Contextualism does not claim that the meaning of knowledge is entirely dependent on context.
Instead, it suggests that a person's qualification of knowledge can be influenced by contextual factors.
Testimony as a Knowledge-Producing Mechanism
Testimony can be viewed as a source of knowledge, where its reliability is examined in relation to evidence.
For instance, a reductionist perspective may hold that testimony is justifiable as a reliable source of evidence due to past experiences and teachings.
Childhood experiences may lead someone, for example, to adopt the belief that the CN Tower opened in 1976 based on various testimonies received over time.
Example Exploration: Timmy's Knowledge
The query presented revolves around whether Timmy possesses actual knowledge of the CN Tower's opening year.
The example illustrates a scenario where past testimony has formed a belief in him.
The distinction lies in assessing if merely having a belief, supported by testimony, equates to true knowledge.