Peers and Relationships
From about 2-12 yeaars old..
-Children spend more time with peers and less time with adults/family
How important are peer relationships
-Social support
-Self-disclosure
-Sociability
-Social Skills
-Preparation for romantic relationships
Deviancy Training
Benefits/risks associated with peer groups
Benefits
-Can mitigate the negative effects of parenting
-High achieving peers; low parental involvement
Risks
-Can undermine the positive effects of parenting
-Low achieving peers; high parental involvement
Importance of Peers: Social Support
Remember Harlow’s Monkeys?
Mother-only monkeys
-Denied contact with “peers”
-Failed to develop normal patterns of social behavior
-Highly aggressive and antisocial
Peer-only monkeys
-Aggressive with peers outside of the group
-Prosocial behavior within the group
-Agitated over minor stresses
Importance of Peers: Sociability in Adolescence
Peer interactions become increasingly complex
Peer group-> Middle childhood
-Peers who interact regularly, defined sense of membership
Clique -> Early Adolescence
-Small group of close friends
Crowds->Mid-adolescence
-Large, reputationally based peer groups
Peers help with identity formation!
Adolescents & Identity
Adolescents start exploring their own identity (in some domains)because they are seeking independence from parents
Some adolescents may take on negative identity
-Idenity that is opposite of what is expected of them
Peers & Identity
Adolescents want to fit in and find their place in society
Peer groups can help with this
Fulfill adolescents need for acceptance
Provide opportunities for exploration and experimentation
-Test out different peer groups
-Use peers as models
-Use peers as an audience
-Peers also serve as a secure base
Peer Pressure
Adolescents’ desire to be accepted can also lead to an increase in their susceptibility to peer pressure
-Conforming to one’s peers
Belonging during adolescence
Fundamental need to belong ( Baumeister & Leary,1995)
Seek out new and meaningful relationships
-Some of these may result in rejection
Belonging/Acceptance is associated with several positive outcomes
Peer Ratings/Status
Sociometric techniques-> Adolescent ratings of peers
Popular Adolescents
-Generally well-liked; disliked by very few
Rejected Adolescents
-Disliked by many; liked by a few
Neglected Adolescents
-Neither liked nor disliked by peers
Controversial Adolescents
-Liked by many AND disliked by many
Social behaviors are strong predictors of social status!
Rejected Adolescents
Two types of rejected youth:
Aggressive-rejected
-Display hostile/threatening behaviors
-May bully others
Withdrawn-rejected
Adolescents who are socially withdrawn
May be warry, timid, and/or anxious in social situations
At risk of being bullied
Rejected Adolescents
Rejection is associated with a number of emotional and behavioral responses
Emotional
Depression, sadness, upset, loneliness, anger, anxiety, shame, etc.
Behavioral
-Avoid- Not associated with the situation try to get away from it
-Prosocial- People pleasing showing they can still contribute
-Antisocial- Anger demand attention from others
Perceiving Acceptance/Rejection
Socially skilled adolescents
-Can quickly and accurately decode/interpret social cues
-Identify optimal responses that mention friendships
Unpopular adolescents
-Selectively attend to social cues
-misinterpret what they observe
-generate aggressive responses
Social Skills Training Programs
-Teach appropriate social behaviors
-Help adolescents think through social experiences and select optimal responses
Peers---Summary
Adolescents place more importance on peer relationships as they get older
Peers have a huge impact on development (e.g., identity)
Peers can mitigate the negative effects of parenting
Importance off peeers can make us susceptible to peer pressure
-But this peaks around 14 years
Peer acceptance/rejection associated with various consequences
Romantic Relationships
History of Dating
“Dating” as we know it today is relatively new
-Started around the 1920s
Historically “dates” were male selection opportunities
Carefully monitored by parents
-Would bargain with other parents about the merits of their adolescents as potential marriage partners
Dating today is much more than courtship for marriage
Funtctions of Dating(Paul & White,1990)
Dating today can serve at least 8 functions
A form of recreation
Source of status and achievement
Socialization opportunity
Learn about intimacy
Context for sexual experimentation/exploration
Companionship
Contribute to identity formation
Meaning of mate sorting/selection
Dating during Addolescence
Dating among Heterosexual Adolescents
-Prior research has identified 3 stages (Connolly & Mclsaac,2009)
Entry to romantic attraction(11-13 years)
Exploring Romantic Relationships (14-16 years)
Consolidating dyadic bonds(17-19 years)
Variations for when these stages occur
-”Early starters”
-Late bloomers
Dating and Developmental Outcomes
Dating at an early age can be problematic
-Associated with adolescent pregnancy
-Also linked to increased social problems at home and school
There are also positive developmental outcomes
-Supportive romantic relationships during adolescence can mitigate negative parental behaviors
-Early intimate disclosure associated with more companionship in romantic relationships later in adolescence
Positive/Negative Outcomes Associated with Breakups
Negative
-Increased likelihood for substance use/abuse
-Decreased self-esteem & increased rates of depression
Positive
-Opportunity for personal growth
-Feeling stronger emotionally
-More self-confident
-Feeling more independent
-Developing new friendships
Attachment and Future Relationships
Early childhood attachment styles can predict future relationships
Mary Ainsworths “strange situation” test
Mother and child are alone in unfamiliar (strange”) room; the child explores the room as mother just sits
The mother leaves the room
After a few moments the mother returns
Process is repeated but with a stranger
Attachment in Adolescence
Childhood attachments have implications for future relations
Secure Child
-Parent is a secure “base”
-Trust the parent
-Goes to parent when upset
Secure Adolescents
-Partner isn't going anywhere
-Both can be independent of one another
-Trust the partner
-Goes to partner when upset
-” Healthy” relationship
Resistant Child
-Cling to the parent
-Dependent on parents
Resistant Adolescent
-Engage in behaviors that may pish partner away
-Excessively “clingy”
-Possessive
-Demanding
-Jealous
Avoidant Child
-Indifferent to parents absence
Avoidant Adolescent
-Emotionally Distant
-May seek out isolation
-May detach easily from loved ones
-”I don't care” in response to breakup
Disorganized Child
-Combination of resistant and avoidant
-Reuniting with caregiver causes confusion
Disorganized Adolescent
-Unpredictable moods
-Cling to AND push away a partner
-Want to rely on partner for safety, but may also fear them
-Overly dramatic: fear of rejection, fear of commitment
Learning Achievement & Work
Transitions in Schooling
Children/adolescents experience a lot of transition in their education
Transition to middle school can be difficult and stressful for many adolescents
Why?
Top-dog phenomenon
-Moving from being biggest/oldest to smallest/youngest
Transition to high school can be just as difficult
High Schools are:
-Larger
-More bureaucratic
-Impersonal
Academic Achievement
Institutional Factors
School Quality
-Funding
-Facilities
-Teacher expertise
-Extracurriculars
Work During Adolescence
Approx. 80%-90% of adolescents are employed ar some point during high school
Almost 10% of employed seniors work more than 30 hours a week
Developmental benefits of working during this time?
-Working several hours in laborer positions can increase likelihood of risky behaviors
Negative relationship with academics
-10th graders who work more than 14 hours a week
-11th graders who work more than 20 hours a week
Spending too much time at work, impact studying and school involvement
-Also greater likelihood of alcohol and marijuana use
Also postive aspects of working during adolescence
Gain valuable skills and mentorship from adults
-Recall Vygotsky
Working can help adolescents from low SES backgrounds
-Financial help AND adult monitoring
Culture and Adolescence
Culture:the behavior,patterns,beliefs, and customs of a specific group that are passed down from generation to generation
Exposure to other culutres is becoming the norm
Historically the study of adolescents has been ethnocentric
-Tendency to favor ones own group over other groups
In-Group vs. Out-group bias
Mere Exposure effect
-We develop a preference for things we are familiar with
The culutre in which an adolescent is being raised can have massive developmental impacts
Cultural messages can impact a variety of individuals differences
-The messages children and adolescents recieve may also influence agression
“Boys will be boys”
-Boys are taught that aggression is sometimes okay
-Boy roughhousing with another boy--> okay
-Boy roughhousing with a girl--> aggression
Girls are taught that it is inappropriate
-Girls seen as aggressive, regardless of the target
Individualism and Collectivism
Individualistic Cultures
-Personal Goals>Group Goals
-Values Independence
-Personal achievement and competition
-Independent behaviors
Collectivistic Cultures
-Personal Goals< Group Goals
-Values interdependence
-Group achievement and cooperation
-Interdependent behaviors
Cultural Influences
There are other cultural influences on aggression
The United States tend to be higher than other industrialized countries in...
-Rape
-Homicide
-Assault
We also see some differences within the US
Differences between Northerners and Southerners (Cohen,1998; Cohen &Nisbett,1994;Cohen,Nisbett,Bowdle, SChwarz,1996;Hayes &Lee,2005;Nisbett,1993)
However, there is an important caveat to this belief
Southerners are more accepting of violence than northerners when it serves a purpose
-Protect themselves
-Protect their families
-Protect their property
-Protect their reputation
All connects to Culture of Honor ( Originated from to be seen as tough to protect their goods from others in the south)
Culture of Honor
Men are devoted to the protection of their family/reputation
-Especially from threats and insults
Men have a need to demonstrate that they are tough
-Will use aggression if necessary
Men (especially White men) in the American South:
-Commit more violent crimes in response to insult
-More physically aggressive when insulted
-Engage in risky behaviors to demonstrate their honor (manliness)
“Asshole” Study (Cohen et al.,1996)
Northern and Southern males were bumped into and insulted(i.e.,called an “asshole”) by a confederate
Males from Southern states were more likely to display heightened...
-Emotional
-Behavioral
-Cognitive
-Physiological
Cohen et al.1996 study showed that southers had a higher amount of COrtisol and testoserone levels
What about violent video games?
Early reseach is inconsitent
-Sakamoto(1994)
-No correlation between video games and soical problems
Scott(1995)
-No support for the claim that violent video games increase aggression
Dorman (1997)
-Increase in aggressive behaviors
But how have video games changed since the 90s?
More “recent” research
Polman et al. (2008)
-Playing violent video games caused boys to be more aggressive than only watching violent video games
Anderson et al.(2010)
-Playing violent video games can increase aggression overtime
Saleem et.al (2012)
-Violent video games increase antisocial behavior and decrease prosocial behavior
Coyne et al.(2018)
-Longitudinal study
-Early exposure to video game violence associated with lower levels of prosocial behavior
-Associated with higher levels of externalizing behavior at the cross-sectional level, but not 5 years later
Why is there a debate?
Differences in how people define aggression
-Aggression--> intent is to hurt someone
-Externalizing behaviors--> can harm others, but more focused on rule-breaking behaviors
Research Ethics
Burden of proof
-Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Association
In Sum...
Socialization does NOT take place in a vacuum
-Parents, Peers,Media,etc.
Each system impacts our development...
Personality
-Aggressice,hostile,impulsive
Emotions
-Shame,gulit, depression
Social
-Attachment, relationships
Cognitive
-Attention, problem solving
Wrapping it all up!
Developmental Psychology
-How and why people change over time
1.Puberty
2.Brain development
3.Cognitive Changes
4.Identity Development
5.Gender identity
6.Sexuality
7.Moral development
8.Families/Peers
10.Culture/Media
There is a lot of development going on during adolescence