Helping Behavior Notes
Perceiving a Need
- Decision-making involves crucial steps:
- Perceiving a need.
- Taking personal responsibility.
- Weighing costs and benefits.
- Deciding how to help.
- Shotland and Huston (1979) identified five emergency characteristics:
- Sudden and unexpected event.
- Clear threat of harm to a victim.
- Harm increases over time without intervention.
- Victim is helpless and needs assistance.
- Effective intervention is possible.
- Interpretation of a situation affects aid offered.
- Shotland and Straw (1976) found different responses to an identical fight scene based on whether it was perceived as a lovers' quarrel or a fight between strangers.
Taking Personal Responsibility
- People are less likely to help if they don't feel personally responsible.
- Moriarity (1975) experiment: People who agreed to watch belongings were more likely to intervene when a theft occurred.
- Maruyama, Fraser, & Miller (1982) field study:
- Children donated more candies when individually responsible.
Weighing the Costs and Benefits
- People consider potential gains and losses before helping.
- Prosocial behavior occurs if perceived profits (rewards minus costs) of helping outweigh not helping.
- The greater the perceived costs, the less likely you are to help.
- Not helping may lead to guilt or negative judgments.
- Altruistic acts can be impulsive, motivated by emotions and values.
Deciding How to Help and Taking Action
- Involves deciding on assistance type and acting, often under stress.
- Decision-making analysis:
- People may fail to help due to not noticing the problem, not feeling responsible, high costs, inability to help, or indecision.
Attribution Theory: Helping Those Who Deserve Help
- People are more likely to help if the person's need is due to uncontrollable circumstances.
- Meyer & Mulherin (1980): College students more willing to lend rent money if need arose due to illness (uncontrollable) rather than laziness (controllable).
- Weiner (1980): More likely to lend lecture notes if needed due to professor's poor lecturing (uncontrollable) rather than classmate's poor note-taking (controllable).
- Attributions affect emotional reactions:
- Sympathy for those with uncontrollable problems.
- Anger towards those responsible for their problems.
The Helper: Who Is Most Likely to Help?
- Researchers investigate moods, emotions, and personality characteristics.
Mood and Helping
- People are more willing to help when in a good mood.
- Mood-maintenance hypothesis: Helping prolongs positive emotional state.
- Limitations:
- Effects of positive moods are short-lived.
- Good mood may decrease helpfulness if assistance detracts from the person's good mood.
- Negative-state relief model: People in a bad mood may help to relieve their own discomfort.
Motives for Helping: Empathy and Personal Distress
- Altruism: Helping with no expectation of personal benefit.
- Personal distress: Emotional reactions to others' plight (shock, horror, alarm).
- Empathy: Sympathy and caring for others, sharing in their suffering.
- Personal distress motivates reducing own discomfort, while empathy motivates helping the person in need.
- Empathy can be increased by focusing on the feelings of the person in need and viewing them as similar to ourselves.
Personality Characteristics
- Specific personality traits and abilities dispose people to help in specific situations.
Good Samaritans
- Often strong, aggressive, principled, and trained to cope with emergencies.
Blood Donors
- Regular donors often had positive models.
- Develop internal motivation and overcome fear.
- View giving blood as part of their personal identity.
Rescuers of Jews in Nazi Europe
- Motivated by social norms, empathy, and moral principles.
- Capacity to respond to suffering and belief in justice enabled them to overcome fear.
Gender and Helping
- Men are more likely to engage in heroic helping.
- Women emphasize nurturant forms of prosocial behavior and are more likely to provide social support.
Bystander Intervention: Helping Strangers in Need
- Research was sparked by the murder of Kitty Genovese.
- Factors include the presence of other people, the nature of the physical environment, and the pressures of limited time.