1/4
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Rules
Acceptance must be unqualified - all the terms must be accepted - no ‘ifs’ or ‘buts’
Acceptance must be communicated to the offeror
Felthouse v Bindley
Facts: An uncle offered to buy his nephew's horse for £30 15s, saying silence would mean acceptance.
Held: No contract – the nephew did not communicate his acceptance.
Reason: Silence cannot be treated as acceptance, even if the buyer says it will be.
Key principle: Silence does not equal acceptance.
The postal rule
Only apply if post is the usual or expected communication
Letter must be properly addressed + stamped
Offeree must be able to prove letter was posted
Adams v Lindsell
Facts: Lindsell offered to sell wool to Adams by letter. Adams posted a letter accepting the offer, but it arrived late. Lindsell had already sold the wool to someone else.
Held: Adams won – a contract was formed as soon as the acceptance letter was posted.
Reason: Acceptance by post is effective when the letter is posted, not received.
Key principle: Established the postal rule.
Yates v Pulleyn
Facts: Pulleyn offered building plots for sale, stating that acceptance should be sent by registered or recorded delivery. Yates accepted by ordinary post, and the letter arrived on time.
Held: A valid contract was formed because the acceptance had reached Pulleyn in time.
Reason: Registered post was not a strict requirement; it was intended to provide proof of postage. Ordinary post caused no disadvantage.
Key principle: If a specified method of acceptance is not mandatory, another method can be valid if it achieves the same purpose without disadvantaging the offeror.