Gov

Democratic vs Authoritarian Regime

  • Authoritarian:

    • Power: Concentrated on the leader

    • Elections: May hold some but often unfair or irregular

    • Civil Liberties: Limited or nonexistent

    • Rule of Law: Absent or weak with arbitrary rule

    • Countries: Russia, Iran, China

  • Democratic:

    • Power: Distributed among the government and people

    • Elections: Free and fair elections

    • Civil Liberties: Protected and guaranteed

    • Rule of Law: A strong and independent judiciary

    • Countries: UK, Mexico, Nigeria (flawed)

Freedom of Press

  • China: Severe restrictions on press freedom

  • Iran: Severe control and restrictions on press freedom

  • Mexico: Journalists often face trouble regarding press freedom

  • Nigeria: Attempts to implement free press but inconsistent

  • Russia: Significant decline in press freedom recently

  • UK: High degree of press freedom

Democracy on a Spectrum

  • Most democratic:

    • United Kingdom: Well-established democracy

    • Mexico: Flawed democracy, progressing but faces challenges

  • Moving Towards Democracy:

    • Nigeria: Hybrid democracy with significant challenges

  • Far From Democracy:

    • Iran: Theocracy with severe restrictions

    • Russia: Increasingly authoritarian state

    • China: One-party state with limited political freedoms

Heads of State and Government

Country

Head of State

Head of Government

China

President (Xi Jinping)

Premier (Li Qiang)

Iran

Supreme Leader (Ali Khamenei)

President (Ebrahim Raisi)

Mexico

President (Andrés Manuel López Obrador/Claudia Sheinbaum)

President

Nigeria

President (Bola Tinubu)

President

Russia

President (Vladimir Putin)

Prime Minister (Mikhail Mishustin)

UK

Monarch (King Charles III)

Prime Minister (Rishi Sunak)

Systems of Government

  • Federal Systems:

    • Mexico: Federal republic

    • Nigeria: Federal republic

  • Unitary Systems:

    • UK: Unitary state with devolved powers

    • China: Unitary state

    • Russia: Federal aspect but functions as unitary

    • Iran: Unitary state

Legitimacy

Country

Source of Legitimacy

China

Claims to care about people's interests

Iran

Religious devotion and charismatic leadership

Mexico

Free, fair elections and constitution adherence

Nigeria

Democratic elections and nationalism

Russia

Charismatic authority and nationalism

UK

Constitutional monarchy and rule of law

Judicial Systems

Country

Term Limit

Who Appoints?

Judicial Independence

Judicial Review

China

Two, five-year terms

CCP

No judicial independence

None

Iran

5 years

Supreme Leader

Claims independence

Yes, Sharia law

Mexico

15 years

President nominates, Senate confirms

Improved

Yes, constitution

Nigeria

Life, must retire at 70

Appointed by council and Senate

Claims independence

Yes

Russia

12 years, must retire at 70

President appoints, Senate confirms

No

Little to none

UK

Life, must retire at 70

Judicial Appointments System

Yes

Yes, precedent

Rule of Law vs. Rule by Law

  • Importance: Ensures everyone is subject to the law

  • China: Rule by law (judiciary manipulated)

  • Iran: Rule by law (adheres to Sharia law)

  • Mexico: Rule of law (constitution adherence)

  • Nigeria: Rule by law (corruption issue)

  • Russia: Rule by law (uses law against opposers)

  • UK: Rule of law (strong legal tradition)

Legislatures

Country

Legislature

China

National People’s Congress (U)

Iran

Majlis (U)

Mexico

Congress of the Union (Senate & Chamber)

Nigeria

National Assembly (Senate & House)

Russia

Federal Assembly (Federation Council & Duma)

UK

Parliament (House of Commons & House of Lords)

This overview should help you understand the comparative political systems and the key elements of democracy and authoritarianism.

robot