V

Introduction to the Criminal Justice System – Lecture Notes (Lecture Overview and Case Context)

Course Logistics and Context

  • The instructor acknowledges there is a cost to the course materials, mentioning that the textbook counts as a textbook and that students should ensure they’re not charged for items that aren’t part of the required materials (e.g., ownership materials).
  • Announced plan: start Chapter 1 and aim to finish the chapter by Friday; the chapter is described as short.
  • The course covers fundamentals and provides an overview before diving deeper into topics that may require more nuanced discussion.
  • The three components of the criminal justice system are introduced here (not necessarily in a fixed order): police, courts, and corrections; some cases are handled entirely by police, some go to court, and some may begin with police and circle back through the system.
  • The instructor references prior exposure (high school criminal justice courses) and clarifies that university courses may address topics that were less comfortable in high school settings; students are reminded that the course will include potentially sensitive material and a disclaimer may be given before certain videos.
  • Emphasis on adult learning and readiness to engage with challenging content in a university setting.

Three Components of the Criminal Justice System

  • Core trio: Police, Courts, Corrections.
  • Order is not fixed; sequence can vary by case.
  • Many cases end at the police stage or are resolved early; others proceed to court, and some move through the full cycle (police → court → corrections) or start at different points and loop back.
  • The material highlights the integrated yet non-linear nature of how cases move through the system.

Context for the Course and Topic Framing

  • The course contrasts high school criminal justice exposure with university-level depth.
  • Acknowledges “hot topics” may be discussed and some topics could be uncomfortable; disclaimer is given at the start of lectures when videos or sensitive content is shown.
  • The lecturer frames the CJ system as a real-world, societal institution that students will engage with beyond the classroom.

Media, Information Literacy, and the Current Situation

  • Media consumption is discussed as the primary source of information for many students today, with social media as the dominant platform, though some still rely on newspapers or traditional news channels (CNN, Fox, etc.).
  • When encountering crime news online, students are advised to:
    • Look beyond the article content to see how others react and discuss the story.
    • Check other platforms for corroboration and seek out video evidence or backups.
    • Assess whether the information is sensationalized or backed by evidence.
    • Read captions and especially the comments section for additional context, explanations, or names/details that can aid understanding, while recognizing comments can also mislead.
  • Social media is described as a double-edged sword: it can provide information but can also distort perception and fuel misinformation or “fake news.”
  • A statistical reference is made: according to FBI data, there are over 8{,}000{,}000 serious offenses reported, underscoring the scale of crime and the relevance of the CJ system to the public.
  • The role of tax dollars is introduced as a critical factor in funding crime prevention, law enforcement, and related services.

Tax Dollars and Resource Allocation in the CJ System

  • Tax dollars fund multiple CJ components (policing, courts, corrections) and related public safety needs.
  • Examples mentioned:
    • A local debate about funding a gym for police officers, illustrating how taxpayers decide among competing priorities (gym vs. bulletproof vests, vehicles, other equipment).
    • The broader investment in infrastructure (e.g., proposed overpasses) that can influence public safety and transportation but also incur costs and potential risks (e.g., car accidents during construction or after).
  • Resource allocation decisions reflect policy priorities and can affect crime prevention effectiveness; insufficient funding may leave gaps in enforcement or services, impacting crime levels in different areas.
  • The CJ system’s cost is framed as a real-world consideration—policing, courts, and corrections each contribute to billions of dollars in expenditure.
  • The discussion ties tax dollars to the capacity to enforce laws, deliver services, and implement crime prevention strategies.

Why We Should Learn About the Criminal Justice System

  • The CJ system is part of a free, democratic society; understanding how it works helps citizens engage thoughtfully in civic life.
  • Online discussions sometimes reveal misinformation or misinterpretations about rights (e.g., bail):
    • The statement: there is no constitutional right to bail; bail is not guaranteed and is determined by judge discretion.
    • The course emphasizes that bail decisions involve legal standards and judgment, not automatic rights.
  • Regardless of whether students are CJ majors, the material is relevant because it affects everyone in society and can impact individuals at any point (victimized, accused, or involved in legal processes).
  • An important goal is to understand how tax dollars are spent within the CJ system and what outcomes arise from funding decisions.

Foundational Role of Criminal Law in the CJ System

  • The CJ system runs on criminal laws established by the state or federal government.
  • Laws provide the framework for police action, prosecution, judicial processes, and corrections; without laws, there would be no basis for enforcement.
  • Examples illustrate that people can be charged and arrested only where the law prohibits certain conduct; the instructor notes that people sometimes misunderstand what is required or prohibited, hence the need for legal literacy.
  • Anecdote about a neighbor who didn’t know a particular law (driving shirtless) to illustrate how laws exist even if individuals are unaware of them; authorities can explain where the law is written when asked.
  • The law forms the basis for what police officers must enforce and how cases proceed through the system.

Case Study Introduction: The Polly Klaas Case and Implications for CJ Policy

  • The instructor introduces a controversial case (the “Hottie class” video) that generated widespread public outrage and discussion about the CJ system.
  • Case details (as recounted in the lecture):
    • In 1993, Claudia (Polly Klaas) was abducted from a slumber party at a mall after being at a sleepover with friends.
    • The perpetrator was a man with a criminal history who had previous priors for rape and attempted kidnapping.
    • The offender had been released from prison after serving a sentence (e.g., an eight-year term) but subsequently committed crimes including torture, rape, and murder.
    • The case raised intense public concern about how repeat offenders are managed within the system, parole decisions, and the adequacy of protections for children.
  • The offender’s prior record included multiple instances of criminal behavior and probation violations, calling into question how parole and release decisions are made.
  • Public reactions included protests and debates about whether the legal and correctional system was doing enough to protect potential victims, and whether laws or policies should change to prevent similar tragedies.
  • Central questions raised by the case:
    • Should repeat offenders be released earlier or granted parole, given a history of violence?
    • Are current laws and sentencing guidelines sufficient to deter crime and protect the public?
    • Where should resources and space (e.g., prison capacity) be prioritized given budget constraints? Should more prisons be built?
    • How do law, policy, and practice intersect to shape crime outcomes, victim welfare, and public trust in the CJ system?
  • The case is framed as an example of how criminal law and corrections policies affect real-world outcomes and how lawmakers, judges, prosecutors, and police officers interpret and apply laws in practice.
  • The broader lesson: laws and policies have wide-reaching impacts on victims, offenders, families, communities, and public perceptions of justice.

Roles and Careers Within the Criminal Justice System

  • The CJ system involves multiple actors with distinct responsibilities:
    • Police officers: front-line enforcers who implement laws and handle initial contact with suspects and victims.
    • Prosecutors and defense attorneys: lawyers who argue cases within the court system, shaping legal outcomes.
    • Judges: interpret and apply the law, determine guilty verdicts, and issue sentences.
    • Legislators: create and amend laws; they set legal standards and policy directions.
  • The instructor emphasizes that police officers carry the immediate burden of enforcing laws and dealing with complexities and disagreements that arise from law interpretations and policy constraints.
  • The message is that this course isn’t just for CJ majors; understanding these roles helps everyone engage with public policy and civic life.

Practical Implications and Takeaways

  • The CJ system is expensive and highly integrated with everyday life through taxes and public policy.
  • Legal literacy matters because it helps citizens understand their rights, the limits of those rights (e.g., bail), and the basis for police actions and penalties.
  • Case examples illustrate how policy decisions (parole, sentencing, prison capacity) have tangible consequences for victims and communities.
  • The overall aim of the course is to equip students with a well-organized, critical framework to analyze how laws, institutions, and budgets interact, and why reforms may be needed.

Closing Notes and Logistics

  • The lecturer mentions continuing the discussion in the next session and acknowledges technical issues with Blackboard Sage; students are instructed to email the instructor if they encounter problems and to resume the material as directed.
  • The overarching goal is to develop a comprehensive, real-world understanding of the criminal justice system and its societal implications.

Key Formulas, Numbers, and Data References

  • Serious offenses reported (FBI reference): 8{,}000{,}000
  • Parole and release context referenced with numeric terms (e.g., 8 years sentence, 16 years sentence) to illustrate contrasting sentencing and release timelines.
  • Course numbers mentioned for prerequisite discussion: five-zero-seven (507) and five-zero-ten (510).

Connections to Foundational Principles

  • Law as the foundation: Without laws, there is no basis for policing, prosecuting, or punishing; laws provide safety, order, and legitimacy to state power.
  • Public policy and ethics: Debates about resource allocation, prisoner reentry, and victim protection reflect ethical considerations and the practicalities of governance.
  • Information literacy: The media environment shapes public perception of crime; critical evaluation of sources is essential for informed civic participation.
  • Real-world relevance: The CJ system impacts everyday life and future careers in law, policy, and public service; understanding its mechanics supports responsible citizenship and professional practice.