REL Shaw, Rosalind, 1990. The invention of African Traditional Religion

Introduction

• Rosalind Shaw discusses the concept of "African Traditional Religion" in her article in the Journal of Religion in Africa (1990).

Comparative Religion and Taxonomy

• Analysis of comparative terms, emphasizing the complexity of categorizing cultural practices such as marriage and witchcraft.

• Edmund Leach critiques "matrilineal societies" as a relevant category, suggesting such classifications hinder anthropological understanding.

Frameworks in Religious Studies

• Religious studies often rely on typological categories (e.g., Eastern, Western, universal religions), leading to artificial classifications.

• Categories like "world religions" and "universal religions" are ambiguous and vary based on region, orientation, and numerical strength.

• Methods of categorization often reflect Western biases, inadvertently excluding various religious practices that do not conform to these categories.

Gaps in Classification

• The use of terms like "traditional religions" and "primal religions" fills gaps left by mainstream classifications.

• These residual categories predispose scholars to invent common features within diverse religious practices, which may misrepresent the complexities of these systems.

The Construction of "Traditional Religions"

• "Traditional" religions denote the continuity of practices through generations but imply stasis, which overlooks their historical evolution.

• Discussions around literacy and religion highlight the inadequacy of dividing religions into "literate" and "non-literate" as many oral traditions have sophisticated systems.

Idowu's Influence on African Religions#

• E. Bolaji Idowu challenged Western conceptualizations, advancing the idea of "diffused monotheism," which contrasts simplistic views of African deities as unrefined.

• Idowu's seminal work impacted the assimilation of African spirituality into academic discourse, often ignoring historical contextualization.

Critique of Western Scholarship

/

• Western scholars often viewed African concepts of God as vague, leading to paternalistic evaluations of African religions.

• Some scholars assert that the misunderstanding stems from an overemphasis on Judeo-Christian norms while interpreting African religious forms.

Missionary Influence on Religious Constructs

• Early studies of African religions often coincided with Christian missions, which shaped the perception of African spiritual practices.

• Missionaries favored specific aspects of African religions, integrating them into a Judeo-Christian context, while dismissing others.

Impact of Nationalism and Independence

• The independence movements in Africa prompted revisions in how African religious forms were viewed and studied, advocating for a positive reevaluation.

• The emergence of independent African churches fostered a notion of cultural reclamation during a period of ethical and intellectual awakening.

Emergence and Critique of "African Traditional Religion"

• Geoffrey Parrinder's terminology helped solidify the term "African Traditional Religion"; however, the aggregation of diverse religions into a singular category often leads to homogenization.

• Contemporary critiques highlight the persistent Western-centric evaluation frameworks in scholarly work.

Recent Reinterpretations of Igbo Religion

• Focus on the reinterpretation of Igbo deities and their significance, with critiques challenging the idea that all deities are merely representations of a supreme being.

• Historians like C. N. Ubah argue against the reductive interpretation of sacrifices as strictly channeled to Chukwu, illustrating more complex beliefs.

• Donatus Nwoga posits that terms for Igbo supreme beings, like Chukwu, were influenced by Judeo-Christian contexts and may not reflect original beliefs.

Conclusion

• The homogenization of African religions under the banner of "African Traditional Religion" serves to perpetuate a Western-centric lens in the study of African spiritual practices.

• This analysis shows the necessity of revisiting and reevaluating traditional classifications to allow for the full spectrum of African religious experiences without oversimplifying or stereotyping.