Chapter 5: Syntax

  • Syntax- the component of grammar that deals with how words and phrases are combined into larger phrases

Basic Ideas of Syntax

  • Linguistic expression- a piece of language with certain form, meaning, and syntactic properties
    • Syntax is broadly related to how expressions combine with one another to form larger expressions
  • Grammatical- when a string of words form a meaningful sentence
  • Ungrammatical- when a string of words do not form a sentence
  • Grammaticality judgement- a reflection of speakers’ mental grammar
    • Not necessarily concerned with prescriptive rules
  • Principle of compositionality- the meaning of a sentence depends on the meanings of the expressions it contains and on the way they are syntactically combined
  • Difference between syntax and semantics:
    • Sentences can @@contain strange meaning@@, and non-sentences can @@convey ordinary meaning@@
    • Syntactic properties of expressions @@cannot be predicted or explained@@ on the basis of an expression’s meaning

Syntactic Properties

  • Syntactic properties- the restrictions on certain combinations of expressions
    • Word order- how expressions are allowed to be ordered with respect to one another
    • Co-occurrence- if some expression occurs in a sentence, what other expressions can or must co-occur with it in that sentence?
  • Argument- when the occurrence of one expression necessitates the occurrence of another expression
  • Complements- non-subject arguments
    • Well-formed sentences need to have all and only the arguments they need
  • Adjuncts- optional expressions that can be added without creating a non-sentence
  • Agreement- distinct expressions that agree with respect to some grammatical feature with the same value

Syntactic Constituency

  • Syntactic constituent- syntactic units that can make up larger phrases in certain groups of expressions
  • You can tell if a string of words forms a syntactic constituent if the words can answer a question
    • Ex) Where is the cat sleeping? On the desk
    • “On the desk” is a constituent
  • Cleft- a sentence in which some constituent is displaced to the left
  • If the cleft is grammatical, the displaced expression is a constituent
    • Ex) The cat was sleeping on the desk → It was the cat that was sleeping on the desk
    • “The cat” is a constituent
  • Substitution- replacing a string of words with a single word.
  • If substitution results in a grammatical sentence, the string of words is a constituent
    • Ex) The cat was sleeping on the desk → She was sleeping on the desk
    • “The cat” is a constituent

Syntactic Categories

  • Syntactic category- a set of expressions that have approximately the same word order and co-occurrence requirements
  • Syntactic distribution- if two expressions are interchangeable in all syntactic environments
    • Ex) Sally likes the cat → Sally likes Fluffy
    • The cat and Fluffy have the same distribution
Syntactic CategoryRelevant PropertiesExample
S (sentence)can occur in Sally thinks that _Fluffy is cute
NP (noun phrase)has the same distribution as a personal pronoun or a proper nameshe, Sally, the cat, this cute dog, that cat under the bed
N (noun)needs a determiner to its left to form a NPcat, cute dog, cat under the bed
Det (determiner)occurs to the left of the noun to form a NPthe, every, this
Adj (adjective)occurs in between a determiner and a noun; can be a noun adjunct, that is, combines with a noun to its right which results in an expression that is also of category Ncute, fluffy, gray
VP (verb phrase)consists minimally of a verb and all its complements; combines with an NP to its left which results in a sentence; has the same distribution as slept or did soslept, write the letter quickly, liked Bob, walked, believed she liked that man
TV (transitive verb)needs an NP complement to form a VPliked, devoured
DTV (ditransitive verb)needs two NP complement to form a VPgave, sent
SV (sentential complement verb)needs a sentential complement to form a VPbelieved, said
Adv (adverb)can be a VP adjunct, that is, combines with a VP to its left which results in an expression that is also of category VPfast, quickly, tomorrow
P (preposition)combines with an NP to form a PPat, for, with
PP (prepositional phrase)can be a VP or an N adjunct; consists of a preposition and its NP complementat the table, for Sally, under the bed

Constructing a Grammar

  • Phrase structure rules- captures patterns of syntactic combination

    • Ex) In English, S → NP VP
  • Phrase structure tree- a visual display of the way a sentence is built up from lexical expressions using the phrase structure rules

  • Ambiguous- linguistic forms can correspond to more than one expression

    • Ex) They went for a walk vs They walk quickly
    • Can be individual words or entire structures