GS

JMC 101

Today's Lecture: The Nature of News

Defining Journalism

  • Definition 1: Journalism as a specific strand of media characterized by ethical, professional, and legal principles.

    • Suggests challenges faced by journalism today.

    • Objective: Unpacking the definition and exploring journalism's conventions and future opportunities.

  • Definition 2: Journalism as a profession, a means of earning income, and a process of creating engaging media.

    • Involves timely reporting on current events (e.g., covering a car crash vs. addressing issues like drunk driving).

Characteristics of Journalism

  • Multimedia Output: Encompasses various forms of media including print, radio, TV, and online formats.

  • Types of Content: Journalism covers events and issues significant to a wide audience.

  • General Definition: Journalism primarily revolves around news.

Expectations from Journalism Audiences
  • Audiences expect journalism to serve both public good and entertainment value, contrasting with general mass media goals.

  • Purpose of Journalism: To provide accurate, factual information that serves the public good.

  • Public Good Example: Peabody Awards for courageous reporting, such as the coverage of civilians' plight in Mariupol during the Ukraine invasion.

Key Concepts and Comparisons

Empiricism in Media
  • Mass Media Audiences: Often escape reality, enjoying fictional narratives (e.g., movies, fictional stories).

  • Journalism Audiences: Seek factual information, emphasizing evidence in reporting.

    • Examples:

    • Barbie movie as escapism vs. 538.com utilizing data for predictions.

    • Definition of Empiricism: Basing stories on evidence, involving thorough investigation and unbiased reporting.

Source Credibility
  • Mass Media Audiences: Frequently indifferent to the sources behind information.

  • Journalism Audiences: Prioritize transparent sourcing and reliability.

    • Importance of citation in journalism to lend credibility (e.g., attributing statements to direct sources).

  • Example of Transparency: Quoting sources in context allows audiences to assess credibility.

Innovation vs. Tradition in Journalism
  • Mass Media: Audiences crave novelty and creativity.

  • Journalism: Follows established conventions and language (e.g., AP Stylebook), maintaining consistency over decades.

  • Examples of Creativity in Mass Media: Films that revolutionize genre conventions (e.g., "The Blair Witch Project", "Complete Unknown").

Ethical Standards in Journalism
  • Differences in Ethical Codes: Journalism possesses a more stringent ethical code through organizations like the Society of Professional Journalists.

  • Consequences of Ethical Breaches: Journalists face potential dismissal or disciplinary action for ethical violations.

Complexities of Journalism
  • Corporate Influence: Journalism is not solely for public good; corporate interests often shape editorial decisions (e.g., ownership influences from Jeff Bezos).

  • Opinion-based Programming: Audience consumption of opinion shows can skew perceptions of facts (e.g., 2020 election misinformation).

  • Diversity of Presentation: Many journalism outlets are evolving by incorporating non-traditional formats like games and podcasts (e.g., The New York Times purchasing Wordle).

Values of Journalism

  • Core Values: Fairness, Accuracy, Context, Truth (FACT).

  • Fairness Definition: Ability to assess each side of a situation responsibly; does not necessitate equal representation of all opinions.

    • Case Study: KKK rally coverage vs. Martin Luther King Day (assessing the obligations of representation).

    • Climate Change Reporting: Balancing academic consensus with public opinion in journalism.

  • Accuracy Definition: Ensuring factual correctness in all aspects of reporting, including names, dates, and statistics.

  • Context Definition: Providing background facts to enrich the story (e.g., ProPublica's approach to linking sources).

  • Truth Definition: Aiming for a comprehensive representation of the story’s reality; truth as the cumulative essence of fairness, accuracy, and context.

Conclusion
  • Journalism positions itself as a public good despite corporate constraints and complexities.

  • Recognizes the influence of outside factors on journalistic integrity and ethical considerations.

  • Reiterates the challenge to uphold high standards in service to truth, evidenced by consistent values and adherence to ethical guidelines.

  • Encourages reflection on the performance of journalism against its ideals and expectations in future assessments.

  • Suggested Essay Questions: Reflect on moments journalism has failed to meet its stated ideals. Evaluate how journalism's identity influences its operations and ethics.