Chapter 13: Wage Determination
Wages are price that employers pay for labor
Wage rate - Price paid per unit of labor services
Nominal wage - Amount of money received per hour/day/year
Real wage - Quantity of goods and services a worker can obtain with nominal wages; real wages reveal the “purchasing power” of nominal wages
Depends on nominal wage + prices of goods/services purchased
Role of productivity
Greater productivity → Greater demand
Plentiful capital
Access to abundant natural resources
Advanced technology
Labor quality
Other factors like management, sizes of markets, etc.
Real wages + productivity
Real income per worker increases at same rate as output per worker
Increases in labor demand > Increases in labor supply
Long-run increase in wage rates + employment
Purely-competitive labor market - Numerous firms competing; qualified workers w/ identical skills; “wage takers”
Supply curve slopes upward
Firms pay higher wages → Attract workers away from alternative job opportunities
Intersection of the market labor demand curve and the market labor supply curve determines the equilibrium wage rate and level of employment
Maximize profits by hiring up until MRP = MRC
MRC = Resource price
Only earning normal profit
(The green area is the firm’s total wage cost; the brown area is its nonlabor costs, including a normal profit)
Monopsony - A market in which a single employer of labor has substantial buying (hiring) power
Only single buyer of labor
“Wage maker”
Labor supply curve for market + firm are identical
Upward sloping supply curve
Paying a uniform wage to all workers means that the cost of an extra worker—the marginal resource (labor) cost (MRC)—is the sum of that worker’s wage rate and the amount necessary to bring the wage rate of all current workers up to the new wage level
MRC above supply curve
Hires smaller # of workers + pays less than competitive wage rate
Examples
Small # of hospitals in a city → Lower starting wages
Professional sports leagues
Unions
Demand-enhancement model
Increase demand for goods/services produced → Increase demand for labor
Political lobbying
Altering price of inputs
Supporting policies that reduce prices of complementary resources
Exclusive/craft union model
Reduce supply of labor
Restrict # of workers that can join union
Exclusive unionism - By excluding workers from unions and therefore from the labor supply, craft unions succeed in elevating wage rates
Occupational licensing - A group of workers in a given occupation pressure Federal, state, or municipal government to pass a law that says that some occupational group (for example, barbers, physicians, lawyers, plumbers, cosmetologists, egg graders, pest controllers) can practice their trade only if they meet certain requirements
Inclusive/industrial union model
Inclusive unionism - Organizing all available workers, no matter skill level
Increase in supply of labor → No drop in wages b/c workers organizing w/ union
Bilateral monopoly - Combo of monopsony + inclusive unionism
The monopsonistic employer will seek the below-competitive-equilibrium wage rate, and the union will press for some above competitive-equilibrium wage rate
Monopolies can cancel out
Minimum wage controversy
Case against
Cause employers to hire fewer workers
“Poorly targeted” to reduce household poverty
Case for
Could cause employers to hire more workers
Could help firms raise productivity
Wage differentials - Hourly wage rates and annual salaries differ greatly among occupations
Caused by differences in supply + demand
Strength of labor demand differs among occupations
Non-competing groups - Each representing different occupations for which members of a group qualify
Ability/physical attributes
Education + training
Human capital - The personal stock of knowledge, know-how, and skills that enables a person to be productive and thus to earn income
Compensating differences - Wage differentials paid to compensate for nonmonetary differences in various jobs
Help allocate society’s scarce labor resources
Market imperfections that impede workers from moving from lower-paying jobs to higher-paying jobs
Lack of job information - Workers may simply be unaware of job opportunities and wage rates in other geographic areas and in other jobs for which they qualify
Geographic immobility - Many workers are reluctant to move to new places
Unions + gov’t restraints - Wage differentials may be reinforced by artificial restrictions on mobility imposed by unions and government
Discrimination - Results in lower wages being paid to women and minority workers than to white males doing very similar or even identical work
Pay for performance
Workers are the firms’ agents; they are hired to advance the interest (profit) of the firms. The principals are the firms; they hire agents to advance their goals.
Interests of firms + workers not identical → Principal agent problem arises
Incentive pay plan - Ties worker compensation more closely to worker output or performance
Piece rates - Compensated based on # of units produced
Commissions/royalties
Bonuses, stock options, profit sharing
Efficiency wages
Problems
Poor product quality
Fraudulent sales practices
Free-riding
Manipulating costs + revenue streams
Wages are price that employers pay for labor
Wage rate - Price paid per unit of labor services
Nominal wage - Amount of money received per hour/day/year
Real wage - Quantity of goods and services a worker can obtain with nominal wages; real wages reveal the “purchasing power” of nominal wages
Depends on nominal wage + prices of goods/services purchased
Role of productivity
Greater productivity → Greater demand
Plentiful capital
Access to abundant natural resources
Advanced technology
Labor quality
Other factors like management, sizes of markets, etc.
Real wages + productivity
Real income per worker increases at same rate as output per worker
Increases in labor demand > Increases in labor supply
Long-run increase in wage rates + employment
Purely-competitive labor market - Numerous firms competing; qualified workers w/ identical skills; “wage takers”
Supply curve slopes upward
Firms pay higher wages → Attract workers away from alternative job opportunities
Intersection of the market labor demand curve and the market labor supply curve determines the equilibrium wage rate and level of employment
Maximize profits by hiring up until MRP = MRC
MRC = Resource price
Only earning normal profit
(The green area is the firm’s total wage cost; the brown area is its nonlabor costs, including a normal profit)
Monopsony - A market in which a single employer of labor has substantial buying (hiring) power
Only single buyer of labor
“Wage maker”
Labor supply curve for market + firm are identical
Upward sloping supply curve
Paying a uniform wage to all workers means that the cost of an extra worker—the marginal resource (labor) cost (MRC)—is the sum of that worker’s wage rate and the amount necessary to bring the wage rate of all current workers up to the new wage level
MRC above supply curve
Hires smaller # of workers + pays less than competitive wage rate
Examples
Small # of hospitals in a city → Lower starting wages
Professional sports leagues
Unions
Demand-enhancement model
Increase demand for goods/services produced → Increase demand for labor
Political lobbying
Altering price of inputs
Supporting policies that reduce prices of complementary resources
Exclusive/craft union model
Reduce supply of labor
Restrict # of workers that can join union
Exclusive unionism - By excluding workers from unions and therefore from the labor supply, craft unions succeed in elevating wage rates
Occupational licensing - A group of workers in a given occupation pressure Federal, state, or municipal government to pass a law that says that some occupational group (for example, barbers, physicians, lawyers, plumbers, cosmetologists, egg graders, pest controllers) can practice their trade only if they meet certain requirements
Inclusive/industrial union model
Inclusive unionism - Organizing all available workers, no matter skill level
Increase in supply of labor → No drop in wages b/c workers organizing w/ union
Bilateral monopoly - Combo of monopsony + inclusive unionism
The monopsonistic employer will seek the below-competitive-equilibrium wage rate, and the union will press for some above competitive-equilibrium wage rate
Monopolies can cancel out
Minimum wage controversy
Case against
Cause employers to hire fewer workers
“Poorly targeted” to reduce household poverty
Case for
Could cause employers to hire more workers
Could help firms raise productivity
Wage differentials - Hourly wage rates and annual salaries differ greatly among occupations
Caused by differences in supply + demand
Strength of labor demand differs among occupations
Non-competing groups - Each representing different occupations for which members of a group qualify
Ability/physical attributes
Education + training
Human capital - The personal stock of knowledge, know-how, and skills that enables a person to be productive and thus to earn income
Compensating differences - Wage differentials paid to compensate for nonmonetary differences in various jobs
Help allocate society’s scarce labor resources
Market imperfections that impede workers from moving from lower-paying jobs to higher-paying jobs
Lack of job information - Workers may simply be unaware of job opportunities and wage rates in other geographic areas and in other jobs for which they qualify
Geographic immobility - Many workers are reluctant to move to new places
Unions + gov’t restraints - Wage differentials may be reinforced by artificial restrictions on mobility imposed by unions and government
Discrimination - Results in lower wages being paid to women and minority workers than to white males doing very similar or even identical work
Pay for performance
Workers are the firms’ agents; they are hired to advance the interest (profit) of the firms. The principals are the firms; they hire agents to advance their goals.
Interests of firms + workers not identical → Principal agent problem arises
Incentive pay plan - Ties worker compensation more closely to worker output or performance
Piece rates - Compensated based on # of units produced
Commissions/royalties
Bonuses, stock options, profit sharing
Efficiency wages
Problems
Poor product quality
Fraudulent sales practices
Free-riding
Manipulating costs + revenue streams