1920 Election:
The 1920 election occurred in the aftermath of World War I and the Spanish flu pandemic. The major candidates were Republican Senator Warren G. Harding and Democratic Governor James M. Cox. Harding campaigned on a platform of "return to normalcy," advocating for a return to pre-war conditions, limited government intervention, and traditional values. Cox, on the other hand, supported the League of Nations and progressive reforms. Harding's message resonated with a public weary of turmoil, leading to a landslide victory for the Republicans. This election marked a shift towards conservatism and isolationism in American politics. citeturn0search15
1924 Election:
By 1924, the political landscape had evolved. The Republicans nominated incumbent President Calvin Coolidge, who had ascended to the presidency after Harding's death in 1923. Coolidge was known for his laissez-faire approach to governance and support for business interests. The Democrats, after a contentious convention, nominated John W. Davis, a conservative lawyer. A Progressive Party also emerged, nominating Senator Robert M. La Follette, who advocated for government ownership of railroads and other progressive reforms. Coolidge won the election decisively, reflecting the electorate's preference for conservative economic policies and limited government intervention during a period of economic prosperity. citeturn0search12
Economic Prosperity:
The 1920s, often dubbed the "Roaring Twenties," were characterized by significant economic growth and widespread prosperity. As the Secretary of Commerce under Presidents Harding and Coolidge, Hoover was closely associated with this economic boom. His campaign promised the continuation of these prosperous times, a message that resonated with many voters. Hoover's landslide victory, securing 58.1% of the popular vote and 444 electoral votes, reflected the public's desire to maintain the economic status quo. citeturn0search9
Cultural and Religious Divides:
Al Smith, the first Roman Catholic nominated by a major party, faced significant anti-Catholic sentiment. Many Protestants harbored suspicions about Catholic influence, fearing potential allegiance to the Pope over American interests. This prejudice was particularly pronounced in the South, where Smith's religion contributed to his loss in several traditionally Democratic states. Additionally, Smith's opposition to Prohibition alienated rural voters who supported the ban on alcohol, further widening the cultural divide. citeturn0search11
Urban vs. Rural Dynamics:
Smith's support base was predominantly urban, reflecting the growing political influence of cities due to increased immigration and industrialization. He carried several major cities, including New York, Cleveland, and St. Louis, indicating a shift in Democratic strength toward urban centers. However, rural areas, wary of Smith's cultural background and policy positions, overwhelmingly favored Hoover. This urban-rural split highlighted the nation's internal divisions during a time of rapid social change. citeturn0search9
Political Realignment:
Hoover's ability to win traditionally Democratic Southern states signaled a potential shift in political allegiances. Factors such as economic prosperity, cultural biases, and Prohibition stances contributed to this realignment. However, this shift was complex and would continue to evolve in subsequent elections. citeturn0search9
/
Stock Market Crash (October 1929) – The most immediate trigger was the stock market crash on Black Tuesday (October 29, 1929). Speculative investments had driven stock prices to unsustainable levels, and when confidence collapsed, investors rushed to sell, causing a market freefall.
Bank Failures – As panic spread, thousands of banks collapsed due to poor regulation, risky loans, and customers withdrawing their money en masse. This wiped out savings and caused further economic contraction.
Reduction in Consumer Spending and Investment – As people lost jobs and savings, consumer demand plummeted, leading businesses to cut production and lay off workers, creating a vicious cycle of economic decline.
Decline in International Trade – The Smoot-Hawley Tariff (1930) raised U.S. tariffs on imported goods, leading other countries to retaliate. This stifled global trade and deepened the depression worldwide.
Overproduction in Industry and Agriculture – Throughout the 1920s, industries and farms had been producing more goods than the market could absorb. When demand fell, businesses had excess supply but no buyers, leading to factory shutdowns and farm bankruptcies.
Income Inequality and Weak Banking System – Wealth was concentrated among the wealthy, while most Americans struggled financially. A fragile banking system, lacking federal safeguards, meant economic shocks spread rapidly.
Monetary Policy Mistakes – The Federal Reserve failed to provide sufficient money supply or lower interest rates in response to the crisis, making credit even harder to access. This worsened deflation and slowed recovery.
Mass Unemployment – By 1933, unemployment soared to 25% in the U.S., leaving millions without income.
Widespread Bank Closures – Thousands of banks failed, erasing people’s life savings.
Decline in Industrial Production – U.S. industrial output dropped nearly 50% between 1929 and 1932.
Farm Foreclosures and Homelessness – Farmers lost land as crop prices collapsed. Many people became homeless, leading to the rise of Hoovervilles—makeshift shantytowns.
Global Economic Collapse – The Depression spread worldwide, devastating economies in Europe and beyond.
Psychological Impact – Hopelessness and despair led to increased suicide rates and long-term skepticism toward financial institutions and capitalism.
The crisis led to major political changes, including the election of Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1932, who introduced the New Deal to combat the Depression.
President Herbert Hoover and Congress initially responded to the Great Depression with economic principles rooted in laissez-faire capitalism, voluntarism, and limited government intervention. Hoover believed that the economy would naturally recover without significant federal intervention, and his policies reflected these principles.
Laissez-Faire Economics – Hoover was influenced by the long-standing belief that the economy was self-correcting and that government intervention could do more harm than good. He resisted direct federal relief to individuals, fearing it would create dependence on government aid.
Voluntarism – Hoover encouraged businesses to maintain wages and production voluntarily rather than resort to layoffs, believing that private-sector cooperation was the best way to stabilize the economy. However, as the Depression worsened, most businesses ignored these appeals and cut wages and jobs to survive.
Balanced Budget and Limited Government Spending – Hoover and Congress were committed to avoiding large budget deficits. They believed that increasing federal spending would lead to government debt and long-term economic instability. As a result, they were reluctant to enact large-scale public works projects or direct relief programs.
Protective Tariffs (Economic Nationalism) – The Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act (1930) was intended to protect American industries by raising tariffs on foreign goods. However, this backfired when other countries retaliated with their own tariffs, severely reducing international trade and worsening the global economic downturn.
Reliance on Local and State Governments – Hoover believed that local governments and private charities should handle relief efforts, rather than the federal government. However, state and local governments lacked the resources to address the growing crisis.
Public Works and Business Aid (Limited Intervention) – As the Depression deepened, Hoover made some exceptions to his limited-government approach:
The Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC) (1932) provided emergency loans to banks, railroads, and businesses to prevent further collapses. However, it was criticized for aiding corporations while offering little direct relief to ordinary Americans.
Public Works Projects, such as the Hoover Dam, were initiated to create jobs, but they were too small in scale to significantly impact unemployment.
Hoover’s policies were largely seen as too little, too late. His insistence on voluntarism and limited government intervention failed to stop the economic decline, and by 1932, the Depression had worsened dramatically. His approach was widely criticized, leading to his overwhelming defeat by Franklin D. Roosevelt, who advocated for a more active government response through the New Deal.
For ordinary Americans, the Great Depression was a time of widespread hardship, uncertainty, and desperation. While statistics tell part of the story, the lived experience of everyday people paints a much starker picture of economic collapse.
Mass Unemployment and Job Insecurity
By 1933, one in four Americans was unemployed, and even those with jobs faced pay cuts and reduced hours.
Breadwinners, particularly men, faced a crisis of identity as they struggled to provide for their families.
Job seekers lined up daily outside factories and businesses, often competing for a single available position.
Hunger and Malnutrition
Many families couldn’t afford basic necessities, forcing them to skip meals or rely on cheap, nutrient-poor food.
Breadlines and soup kitchens, often run by churches or charities, became a common sight in cities.
In rural areas, farmers who couldn’t sell their crops at a profit saw them rot in the fields, even as people went hungry.
Homelessness and Displacement
As banks foreclosed on homes, thousands of families became homeless.
Makeshift "Hoovervilles" (shantytowns named after President Hoover) sprang up in urban areas, with people living in cardboard shacks and scavenging for food.
Many desperate Americans became "hobos," riding freight trains across the country in search of work.
Impact on Families and Mental Health
Families struggled to stay together, as economic stress led to higher rates of desertion and family breakups.
Children had to drop out of school to help support their families, either by working or by begging.
The psychological toll was severe—suicide rates increased, and many suffered from feelings of hopelessness and shame.
The Dust Bowl and Rural Suffering
In the Midwest, farmers faced additional devastation due to the Dust Bowl, a series of severe droughts and dust storms.
Thousands of farming families, especially from Oklahoma and Texas ("Okies"), migrated to California in search of work, often facing discrimination and exploitation.
Farm prices were so low that some farmers burned their crops for heat rather than sell them at a loss.
Racial and Ethnic Disparities
African Americans, Latinos, and immigrants faced even greater discrimination in hiring and relief efforts.
Many black workers in the South were pushed out of jobs by desperate white laborers competing for work.
Mexican Americans were often scapegoated and, in some cases, forcibly deported—even if they were U.S. citizens.
People turned to movies, radio shows, and music as an escape from their hardships. Hollywood flourished with uplifting films, and songs like "Brother, Can You Spare a Dime?" captured the era’s despair.
Writers such as John Steinbeck (in The Grapes of Wrath) chronicled the struggles of the working poor.
The Depression fueled a growing interest in labor unions and political activism, as people demanded government action.
By 1932, the Great Depression had devastated the country, and Herbert Hoover’s response was widely seen as ineffective. Franklin D. Roosevelt (FDR) emerged as a far more appealing choice for several reasons:
A Message of Hope and Change
While Hoover remained committed to limited government intervention, FDR promised bold action.
His optimistic and confident tone, captured in his famous phrase, "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself," reassured a desperate public.
The Promise of the New Deal
FDR pledged a "New Deal for the American people," signaling an activist government approach to relief, recovery, and reform.
He proposed direct aid to struggling Americans, in contrast to Hoover’s belief that private charities and local governments should provide relief.
Criticism of Hoover’s Failures
Under Hoover, unemployment soared to 25%, and banks continued failing.
Many Americans blamed Hoover for inaction and policies like the Smoot-Hawley Tariff, which worsened the economic crisis.
The Bonus Army incident, where Hoover ordered the violent removal of World War I veterans protesting for early bonuses, damaged his reputation.
Democratic Appeal to Working-Class and Minority Voters
FDR’s Democratic Party began forming a new coalition of urban workers, African Americans, and progressives who had suffered under Republican policies.
His campaign emphasized government intervention to help struggling Americans, making him the clear choice for those seeking change.
In a landslide victory, FDR won 42 out of 48 states, demonstrating the country’s overwhelming rejection of Hoover’s policies.
During his first 100 days in office (March–June 1933), FDR and Congress passed sweeping legislation that reshaped the government’s role in the economy. The government took on three major new roles:
Direct Economic Relief
Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA) – Provided direct cash assistance to states for unemployment relief.
Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) – Created jobs for young men in conservation projects like planting trees and building national parks.
Financial and Banking Reform
Emergency Banking Act – Closed all banks ("Bank Holiday"), allowing only stable banks to reopen and restoring public confidence in the banking system.
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) – Insured bank deposits to prevent bank runs and protect savings.
Securities Act (1933) – Established regulations for stock market transparency, reducing speculation and fraud.
Government-Led Economic Recovery and Regulation
Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA) – Paid farmers to reduce crop production, stabilizing food prices and farm income.
Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) – Built dams, power plants, and infrastructure to bring electricity and jobs to rural areas.
National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA) – Encouraged businesses to set fair wages and prices while promoting union rights.
1. Business Leaders and Conservatives
Many business leaders and Republicans believed the New Deal was too interventionist, harming free enterprise and expanding government power too much.
They opposed high government spending, regulations, and pro-union policies that they saw as threats to capitalism.
The American Liberty League (1934) – A group of conservative politicians and businessmen that accused FDR of pushing the U.S. toward socialism and violating individual liberties.
2. Supreme Court Opposition
The Supreme Court struck down key New Deal programs, such as the National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA) and the Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA), ruling them unconstitutional for overextending federal power.
This led FDR to propose the "court-packing" plan in 1937, which failed but pressured the Court to be more favorable toward the New Deal.
3. Southern Democrats
Many Southern Democrats supported segregation and opposed New Deal labor policies that empowered Black workers and strengthened labor unions.
They resisted federal interference in state affairs, fearing civil rights reforms could follow economic regulations.
1. Huey Long – "Share Our Wealth" Movement
Huey Long, a populist senator from Louisiana, argued that the New Deal was too moderate and did not do enough to redistribute wealth.
Proposed a "Share Our Wealth" plan, which would tax the rich heavily and provide guaranteed incomes, housing, and education for all Americans.
Gained massive popularity, but he was assassinated in 1935 before he could challenge FDR in 1936.
2. Father Charles Coughlin – Radical Economic Reform
A Catholic priest with a huge radio following, Coughlin initially supported FDR but later accused him of being too friendly to bankers.
Advocated for nationalizing banks, inflating the currency, and stronger government control over the economy.
Eventually became controversial due to anti-Semitic rhetoric and lost mainstream support.
3. Francis Townsend – Old-Age Pensions
Dr. Francis Townsend, a retired doctor, argued that the New Deal failed to help the elderly.
Proposed the Townsend Plan, which would give $200 per month to every American over 60, funded by a national sales tax.
Though never enacted, Townsend’s movement pressured FDR to pass Social Security in 1935.
FDR had to balance between both sides, adjusting the New Deal to maintain broad support.
Left-wing pressures led to more aggressive reforms, such as Social Security, higher taxes on the wealthy, and stronger labor protections in the Second New Deal.
Right-wing opposition contributed to slowing some reforms, and after 1938, a conservative coalition in Congress blocked further expansions.
Feature | First New Deal (1933–1934) | Second New Deal (1935–1938) |
Primary Focus | Relief & Recovery | Reform & Economic Security |
Approach | Experimentation & Emergency Action | More Systematic & Institutionalized Changes |
Target Audience | Banks, Businesses, and Farmers | Workers, the Elderly, and the Poor |
Government Role | Government as Economic Stabilizer | Government as Social Welfare Provider |
Opposition Response | Responded to business and conservative critics | Responded to radical critics calling for more reform |
Social Security Act (1935)
Created Social Security, providing pensions for retirees, unemployment insurance, and aid to disabled individuals.
First major government program for long-term financial security.
Wagner Act (National Labor Relations Act, 1935)
Guaranteed workers’ rights to unionize and collectively bargain.
Strengthened labor protections and led to a rise in union membership.
Works Progress Administration (WPA, 1935)
Created millions of jobs in public works, including roads, bridges, schools, and artistic projects.
Provided employment for artists, writers, and musicians, supporting cultural projects.
Wealth Tax Act (1935)
Raised taxes on the wealthy and large corporations, responding to criticisms from populists like Huey Long.
Rural Electrification Administration (REA, 1935)
Brought electricity to rural America, improving the quality of life for farmers.
Fair Labor Standards Act (1938)
Established the first national minimum wage, maximum work hours (40 per week), and banned child labor.
Expanded the role of government in everyday life by establishing programs that provided long-term economic protections.
Strengthened labor rights and social safety nets, laying the foundation for modern welfare programs.
Increased opposition from conservatives and business leaders, leading to the rise of the conservative coalition in Congress after 1938, which slowed further reforms.
The Great Depression coincided with severe environmental crises, particularly the Dust Bowl, which devastated farms and displaced thousands of Americans. FDR and his administration saw environmental restoration as a way to create jobs, conserve natural resources, and promote long-term economic recovery.
The Dust Bowl Crisis (1930s)
Severe drought and overfarming turned the Great Plains into a wasteland of dust storms, displacing thousands of farm families (especially in Oklahoma and Texas).
The government recognized the need for soil conservation programs to prevent future agricultural disasters.
Job Creation Through Conservation Work
Many unemployed Americans could be put to work on environmental projects such as planting trees, preventing erosion, and building infrastructure.
These projects combined economic relief with long-term environmental benefits.
FDR’s Personal Conservation Interests
FDR was a strong advocate for natural resource conservation, influenced by early environmentalists like Theodore Roosevelt and Gifford Pinchot.
He believed in restoring forests, waterways, and farmlands to ensure the nation’s long-term prosperity.
Sustainable Land and Water Use for Future Growth
The New Deal aimed to modernize rural America, bringing electricity, irrigation, and flood control to underdeveloped regions.
✅ Results:
Employed over 3 million young men in forestry, national parks, and erosion control.
Planted over 3 billion trees, restored grasslands, and built trails, parks, and fire lookout towers.
Helped develop the modern National Parks system.
✅ Results:
Introduced crop rotation, contour plowing, and reforestation to prevent further Dust Bowl conditions.
Encouraged scientific farming methods to restore soil health.
✅ Results:
Built dams and hydroelectric plants, bringing electricity, flood control, and irrigation to the Tennessee Valley.
Improved soil conditions and water management for agriculture.
✅ Results:
Provided electricity to remote rural areas, improving farm productivity and quality of life.
✅ Results:
Built major infrastructure projects, including dams (e.g., Hoover Dam, Grand Coulee Dam) to improve water supply and irrigation.
Expanded national infrastructure for future growth.
✔ Helped prevent future environmental disasters through soil conservation and reforestation.
✔ Created lasting national parks, forests, and infrastructure that benefited future generations.
✔ Transformed rural America, bringing electricity, irrigation, and modernized farming techniques.
✔ Laid the foundation for future environmental policies, influencing later conservation efforts.
Expansion of the Federal Government: The New Deal significantly increased the size and role of the federal government, establishing it as an active participant in the economy through social welfare programs, labor protections, and economic regulation.
Social Safety Nets: Programs like Social Security, unemployment insurance, and public health initiatives laid the foundation for the modern welfare state, providing long-term support for vulnerable populations.
Labor Rights and Unions: The New Deal strengthened labor rights with the Wagner Act, allowing unions to grow and secure better wages, hours, and working conditions for workers, shaping the future of labor movements in America.
Environmental Conservation and Infrastructure: Programs like the Civilian Conservation Corps and Tennessee Valley Authority created lasting environmental improvements and infrastructure, modernizing rural areas and laying the groundwork for future environmental policies.
The expansionist ambitions of Japan, Italy, and Germany in the early 20th century were motivated by a combination of economic, political, and ideological factors. Each country sought to enhance its global power, secure resources, and assert dominance in the face of perceived challenges. Here are the key motivations behind their actions:
Economic Needs: Japan's rapid industrialization created a need for raw materials and markets. As its population grew, Japan sought new territories to supply the resources it lacked, such as oil, rubber, and food.
Imperial Ambition: Japan aimed to become a dominant power in East Asia, similar to Western imperial powers. This led to territorial expansion in China, Korea, and later Southeast Asia.
Military Influence: Japan's military elite believed that expansion was essential for national security and to assert Japan as a world power on par with European nations and the United States.
Desire to Challenge the West: Japan sought to assert independence from Western powers, particularly after feeling humiliated by the unequal treaties imposed on them in the 19th century.
National Prestige: Italy, unified only in 1861, sought to enhance its status as a great European power. Its leaders believed that acquiring colonies would bring prestige, similar to other European powers like Britain and France.
Economic Resources: Italy's economy was relatively underdeveloped compared to other European nations, so it sought to secure new markets and resources through territorial expansion.
Fascist Ideology: Under Benito Mussolini, fascist ideology promoted the idea of an Italian empire. Mussolini sought to restore Italy to the glory of the Roman Empire, aiming to expand into North Africa (especially Ethiopia) and the Mediterranean.
Military Might: Mussolini believed that military conquest was essential for national strength and unity, using wars like the invasion of Ethiopia (1935) to enhance his regime’s power and distract from domestic issues.
Lebensraum (Living Space): Under Adolf Hitler, Germany's expansionism was driven by the belief that the German people needed more territory to thrive. Hitler envisioned expanding eastward into Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union to provide land and resources for Germans.
Nationalism and Racial Superiority: Hitler’s Nazi ideology promoted the idea that Aryan Germans were a superior race and had the right to dominate and colonize other peoples, particularly Slavs and Jews, whom the Nazis considered inferior.
Economic Resources and Strategic Control: Germany sought control over key resources, especially in the resource-rich Soviet Union and Eastern Europe. Hitler’s goal was to make Germany self-sufficient (autarky), reducing reliance on other countries.
Revenge and Revisionism: The Treaty of Versailles (1919), which ended World War I, had imposed harsh penalties on Germany. Nazi leaders aimed to reverse these terms, rebuild military strength, and regain lost territories such as the Saar and Sudetenland, and ultimately expand into neighboring countries.
Desire for Power and Prestige: All three nations sought to assert themselves as dominant global powers, challenging the influence of Western colonial empires and other major countries.
Economic Necessity: Securing territories for resources was a key motivator, driven by the need for natural resources, markets, and food production.
Militaristic Ideologies: Each country was motivated by militaristic ideologies that promoted the idea that war and conquest were essential for national greatness and survival.
Nationalism and Ideology: Strong nationalist and ideological currents, including fascism in Italy and Nazism in Germany, led to the belief in the superiority of their nations and justified aggressive expansionism.
Isolationist Sentiment: In the 1930s, the United States had a strong isolationist sentiment, stemming from the trauma of World War I and the belief that America should avoid entangling itself in foreign conflicts. Many Americans felt that the U.S. should focus on domestic issues, especially during the Great Depression.
Neutrality Acts (1935-1937): To keep the U.S. out of foreign conflicts, Congress passed the Neutrality Acts, which restricted arms sales and loans to belligerent nations. The goal was to prevent American involvement in the growing tensions in Europe and Asia.
Public Opinion: While many Americans were sympathetic to the Allied cause, the prevailing attitude was still one of non-intervention.
German Expansion: By 1940, Germany's rapid conquest of Europe—invading Poland (1939), France (1940), and much of Western Europe—began to shift public opinion. The threat of Nazi Germany was seen as a growing danger to global stability.
Lend-Lease Act (1941): In 1941, President Franklin D. Roosevelt introduced the Lend-Lease Act, which allowed the U.S. to supply military aid to Allied nations, including Britain, the Soviet Union, and China, without direct military involvement. This was a crucial shift from neutrality to indirect support.
Economic Mobilization: The U.S. began ramping up military production and trade with the Allies, providing them with essential resources, particularly weapons, ammunition, and food.
Japanese Expansion: In the Pacific, Japan’s aggression toward China and Southeast Asia led to increasing tensions with the U.S., which imposed economic sanctions, including oil embargoes, in retaliation.
German and Italian Declarations of War: After Japan’s attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, the U.S. declared war on Japan the following day. Germany and Italy declared war on the U.S. shortly after, further solidifying America’s entry into the conflict.
The Shift to Total War: After Pearl Harbor, the U.S. quickly shifted from supporting the Allies with resources to direct military involvement in both the European and Pacific theaters.
War Effort Mobilization: The U.S. rapidly mobilized for war, with massive industrial production churning out war materials, including tanks, planes, and ships. The war effort also involved millions of soldiers, sailors, and airmen who served on multiple fronts.
Military Strategy and Alliances: The U.S. played a central role in key military victories, including the D-Day invasion (1944) in Europe and the defeat of Japan through the island-hopping campaign in the Pacific.
Economic and Military Power: By the end of the war, the U.S. had not only helped to secure Allied victory but also became the dominant global superpower, having emerged from the war with a strong economy, a well-equipped military, and nuclear weapons.
Global Leadership: After WWII, the U.S. emerged as a leader in creating the United Nations, an international organization aimed at promoting peace and preventing future wars.
Cold War and Superpower Status: The war marked the beginning of the Cold War between the U.S. and the Soviet Union, leading the U.S. to become more involved in global affairs, particularly in Europe, Asia, and Latin America, where it sought to contain communism.