MR

Introduction to Evolutionary Biology

Overview and Course Focus

  • The course introduces biology through an evolutionary lens to explain life on Earth, including history, distribution, interactions, and diversity of living things.
  • Key guiding questions include:
    • How did life on Earth get here? What is the history of life?
    • Why are living things distributed as they are globally (e.g., why are most marsupials in Australia, with a race of marsupials also in the Americas like the opossum in Ohio)?
    • How do predator–prey interactions and host–parasite interactions evolve?
    • How can evolution inform health, disease, and medicine (Darwinian or evolutionary medicine)?
  • The instructor emphasizes examples from his research (predator–prey, snakes, host–parasite dynamics) and modern health concerns (parasites, infections, COVID) to illustrate evolutionary concepts.
  • Practical illustration: COVID as a microevolutionary system showing natural selection, mutation, recombination, and immune escape. Vaccines and drugs target viral features (e.g., spike proteins) that viruses use to enter host cells.
  • The course also highlights how to connect evolutionary theory to real-world issues and current events, such as emerging pathogens and mass extinctions.
  • The transcript also distinguishes between theoretical ideas and tested, evidence-based ideas in science, especially around what a scientific theory is versus everyday usage.

Core Questions Driving the Course

  • How did life begin and evolve on Earth?
  • Why are distributions of life forms non-random across the globe?
    • Example: concentrated marsupials in Australia, with a few in the Americas.
  • What explains predator–prey interactions from an evolutionary perspective?
  • How do host–parasite interactions shape health and disease across populations?
  • How can evolutionary concepts improve understanding and treatment of diseases (e.g., infectious agents evolving to resist treatments)?
  • How diverse are life cycles, and why do life cycles vary among organisms?

What is a Theory? Two Meanings Defined

  • Scientific meaning:
    • A theory is a well-supported explanation of a broad group of facts or phenomena, built from extensive observations and experiments, and supported by a large body of evidence. It is a mature, tested framework.
    • Process: start with a hypothesis, test with falsifiable experiments, accumulate evidence, refine, then elevate to a theory, and still test for new evidence. A theory is strong but not immutable; it remains open to falsification and refinement.
  • Everyday meaning:
    • A conjecture or provisional guess; less certain and not necessarily backed by extensive evidence.
  • Examples:
    • Gravity is a theory: widely accepted and well-supported, yet still testable and improvable with new data.
    • The distinction between a theory and a fact: facts are observations; theories explain why those facts are the way they are and predict new facts.
  • Why this matters in biology:
    • Distinguishing theory from hypothesis vs fact helps students understand how evolutionary biology is built on long-standing evidence and ongoing testing.
  • Key takeaway:
    • Evolutionary theory represents a very well-supported framework, not a casual speculation.

Microevolution vs Macroevolution

  • Microevolution:
    • Changes within populations over relatively short timescales, often observable in genomes and genetics.
    • Core mechanisms discussed:
    • Natural selection: differential survival and reproduction based on variation.
    • Migration (gene flow): movement of individuals across populations changes genetic makeup.
    • Mutation: ultimate source of genetic variation; random changes in DNA sequence.
    • Random genetic drift: random changes in allele frequencies due to chance events (e.g., after a population bottleneck or a founder effect).
    • Emphasizes genetic change within populations.
    • Example for microevolution: rapid evolution of viruses/bacteria with short generation times and genetic variation.
  • Macroevolution:
    • Patterns and processes over long timescales that lead to the origin of new taxa and major evolutionary transitions.
    • Topics include:
    • Adaptive radiations: rapid diversification of a lineage into a variety of ecological niches (e.g., mammals after the end-Cretaceous mass extinction).
    • Mass extinctions: drastic reductions in diversity that reshape subsequent evolution; the K–T extinction (~6.5 imes 10^{7} years ago) is a classic example.
    • Patterns in the fossil record and how fossils document transitions over deep time.
  • The fossil record:
    • The fossil record is our primary direct link to the past and helps trace major transitions and lineages.
    • Big unknowns remain in many areas of history, illustrating the tentative nature of historical science.
  • The course emphasizes that microevolutionary processes build toward macroevolutionary patterns over deep time, with fossils and genetics providing converging lines of evidence.

Practical and Real-World Relevance of Evolutionary Thought

  • Evolutionary reasoning in medicine (Darwinian or evolutionary medicine):
    • Pathogen evolution and immune evasion are central to understanding infectious diseases.
    • How new pathogens emerge and how existing pathogens change in response to host environments and medical interventions.
  • COVID as an instructional case study:
    • Virus basics: A virus is an infectious particle with nucleic acid (DNA or RNA) surrounded by a protein coat (capsid), sometimes with an envelope.
    • Viruses cannot replicate on their own; they hijack host cells to produce more viruses, often causing illness.
    • Spike proteins on SARS-CoV-2 enable binding to host cells and entry; vaccines often target these spikes to trigger immune responses.
    • Variation in viruses arises from recombination and mutation:
    • Recombination: genetic exchange between different viral genomes within the same host cell.
    • Mutation: copying errors during replication; faster replication yields more mutations.
    • Natural selection in viruses: variants with better survival or immune escape tend to expand; vaccines and therapies select for resistance, which then can spread unless countered by new interventions.
    • Historical data example (as of 2022–2023): Alpha and Beta variants initially had higher lethality; Delta rose as a dominant variant with different resistance profiles; Omicron and later variants showed different symptom profiles and transmission dynamics. The pattern demonstrates real-time microevolution in a contemporary pathogen.
  • Meta-point: Evolutionary thinking helps explain how pathogens evolve and why medical strategies must adapt accordingly. This is a practical, ongoing area of study in human health.

The Biology and Evolution of Viruses: A Focused Case

  • What is a virus?
    • Basic components: nucleic acid (DNA or RNA) enclosed by a protein capsid; sometimes an envelope.
    • Viruses cannot replicate independently; they depend on host cellular machinery to produce new viral particles.
    • The infection cycle: enters host cell, hijacks cellular processes to replicate viral genomes and produce viral proteins, assembles new viruses, and releases them to infect new cells.
  • SARS-CoV-2 highlights:
    • Spike proteins are key for attaching to host cells; vaccines target these spikes to train the immune system.
    • Variation arises via recombination and mutation, producing new variants with different properties (transmissibility, virulence, immune escape).
  • Mutation and recombination in viruses:
    • Recombination: exchange of genetic material between genomes within a cell (analogous to genetic shuffling).
    • Mutation: random genetic changes during replication; higher replication rates yield more mutations.
  • Natural selection in the viral world:
    • Variants with advantageous traits (e.g., higher transmissibility, immune escape) increase in frequency over generations.
    • Human interventions (vaccines, drugs) create new selective pressures that drive further evolution.
  • Practical implication:
    • Ongoing adaptation of vaccines, therapies, and public health strategies is necessary due to the fast-paced evolution of pathogens.

Whales: A Macro Evolution Case Study

  • Why whales matter as a macroevolution example:
    • They are aquatic mammals with clear evidence of a terrestrial origin, illustrating a dramatic lineage transition from land to sea.
  • Linnaeus and the challenge of classification:
    • Linnaeus initially categorized whales as fish; by the 10th edition, he moved them into mammals based on key mammalian traits (lungs, uterus, placenta,äął milk).
  • Darwin’s thought experiment and its purpose:
    • Darwin proposed that whales likely originated from land-dwelling ancestors, with gradual aquatic adaptations over many generations. He used a hypothetical scenario with bears to illustrate a plausible pathway, not to claim bears are direct ancestors, but to show natural selection could drive a land mammal toward aquatic life.
  • What evidence supports land-to-sea whale evolution?
    • Fossil record: intermediate forms show progressively aquatic features and mammalian traits.
    • Anatomy and bone structure: skulls reveal mammalian features (ear ossicles, jaw structure, secondary palate, etc.). The auditory bulla and its involucrum (a thick rim unique to whales) help identify cetaceans.
    • Transitional fossils and key specimens:
    • Juradon (about 4.0 imes 10^{7} years old): a 4-legged mammal with flippers and a whale-like skull; possesses the involucrum in the auditory bulla.
    • Ambulocetus (referred to as Amulocetes/datans in the talk, about 4.9 imes 10^{7} years old): called the walking swimming whale; has hind-limb remnants and aquatic adaptations.
    • Pachycetus (about 5.0 imes 10^{7} years old): provides evidence linking terrestrial mammals to cetaceans
    • Indioitis (a fossil cited here): part of the broader transition narrative toward cetaceans.
    • Pakicites (Pakicites) (about 5.0 imes 10^{7} years old): terrestrial in some respects; skull morphology shows cetacean ties via the involucrum, indicating an early terrestrial cetacean lineage.
    • Key anatomical features used by paleontologists to classify mammals and identify cetaceans:
    • Mammalian traits in skulls: auditory bulla, ear ossicles, secondary palate, and two-part upper dentition (upper teeth on two bones: maxilla and premaxilla).
    • Cetacean-specific traits: aquatic adaptations, bulla with a thick involucrum; retention of mammalian features like lactation and mammary glands, and yet limb/bone modifications for aquatic life.
    • Transition pattern revealed by bone and dental anatomy:
    • Early terrestrial-to-semi-aquatic forms show a mix of features; later forms show stronger aquatic adaptations while maintaining mammalian characteristics.
  • Relation to artiodactyls (even-toed ungulates):
    • Artiodactyls share a distinctive ankle bone called the astragalus; this bone is used to link cetaceans to artiodactyls genetically and anatomically.
    • Representative members: cows, goats, camels, and hippopotamuses (hippos are notable because they are semi-aquatic and show close affinities with whales in DNA analyses).
    • The whale lineage shows a close connection to hippopotamuses in genetic studies, which aligns with the emergence of aquatic adaptations.
  • DNA evidence and phylogeny:
    • DNA analysis across species (cow, deer, whale, hippo, pig, peccary, camel) shows whales share the greatest genetic similarity with hippos, more than with other analyzed mammals.
    • Hippos’ semi-aquatic lifestyle provides an ecological context for this relationship.
    • Building a phylogenetic tree (a hypothesis of evolutionary relationships) uses DNA data as well as fossil data to connect whales with hippos and other artiodactyls; this tree evolves as more data becomes available.
  • Integrated view of whale evolution:
    • The fossil record, combined with DNA evidence, supports a land-dwelling ancestry transitioning through intermediate aquatic stages to modern cetaceans (whales, dolphins, and porpoises).
    • The narrative is strengthened by multiple lines of evidence (anatomy, paleontology, molecular data, and functional morphology).
    • The field remains open to new discoveries, and the whale-evolution story is continually refined with new fossils and genomic data.
  • Big picture takeaways about evolution as a science:
    • Evolution is a historical science: it reconstructs past events using present evidence.
    • Time scales matter: long timelines reveal gradual transitions; short timescales reveal microevolutionary changes that accumulate.
    • Evolution is not goal-directed or teleological; there is no predetermined endpoint—organisms are “tinkers” that repurpose existing features to fit new environments.
    • The whale case illustrates how multiple lines of evidence (bones, teeth, ear structures, astragalus, involucrum, and DNA) converge to form a coherent evolutionary narrative.
  • Implications for understanding biological design:
    • Observed “design” features are often the result of historical contingency and incremental modification (e.g., retinas in vertebrates can be backwards due to historical constraints).
    • Similar functional outcomes can arise via different anatomical solutions (e.g., convergent features across lineages; octopuses have camera-type eyes with different wiring than vertebrates).

Evidence, Methods, and Tools in Evolutionary Biology

  • Fossils and skeletal anatomy:
    • Fossils provide direct evidence of past forms; bones are particularly durable and informative for identifying mammalian traits and cetacean relationships.
    • Key diagnostic features for mammals include:
    • Auditory bulla (inner ear bone housing) and its structure.
    • Two-part dental arrangement (upper teeth on two bones: maxilla and premaxilla).
    • Secondary palate for feeding specialization.
    • Cetacean-specific skull features include the posterior bulge and thick involucrum within the auditory bulla.
  • Molecular data:
    • DNA sequences (e.g., A, G, T, C letters) across species allow inference of phylogenetic relationships via sequence similarity.
    • An outgroup (a species outside the group of interest) is used to root phylogenetic trees.
    • Examples: comparing DNA across cows, deer, whales, hippos, pigs, peccaries, camels shows whales are most closely related to hippos among the examined taxa.
  • Phylogenies and hypotheses:
    • Phylogeny is a hypothesis about evolutionary relationships, built from evidence and refined with new data.
    • The whale-hippo relationship is a key example of how combined data sets shape our understanding of evolutionary history.
  • Concepts of time and evidence integration:
    • Evolutionary hypotheses are strengthened by converging lines of evidence from both fossils and molecular data.
    • When evidence contradicts a hypothesis, scientists revise the hypothesis accordingly.

Big-Picture Themes in Evolutionary Biology

  • Variation and diversity:
    • Variation within populations is fundamental to evolution; diversity is the raw material for natural selection and adaptation.
    • The COVID example illustrates how variation drives differential survival and spread of viral variants.
  • Evolution as a historical science:
    • Our knowledge of the past is inferred from present-day data; time scales of evolution span billions of years.
    • If the Earth’s history were compressed to a clock: microbe-dominated first ~50 minutes; animals appeared only in the last ~hundredth of a second.
  • Limits and directionality in evolution:
    • There is no ultimate goal or endpoint in evolution; it is not a linear path toward “progress.”
    • Evolution is a tinkerer: it works with existing structures and constraints, leading to features that are optimally functional given prior history and available variation.
    • This approach explains imperfect designs (e.g., human retina inversion, occasional detachment) as byproducts of historical constraints.
  • Encouraging an evolutionary perspective in everyday life:
    • Observe natural phenomena with an evolutionary lens (e.g., how a tree or bird’s features may reflect historical adaptations).
    • Consider questions like, “Where did this come from? What pressures shaped it? What are the trade-offs?”

The Bigger Picture: Implications and Societal Relevance

  • Education and critical thinking:
    • Clarifying scientific vs everyday use of terms like theory helps prevent misunderstandings about the robustness of scientific explanations.
  • Public health and policy:
    • Understanding pathogen evolution informs vaccine development, public health responses, and drug design.
  • Ethics and philosophy:
    • Recognizing evolution’s historical nature challenges teleological thinking and prompts discussions about destiny, purpose, and design in nature.
  • The role of science in society:
    • Ongoing data collection, analysis, and revision illustrate how science advances—through hypotheses, testing, and refining based on new evidence.

Quick Reference: Key Terms to Know

  • Evolution: Change in the heritable traits of a population over generations.
  • Microevolution: Evolutionary changes within populations over short timescales.
  • Macroevolution: Large-scale evolutionary changes that create new taxa over long timescales.
  • Natural selection: Differential survival and reproduction due to variation in traits.
  • Migration (gene flow): Movement of individuals and their genes between populations.
  • Mutation: Random genetic changes; the primary source of new genetic variation.
  • Random genetic drift: Random fluctuations in allele frequencies due to chance events.
  • Adaptive radiation: Rapid diversification of a lineage into multiple ecological niches.
  • Mass extinction: Widespread, rapid loss of diverse taxa, creating new evolutionary opportunities.
  • K–T extinction: The mass extinction event about 6.5 imes 10^{7} years ago that ended the reign of non-avian dinosaurs and reshaped life on Earth.
  • Auditory bulla: A bony structure in the skull housing the inner ear bones; a diagnostic feature in fossil mammals.
  • Involucrum: A thick ridge in the auditory bulla unique to whales, a key cetacean feature.
  • Artiodactyls: The order of even-toed ungulates (e.g., cows, goats, camels, hippos) linked to whales via anatomical and molecular data.
  • Astragalus: A distinctive ankle bone used to classify artiodactyls and explore whale ancestry.
  • Outgroup: A species used to root a phylogenetic tree and infer evolutionary relationships.
  • Phylogeny: A hypothesis or diagram showing evolutionary relationships among species.
  • Cetaceans: The group that includes all whales, dolphins, and porpoises; divided into baleen and toothed whales.
  • Baleen whales (Mysticeti): Whales that feed by filtering small organisms through baleen plates.
  • Tooth whales (Odontoceti): Whales with teeth (e.g., dolphins, sperm whales).
  • Pneumatically, pterygsex: Not present in notes; ignore.

Takeaway for Exam Preparation

  • Be able to explain, with examples, the distinction between microevolution and macroevolution and how they connect.
  • Describe how fossil evidence and DNA data complement each other in constructing phylogenies, especially in the whale lineage.
  • Understand the difference between a scientific theory and everyday use of the word theory, and why this matters for interpreting evolutionary biology.
  • Use the COVID example to illustrate how natural selection, mutation, and recombination drive microevolution in real time and how this informs public health responses.
  • Explain the role of specialization (baleen vs toothed whales), transitional fossils (e.g., Juradon, Ambulocetus, Pakicites), and the link to artiodactyls via the astragalus and the hippo connection.
  • Reflect on the philosophy of evolution: no endpoint, evolution as tinkering with existing traits, and why that results in imperfect designs.
  • Recognize the practical implications of Darwinian medicine for understanding host–parasite dynamics and pathogen evolution.

Next Steps

  • In the next lecture, we will build on these foundations by examining more fossil evidence, refining phylogenetic methods, and exploring additional examples of macroevolutionary transitions.