mex/am causes notes
Historians have perspectives and arguments; Greg Brandon sides with John Quincy Adams in historical debates.
Understanding that an author has a thesis is crucial; Brandon’s viewpoint influences how he presents historical events.
John Quincy Adams: Exceptional post-presidency career; remained active in Congress for 20 years and argued cases in front of the Supreme Court.
Importance of identifying Brandon's overall thesis, which is present in every chapter despite the lack of introductory reading.
The concept of the frontier is significant in framing his arguments.
Discussion of the racial dynamics and racism affecting various groups, as highlighted by Linda.
Quotes from Brandon and historical figures like John Quincy Adams provide evidence for the argument.
Brandon discusses the idea of America deflecting inward class conflicts outward to the frontier.
Key quote on page 86: comparison of crowded cities and workers fighting oppression,
Instead of class war, Americans waged a race war on the frontier.
The frontier served as an escape from domestic issues, echoing historical conflicts.
The narrative of westward expansion as a solution to societal problems.
Brandon describes the impact of expansion on Native Americans and Mexicans as a 'race war'.
Discussion of historical context where poorer white populations view Native Americans and Mexicans as obstacles rather than allies.
The 'safety valve' concept posits that instead of reforming society, individuals turned to the West for opportunity.
Dissent during the Mexican American War was vocal but limited.
John Quincy Adams and Abraham Lincoln were significant dissenters in Congress.
Lincoln’s challenge to President Polk regarding the justification for war highlighted opposition through a map showing disputed territory.
Thoreau's civil disobedience emphasizes individual resistance against the war, which influenced future movements like the Civil Rights Movement.
Henry David Thoreau wrote about civil disobedience, influencing future protests against unjust wars.
Ulysses S. Grant expressed his opposition to the war, highlighting the moral complexities of military actions.
The mainstream support for manifest destiny overshadowed dissent.
The United States conquered much of Mexico but did not annex the entire country, keeping only the northern territories.
Discussions on slavery rejection by Mexico and its implications for expansion are recognized.
Historians have perspectives and arguments; Greg Brandon sides with John Quincy Adams in historical debates.
Understanding that an author has a thesis is crucial; Brandon’s viewpoint influences how he presents historical events.
John Quincy Adams: Exceptional post-presidency career; remained active in Congress for 20 years and argued cases in front of the Supreme Court.
Importance of identifying Brandon's overall thesis, which is present in every chapter despite the lack of introductory reading.
The concept of the frontier is significant in framing his arguments.
Discussion of the racial dynamics and racism affecting various groups, as highlighted by Linda.
Quotes from Brandon and historical figures like John Quincy Adams provide evidence for the argument.
Brandon discusses the idea of America deflecting inward class conflicts outward to the frontier.
Key quote on page 86: comparison of crowded cities and workers fighting oppression,
Instead of class war, Americans waged a race war on the frontier.
The frontier served as an escape from domestic issues, echoing historical conflicts.
The narrative of westward expansion as a solution to societal problems.
Brandon describes the impact of expansion on Native Americans and Mexicans as a 'race war'.
Discussion of historical context where poorer white populations view Native Americans and Mexicans as obstacles rather than allies.
The 'safety valve' concept posits that instead of reforming society, individuals turned to the West for opportunity.
Dissent during the Mexican American War was vocal but limited.
John Quincy Adams and Abraham Lincoln were significant dissenters in Congress.
Lincoln’s challenge to President Polk regarding the justification for war highlighted opposition through a map showing disputed territory.
Thoreau's civil disobedience emphasizes individual resistance against the war, which influenced future movements like the Civil Rights Movement.
Henry David Thoreau wrote about civil disobedience, influencing future protests against unjust wars.
Ulysses S. Grant expressed his opposition to the war, highlighting the moral complexities of military actions.
The mainstream support for manifest destiny overshadowed dissent.
The United States conquered much of Mexico but did not annex the entire country, keeping only the northern territories.
Discussions on slavery rejection by Mexico and its implications for expansion are recognized.