Chapter 9: Competing in International Markets

Chapter 9: Competing in International Markets

9.1 Introduction

  • Definition of International Strategy:

    • The third type of strategy in strategic management, focusing on expanding into foreign markets or reducing costs through international operations.

  • Types of Strategies:

    • Generic Business-Level/Competitive Strategy: Competing with rival firms directly based on products and services.

    • Corporate Strategy: Diversifying into other industries or expanding geographically to reduce risk and increase profits.

  • Importance of International Strategy: Firms must evaluate potential risks and benefits when entering international markets.

  • Notable Tools for Assessment: Various frameworks help evaluate potential success, such as the CAGE Framework and methods of market entry.

9.2 Advantages and Disadvantages of Competing in International Markets

  • Kia Motors Case Study:

    • June 2, 2011, Kia plans to expand its US manufacturing facility, increasing capacity by 20% (from 300,000 to 360,000 vehicles).

    • Estimated cost: $100 million, expected to create 1,000 new jobs.

    • Kia's success attributed to robust performance in the US, with sales exceeding 350,000 vehicles in 2010, marking a 53% increase from the previous year.

  • Economic Revitalization:

    • The establishment of KMMG (Kia Motors Manufacturing Georgia) revitalized the West Point region economically after local textile closures.

  • Corporate Welfare Example: State and local incentives amounting to over $400 million were provided to attract Kia’s investment.

  • International Trade Growth: Projections suggest the total dollar value of international trade will surpass internal trade in coming years, influenced by the opening of economies like China and Russia.

Key Reasons for Competing in New Markets

  • Access to New Customers:

    • Example: China’s population (4x that of the US) presents substantial market opportunities despite political and cultural risks.

  • Lowering Costs:

    • Outsourcing and offshoring to access cheaper labor and raw materials, exemplified by our reliance on Indian call centers.

  • Diversification of Business Risk:

    • Firms can spread risk across multiple markets; Coca-Cola operates in 200 markets worldwide.

Case Studies/Statistics

  • McDonald's Global Sales: By 2011, McDonald’s derived 40% of its revenue from Europe, shifting its reliance from the US.

  • Global Vehicle Sales: GM sold more vehicles in China (3.1 million) than in the US (2.9 million).

9.3 CAGE Framework

  • Purpose of CAGE Framework: Assesses risks by measuring distance across four dimensions when entering new markets.

  • Dimensions of CAGE:

    1. Cultural Distance: Differences in language, customs, values.

    2. Administrative Distance: Differences in legal and political systems, enforcement of laws.

    3. Geographic Distance: Physical distance and transportation/logistics considerations.

    4. Economic Distance: Differences in economic factors, development, and GDP per capita.

  • CAGE Example: Chipotle considering expansion to Canada vs. Spain based on cultural, geographic, and economic distances.

9.4 Types of International Strategies

  • Multinational Corporations (MNCs): Entities that operate in multiple countries.

  • Four Main International Strategies:

    1. International Strategy: Selling products with minimal changes across borders (e.g., Harley Davidson).

    2. Multi-Domestic Strategy: Customizing products and services for local markets (e.g., Netflix, Heinz).

    3. Global Strategy: Prioritizing cost efficiency, often selling similar products globally (e.g., Microsoft, P&G).

    4. Transnational Strategy: Balancing cost efficiency and local responsiveness (e.g., McDonald's localized menu items).

9.5 Drivers of Success and Failure When Competing in International Markets

  • Friedman’s World is Flat: Technological advances increase competitiveness among nations.

  • Porter’s Diamond Model: Framework that determines factors leading to national competitive advantage:

    1. Demand Conditions: Local customer expectations shape global competitiveness.

    2. Factor Conditions: Availability of resources, labor, and infrastructure in the home country.

    3. Related and Supporting Industries: Strength of local suppliers enhances competitive success.

    4. Firm Strategy, Structure, and Rivalry: The presence of fierce domestic rivalry fosters innovation.

Example Influenced by the Diamond Model

  • Japanese firms succeed globally due to high domestic expectations and a culture of excellence.

9.6 Options for Competing in International Markets

  • Market Entry Options (Table 9.11):

    • Exporting: Producing goods at home for sale abroad.

    • Licensing: Allowing foreign firms to produce using your brand’s technology for a fee.

    • Franchising: Renting the brand and business process to local entrepreneurs.

    • Joint Ventures: Collaboration with local firms to form new entities.

    • Acquisition: Purchasing existing businesses or establishing wholly owned subsidiaries.

    • Greenfield Investment: Establishing new operations from the ground up.

Trade-Off Analysis of Entry Methods

  • Risk vs. Control vs. Profit Potential: Exporting is lower risk but offers low control/profit; greenfield investments entail high risk but high control/profit potential.

9.7 Conclusion

  • Summary of Key Determinants in International Market Competition:

    • Firms must weigh the advantages against potential risks before expanding internationally.

    • Utilizing the CAGE framework helps evaluate the fit between home and target markets.

    • The diamond model provides insights into firm performance based on domestic market factors.

    • Selecting appropriate market entry methods is critical to maximize profit and control.

Exercises

  • Engage in group discussions about various international strategies and identify successful firms in each category.