Title: Nicotine II
Lecture: 07
Topic: Cognitive enhancement
Agenda:
Discussion Question
What is Cognitive enhancement?
Therapeutic drugs for cognitive enhancement
Cognitive enhancement in a neurotypical population
Discussion Question:
Posted on Canvas.
Due date: 02/27
Discussion Question Details:
Discuss nootropics—drugs that boost cognitive performance.
Provide an argument for or against their use in a neurotypical population, based on scientific findings, effects, and side effects.
Response Requirements:
Minimum six sentences.
Maximum of three paragraphs.
Original writing only; no AI-generated content.
Choose one nootropic as an example for the argument.
Stance Requirements Based on Last Name:
A-L: Argue against cognitive-enhancing drugs.
M-Z: Argue for the use of cognitive-enhancing drugs.
Definition of Cognitive Enhancement:
Intervention that boosts cognitive processes (learning, memory, attention).
Can be behavioral or pharmacological.
Used to treat disorders like ADHD and dementia (Alzheimer's, Parkinson's disease).
Therapeutic Cognitive Enhancers:
ADHD:
Psychostimulants:
Methylphenidate (Ritalin)
Amphetamine (Adderall)
Modafinil
Neurodegenerative Diseases:
Alzheimer's disease
Parkinson's disease
Alzheimer's Disease Characteristics:
Associated with dementia and memory loss.
Progressive condition.
Neurological Changes in Alzheimer's Disease:
Brain atrophy in:
Hippocampus
Basal forebrain cholinergic nuclei
Key areas:
Hippocampus, Thalamus, Basal Forebrain Cholinergic System, etc.
Drug Treatments for Alzheimer's Disease:
Symptom treatment available.
Does not slow disease progression.
Acetylcholine and Symptom Treatment:
Role of acetylcholine in cognitive function.
Acetylcholinesterase Inhibitors: interact with presynaptic terminals, enhancing acetylcholine availability.
Examples of Acetylcholinesterase Inhibitors:
Donepezil
Rivastigmine
Galantamine
Cognitive Benefits of AchE Inhibitors:
Restoration of reasoning and cognitive ability in Alzheimer's patients.
Benefits can last up to 4 years.
Side Effects of Cognitive Enhancers:
Similar to nicotine effects:
Muscle cramps
Nausea/vomiting
Gastrointestinal distress
NMDA Receptor Antagonists:
Role of glutamate in Alzheimer's:
Increased extracellular glutamate chronically activates NMDA receptors, impairing cognitive function.
Memantine:
A non-competitive NMDA antagonist.
Improves cognitive function in individuals with moderate to severe Alzheimer's.
Overview of Cognitive Enhancers:
For ADHD: Psychostimulants (Ritalin, Adderall).
For Dementia: Cholinergic drugs and Glutamate drugs (e.g., Memantine).
Cognitive Enhancement in Neurotypicals:
8-10% of college students use cognitive-enhancing "study drugs."
Article Reference in Nature:
Towards responsible use of cognitive-enhancing drugs by the healthy.
Focus on societal responses to the demand for enhancement.
Contemplation for Healthy Individuals:
Should healthy people utilize cognitive-enhancing drugs?
Ethical and Scientific Questions:
Ethical considerations: fairness and comparison to steroids in sports.
Scientific validity: effectiveness of cognitive enhancers.
Evaluating Nootropic Effects:
Aspects of cognition enhanced by nootropics.
Variability in effects across individuals.
Cognitive Processes Affected by Psychostimulants:
Working memory
Episodic & Semantic memory
Inhibitory control
Visuospatial Working Memory Enhancement:
Experiment showcasing enhancement of phonological working memory and visuospatial working memory.
Detailed Cognitive Processes:
Affected areas include short-term and long-term memory, as well as inhibitory control.
Enhancement of Short-term Episodic Memory:
Training phase: covers short-term to long-term.
Test phases evaluate retention and recall.
Methylphenidate Effects on Cognition:
Explores effects on working memory and episodic memory, both short and long-term.
Long-term Memory Study:
Emphasizes encoding, storage/consolidation, and retrieval phases, particularly focusing on the hippocampus.
Hippocampal and Cortical Contributions to Long-term Memory:
Differentiation of roles between the hippocampus and cortex.
State Dependent Learning:
Relationship between drug states and memory encoding/recall—influence of drugs as context cues.
Cognitive Enhancements from Methylphenidate:
Identifies enhancements in specific cognitive areas such as working memory and episodic memory.
Further Examination of Methylphenidate Effects:
Concentrates again on working and episodic memory improvements, emphasizing variations in duration and retention.
Distinction Between Arousal and Enhancement:
Drugs enhance performance by increasing arousal, motivation, and effort but do not necessarily increase intelligence.
Cognition Enhancement Aspects:
Working memory and short-term episodic memory enhancement highlighted.
Variability of effects noted.
Understanding Dose-Response Curves:
Describes relationship between drug dose and extent of cognitive effects.
Inverted U Curve - Yerkes-Dodson Law:
Illustrates performance in relation to arousal levels—optimal vs. high and low arousal states.
Inverted U Curve with Methylphenidate Effects:
Abstraction showing how methylphenidate affects performance across varied arousal levels.
Reaffirmation of Dose-Response with Methylphenidate:
Similar indications as previous curve regarding performance metrics across arousal spectrums.
Consistency of Inverted U Curve Representation:
Maintains the performance-based assessments relating to optimum arousal through various scenarios.
Cognition and Variability Outcomes:
Revisitation of aspects enhancing cognition and reassertion of strong variability in effects.
Arguments Against Use in General Population:
Limited and narrow cognitive benefits
Potential impairment of cognitive processes
Reduced long-term effectiveness
Promotion of a pill culture
Arguments For Use in General Population:
Can provide modest enhancements
Possible benefits for undiagnosed individuals
Relatively low side effects if used properly
Comparison to common cognitive enhancers like caffeine
Next Topics for Discussion:
Focus on Nicotine and Alcohol in upcoming lectures.