The U.S. declared war on Britain in June 1812, but support for war was not unanimous.
Regional Divide:
Supported by: Southern and Western states, along with Pennsylvania and Vermont.
Opposed by: Most of New York, New Jersey, and New England.
Election of 1812:
James Madison (Democratic-Republican) won reelection, defeating DeWitt Clinton (Federalist & antiwar Dem-Rep candidate).
War remained unpopular in the Northeast, where trade with Britain was critical.
Many called it “Mr. Madison’s War”, believing it was pushed by War Hawks in Congress.
Who opposed it?
New England merchants – Trade with Britain had rebounded, and they saw impressment as a minor issue.
Federalist politicians – Feared the war was a ploy to conquer Canada, increasing Democratic-Republican power.
“Quids” (Old Democratic-Republicans) – Criticized the war for violating the party’s principles of limited government and peace.
U.S. launched a three-part invasion from Detroit, Niagara, and Lake Champlain.
All three attacks failed, as British and Canadian forces, often aided by Native American allies, repelled U.S. troops.
Only success: In 1813, U.S. forces burned York (Toronto), but this provoked British retaliation.
Despite Britain’s powerful navy, the U.S. had some victories:
The USS Constitution (“Old Ironsides”) sank a British ship, boosting American morale.
American privateers captured British merchant ships.
British retaliated with a naval blockade, severely damaging U.S. trade.
The Great Lakes & Northwest Theater (1813-1814):
Battle of Lake Erie (1813) – U.S. victory led by Oliver Hazard Perry.
Battle of the Thames (1813) – William Henry Harrison defeated British and Native forces; Tecumseh was killed, weakening Native resistance.
Battle of Lake Champlain (1814) – Thomas Macdonough defeated a British fleet, forcing Britain to abandon its invasion of New York.
After Napoleon’s defeat in Europe, Britain increased forces in North America.
British troops invaded Washington, D.C., burning the White House and Capitol in retaliation for York.
Attack on Baltimore:
Fort McHenry held firm, preventing British forces from taking the city.
Inspired Francis Scott Key to write “The Star-Spangled Banner.”
Battle of Horseshoe Bend (1814):
Andrew Jackson defeated the Creek Nation, removing them as a British ally and opening Southern lands to white settlers.
Battle of New Orleans (1815):
Jackson led a mixed force of frontier militia, free African Americans, and Creoles to a major victory against British forces.
Fought after the Treaty of Ghent was signed, but before news of peace reached the U.S.
Made Jackson a national hero, boosting his political future.
Signed on December 24, 1814, in Ghent, Belgium.
Key terms:
All prewar boundaries restored; no land was gained or lost.
No concessions were made on impressment or maritime rights.
Outcome:
War ended in stalemate, with no clear winner.
U.S. gained diplomatic respect by surviving a second war against Britain.
New England Federalists met in Hartford, Connecticut, to discuss their grievances.
Proposals included:
A two-thirds vote requirement for war declarations to prevent future unpopular wars.
Some radicals proposed secession, but it never gained widespread support.
Impact:
The convention’s timing was disastrous—news of Jackson’s victory at New Orleans and the Treaty of Ghent made the Federalists look unpatriotic and treasonous.
The Federalist Party collapsed as a national force.