Property Law Act unless excluded, which include non-derogation from grant, quiet enjoyment, and other lessee obligations
Lessee powers
Power of entry
Power of cancellation
Termination
Power of entry
Lessor's right to enter the premises for inspection or repairs.
Power of cancellation
Lessor's right to terminate the lease under specified circumstances, such as unpaid rent.
Lesseeās right to termination
Lessee can terminate lease if premises become unusable for purposes specified in lease
Freedom of contract
The principle allowing parties to modify statutory implied covenants in non-residential leases.
Commercial v residential covenants
Merchants presumed to have equal bargaining power v tenants with less
Specifics of rental covenants
Rent as consideration
Accural and certainty
Liability
Accural
Under the PLA, the default is that rent accrues day by day despite parties usually negotiated monthly or weekly periods
Liability
Joint liability: if one co-lessee is released, all are released
Joint and several liability: releasing one co-lessee does not release the others from their to pay the full rent
Non-residential lease flexibility
Express covenants are highly flexible. Parties can use them to negate, modify, or extent statutory implied covenants under PLA
Limitation of non-residential lease flexibility concerning covenants
Partiesā ability to contract out of inherent rights like quiet enjoyment is limited
Flexibility of residential tenancy covenants
Residential Tenancies Act assumes an unequal bargaining power, making it significantly more difficult to modify implied covenants
Covenant to pay rent
An express term in leases outlining the obligation to pay rent.
Rental abatement
Temporary suspension of rent payment under certain conditions.
Covenant to repair
The obligation for a lessee to keep the premises in good repair.
Eviction impact on lessee
If a lessor effectively evicts a lessee, the lessee is not liable for rent or other covenants during the period
Partial eviction
If the lessee is evicted from only a portion of the premises, the liability to pay rent is abated proportionally to that part
Covenant to repair
In non-residential leases, often placed on lessee, but, in residential leases, placed on lessor
Covenant to repair and wear and tear
Normal wear and tear is typically accepted
Right to assign
Inherent right of lessees to transfer leasehold interests to another party.
Types of prohibution covenants
Absolute prohibition
Qualified prohibition
Absolute prohibition
In non-residential leases, it is possible to prohibit assignment completely.
Qualified prohibition
Assignment is permitted only with lessorās consent which cannot be unreasonably witheld with the lessee having the burden of proof
Major lease transactions
Renewal
Pruchase of the reversion
Renewal
Exclusively relevant to fixed-term leases and gives the lessee a right to renew the lease
Renewal requirement
Must be in writing unless it involves a short-term lease
Purchase of the reversion
Allows the lessee ti purchase the future interest (bundle of rights), converting their leasehold into a fee simple/freehold tenancy. Considered a unilateral offer
Duality of leases
Both proprietary and contractual
Types of privity
Privity of estate
Privity of contract
Privity of estate
The proprietary relationship of tenure in land between the current lessor and lessee.
Privity of contract
Relationship based on the rights and obligations set out in the lease agreement
Dynamic of privity after assignment example
If lessor A leases to lessee B, and B assigns to assignee C, privity of estate now exists between A and C, while privity of contract remains between A and B
Sublease
Transfer of lease rights by the lessee to a third party without granting the entire remaining leasehold interest.
Right of subleases
Inherent but can be limited by express covenants in non-residential contexts
Reversion test subleases
If the original lessee retains any interest or gets the property back at any point, it is a sublease. If they part with the entire interest, it is an assignment
When determining leases, what does the court focus on?
Substance over form, meaning that the label assigned by parties is not determinative
Determination of leases
The process where a lease naturally comes to an end, typically at a specified date.
Expiry and terminating events for leases
Expiry
Hokding over situations
Holding over clauses
Occurence of a terminating event
Expiry
When fixed-term leases come to an end
Holding over situations
If a lessee remains on the property after the expiry date, they are in a holding over position. The nature of the resulting arrangement is determined by:
S210 PLA in absence of express agreement
Tenancy at will: minimal protection arrangement
Tenancy at sufferanceL minimal protection where the lessorās stance is unclear
Holding over clauses
Msny non-residential leases contain express clauses that convert a fixed-term lease into a periodic tenancy upon expiry
Break clause
A provision allowing the lessee to terminate a lease before the term expires.
Joint party rule
To exercise a break clause, all joint lesses must agree to the surrender; a unilateral action one joint lessee is not effective. Similarly, all joint lessors must agree to accept the surrender
Unilateral action in periodic tenancies
Notice to terminate a periodic lease may be given by fewer than all joint lessors or joint lessees
Requirements for notice
Must be clear and unambiguous
Specific form and notice periods are typically defined in lease agreement
Statutory rules: S210 PLA requires 20 working day notice
Notice period calibration periodic tenancies
In the absence on an express agreement, common law calibrates the notice period to the rental payment cycle
Merger
Occurs when leasehold interest and reversionary interest (fee simple) merge under one ownership.
Frustration
A contract law principle applicable when unforeseen events destroy a contract's basis (rare)
Express surrender
Explicit offering of the estate back by the lessee, which the lessor can accept. Must be in writing
Express surrender outcome
Merger and extinguishment of the lease
Implied surrender
Inferred from conduct showing mutual intention to end the lease.
Limit of conduct for implied surrender
Silence or independent action by the lessee is not enough to imply acceptance by the lessor
Repudiatory conduct
One party indicating intent to abandon the contract, which may enable cancellation, governed by S244-261 PLA.
Methods of cancellation by lessor
Physical reentry
Court order
Legal proceedings
Constructive reentry
Notice prerequisite
Lessor cannot reenter without first giving notice to the lessee. stating the breach and intention to reeter or seek a court otder
Relief from cancellation
Lesseeās right to seek court intervention against a lessor's intent to cancel the lease.
Threshold of relief from cancellation
Highly unlikely a court will grant relief if the lessee has not, at minimum, paid up the rent currently in arrears
What the court considers for relief from cancellation
Intent
Remediability
Conduct
Gravity
Financial position
Proportionality