Chapter 1
The Black Death
1346-1353; left ⅖ of the population dead
Preconditions and Causes of the Plague
Overpopulation and malnutrition
9/10 of the population live in the countryside
3-field system of crop produciton increased arable land and food supply
Population doubled between 1000-1300
More people than food and jobs
1315-1317
Crop failures created greatest famines of Middle Ages
Densely populated urban areas suffered the most
industrial towns in the Netherlands
Factors that weakened Europe
Overpopulation
Economic depression
Famine
Bad health
Left Europe vulnerable to a bubonic plague that struck in 1348
“The Black Death”
Referenced the discoloration of its victims
The plague-infested fleas on rats came from the Black Sea area on ships on trade routs from Asia to Europe
Appears in Constantinople in 1936 and entered in the ports of Venice, Genoa, and Pisa by 1347 and went through Spain and southern France to Northern Europe
Not/little in Russia
Popular Remedies
Plague reached the lungs
Sneezing and wheezing ould spread the plague by direct contact (person-to-person)
Physicians, academics, and educated laypeople ways
Advice literature
By punishment for sin and penance was the best solution
Physicians
Used natural herbal medications
Had good effects
“Green measures”
Fumigating rooms
Aerating city spaces with herbs and smoke to lower flea numbers
Washing and cleansing with scented water
Corruptions in atmosphere caused plague
Poisonous fumes released by earthquakes
Protection taken in aromatic amulets
Giovanni Boccaccio
Recorded reactions in The Decameron (1358)
Best remedy- flight and seclusion, migration to non-infected lands, and faith
Some people- escape moderation and temperate life or gave themselves over to their passions
Flagellants
Religious fanatics who beat themselves in ritual penance to bring divine help
With dirty, bleeding bodies, they probably spread the disease and increased terror
The church outlawed the processions because of disruptions and threats
Jews were scapegoats
Christian propaganda bred hatred
Role as society’s moneylenders
Pogroms
Organized riots against Jews
Incicded by flagellants
Bacterium, Yersinia pestis
Caused the plague
Still unknown strands
Don’t know if it was the sole lethal agent or how the bacillus, fleas, rats, and humans interacted at various temperatures, humidity, and geographical locations to spread the epidemic
Social and Economic Consequences
High depopulation with shrunken labor supply and decline in nobility’s estate values
Farms Decline
Farm laborers decreased
Wages increased especially for skilled artisans
Agricultural prices fell
Prices of luxury and manufactured goods rose
Noble landholders suffered the freatest decline
Paid more for products and farm labor with litter return
Rents declined everywhere after the plague
Peasants Revolt
Arable land was converted to sheep pasture
More profitable wool production
Farms were abandoned and leased
New repressive legislation
1351- English Parliament passed the Statute of Laborers
Forced peasants to stay on farms while freezing wages at low levels
In response, peasants’ revolt in 1381
Direct tax on peasantry, the taille, increased
Opposition to it ignited the French peasant uprising
Jacquerie
In France
Cities Rebound
Cities and skilled industries prospered from its effects
Protected interests by passing legislation to regulate competition and contorl immigration from rural areas
Laws extended beyond the cities to lands of noble and landlords after plague
Omnipresence of death increased want for goods skilled industries produced
Also expensive clothes and jewlery, furs from north, and silks from south in demand
Demand could not be met
Basic unit of urban industry (master and 1/2 apprentices) keep numbers low, guarding privileges
Prices of luxury items rose and encouraged works to migrate to the city and learn the skills
Townspeople profited and wealth poured into cities
Per capita rose and prices of agricultural products declined
New Conflicts and Opportunities
Economic and political power of local artisans and trade guilds grew steadily with demand for goods and services
Mechants and patrician classes did not keep their traditional dominance and hated giving guild masters a voice in city government
Guilds won political power
Pushed for restrive legislation to protect local industries
Conflicts between master artisans who wanted low numbers and expand very very slowly
After 1350, traditional monarchy- nobility and Church- on defensive
Kings exploited national sentiment to centralize governments and economies
Plague killed many members of the clergy
Pope move from Rome to Avignon in southeastern France (1309-1377) and the Great Schism (1378-1417) divded the Church
Hundred Years’ War
Paid professional armies over old noble cavalry
The Hundred Years’ War and the Rise of National Sentiment
Medieval governments were not secure
Petty lords kept lands in turmoil
Dynastic rivalries plunged entire lands into war
Specifically when power was transferred
Doubled woes of ruling dynasty when no male heir
Needed alliances among lesser powers to field armies and get revenues
Feudal government
Norman kings of England and the Capetian kings of France fine-tuned traditional feudal relationships by stressing the sacred duties of lesser powers to higher ones and loyalty noble vassals owed their king
Created a sort of centralized royal power
Prepared France and England for war
The Causes of the War
May 1337- October 1453 (on-and-off)
cause- English king Edward III (Phillip the Fair of France grandson) asserted his claim to French throne after French king Charles IV (last of Philip the Fair’s surviving sons) dies without a male heir
French didn’t want 15 year-old Edward on the French throne
Chose Philip VI of Valois (1st cousin of Charles IV)
First of new French dynasty of 16th century
Cause- England and France, two emergent territorial powers in close proximity
Edward (vassal of Philip VI) controlled several French territories as fiefs (land) from France’s king, dating back to Norman conquest
English possession was repulsive to the French
Threatened royal policy of centralization
Also quarrel over control of Flanders
A French fief subject to political influence from England because of principal industry, the manufacture of cloth, depended on supplies of imported English wool
Long animosity between England and French who fought on the seas and in ports
The war became a struggle for national identity and control of territory
French Weakness
French population was three times England’s
Wealthier land
Fought on own soil
Major battles had English victories
French failures because of internal endemic social conflict
Still struggling to transition from splintered feudal society to centralized “modern” state
Raise money for war
French kings had financial policies as depreciating the currency and borrowing heavily from Italian bankers (aggravating interal conflicts)
In 1355, turned to Estates General
Representative council of townspeple, clergy, and nobles
Levied taxes at king’s request, independent members exploited the king’s plight to broaden regional sovereignty and deepen territorial divisions
English military superiority
English infantry was more disciplined
English archers mastered the longbow, capable of firing six arrows a minute with enough force to pierce an inch of wook or armor at two hundred years
Mediocrity for its rulers
English kings were more astute in state building
Progress of the War
The Conflict During the Reign of Edward III
Edward embargoed English wool to Flanders, creating merchant urban rebellions and trade guilds
Jacob van Artevelde, the Flemish cities, led by Ghent, revolted against France
In 1340 signed an alliance acknowledging Edward as king of France
On June 23, 1340, the first great battle where Edward defeated Franch in the Bay of Sluys but did not invade France through the Flanders
1346- Edward attacked Normandy and had victories that led to the Battle of Crécy, gaining the port of Calais
Exhaustion and the Black Death led to a truce in late 1347
1356- English routed the Frech cavalry and took French king captive after a complete breakdown of France political order
Estates General has power
Powerful merchants of Paris took advantage of royal weakness, demanding and receiving rights similar to English privilege class
Too divided to be an instrument for effective government
Forced peasantry to pay increasing taxes and repair war-damaged properties without compensation
Jacquerie of 1358
Bloody rebellions
Named for peasant revolutionary Jacques Bonhomme (simple Jack)
Nobility put revolt down matching the rebels atrocity
May 9, 1360- England forced the Peace of Brétigny-Calais on France
Agreement declared an end to Edward’s vassalage to the king and affirmed his sovereignty over English territories in France
Both sides knew it would not last
France struck back in 1360s
Edward died in 1377 when France had beated the English back to coastal enclaves
French Defeat and the Treaty of Troyes
During Richard II reign, England had a Jacquerie version
June 1381- long-oppressed peasants and artisans followed John Ball, a secular (not religious) priest, and Wat Tyler, a journeyman, into a revolt of underprivilege class
Brutally crushed within a year and divided the country for decades
England started up the war under Henry V
Routed the French at Agincourt on October 25, 1415
Burgundians closed ranks with French royal forces
Duke of Burgundy was assassinated in September 1419 stopping victory dreams
Treaty of Troyes (1420)
Stated Henry V was the successor to French king, Charles VI
Both kings died within months of each other (1420)
Infant Henry IV of England became king of England and France
Edward III’s dream of one ruler launched great war into motion
Son of Charles VI became king Charles VII after his father died ignoring the Treaty of Troyes
Rallied his cause and had a victorious coalition after inspiration of Joan of Arc
Joan of Arc and the War’s Conclusion
Joan of Arc (1412-1431)
Peasant from Domrémy in Lorraine in eastern France
Gave France many victories and proud enraged sense of national identity and destiny
March 1429
Told Charles VII that the King of Heaven had called her to deliver the besieged city of Orléans from the English
Charles was skeptical but willing to take the risk
Desperation to control territory south of Loire River overcame skepticism
English force was exhausted by 6-month siege
Fresh French troops drove the English from Orléans
Charles IV got his crown in Rheims, ending 9 year “disinheritance” by Troyes Treaty
May 1430- Burgundians took Joan captive
Charles IV did nothing to get her released
Burgundians and English discredited her to discredit King Charles IV and demoralize French resistance
Joan was given to Inquisition in English-held Rouen
Broke the courageous “Maid of Orléans” after 10 weeks
May 30, 1431- Joan was executed as a relapsed heretic
1456- Charles reopened her trial to declare her innocent of all charges
1920- Roman Catholic Church made her a saint
1435- Duke of Burgundy made peace with Charles
Pushed English back
1453- war ended
England only had coastal enclave of Calais
68 years of nominal peace and 44 years of hot war
Left lasting political and social consequences
Devastated France and awakened French nationalism, transitioned from feudal monarchy to centralized state
Burgundy became a major European political power
Ecclesiastical Breakdown and Revival: The Late Medieval Church
The Thirteenth-Century Papacy
Papal power reached its height during early reign of Pope Innocent III (r. 1198-1216)
Papal Plenitude of Power
Declared Church’s saints, disposed benefices to clergy, and created a centralized papal monarchy with a strong political mission
Innocent transformed the papacy into a secular power
Weakened spiritually but strengthened politically
Papal monarchy church parted from church as “body of the faithful”
Successors continued Innocent’s actions
Urban IV (r. 1261-1264)
Papacy had its own court, Rota Romana, that centralized the church’s legal proceedings
End of 13th century
New elaboration of clerical taxation system
Reform as an emergency measure to raise funds for the Crusaders but became a fixed institution
Papal power determined all appointments to major and minor church officers
“Reservation of benefices” broadened
Papal office was a powerful, political institution governed by its own laws and courts, serviced by international bureaucracy, preoccupied with secular tasks and goals
Papal centralization of the Church
Undermined diocesan authority and popular support
Rome’s interests controlled church appointments, policies, and discipline
Discontented lower clergy made Rome address the lax discipline of local bishops
2nd Half of 13th century
Bishops and abbots protested undercutting of powers
The church in Rome was nothing more than a legalized, fiscalized, bureaucratic institution
Heretical movements of Cathars and Waldensians appealed to the biblical ideal of simplicity and separation from the world
Other reformers were loyal to the church also protested perceived materialism in official religious garb
Francis of Assisi
Political Fragmentation
Spiritual undermining of the 13th century church
Demise of imperial power
Papacy in Rome was not the leader of anti-imperial (Guelf) sentiment in Italy
Popes now on the defensive against old allies since not being the center of Italian resistance
Price papacy paid to vanquish the Hohenstaufen rulers
Rulers directed intrigue from the emperor to College of Cardinals
Boniface VIII and Philip the Fair
Boniface ruled when France and England were maturing as nation-states
England
Long tradition of consultation created formal parliaments during Henry III (r. 1216-1272) and Edward I (r. 1272-1307)
Created unified kingdom
France
Philip IV the Fair (r. 1285-1314) made France an efficient, centralized monarchy
He was ruthless politician
Tried to end England’s continental holdings, control wealthy Flanders, and establish French hegemony within Holy Roman Empire
Brough the papal throne memories the same way earlier popes brought kings and emperors to their knees
Papal monarchy of 13th century was no match for new political juggernauts (large, powerful force) of late 13th century
The Royal Challenge to Papal Authority
1294- France and England close to war
Boniface became pope
Edward I’s preoccupation with Scotland rebellion prevented France invasion and Hundred Years’ War
Both countries used preparing for Crusade to heavily tax clergy
Boniface took strong stand against taxation
Believed Pope Innocent III’s decree (1215) where clergy should pay no taxes without papal consent
English and French taxation was an assault on traditional clerical rights
Feb. 5, 1296- issued Clericis laicos
Forbade lay taxation of the clergy without papal approval
Revoked papal dispensations (The method or scheme according to which God carries out his purposes towards men)
Edward I retaliated by denying the clergy the right to be heard in royal court
No protection of the king
Philip the Fair (August 1296) forbade money exportation from France to Rome
Denied papacy the revenues necessary to operate
Boniface came to terms quickly with Philip
Boniface under siege of Italian enemies
Noble family (the Colonnas) wanted to invalidate Boniface’s election as pope because Celestine V had been forces to resign
Charges of heresy, simony, and even Celestine’s murder on Boniface
Boniface’s fortunes revived in 1300 (“Jubilee year”)
Catholics fulfill conditions to have unrepented sins remitted
Tens of thousands of pilgrims flocked to Rome
Boniface reinserted himself into international politics with the popular religiosity display
Championed Scottish resistance to English
Outraged Edward I
Philip arrested Boniface’s Parisian legate, Bernard Saisset
Philip opposed his independence
Accused of heresy and treason
Philip demanded Boniface to recognize Saisset’s royal process
Boniface would have to surrender his jurisdiction over French episcopate
Boniface champion Saisset as a defender of clerical, political independence within France
Revoked all previous agreements
Clerical taxation
Ordered French bishops to convene in Rome
Sent bull Ausculta fili (“Listen, My Son”) to Philip in December 1301 to inform that “God has set popes over kins and kingdoms”
Unam Sanctam (1302)
Philip launched an antipapal campaign
Royal apologists, Pierre Dubois and John of Paris, rebutted papal claims to intervene in temporal (secular) matters
The Avignon Papacy (1309-1377)
Sometimes under strong French influence
With Pope Clement V, the French controlled the College of Cardinals, testing the papacy’s politically and economically
Clement expanded papal taxes (annates- 1st revenue of church office) or (benefice- bestowed by pope) for funds after being cut off from Roman estates
Also sold indulgences (pardons) for sins
Church doctrine on purgatory (punishment place for souls with venial sins) developed that century
By 15th century, induglences were extended to people already dead
Living could buy a reduced sentence for deceased
Contributed to Avignon papacy’s reputation for materialism and political scheming
Reformers got new ammunition against the Church
Pope John XXII
R. 1316-1334
Most powerful Avignon pope
Tried to restore papal independence and return to Italy
Ended up at war with the Visconti, Milan ruling family, and Emperor Louis IV (r. 1314-1347)
Challenged Louis’s election by being in favor with rival Habsburg candidate
Replay of Philip the Fair and Boniface VIII
Refused to recognize Louis’s election
Louis replaced him with a antipope and gained Spiritual Franciscan support (absolute poverty view)
William of Ockham
John excommunicated
Marsilius of Padua
Heretical teaching
Defender of Peace (1324)
Independent origins and autonomy of secular government
Clergy- only spiritual functions
Pope- no coercive judgment
Spiritual crimes need eternal punishment
Transgression of divine law
Challenged pope to excommunicate rulers and interdict countries
The pope is a subordinate member of society and temporal peace is highest god
Made papacy an international agency and integrated it into the European money economy
Curia (papal court) mastered the economy, it became vulnerable to secular criticism
Papacy became established in the city of Avignon under Benedict XII (r. 1334-1342)
John’s successor
Built great Palace of the Popes
Aimed to reform papal government and religious life
Pope Clement VI (r. 1342-1452)
Placed papal policy with French
Successor of Benedict
Cardinal period was lobbyists for policies their secular patrons favored
National Opposition to the Avignon Papacy
Latter half of 14th century had legislation restricting papal jurisdiction and taxation in France, England, and Germany
England- parliament passed several statutes to restrict payments and appeals to Rome and pope’s power to make appointments
France- Gallican (“French liberties”) regulated ecclesiastical (church) appointments and taxation
Church legally acknowledge them in Pragmatic Sanction of Bourges
(1438)
Recognized French church's right to elect clergy without papal interference, prohibited annates payment to Rome, and limited appeal rights from French courts to the Curia
National rights over religion
Switzerland and Germany- local city governments limited and overturned clerical privileges and immunities
John Wycliffe and John Huss
Lollards
English religious movement
John Wycliffe (d. 1384)
Oxford theologian and philosopher of high standing
Anticlerical policies of the English government
Spokesman for royalty rights against secular pretensions of popes
Believed in reducing Avignon papacy power
Clerical poverty- followed Franciscan ideals and justified government restriction and confiscation of church properties
Only needs food and clothing
Personal merit and morality over rank and office for authority
“Good” people should get money and power over “immoral” people
Directly threatened civic-secular dominion and governance
Wycliff accused of Donatism
Teaching of success of church sacraments depended on true performance and clergy’s moral character
Challenged papal infallibility, indulgence sales, Scripture authority, and transubstantiation dogma
Preached incomplete Holy Scripture translations and defended clerical poverty
Joined in confiscating clerical property
Became a capital offense in 1401 because of the English peasants’ revolt fo 1381 leading them to be subversive
Hussites
Bohemia
University of Prague was the center for a new religious reform movement within the bounds of orthodoxy
John Huss
Rector of Prague after 1403
Leader of pro-Wycliffe faction at Prague
1410- excommunicated (excluded from Christian church) and Prague is under papal interdict
1414- talked to Council of Constance
Traveled with safe-conduct pass form Emperor Sigismund
Didn’t convince his strongest critics
November 1414- arrived
Weeks later was accused of heresy and imprisoned
July 6th, 1415- died at stake
A year later so did Jermone of Prague (colleague)
Caused a revolt
Militant Hussites and Taborites fought to transform Bohemia against John Ziska
10 years later, Hussites won religious reforms and controlled Bohemian church form Council of Basel
Czech reformers
Vernacular translations of the Bible and critical of ceremonies and superstitious practices (Eucharist sacrament)
Lay communion with bread and wine
Usually wine was only clergy as spiritual superiority
Bread and wine remained bread and wine after priestly consecration
Questioned sacraments validity
Influenced the movement since marriage of Anna of Bohemia ot King Richard II of England in 1318 and bohemian students at Oxford
The Great Schism (1378-1417) and the Conciliar Movement to 1449
Reestablished papacy in Rome in January 1377 (“Babylnian Captivity”- church in Avignon) by Pope Gregory XI (r. 1370-1378)
Urban VI and Clement VII
Urban VI (r. 1378-1389) was the successor
Aimed to reform the Curia
Cardinals (most French) and French King Charles V (r. 1364-1380) wanted the papacy to return to Avignon/French influence
led to Great Schism
5 months after Urban VI was elected, 13 cardinals elected Pope Clement VII (r. 1378-1397)
Said they voted for Urban in fear because they were surrounded by a Roman mob demanding an Italian pope election
Papacy now had two popes (scandal to Christendom)
England + allies = Urban VI
France + allies = Clement VII
End schism (2 plans)
Mutual firing to open election
Secure resignaiton of one
Both failed because popes thought they were legitimate and did not want a concession
Final way- special church council deposes both
Competing popes did not want to summon one
Removing legitament pope was very serious as removing monarchy
Conciliar deposition of pope
Debated for 30 years
Conciliar theory
Fashion a church for a representative council to effectively regulate pope’s actions
The followers, conciliarists
Church- whole body of the faithful (pope only a part)
Popes felt threatened
Council of the church had better authority
Maintain unity of church unlike the schismatic popes
Cardinals representing both popes made a council on their own in Pisa in 1409
Deposed both popes
They didn’t accept it
Elected Alexander V
Widely accepted along with John XXIII (r. 1410-1415) successor
Christendom now had 3 popes
Schism ended
Emperor Sigismund prevailed on John XXIII to create new council in Constance in 1414
Roman pope Gregory XII also recognized
Sacrosancta declaration had council declare supremacy and elected new pope, Martin V (r. 1417-1431)
The other popes resigned or were deposed
Made regular meetings of church councils (was 5, then 7, now 10)
The Council of Basel (1431-1449)
Council directly negotiated church doctrine with heretics
Conciliar government of church peaked then
1432- Hussites presented Four Articles of Prague
Basis for negotiation
Requested
Laity the Eucharist with cup and bread
Free, traveling preaching
Exclusion of clergy holding secular offices and owning property
Not accepted
Punishment for clergy who commit mortal sins
1433- agreement among Emperor, council, and Hussites for Bohemian jurisdiction over the church
1438- unpleased pope upstaged the Council of Basel by reuniting Eastern church
Signed in Florence in 1439
Restored papal prestige and downfall of conciliar movement
Council of Basel collapsed in 1449
Pope Pius II (r. 1458-1464) 10 years later issued papal bull Execrabilis (1460) for appeals to council to be void
Consequence of short-lived conciliar movement
Devolving of religious responsibility onto laity and secular governments
No effective papal authority and leadership
Lots of secular control of churches
But papacy became limited, Italian territorial regime
Papal states can now be opposed on grounds of “national” policy for religious reasons
Medieval Russia
Prince Vladimir of Kiev (r. 980-1015) of Russia received delegations from different religions to persuade the Russians to embrace a religion
Chose Greek Orthodoxy because of strong cultural bonds and close commercial ties with the Byzantine Empire
Politics and Society
Vladimir’s successor Yaroslav the Wise (r. 1016-1054) made Kiev a polical and cultural center with stunning architecture
Tried to pursue West contacts to counter Byzantine political influence
After his death rivalry divded Russia
Great Russians
White Russians
Little Russians (Ukrainians)
Principalities challenged Kiev’s dominance
Government with principalities
Monarchy (prince)
Aristocracy (prince’s nobleman council)
Democracy (assembly of free adult males)
Clergy, army officers, boyars (wealthy landowners), townspeople, peasants
Slaves were prisoners of war
Debtors made up large, semifree group
Mongol Rule (1243-1480)
13th century- Mongol (Tatar) armies swept through China, Islamic world, and Russia
Grassland people with strongholds in south
Devastated Russia and compelling obedience of Moscow
Glengis Khan (1155-1227) invaded Russia in 1223
Kiev fell to Batu Khan in 1240
Russia cities were dependent, tribute-paying principalities of Mongol Empire, Golden Horde (color of Batu Khan’s tent in Tatar)
Included grassland (steppe) of modern southern Russia nad capital of Sarai o blower Volga
Had own officials to oversee taxation and enlist Russians into Tatar armies
Got Russian women as harems (wives)
Under influence of Islam (Golden Horde religion) were forced to wear veils and have secluded lives
Sold Russians who disobeyed
Left political and religious institutes intact
Brought some Russians into prosperity
Mongol integration culturally divided Russia and the West
Princes of Moscow
Collected tribute and grew wealthy
Took control of surrounding territory- “Gathering of the Russian Land”
Principality of Moscow
Expanded through land purchases, colonization, and conquest
1380- Grand Duke Dimitri of Moscow (r. 1350-1389) defeated Tatar forces at Kulikov Meadow
Marked beginning of Mongol hegemony declline
Took a centry for Ivan III, the Great, to bring northern Russia under Moscow’s control and end Mongol rule (1480)
Moscow became political and religious center of Russia
After Constantinople fell to the Turks in 1453, Moscow became the “3rd Rome”
The Black Death
1346-1353; left ⅖ of the population dead
Preconditions and Causes of the Plague
Overpopulation and malnutrition
9/10 of the population live in the countryside
3-field system of crop produciton increased arable land and food supply
Population doubled between 1000-1300
More people than food and jobs
1315-1317
Crop failures created greatest famines of Middle Ages
Densely populated urban areas suffered the most
industrial towns in the Netherlands
Factors that weakened Europe
Overpopulation
Economic depression
Famine
Bad health
Left Europe vulnerable to a bubonic plague that struck in 1348
“The Black Death”
Referenced the discoloration of its victims
The plague-infested fleas on rats came from the Black Sea area on ships on trade routs from Asia to Europe
Appears in Constantinople in 1936 and entered in the ports of Venice, Genoa, and Pisa by 1347 and went through Spain and southern France to Northern Europe
Not/little in Russia
Popular Remedies
Plague reached the lungs
Sneezing and wheezing ould spread the plague by direct contact (person-to-person)
Physicians, academics, and educated laypeople ways
Advice literature
By punishment for sin and penance was the best solution
Physicians
Used natural herbal medications
Had good effects
“Green measures”
Fumigating rooms
Aerating city spaces with herbs and smoke to lower flea numbers
Washing and cleansing with scented water
Corruptions in atmosphere caused plague
Poisonous fumes released by earthquakes
Protection taken in aromatic amulets
Giovanni Boccaccio
Recorded reactions in The Decameron (1358)
Best remedy- flight and seclusion, migration to non-infected lands, and faith
Some people- escape moderation and temperate life or gave themselves over to their passions
Flagellants
Religious fanatics who beat themselves in ritual penance to bring divine help
With dirty, bleeding bodies, they probably spread the disease and increased terror
The church outlawed the processions because of disruptions and threats
Jews were scapegoats
Christian propaganda bred hatred
Role as society’s moneylenders
Pogroms
Organized riots against Jews
Incicded by flagellants
Bacterium, Yersinia pestis
Caused the plague
Still unknown strands
Don’t know if it was the sole lethal agent or how the bacillus, fleas, rats, and humans interacted at various temperatures, humidity, and geographical locations to spread the epidemic
Social and Economic Consequences
High depopulation with shrunken labor supply and decline in nobility’s estate values
Farms Decline
Farm laborers decreased
Wages increased especially for skilled artisans
Agricultural prices fell
Prices of luxury and manufactured goods rose
Noble landholders suffered the freatest decline
Paid more for products and farm labor with litter return
Rents declined everywhere after the plague
Peasants Revolt
Arable land was converted to sheep pasture
More profitable wool production
Farms were abandoned and leased
New repressive legislation
1351- English Parliament passed the Statute of Laborers
Forced peasants to stay on farms while freezing wages at low levels
In response, peasants’ revolt in 1381
Direct tax on peasantry, the taille, increased
Opposition to it ignited the French peasant uprising
Jacquerie
In France
Cities Rebound
Cities and skilled industries prospered from its effects
Protected interests by passing legislation to regulate competition and contorl immigration from rural areas
Laws extended beyond the cities to lands of noble and landlords after plague
Omnipresence of death increased want for goods skilled industries produced
Also expensive clothes and jewlery, furs from north, and silks from south in demand
Demand could not be met
Basic unit of urban industry (master and 1/2 apprentices) keep numbers low, guarding privileges
Prices of luxury items rose and encouraged works to migrate to the city and learn the skills
Townspeople profited and wealth poured into cities
Per capita rose and prices of agricultural products declined
New Conflicts and Opportunities
Economic and political power of local artisans and trade guilds grew steadily with demand for goods and services
Mechants and patrician classes did not keep their traditional dominance and hated giving guild masters a voice in city government
Guilds won political power
Pushed for restrive legislation to protect local industries
Conflicts between master artisans who wanted low numbers and expand very very slowly
After 1350, traditional monarchy- nobility and Church- on defensive
Kings exploited national sentiment to centralize governments and economies
Plague killed many members of the clergy
Pope move from Rome to Avignon in southeastern France (1309-1377) and the Great Schism (1378-1417) divded the Church
Hundred Years’ War
Paid professional armies over old noble cavalry
The Hundred Years’ War and the Rise of National Sentiment
Medieval governments were not secure
Petty lords kept lands in turmoil
Dynastic rivalries plunged entire lands into war
Specifically when power was transferred
Doubled woes of ruling dynasty when no male heir
Needed alliances among lesser powers to field armies and get revenues
Feudal government
Norman kings of England and the Capetian kings of France fine-tuned traditional feudal relationships by stressing the sacred duties of lesser powers to higher ones and loyalty noble vassals owed their king
Created a sort of centralized royal power
Prepared France and England for war
The Causes of the War
May 1337- October 1453 (on-and-off)
cause- English king Edward III (Phillip the Fair of France grandson) asserted his claim to French throne after French king Charles IV (last of Philip the Fair’s surviving sons) dies without a male heir
French didn’t want 15 year-old Edward on the French throne
Chose Philip VI of Valois (1st cousin of Charles IV)
First of new French dynasty of 16th century
Cause- England and France, two emergent territorial powers in close proximity
Edward (vassal of Philip VI) controlled several French territories as fiefs (land) from France’s king, dating back to Norman conquest
English possession was repulsive to the French
Threatened royal policy of centralization
Also quarrel over control of Flanders
A French fief subject to political influence from England because of principal industry, the manufacture of cloth, depended on supplies of imported English wool
Long animosity between England and French who fought on the seas and in ports
The war became a struggle for national identity and control of territory
French Weakness
French population was three times England’s
Wealthier land
Fought on own soil
Major battles had English victories
French failures because of internal endemic social conflict
Still struggling to transition from splintered feudal society to centralized “modern” state
Raise money for war
French kings had financial policies as depreciating the currency and borrowing heavily from Italian bankers (aggravating interal conflicts)
In 1355, turned to Estates General
Representative council of townspeple, clergy, and nobles
Levied taxes at king’s request, independent members exploited the king’s plight to broaden regional sovereignty and deepen territorial divisions
English military superiority
English infantry was more disciplined
English archers mastered the longbow, capable of firing six arrows a minute with enough force to pierce an inch of wook or armor at two hundred years
Mediocrity for its rulers
English kings were more astute in state building
Progress of the War
The Conflict During the Reign of Edward III
Edward embargoed English wool to Flanders, creating merchant urban rebellions and trade guilds
Jacob van Artevelde, the Flemish cities, led by Ghent, revolted against France
In 1340 signed an alliance acknowledging Edward as king of France
On June 23, 1340, the first great battle where Edward defeated Franch in the Bay of Sluys but did not invade France through the Flanders
1346- Edward attacked Normandy and had victories that led to the Battle of Crécy, gaining the port of Calais
Exhaustion and the Black Death led to a truce in late 1347
1356- English routed the Frech cavalry and took French king captive after a complete breakdown of France political order
Estates General has power
Powerful merchants of Paris took advantage of royal weakness, demanding and receiving rights similar to English privilege class
Too divided to be an instrument for effective government
Forced peasantry to pay increasing taxes and repair war-damaged properties without compensation
Jacquerie of 1358
Bloody rebellions
Named for peasant revolutionary Jacques Bonhomme (simple Jack)
Nobility put revolt down matching the rebels atrocity
May 9, 1360- England forced the Peace of Brétigny-Calais on France
Agreement declared an end to Edward’s vassalage to the king and affirmed his sovereignty over English territories in France
Both sides knew it would not last
France struck back in 1360s
Edward died in 1377 when France had beated the English back to coastal enclaves
French Defeat and the Treaty of Troyes
During Richard II reign, England had a Jacquerie version
June 1381- long-oppressed peasants and artisans followed John Ball, a secular (not religious) priest, and Wat Tyler, a journeyman, into a revolt of underprivilege class
Brutally crushed within a year and divided the country for decades
England started up the war under Henry V
Routed the French at Agincourt on October 25, 1415
Burgundians closed ranks with French royal forces
Duke of Burgundy was assassinated in September 1419 stopping victory dreams
Treaty of Troyes (1420)
Stated Henry V was the successor to French king, Charles VI
Both kings died within months of each other (1420)
Infant Henry IV of England became king of England and France
Edward III’s dream of one ruler launched great war into motion
Son of Charles VI became king Charles VII after his father died ignoring the Treaty of Troyes
Rallied his cause and had a victorious coalition after inspiration of Joan of Arc
Joan of Arc and the War’s Conclusion
Joan of Arc (1412-1431)
Peasant from Domrémy in Lorraine in eastern France
Gave France many victories and proud enraged sense of national identity and destiny
March 1429
Told Charles VII that the King of Heaven had called her to deliver the besieged city of Orléans from the English
Charles was skeptical but willing to take the risk
Desperation to control territory south of Loire River overcame skepticism
English force was exhausted by 6-month siege
Fresh French troops drove the English from Orléans
Charles IV got his crown in Rheims, ending 9 year “disinheritance” by Troyes Treaty
May 1430- Burgundians took Joan captive
Charles IV did nothing to get her released
Burgundians and English discredited her to discredit King Charles IV and demoralize French resistance
Joan was given to Inquisition in English-held Rouen
Broke the courageous “Maid of Orléans” after 10 weeks
May 30, 1431- Joan was executed as a relapsed heretic
1456- Charles reopened her trial to declare her innocent of all charges
1920- Roman Catholic Church made her a saint
1435- Duke of Burgundy made peace with Charles
Pushed English back
1453- war ended
England only had coastal enclave of Calais
68 years of nominal peace and 44 years of hot war
Left lasting political and social consequences
Devastated France and awakened French nationalism, transitioned from feudal monarchy to centralized state
Burgundy became a major European political power
Ecclesiastical Breakdown and Revival: The Late Medieval Church
The Thirteenth-Century Papacy
Papal power reached its height during early reign of Pope Innocent III (r. 1198-1216)
Papal Plenitude of Power
Declared Church’s saints, disposed benefices to clergy, and created a centralized papal monarchy with a strong political mission
Innocent transformed the papacy into a secular power
Weakened spiritually but strengthened politically
Papal monarchy church parted from church as “body of the faithful”
Successors continued Innocent’s actions
Urban IV (r. 1261-1264)
Papacy had its own court, Rota Romana, that centralized the church’s legal proceedings
End of 13th century
New elaboration of clerical taxation system
Reform as an emergency measure to raise funds for the Crusaders but became a fixed institution
Papal power determined all appointments to major and minor church officers
“Reservation of benefices” broadened
Papal office was a powerful, political institution governed by its own laws and courts, serviced by international bureaucracy, preoccupied with secular tasks and goals
Papal centralization of the Church
Undermined diocesan authority and popular support
Rome’s interests controlled church appointments, policies, and discipline
Discontented lower clergy made Rome address the lax discipline of local bishops
2nd Half of 13th century
Bishops and abbots protested undercutting of powers
The church in Rome was nothing more than a legalized, fiscalized, bureaucratic institution
Heretical movements of Cathars and Waldensians appealed to the biblical ideal of simplicity and separation from the world
Other reformers were loyal to the church also protested perceived materialism in official religious garb
Francis of Assisi
Political Fragmentation
Spiritual undermining of the 13th century church
Demise of imperial power
Papacy in Rome was not the leader of anti-imperial (Guelf) sentiment in Italy
Popes now on the defensive against old allies since not being the center of Italian resistance
Price papacy paid to vanquish the Hohenstaufen rulers
Rulers directed intrigue from the emperor to College of Cardinals
Boniface VIII and Philip the Fair
Boniface ruled when France and England were maturing as nation-states
England
Long tradition of consultation created formal parliaments during Henry III (r. 1216-1272) and Edward I (r. 1272-1307)
Created unified kingdom
France
Philip IV the Fair (r. 1285-1314) made France an efficient, centralized monarchy
He was ruthless politician
Tried to end England’s continental holdings, control wealthy Flanders, and establish French hegemony within Holy Roman Empire
Brough the papal throne memories the same way earlier popes brought kings and emperors to their knees
Papal monarchy of 13th century was no match for new political juggernauts (large, powerful force) of late 13th century
The Royal Challenge to Papal Authority
1294- France and England close to war
Boniface became pope
Edward I’s preoccupation with Scotland rebellion prevented France invasion and Hundred Years’ War
Both countries used preparing for Crusade to heavily tax clergy
Boniface took strong stand against taxation
Believed Pope Innocent III’s decree (1215) where clergy should pay no taxes without papal consent
English and French taxation was an assault on traditional clerical rights
Feb. 5, 1296- issued Clericis laicos
Forbade lay taxation of the clergy without papal approval
Revoked papal dispensations (The method or scheme according to which God carries out his purposes towards men)
Edward I retaliated by denying the clergy the right to be heard in royal court
No protection of the king
Philip the Fair (August 1296) forbade money exportation from France to Rome
Denied papacy the revenues necessary to operate
Boniface came to terms quickly with Philip
Boniface under siege of Italian enemies
Noble family (the Colonnas) wanted to invalidate Boniface’s election as pope because Celestine V had been forces to resign
Charges of heresy, simony, and even Celestine’s murder on Boniface
Boniface’s fortunes revived in 1300 (“Jubilee year”)
Catholics fulfill conditions to have unrepented sins remitted
Tens of thousands of pilgrims flocked to Rome
Boniface reinserted himself into international politics with the popular religiosity display
Championed Scottish resistance to English
Outraged Edward I
Philip arrested Boniface’s Parisian legate, Bernard Saisset
Philip opposed his independence
Accused of heresy and treason
Philip demanded Boniface to recognize Saisset’s royal process
Boniface would have to surrender his jurisdiction over French episcopate
Boniface champion Saisset as a defender of clerical, political independence within France
Revoked all previous agreements
Clerical taxation
Ordered French bishops to convene in Rome
Sent bull Ausculta fili (“Listen, My Son”) to Philip in December 1301 to inform that “God has set popes over kins and kingdoms”
Unam Sanctam (1302)
Philip launched an antipapal campaign
Royal apologists, Pierre Dubois and John of Paris, rebutted papal claims to intervene in temporal (secular) matters
The Avignon Papacy (1309-1377)
Sometimes under strong French influence
With Pope Clement V, the French controlled the College of Cardinals, testing the papacy’s politically and economically
Clement expanded papal taxes (annates- 1st revenue of church office) or (benefice- bestowed by pope) for funds after being cut off from Roman estates
Also sold indulgences (pardons) for sins
Church doctrine on purgatory (punishment place for souls with venial sins) developed that century
By 15th century, induglences were extended to people already dead
Living could buy a reduced sentence for deceased
Contributed to Avignon papacy’s reputation for materialism and political scheming
Reformers got new ammunition against the Church
Pope John XXII
R. 1316-1334
Most powerful Avignon pope
Tried to restore papal independence and return to Italy
Ended up at war with the Visconti, Milan ruling family, and Emperor Louis IV (r. 1314-1347)
Challenged Louis’s election by being in favor with rival Habsburg candidate
Replay of Philip the Fair and Boniface VIII
Refused to recognize Louis’s election
Louis replaced him with a antipope and gained Spiritual Franciscan support (absolute poverty view)
William of Ockham
John excommunicated
Marsilius of Padua
Heretical teaching
Defender of Peace (1324)
Independent origins and autonomy of secular government
Clergy- only spiritual functions
Pope- no coercive judgment
Spiritual crimes need eternal punishment
Transgression of divine law
Challenged pope to excommunicate rulers and interdict countries
The pope is a subordinate member of society and temporal peace is highest god
Made papacy an international agency and integrated it into the European money economy
Curia (papal court) mastered the economy, it became vulnerable to secular criticism
Papacy became established in the city of Avignon under Benedict XII (r. 1334-1342)
John’s successor
Built great Palace of the Popes
Aimed to reform papal government and religious life
Pope Clement VI (r. 1342-1452)
Placed papal policy with French
Successor of Benedict
Cardinal period was lobbyists for policies their secular patrons favored
National Opposition to the Avignon Papacy
Latter half of 14th century had legislation restricting papal jurisdiction and taxation in France, England, and Germany
England- parliament passed several statutes to restrict payments and appeals to Rome and pope’s power to make appointments
France- Gallican (“French liberties”) regulated ecclesiastical (church) appointments and taxation
Church legally acknowledge them in Pragmatic Sanction of Bourges
(1438)
Recognized French church's right to elect clergy without papal interference, prohibited annates payment to Rome, and limited appeal rights from French courts to the Curia
National rights over religion
Switzerland and Germany- local city governments limited and overturned clerical privileges and immunities
John Wycliffe and John Huss
Lollards
English religious movement
John Wycliffe (d. 1384)
Oxford theologian and philosopher of high standing
Anticlerical policies of the English government
Spokesman for royalty rights against secular pretensions of popes
Believed in reducing Avignon papacy power
Clerical poverty- followed Franciscan ideals and justified government restriction and confiscation of church properties
Only needs food and clothing
Personal merit and morality over rank and office for authority
“Good” people should get money and power over “immoral” people
Directly threatened civic-secular dominion and governance
Wycliff accused of Donatism
Teaching of success of church sacraments depended on true performance and clergy’s moral character
Challenged papal infallibility, indulgence sales, Scripture authority, and transubstantiation dogma
Preached incomplete Holy Scripture translations and defended clerical poverty
Joined in confiscating clerical property
Became a capital offense in 1401 because of the English peasants’ revolt fo 1381 leading them to be subversive
Hussites
Bohemia
University of Prague was the center for a new religious reform movement within the bounds of orthodoxy
John Huss
Rector of Prague after 1403
Leader of pro-Wycliffe faction at Prague
1410- excommunicated (excluded from Christian church) and Prague is under papal interdict
1414- talked to Council of Constance
Traveled with safe-conduct pass form Emperor Sigismund
Didn’t convince his strongest critics
November 1414- arrived
Weeks later was accused of heresy and imprisoned
July 6th, 1415- died at stake
A year later so did Jermone of Prague (colleague)
Caused a revolt
Militant Hussites and Taborites fought to transform Bohemia against John Ziska
10 years later, Hussites won religious reforms and controlled Bohemian church form Council of Basel
Czech reformers
Vernacular translations of the Bible and critical of ceremonies and superstitious practices (Eucharist sacrament)
Lay communion with bread and wine
Usually wine was only clergy as spiritual superiority
Bread and wine remained bread and wine after priestly consecration
Questioned sacraments validity
Influenced the movement since marriage of Anna of Bohemia ot King Richard II of England in 1318 and bohemian students at Oxford
The Great Schism (1378-1417) and the Conciliar Movement to 1449
Reestablished papacy in Rome in January 1377 (“Babylnian Captivity”- church in Avignon) by Pope Gregory XI (r. 1370-1378)
Urban VI and Clement VII
Urban VI (r. 1378-1389) was the successor
Aimed to reform the Curia
Cardinals (most French) and French King Charles V (r. 1364-1380) wanted the papacy to return to Avignon/French influence
led to Great Schism
5 months after Urban VI was elected, 13 cardinals elected Pope Clement VII (r. 1378-1397)
Said they voted for Urban in fear because they were surrounded by a Roman mob demanding an Italian pope election
Papacy now had two popes (scandal to Christendom)
England + allies = Urban VI
France + allies = Clement VII
End schism (2 plans)
Mutual firing to open election
Secure resignaiton of one
Both failed because popes thought they were legitimate and did not want a concession
Final way- special church council deposes both
Competing popes did not want to summon one
Removing legitament pope was very serious as removing monarchy
Conciliar deposition of pope
Debated for 30 years
Conciliar theory
Fashion a church for a representative council to effectively regulate pope’s actions
The followers, conciliarists
Church- whole body of the faithful (pope only a part)
Popes felt threatened
Council of the church had better authority
Maintain unity of church unlike the schismatic popes
Cardinals representing both popes made a council on their own in Pisa in 1409
Deposed both popes
They didn’t accept it
Elected Alexander V
Widely accepted along with John XXIII (r. 1410-1415) successor
Christendom now had 3 popes
Schism ended
Emperor Sigismund prevailed on John XXIII to create new council in Constance in 1414
Roman pope Gregory XII also recognized
Sacrosancta declaration had council declare supremacy and elected new pope, Martin V (r. 1417-1431)
The other popes resigned or were deposed
Made regular meetings of church councils (was 5, then 7, now 10)
The Council of Basel (1431-1449)
Council directly negotiated church doctrine with heretics
Conciliar government of church peaked then
1432- Hussites presented Four Articles of Prague
Basis for negotiation
Requested
Laity the Eucharist with cup and bread
Free, traveling preaching
Exclusion of clergy holding secular offices and owning property
Not accepted
Punishment for clergy who commit mortal sins
1433- agreement among Emperor, council, and Hussites for Bohemian jurisdiction over the church
1438- unpleased pope upstaged the Council of Basel by reuniting Eastern church
Signed in Florence in 1439
Restored papal prestige and downfall of conciliar movement
Council of Basel collapsed in 1449
Pope Pius II (r. 1458-1464) 10 years later issued papal bull Execrabilis (1460) for appeals to council to be void
Consequence of short-lived conciliar movement
Devolving of religious responsibility onto laity and secular governments
No effective papal authority and leadership
Lots of secular control of churches
But papacy became limited, Italian territorial regime
Papal states can now be opposed on grounds of “national” policy for religious reasons
Medieval Russia
Prince Vladimir of Kiev (r. 980-1015) of Russia received delegations from different religions to persuade the Russians to embrace a religion
Chose Greek Orthodoxy because of strong cultural bonds and close commercial ties with the Byzantine Empire
Politics and Society
Vladimir’s successor Yaroslav the Wise (r. 1016-1054) made Kiev a polical and cultural center with stunning architecture
Tried to pursue West contacts to counter Byzantine political influence
After his death rivalry divded Russia
Great Russians
White Russians
Little Russians (Ukrainians)
Principalities challenged Kiev’s dominance
Government with principalities
Monarchy (prince)
Aristocracy (prince’s nobleman council)
Democracy (assembly of free adult males)
Clergy, army officers, boyars (wealthy landowners), townspeople, peasants
Slaves were prisoners of war
Debtors made up large, semifree group
Mongol Rule (1243-1480)
13th century- Mongol (Tatar) armies swept through China, Islamic world, and Russia
Grassland people with strongholds in south
Devastated Russia and compelling obedience of Moscow
Glengis Khan (1155-1227) invaded Russia in 1223
Kiev fell to Batu Khan in 1240
Russia cities were dependent, tribute-paying principalities of Mongol Empire, Golden Horde (color of Batu Khan’s tent in Tatar)
Included grassland (steppe) of modern southern Russia nad capital of Sarai o blower Volga
Had own officials to oversee taxation and enlist Russians into Tatar armies
Got Russian women as harems (wives)
Under influence of Islam (Golden Horde religion) were forced to wear veils and have secluded lives
Sold Russians who disobeyed
Left political and religious institutes intact
Brought some Russians into prosperity
Mongol integration culturally divided Russia and the West
Princes of Moscow
Collected tribute and grew wealthy
Took control of surrounding territory- “Gathering of the Russian Land”
Principality of Moscow
Expanded through land purchases, colonization, and conquest
1380- Grand Duke Dimitri of Moscow (r. 1350-1389) defeated Tatar forces at Kulikov Meadow
Marked beginning of Mongol hegemony declline
Took a centry for Ivan III, the Great, to bring northern Russia under Moscow’s control and end Mongol rule (1480)
Moscow became political and religious center of Russia
After Constantinople fell to the Turks in 1453, Moscow became the “3rd Rome”