Ch. 24: Industrialization and Labor Unions
Exponential Growth
Railroad was developing and resulted in an economic transformation in post civil war era which allowed US to become the US economic and industrial giant
Started in Nebraska and headed west; already railroads in east of Mississippi
Most workers were Irish immigrants
Built more rail line- built over 1000 miles of rail
Started in California and was going east
Workers were Chinese Immigrants (stereotypically they were more hard workers)
Built just under 700 miles of rail
Blast through mountains
There were more mountains in the west
Topography: plains were flat and easy to build
Companies meet up in Utah
First transcontinental railroad in the world
Railroad: Social, Political, Economic Benefits
Towns that got touched by railroad flourished; others became ghost towns
Communities were fighting one another to get railroad to come through
Bribe railroad officials to get through your town for flourishing town
Joined west more firmly to the Union; we don’t have 50 states yet
Facilitated flourishing trade with Asia; import and export goods
The economic center was the northeast because shipping goods was easier
Helped pave the way for the growth of the west
Hard Money Policy
Banking of gold
Republicans desired hard money
Wealthy and Creditors want a return on investments (someone who loans money but wants something in return) through hard money
Soft Money Policy
Anything that’s worth less than gold; various forms of collateral
Democrats wanted inflation and the soft money policy
Greenback labor party also advocated for soft money
Debtors/Working class want soft money because it causes inflation and makes debts easier to pay
How did the federal government fund the building of the transcontinental railroad?
Land grants (Give railroad companies land, railroad companies determine what land they need, then they sell other parcels of land to help build the railroad)
Federal government gives them loans
Subsidizes transcontinental railroad
Railroad Touches American Life
Unites the nation in a physical sense; Joining the west with the east
Created an enormous domestic market for raw materials and manufactured goods (Ex. coal and lumber)
Invited foreign and domestic investors
Stimulated other industries including mining and agriculture industries
They grow off of the railroad
Spurred (Incited) industrialization of the post-civil war years
Boom for Cities (business and population) and played leading role in city-ward movement; America was changing in post-civil war years---America starts to develop
Stimulated stream of immigration: opportunities (Jobs!)- advertising overseas
Led to the formation of time zones
They used the sun to set the time zones
They had to standardize time to avoid train crashes
24 time zones: AROUND THE WORLD; 24 hours in a day
A maker of millionaires
Stock watering: Inflating the value of a company and selling the stock for more than it’s actually worth- harmful to the public because people inside company knows actually profitable
Everyday investor was swindled
Pool: agreement to divide business in given area and share the profits
They start to establish monopolies
WE have a regulated capitalist society; have to follow rules and regulations
Capitalist economy: The consumers dictate the prices of goods and services
Other railroad industrialists granted secret rebates in kickbacks to certain shippers (Rebate: Discount); rebates to people in power
The farmers hated the railroads because of unfair competition
When there’s monopolies it doesn’t help the smaller company, it helps the bigger company
Populists wanted public ownership of railroads
Government involvement in the economy started at the local level with Granger Laws--State laws that regulated the railroad (no pool, publish prices, etc.)
The railroaders aren’t happy; they don’t want their businesses regulated
Lawyers file lawsuits
It goes to the supreme court: Wabash vs. Illinois
Ruled that individual states had no power to regulate interstate commerce
In essence it says that the Granger Laws are unconstitutional
People aren’t happy with decision; here’s another example of government helping to protect the interest of big businesses rather than people
Farmers have started to become political and they started to vote in blocks and congress doesn’t do something to appease farmers, they might be voted out of office
In 1887: Congress passed Interstate Commerce Act
Rebates and pools are prohibited
Railroads had to publish their rates openly (have to know what you’re gonna pay; public has right to know)
First attempt by federal government to regulate business in the interest of society
the Interstate Commerce Act serve notice there was a public interest in private Enterprise the government was bound to protect
In private business (Public interest) and government has to protect public interest; businesses can’t do anything they want
Ex. Minimum wage laws, health and safety standards,
Carnegie, Rockefeller, Vanderbilt,Gould, Jay Cook,
Believed in Social Darwinism
New arriving wealth
Pulled themselves up
Carnegie
American rags to riches
He was an immigrant came from Scotland and lived in poverty in Scotland and came to America with no money and turned himself into the richest man in the world
he believes he had innate qualities in trades that allowed him to excel and achieve
However, the poor can’t rise up because they don’t have the same the qualities
They believed that God had chosen them to lead and that’s why they had been given these gifts; Carnegie takes it a step further in Gospel Of Wealth
Carnegie believes that the wealthy have an obligation to make society a better place because God has chosen them and this is what God would want; when Carnegie sells Carnegie Steels to JP Morgan
Carnegie made a commitment to giving his fortune away---philanthropic and charitable; he had given away 90% of his fortune by the time he died---donated to museums, universities, libraries
Carnegie believed who were born into poverty---some had special gifts and needed to give them a vessel to utilize them; he makes libraries free, museums can utilize to grow and enhance their knowledge; endowing universities resulted in providing formal education
NOT ALL POOR were Lazy; some need opportunities given to them
Believed in the 3 phases of life:
Learn as much as you can ; Carnegie learned on his own
Earn as much as you can
Give back; if you died with a fortune you wasted your life (according to Carnegie); he means leaving something to make society better
Moving away from Laissez Faire
Sherman AntiTrust Act: Passed in 1890
What it was supposed to: Forbade combinations in restraint of trade; supposed to prevent monopolies and trusts from forming
USED IT TO GO AFTER LABOR UNIONS (Ex. through strikes, restraining freedom of trade)
US vs. EC Knight Co.
EC Knight Company was the textbook definition of monopoly
US justice dept filed against them
The court was In favor of EC Knight Company
It was confirmation that the government was working on behalf of big businesses in late 19th century
After Civil War, South remained overwhelmingly agrarian (If there was a transcontinental railroad, it could have industrialized)
One industry growth in south was the textile (make clothes/fabric) industry
They used immigrants, poor uneducated whites, and former slaves for cheap labor
Era of monopoly capitalism
Business was very powerful and workers had very little rights
On average (non-agrarian) working 6 days a week 10 hours; $1.50 a day
The workers saw that enormous fortunes were being made and they had dangerous conditions and not enough money
They Wanted better wages and better working conditions
better work-life balance
Felt like they were being used
Railroad Strike of 1877: AKA great upheaval
railroad strike on the east coast (hit major cities)
became violent
rutherford sent in troops to cut down violence
first-time federal troops were used to put down a strike
Haymarket Square:
huge protest
Haymarket Riot/Massacre: somebody threw bomb into the crowd
Never found who threw the bomb
4 people were hanged for their crimes
Public blames Knights of Labor and AFL
Public support is lost when it became violent
Homestead:
Carnegie’s home factory
Was very violent, so it lost support
Important: wiped out steel industry for 45 years
Public become completely against the strikes
Pullman Strike: people were attacked and the military was brought in
justification for violence was the mail (the president)
Gilded Era:
Industrialization and Monopoly Capitalism
Not many rights on Capitalism
Factory workers worked 10 hour days, 6 days a week, and wages were $1.50 a day
Reactions to Monopoly Capitalism
political:
greenback labor party →populist →progressive era
people were fighting back they felt that they were being left behind and they were being ignored by the government (state and federal)
Leader: William H. Sylvis
Membership:
Lasted 6 years and attracted 600,000 members: skilled, unskilled, and farmers; excluded Chinese, women and African Americans
Somewhat promoted that they would allow all workers, but their actions were different and they were discriminatory
Goals:
Unify workers across locales and trades to challenge powerful bosses
eight-hour work day, winning the latter for government workers
Better wages and better working conditions
Tactics:.
Salary Arbitration (neutral third party for negotiation)
Binding arbitration: this is agreement and both sides need to stick to it
Leader: Uriah Smith Stevens
Terence Powderly (1869)
Membership:
One big union: only restricted services (non-producer), lawyers, alcohol sellers, bankers, lawyers; wanted all men and women and African Americans and Chinese
Open membership; few successful strikes led to a period of rapid growth
Goals:
Wanted to unify all men and women into a national union; workers to combine their wages so they could collectively purchase mines, factories, and stores
End prison labor; reduces job availability
End Child labor (work for lower wages)
Tactics: Oppose strikes (no social unrest) and favored arbitration
Demise knights of labor: Haymarket Square
Union: Association of workers to improve working conditions (ex. Carpenters, teachers)
Leader: Samuel Gompers (leaders during the Gilded Age)
Membership:
No individual laborer could join the central organization (self-governing national unions)
Basically non political
Included: Skilled craftsmen (Carpenters, bricklayers, electricians, confederation of unions togethers resulted in strength in numbers)
unskilled laborers, including women and especially AFrican Americans fend for themselves
Goals:
Shunned politics for economic strategies and goals
Demanded fairer share for laborer; promoting what he called a pure and simple”unionism, he wanted better wages and working conditions
“Trade agreement”authorizing the closed shop--all union labor
“Closed shop” and collective bargaining---no political/economic clout
“Closed shop”: Hire union members only
Collective Bargaining: Negotiation of contract with business (leave, safety policies, wages, etc.) (everybody was under same contract);
different wages were unfair and then strike; same wages resulted in equality
In Numbers there is strength
Tactics:
Walkout and boycotts
Stronger craft unions of the federation--by pooling funds--were able to amass money that would enable them to ride out prolonged strikes
Leader: Ben Haywood, Eugene V. Debs, Mother Jones
Membership: never attracted more than 150,000 members
All workers: teachers, social workers, construction, bartenders, ANYBODY CAN JOIN (Bosses can’t join) because they wanted worker unity and wanted to overthrow bosses; replace capitalism with socialism
Goals: Craft unionism; Intended to be “One Big Union”; unite skilled and unskilled workers; a socialist economy
Tactics: Pursued what was considered “bread and butter” issues (issues everyone wants to solve: better wages, better conditions, etc.)
Direct Action Method: Propaganda, Strikes, Class Warfare/Violence, boycotts
Most successful: AFL (only focused on Unions’ needs and ONLY skilled workers)
Became symbol of America’s transition from an agricultural to an industrial society (Small town and farms to urbanization) zx
Impact of Industrial Growth in the US was Uneven in Terms Of:
Geography- most industry was in the North and Midwest with less in South
People- few gained fortunes but most worked long, dangerous hours for little pay
1865- US ranked fourth in industrial output behind Britain, France, and Germany
1900- in many industries, the US produced more than the other three combined
By 1900- the US accounted for ⅓ of the world’s manufacturing capacity
Huge income gap during the Gilded Age
10% of the population (industrialists and their families) controlled 90% of the income
Urban poor were at the bottom of the income ladder
They were working long hours in factory and mills jobs for little pay and no benefits
Now the rural poor were at the bottom
Despite the poor working conditions, most Americans did see an increase in their standard of living, if even a slight one
By 1900, ⅔ of all employed Americans worked for wages
The late 19th century witnessed the most deadly--and frequent--labor conflicts in American history; so many people felt exploited by big companies
By 1900 only 3% of American workers belonged to unions
Management held the upper hand in labor disputes, with support (generally) from the government
People were beginning to recognize the need for better balance in the workplace
Public attitudes were changing toward labor unions (muck bringing journalists expose horrible working conditions)
One adult woman out of five in 1900 was in the labor force working for wages (OUT OF ECONOMIC NECESSITY)
Women were paid half of the men wages
Worked the same hours as men----reasoning: men were more productive
Though hard to believe, industrialization did have modest positive effect on women: Earning their place in society and becoming more independent
South During Industrialization
Some Southerners promoted a vision for a “New South” with self-sufficient economy, industrial growth, modernized transportation, and improved race relations (ROMANTICIZED)
Some success stories (NOT in race relations) were Birmingham, Memphis, and Richmond;
South failed to prosper and grow as much as the North
Remained rural and agricultural
Textile industry did thrive in the South (cheap labor)
Work and Business (1865)
Farming and sharecropping
Working in maills
Mining and Railroad work
Segregation
Start of business consolidation (predates monopolies) (Vertical/horizontal integration eventually becomes trusts)
Work and Business (1900)
Farming and sharecropping
Segregation
Women and Children in workforce were cheaper labor
Mechanization of agriculture
Wage work in factories
Monopolies and trusts
Unions
Exponential Growth
Railroad was developing and resulted in an economic transformation in post civil war era which allowed US to become the US economic and industrial giant
Started in Nebraska and headed west; already railroads in east of Mississippi
Most workers were Irish immigrants
Built more rail line- built over 1000 miles of rail
Started in California and was going east
Workers were Chinese Immigrants (stereotypically they were more hard workers)
Built just under 700 miles of rail
Blast through mountains
There were more mountains in the west
Topography: plains were flat and easy to build
Companies meet up in Utah
First transcontinental railroad in the world
Railroad: Social, Political, Economic Benefits
Towns that got touched by railroad flourished; others became ghost towns
Communities were fighting one another to get railroad to come through
Bribe railroad officials to get through your town for flourishing town
Joined west more firmly to the Union; we don’t have 50 states yet
Facilitated flourishing trade with Asia; import and export goods
The economic center was the northeast because shipping goods was easier
Helped pave the way for the growth of the west
Hard Money Policy
Banking of gold
Republicans desired hard money
Wealthy and Creditors want a return on investments (someone who loans money but wants something in return) through hard money
Soft Money Policy
Anything that’s worth less than gold; various forms of collateral
Democrats wanted inflation and the soft money policy
Greenback labor party also advocated for soft money
Debtors/Working class want soft money because it causes inflation and makes debts easier to pay
How did the federal government fund the building of the transcontinental railroad?
Land grants (Give railroad companies land, railroad companies determine what land they need, then they sell other parcels of land to help build the railroad)
Federal government gives them loans
Subsidizes transcontinental railroad
Railroad Touches American Life
Unites the nation in a physical sense; Joining the west with the east
Created an enormous domestic market for raw materials and manufactured goods (Ex. coal and lumber)
Invited foreign and domestic investors
Stimulated other industries including mining and agriculture industries
They grow off of the railroad
Spurred (Incited) industrialization of the post-civil war years
Boom for Cities (business and population) and played leading role in city-ward movement; America was changing in post-civil war years---America starts to develop
Stimulated stream of immigration: opportunities (Jobs!)- advertising overseas
Led to the formation of time zones
They used the sun to set the time zones
They had to standardize time to avoid train crashes
24 time zones: AROUND THE WORLD; 24 hours in a day
A maker of millionaires
Stock watering: Inflating the value of a company and selling the stock for more than it’s actually worth- harmful to the public because people inside company knows actually profitable
Everyday investor was swindled
Pool: agreement to divide business in given area and share the profits
They start to establish monopolies
WE have a regulated capitalist society; have to follow rules and regulations
Capitalist economy: The consumers dictate the prices of goods and services
Other railroad industrialists granted secret rebates in kickbacks to certain shippers (Rebate: Discount); rebates to people in power
The farmers hated the railroads because of unfair competition
When there’s monopolies it doesn’t help the smaller company, it helps the bigger company
Populists wanted public ownership of railroads
Government involvement in the economy started at the local level with Granger Laws--State laws that regulated the railroad (no pool, publish prices, etc.)
The railroaders aren’t happy; they don’t want their businesses regulated
Lawyers file lawsuits
It goes to the supreme court: Wabash vs. Illinois
Ruled that individual states had no power to regulate interstate commerce
In essence it says that the Granger Laws are unconstitutional
People aren’t happy with decision; here’s another example of government helping to protect the interest of big businesses rather than people
Farmers have started to become political and they started to vote in blocks and congress doesn’t do something to appease farmers, they might be voted out of office
In 1887: Congress passed Interstate Commerce Act
Rebates and pools are prohibited
Railroads had to publish their rates openly (have to know what you’re gonna pay; public has right to know)
First attempt by federal government to regulate business in the interest of society
the Interstate Commerce Act serve notice there was a public interest in private Enterprise the government was bound to protect
In private business (Public interest) and government has to protect public interest; businesses can’t do anything they want
Ex. Minimum wage laws, health and safety standards,
Carnegie, Rockefeller, Vanderbilt,Gould, Jay Cook,
Believed in Social Darwinism
New arriving wealth
Pulled themselves up
Carnegie
American rags to riches
He was an immigrant came from Scotland and lived in poverty in Scotland and came to America with no money and turned himself into the richest man in the world
he believes he had innate qualities in trades that allowed him to excel and achieve
However, the poor can’t rise up because they don’t have the same the qualities
They believed that God had chosen them to lead and that’s why they had been given these gifts; Carnegie takes it a step further in Gospel Of Wealth
Carnegie believes that the wealthy have an obligation to make society a better place because God has chosen them and this is what God would want; when Carnegie sells Carnegie Steels to JP Morgan
Carnegie made a commitment to giving his fortune away---philanthropic and charitable; he had given away 90% of his fortune by the time he died---donated to museums, universities, libraries
Carnegie believed who were born into poverty---some had special gifts and needed to give them a vessel to utilize them; he makes libraries free, museums can utilize to grow and enhance their knowledge; endowing universities resulted in providing formal education
NOT ALL POOR were Lazy; some need opportunities given to them
Believed in the 3 phases of life:
Learn as much as you can ; Carnegie learned on his own
Earn as much as you can
Give back; if you died with a fortune you wasted your life (according to Carnegie); he means leaving something to make society better
Moving away from Laissez Faire
Sherman AntiTrust Act: Passed in 1890
What it was supposed to: Forbade combinations in restraint of trade; supposed to prevent monopolies and trusts from forming
USED IT TO GO AFTER LABOR UNIONS (Ex. through strikes, restraining freedom of trade)
US vs. EC Knight Co.
EC Knight Company was the textbook definition of monopoly
US justice dept filed against them
The court was In favor of EC Knight Company
It was confirmation that the government was working on behalf of big businesses in late 19th century
After Civil War, South remained overwhelmingly agrarian (If there was a transcontinental railroad, it could have industrialized)
One industry growth in south was the textile (make clothes/fabric) industry
They used immigrants, poor uneducated whites, and former slaves for cheap labor
Era of monopoly capitalism
Business was very powerful and workers had very little rights
On average (non-agrarian) working 6 days a week 10 hours; $1.50 a day
The workers saw that enormous fortunes were being made and they had dangerous conditions and not enough money
They Wanted better wages and better working conditions
better work-life balance
Felt like they were being used
Railroad Strike of 1877: AKA great upheaval
railroad strike on the east coast (hit major cities)
became violent
rutherford sent in troops to cut down violence
first-time federal troops were used to put down a strike
Haymarket Square:
huge protest
Haymarket Riot/Massacre: somebody threw bomb into the crowd
Never found who threw the bomb
4 people were hanged for their crimes
Public blames Knights of Labor and AFL
Public support is lost when it became violent
Homestead:
Carnegie’s home factory
Was very violent, so it lost support
Important: wiped out steel industry for 45 years
Public become completely against the strikes
Pullman Strike: people were attacked and the military was brought in
justification for violence was the mail (the president)
Gilded Era:
Industrialization and Monopoly Capitalism
Not many rights on Capitalism
Factory workers worked 10 hour days, 6 days a week, and wages were $1.50 a day
Reactions to Monopoly Capitalism
political:
greenback labor party →populist →progressive era
people were fighting back they felt that they were being left behind and they were being ignored by the government (state and federal)
Leader: William H. Sylvis
Membership:
Lasted 6 years and attracted 600,000 members: skilled, unskilled, and farmers; excluded Chinese, women and African Americans
Somewhat promoted that they would allow all workers, but their actions were different and they were discriminatory
Goals:
Unify workers across locales and trades to challenge powerful bosses
eight-hour work day, winning the latter for government workers
Better wages and better working conditions
Tactics:.
Salary Arbitration (neutral third party for negotiation)
Binding arbitration: this is agreement and both sides need to stick to it
Leader: Uriah Smith Stevens
Terence Powderly (1869)
Membership:
One big union: only restricted services (non-producer), lawyers, alcohol sellers, bankers, lawyers; wanted all men and women and African Americans and Chinese
Open membership; few successful strikes led to a period of rapid growth
Goals:
Wanted to unify all men and women into a national union; workers to combine their wages so they could collectively purchase mines, factories, and stores
End prison labor; reduces job availability
End Child labor (work for lower wages)
Tactics: Oppose strikes (no social unrest) and favored arbitration
Demise knights of labor: Haymarket Square
Union: Association of workers to improve working conditions (ex. Carpenters, teachers)
Leader: Samuel Gompers (leaders during the Gilded Age)
Membership:
No individual laborer could join the central organization (self-governing national unions)
Basically non political
Included: Skilled craftsmen (Carpenters, bricklayers, electricians, confederation of unions togethers resulted in strength in numbers)
unskilled laborers, including women and especially AFrican Americans fend for themselves
Goals:
Shunned politics for economic strategies and goals
Demanded fairer share for laborer; promoting what he called a pure and simple”unionism, he wanted better wages and working conditions
“Trade agreement”authorizing the closed shop--all union labor
“Closed shop” and collective bargaining---no political/economic clout
“Closed shop”: Hire union members only
Collective Bargaining: Negotiation of contract with business (leave, safety policies, wages, etc.) (everybody was under same contract);
different wages were unfair and then strike; same wages resulted in equality
In Numbers there is strength
Tactics:
Walkout and boycotts
Stronger craft unions of the federation--by pooling funds--were able to amass money that would enable them to ride out prolonged strikes
Leader: Ben Haywood, Eugene V. Debs, Mother Jones
Membership: never attracted more than 150,000 members
All workers: teachers, social workers, construction, bartenders, ANYBODY CAN JOIN (Bosses can’t join) because they wanted worker unity and wanted to overthrow bosses; replace capitalism with socialism
Goals: Craft unionism; Intended to be “One Big Union”; unite skilled and unskilled workers; a socialist economy
Tactics: Pursued what was considered “bread and butter” issues (issues everyone wants to solve: better wages, better conditions, etc.)
Direct Action Method: Propaganda, Strikes, Class Warfare/Violence, boycotts
Most successful: AFL (only focused on Unions’ needs and ONLY skilled workers)
Became symbol of America’s transition from an agricultural to an industrial society (Small town and farms to urbanization) zx
Impact of Industrial Growth in the US was Uneven in Terms Of:
Geography- most industry was in the North and Midwest with less in South
People- few gained fortunes but most worked long, dangerous hours for little pay
1865- US ranked fourth in industrial output behind Britain, France, and Germany
1900- in many industries, the US produced more than the other three combined
By 1900- the US accounted for ⅓ of the world’s manufacturing capacity
Huge income gap during the Gilded Age
10% of the population (industrialists and their families) controlled 90% of the income
Urban poor were at the bottom of the income ladder
They were working long hours in factory and mills jobs for little pay and no benefits
Now the rural poor were at the bottom
Despite the poor working conditions, most Americans did see an increase in their standard of living, if even a slight one
By 1900, ⅔ of all employed Americans worked for wages
The late 19th century witnessed the most deadly--and frequent--labor conflicts in American history; so many people felt exploited by big companies
By 1900 only 3% of American workers belonged to unions
Management held the upper hand in labor disputes, with support (generally) from the government
People were beginning to recognize the need for better balance in the workplace
Public attitudes were changing toward labor unions (muck bringing journalists expose horrible working conditions)
One adult woman out of five in 1900 was in the labor force working for wages (OUT OF ECONOMIC NECESSITY)
Women were paid half of the men wages
Worked the same hours as men----reasoning: men were more productive
Though hard to believe, industrialization did have modest positive effect on women: Earning their place in society and becoming more independent
South During Industrialization
Some Southerners promoted a vision for a “New South” with self-sufficient economy, industrial growth, modernized transportation, and improved race relations (ROMANTICIZED)
Some success stories (NOT in race relations) were Birmingham, Memphis, and Richmond;
South failed to prosper and grow as much as the North
Remained rural and agricultural
Textile industry did thrive in the South (cheap labor)
Work and Business (1865)
Farming and sharecropping
Working in maills
Mining and Railroad work
Segregation
Start of business consolidation (predates monopolies) (Vertical/horizontal integration eventually becomes trusts)
Work and Business (1900)
Farming and sharecropping
Segregation
Women and Children in workforce were cheaper labor
Mechanization of agriculture
Wage work in factories
Monopolies and trusts
Unions