Chapter 15 - The West and the Changing World Balance
Introduction
1400 – world in period of transition
Downfall of Arab caliphate
Spread of Mongols
Who would take new international trade role? Maybe China?
But…Enter the Europeans – finally, they’ve been behind everyone for 8000 years
Italy, Spain, Portugal took leadership role
Americas couldn’t respond to European invasions
Key question – why did different civilizations react differently?
This could be a key question – notice the word differences
This class just loves to compare civilizations
The Decline of the Old Order
1200 – Middle East run by Byzantine Empire (North) – Arab Empire (South)
But…Turks took over Byzantines in 1453, 1258 Mongols - Caliph
Social and Cultural Change in the Middle East
Religious leaders gained power over artistic leaders in Arab world
New piety – think about orthodox Muslims today
Religious art themes
Rationalism of Greece (Hellenism) now seen as bad, a threat
…don’t think this is just Arab world, Europeans getting scared of logic/rationalism as well
Economic shifts
As centralized power slows, provincial leaders (landlords) get more power
Hmmm…what an interesting pattern I’ve never seen before
But…bad things resulted
Lower agricultural yield
Less taxes
Less trade
Indian Ocean trade still strong
A gradual decline, not sudden like in Rome
But…even though politically weak, other political areas took more power
Ottoman Turks took over control – more powerful than before
A Power Vaccum in International Leadership
Ottoman Turks not an international leader like Islamic caliphate
Mongols provided next global leader
Encouraged interregional trade
Exchanged technology/ideas
End of empire turned to seaborne trade, as land trade less protected
Chinese Thrust and Withdrawal
Ming “brilliant” dynasty took over 1368-1644
pushed out Mongols first
re-established tributary links with Southeast Asian states
State-sponsored trade expeditions
Admiraly Zhenghe – 1405-1433 led vast, unparalleled fleet
Former eunuch – why do you think leaders like eunuchs for advisors?
Brought fleet of 28,000 troops – scared the willies out of local leaders
Eventually brought back – threatened the Confucian bureaucrats
Remember – they don’t like merchants having power
Other reasons – cost
Money better spent building Beijing, fighting Mongols
What if Chinese kept trading? Lost chance to be world power
Dainty little European ships no match
Followed Chinese pattern of spending money internally, practically
Not like West, where power is judged by expansion
Instead – worked on infrastructure – population increased, manufacturing improved
Arabs on decline, Mongols dying out, China not stepping to the plate…leads to…
The Rise of the West
Why is their rise surprising?
Still awed by other bureaucracies
Church under attack
warrior aristocrats softened life – ridiculous tournaments/armor
lives of ordinary Europeans falling apart
famine
vulnerable to bubonic plague
China’s population hit by 30%
Europe lost 30 million
Led to strikes/peasant uprisings
Sources of Dynamism: Medieval Vitality
Why was Europe still strong?
Strong regional governments created during feudalism
Military innovations thanks to Hundred Years War
Nonaristocratic soldiers – regular guys not paid boy gov’t
Paid by central gov’t = more taxes = more central power
Growth of cities – helped commerce
Church content with capitalism – notice alliteration
Technology improving – metalwork
Imitation and International Problems
Technology pushes expansion
During Mongol period – Europe has ideal access
Not controlled, but still involved in trade
Internal conflict spurs regions to improve technology to win battles
International Factors push expansion
Interest in luxury goods
Nobody wants European products, so they have to pay in gold
Europe doesn’t have gold…so…they need to go find some
Fears of a Muslim threat
Need to secure Western ports
Need to create sea trade since Muslims now control land trade
Secular Directions in the Italian Renaissance
First…I can’t believe we’re going to spend two paragraphs talking about the Renaissance when this was discussed ad nauseum in Western Civ
West’s surge forward – rebirth of culture and political views of Classical Europe
Artists create more human-centered works of art – humanism
Artist/writers pushed for own reputation
Works now secular, and religious simultaneously
Italy started – wealthy merchants want to impress others – patrons
Help sponsor cultural activities, scholars – competition
Human Values and Renaissance Culture
Focus of art changes – it’s a cultural revolution
Subject – people, nature, portraits
Created perspective
Vivid, realistic statues – like classic Rome/Greece
But…not a full break from Medieval World…usually had to involve religion too
Change mindset – looking outward
Building ships, pushing commerce
Ambitious city-state governments funded new ventures
Human ambition, pursuit of glory focused on exploration/conquest
The Iberian Spirit of Religious Mission
Spanish and Portugese rulers pushing military/religious agenda
Goal of armies – push Christianity, kick out Arabs/Jews
Government enforced Church codes
Inquisition courts to enforce orthodoxy
Key…government with religious mission
Western Expansion: The Experimental Phase
Early Explorations
Western route to the Indies – spice trade area?
Vivaldis from Genoa sailed off to the land of nowhereville
Mostly had to stick to the coast of Africa
After 1430, some navigational problems solved
compass/astrolabe – navigation by stars – from Arabs
Improved mapmaking
but…geographically inaccurate maps give false confidence
1498 – Vasco de Gama heads to Indian Ocean
Colonial Patterns
How to make expeditions profitable?
Henry the Navigator pushed for scientific, intellectual, religious, economic
Islands off Africa became test ground for colonialism
large agricultural estates
sugar, cotton, tobacco
brought in slaves by Portugese
Success of early programs led to expansion
Forces influencing European expansion
inferiorities and fears - Muslims
energies of Renaissance merchants
economic pressures
population surge
Outside the World Network
Introduction
America/Polynesia not affected by world exchange – they’d be centuries behind
New problems left civilizations vulnerable
Political Issues in the Americas
Resentment for leadership
For some reason tribute regions tired of being enslaved, sacrificed
Overextension – difficult to control
Other cultures developing – maybe would have surpassed
All irrelevant, because when Europeans arrive…
Expansion, Migration, and Conquest in Polynesia
Between 7th and 14th spread eastward – Hawaii – spread culture
Society in caste system – military leaders/priests dominate
No written language – oral history
Isolated Achievements by the Maori
8th century – Maori in New Zealand
Most elaborate art
Military leaders/priests have great power
Slaves
Because developed in isolation
Vulnerable to disease
Inferior weapons
Cultural disintegration
Adding up the Changes
Master plan that Europeans would dominate or series of coincidences?
Political instability in Americas
Developed in isolation left technologically inferior
Vulnerable to diseases
China decides not to continue pursuit of world trade domination
Individuals try to improve Europe’s trade deficit – Henry the Navigator
Muslim impact on Africa less control
Africans don’t benefit from trade with Mongols
Global Connections
Global contacts
Muslim traders/missionaries still active
Mongols readily shared ideas from one end of empire to the other
China made new contacts
But by 1450…who would dominate next was in flux
Key continuity
Regions required trade to survive
Africa relied on Middle East
Southeast Asia linked to Muslim traders/China
Western Europe contacts increasing
China, India, Middle East see Africa/Europe as consumer source
And that’s it…not that painful of a chapter, agree?
Introduction
1400 – world in period of transition
Downfall of Arab caliphate
Spread of Mongols
Who would take new international trade role? Maybe China?
But…Enter the Europeans – finally, they’ve been behind everyone for 8000 years
Italy, Spain, Portugal took leadership role
Americas couldn’t respond to European invasions
Key question – why did different civilizations react differently?
This could be a key question – notice the word differences
This class just loves to compare civilizations
The Decline of the Old Order
1200 – Middle East run by Byzantine Empire (North) – Arab Empire (South)
But…Turks took over Byzantines in 1453, 1258 Mongols - Caliph
Social and Cultural Change in the Middle East
Religious leaders gained power over artistic leaders in Arab world
New piety – think about orthodox Muslims today
Religious art themes
Rationalism of Greece (Hellenism) now seen as bad, a threat
…don’t think this is just Arab world, Europeans getting scared of logic/rationalism as well
Economic shifts
As centralized power slows, provincial leaders (landlords) get more power
Hmmm…what an interesting pattern I’ve never seen before
But…bad things resulted
Lower agricultural yield
Less taxes
Less trade
Indian Ocean trade still strong
A gradual decline, not sudden like in Rome
But…even though politically weak, other political areas took more power
Ottoman Turks took over control – more powerful than before
A Power Vaccum in International Leadership
Ottoman Turks not an international leader like Islamic caliphate
Mongols provided next global leader
Encouraged interregional trade
Exchanged technology/ideas
End of empire turned to seaborne trade, as land trade less protected
Chinese Thrust and Withdrawal
Ming “brilliant” dynasty took over 1368-1644
pushed out Mongols first
re-established tributary links with Southeast Asian states
State-sponsored trade expeditions
Admiraly Zhenghe – 1405-1433 led vast, unparalleled fleet
Former eunuch – why do you think leaders like eunuchs for advisors?
Brought fleet of 28,000 troops – scared the willies out of local leaders
Eventually brought back – threatened the Confucian bureaucrats
Remember – they don’t like merchants having power
Other reasons – cost
Money better spent building Beijing, fighting Mongols
What if Chinese kept trading? Lost chance to be world power
Dainty little European ships no match
Followed Chinese pattern of spending money internally, practically
Not like West, where power is judged by expansion
Instead – worked on infrastructure – population increased, manufacturing improved
Arabs on decline, Mongols dying out, China not stepping to the plate…leads to…
The Rise of the West
Why is their rise surprising?
Still awed by other bureaucracies
Church under attack
warrior aristocrats softened life – ridiculous tournaments/armor
lives of ordinary Europeans falling apart
famine
vulnerable to bubonic plague
China’s population hit by 30%
Europe lost 30 million
Led to strikes/peasant uprisings
Sources of Dynamism: Medieval Vitality
Why was Europe still strong?
Strong regional governments created during feudalism
Military innovations thanks to Hundred Years War
Nonaristocratic soldiers – regular guys not paid boy gov’t
Paid by central gov’t = more taxes = more central power
Growth of cities – helped commerce
Church content with capitalism – notice alliteration
Technology improving – metalwork
Imitation and International Problems
Technology pushes expansion
During Mongol period – Europe has ideal access
Not controlled, but still involved in trade
Internal conflict spurs regions to improve technology to win battles
International Factors push expansion
Interest in luxury goods
Nobody wants European products, so they have to pay in gold
Europe doesn’t have gold…so…they need to go find some
Fears of a Muslim threat
Need to secure Western ports
Need to create sea trade since Muslims now control land trade
Secular Directions in the Italian Renaissance
First…I can’t believe we’re going to spend two paragraphs talking about the Renaissance when this was discussed ad nauseum in Western Civ
West’s surge forward – rebirth of culture and political views of Classical Europe
Artists create more human-centered works of art – humanism
Artist/writers pushed for own reputation
Works now secular, and religious simultaneously
Italy started – wealthy merchants want to impress others – patrons
Help sponsor cultural activities, scholars – competition
Human Values and Renaissance Culture
Focus of art changes – it’s a cultural revolution
Subject – people, nature, portraits
Created perspective
Vivid, realistic statues – like classic Rome/Greece
But…not a full break from Medieval World…usually had to involve religion too
Change mindset – looking outward
Building ships, pushing commerce
Ambitious city-state governments funded new ventures
Human ambition, pursuit of glory focused on exploration/conquest
The Iberian Spirit of Religious Mission
Spanish and Portugese rulers pushing military/religious agenda
Goal of armies – push Christianity, kick out Arabs/Jews
Government enforced Church codes
Inquisition courts to enforce orthodoxy
Key…government with religious mission
Western Expansion: The Experimental Phase
Early Explorations
Western route to the Indies – spice trade area?
Vivaldis from Genoa sailed off to the land of nowhereville
Mostly had to stick to the coast of Africa
After 1430, some navigational problems solved
compass/astrolabe – navigation by stars – from Arabs
Improved mapmaking
but…geographically inaccurate maps give false confidence
1498 – Vasco de Gama heads to Indian Ocean
Colonial Patterns
How to make expeditions profitable?
Henry the Navigator pushed for scientific, intellectual, religious, economic
Islands off Africa became test ground for colonialism
large agricultural estates
sugar, cotton, tobacco
brought in slaves by Portugese
Success of early programs led to expansion
Forces influencing European expansion
inferiorities and fears - Muslims
energies of Renaissance merchants
economic pressures
population surge
Outside the World Network
Introduction
America/Polynesia not affected by world exchange – they’d be centuries behind
New problems left civilizations vulnerable
Political Issues in the Americas
Resentment for leadership
For some reason tribute regions tired of being enslaved, sacrificed
Overextension – difficult to control
Other cultures developing – maybe would have surpassed
All irrelevant, because when Europeans arrive…
Expansion, Migration, and Conquest in Polynesia
Between 7th and 14th spread eastward – Hawaii – spread culture
Society in caste system – military leaders/priests dominate
No written language – oral history
Isolated Achievements by the Maori
8th century – Maori in New Zealand
Most elaborate art
Military leaders/priests have great power
Slaves
Because developed in isolation
Vulnerable to disease
Inferior weapons
Cultural disintegration
Adding up the Changes
Master plan that Europeans would dominate or series of coincidences?
Political instability in Americas
Developed in isolation left technologically inferior
Vulnerable to diseases
China decides not to continue pursuit of world trade domination
Individuals try to improve Europe’s trade deficit – Henry the Navigator
Muslim impact on Africa less control
Africans don’t benefit from trade with Mongols
Global Connections
Global contacts
Muslim traders/missionaries still active
Mongols readily shared ideas from one end of empire to the other
China made new contacts
But by 1450…who would dominate next was in flux
Key continuity
Regions required trade to survive
Africa relied on Middle East
Southeast Asia linked to Muslim traders/China
Western Europe contacts increasing
China, India, Middle East see Africa/Europe as consumer source
And that’s it…not that painful of a chapter, agree?