C

Book X Summary

Poetry in Kallipolis

  • Socrates addresses poetry's role, crucial due to its impact on education.
  • New philosophy challenges traditional poetry-based education.
  • Mimesis: shifted from impersonation (Book III) to poems/paintings imitating.
  • Poets don't qualify as teachers of virtue; their works are "third from the truth" (597e).
  • Makers have true belief, but imitators (poets) only have opinions (598d-607a).
  • Imitative poetry is banned for its unsettling influence.
  • Socrates considers a possible defense of poetry (607b-608b).

Imitation

  • Imitative poetry distorts thought unless one knows its true nature (595a-596b).
  • Forms: many particulars share a single Form (e.g., beds, tables) (596b).
  • Craftsmen create based on Forms, but don't create the Forms themselves (596b-597d).
  • Imitators' products are third from the truth; e.g., painter imitates a carpenter's bed, which is already an imitation of the Form of a bed (597e).
  • Imitation is far removed from truth, dealing with appearances (598b).
  • Poets lack knowledge of crafts they depict (598c).
  • Good poets should improve cities or educate people if they possess true knowledge (599c-d).

Impact of Imitation

  • Imitators work at "third remove from that which is" (599e).
  • Poetic imitators paint colored pictures using words without true knowledge (601a).
  • Imitators lack worthwhile knowledge; imitation is a game (602c).
  • Imitation appeals to inferior parts of the soul, not reason
  • Measuring, counting, and weighing are tools of the rational soul (602c-603a).

The Soul and Immortality

  • Rational part resists pain, irrational part gives in (603b-604d).
  • Imitative poet appeals to the excitable character (604e-605a).
  • Imitation corrupts even decent people by indulging in emotions vicariously.
  • Only hymns to gods and eulogies to good people should be admitted in the city (606d-607a).

Immortality of the Soul

  • Socrates argues for the soul's immortality; evil doesn't destroy it (609b).
  • The soul's true nature is masked by association with the body (611c).
  • Study the soul through philosophy to understand its true form (611d-612d).

Consequences of Justice and Injustice

  • Justice brings rewards from gods and humans both in life and after death (612d-613b).
  • Myth of Er: souls are judged, rewarded, or punished after death (613b-614b).
  • Souls choose new lives; choices reflect past lives and character (615c-618d).
  • Importance of choosing a just life, guided by wisdom (619a).
  • Er's tale should persuade individuals to practice justice (621b-d).