Rindfuss and Brauner-Otto 2008
Low fertility levels
Should we introduce explicit policies to increase fertility?
Timing changes: major component of the low levels of period fertility in countries
Women have children older: decreases TFR
Institutions: set of norms or rules, formal or informal, which guide relationships among role occupants in areas of structured social interactions and organizations
Policies: formal norms or rules within institutions, and exist until formally changed
Appropriate macro units for studying institutions: multi-country units + sub-national units
Timing changes: strongly influence cohort size
Feedback loop though the low-fertility trap hypothesis: postponement of fertility produces small cohorts and children from these small cohorts may grow up knowing many adults who had only 1 child or no children
Timing and number issues are positively correlated: later means fewer
Childrearing: generates incompatibility with other roles
Increase in the time mothers spend caring for their children - active care
Supervisory child care: mother has the responsibility of ensuring the appropriate supervision is in place
Reducing parental supervisory time
Child care centres
Affordable and high quality centres
Help from family members
Shift work
Availability of part-time jobs
Convenient school hours
Social norms: play a role in the sequencing of events
Education occupies more young adult years of men and women
Increase in educational enrollment
Led to women’s preferences for establishing themselves in the labour market prior to becoming mothers
Spread of education: women postpone childbearing
Starting schooling at a younger age: earlier start of childbearing
Important factor: extent to which it is possible to return to school once one has left for a period of time
Openness of the educational system
More vocationally-specific education systems may lead to earlier childbearing
It can also lead to a mismatch between labour supply and demand, leading to under-employment
Long search times for employment lead to delayed childbearing
Important factors: maternity leaves, policies, openness of the labour market
Family leaves: delay entering parenthood
Mothers suffer a substantial penalty when they return to the labour market
Uncertainty to find a job after childrearing: women postpone childbearing
Higher level of education: more chances to want a career as opposed to having a job
Availability of part-time jobs: ease mother’s re-entry into the labour market
These are not career-type jobs
Inability to obtain appropriate living quarters likely postpones childbearing
Independent household = necessary pre-condition for having children
Not affordable nowadays
Couples in single-family homes have faster entry into parenthood than those in apartments or other housing types
Low fertility levels
Should we introduce explicit policies to increase fertility?
Timing changes: major component of the low levels of period fertility in countries
Women have children older: decreases TFR
Institutions: set of norms or rules, formal or informal, which guide relationships among role occupants in areas of structured social interactions and organizations
Policies: formal norms or rules within institutions, and exist until formally changed
Appropriate macro units for studying institutions: multi-country units + sub-national units
Timing changes: strongly influence cohort size
Feedback loop though the low-fertility trap hypothesis: postponement of fertility produces small cohorts and children from these small cohorts may grow up knowing many adults who had only 1 child or no children
Timing and number issues are positively correlated: later means fewer
Childrearing: generates incompatibility with other roles
Increase in the time mothers spend caring for their children - active care
Supervisory child care: mother has the responsibility of ensuring the appropriate supervision is in place
Reducing parental supervisory time
Child care centres
Affordable and high quality centres
Help from family members
Shift work
Availability of part-time jobs
Convenient school hours
Social norms: play a role in the sequencing of events
Education occupies more young adult years of men and women
Increase in educational enrollment
Led to women’s preferences for establishing themselves in the labour market prior to becoming mothers
Spread of education: women postpone childbearing
Starting schooling at a younger age: earlier start of childbearing
Important factor: extent to which it is possible to return to school once one has left for a period of time
Openness of the educational system
More vocationally-specific education systems may lead to earlier childbearing
It can also lead to a mismatch between labour supply and demand, leading to under-employment
Long search times for employment lead to delayed childbearing
Important factors: maternity leaves, policies, openness of the labour market
Family leaves: delay entering parenthood
Mothers suffer a substantial penalty when they return to the labour market
Uncertainty to find a job after childrearing: women postpone childbearing
Higher level of education: more chances to want a career as opposed to having a job
Availability of part-time jobs: ease mother’s re-entry into the labour market
These are not career-type jobs
Inability to obtain appropriate living quarters likely postpones childbearing
Independent household = necessary pre-condition for having children
Not affordable nowadays
Couples in single-family homes have faster entry into parenthood than those in apartments or other housing types