MacKayPiratesEscapeSocietiesInChina

Joseph MacKay's Analysis of Maritime Pirates

This article titled "Pirate Nations: Maritime Pirates as Escape Societies in Late Imperial China" explores the phenomenon of pirate bands in the coastal waters of late imperial China, framing them as political communities that escape state control. It builds off James C. Scott's (2009) concept of fugitive political communities, which describes small groups living as escapees from oppressive state systems. MacKay argues that pirate bands not only evaded state coercion but also gained sufficient power to re-engage and sometimes dictate terms to the authorities they originally fled from.

Nature of Pirate Groups

• Pirate bands formed a complex relationship with the Chinese state characterized by:

  • Competition: Rivalry and conflict with state powers.

  • Cooperation: Instances where pirates offered their services to dynasties.

  • Coercion: The ability of pirates to use their power to force compliance from state authorities.

  • Extraction: Collecting taxes and controlling trade routes.

• These groups operated independently, deriving loyalty primarily to themselves rather than to any governing authority. With historical examples such as Zheng Zhilong and his son Zheng Chenggong, alongside the prominent pirate queen Zheng Yi Sao, this article demonstrates that during the 17th to early 19th centuries, piracy flourished in southern coastal China.

The Role of Pirates in Political Dynamics

• In asserting power, pirate bands not only resisted state authority but also governed territories, controlled sea routes, and collected taxes from local populations. Their actions not only threatened the political legitimacy of the Chinese empire but also countered the economic interests of European colonial forces in the region.

Expanding Scott's Thesis

• MacKay connects Scott's analysis of escape societies, which he describes as decentralized and resilient to state coercion.

• Escape societies leverage local resources, geographical knowledge, and flexible social structures to evade extraction, but they also demonstrate a capability for re-engagement with state forces—posing as rivals rather than subjects.

Historical Context of Chinese Piracy

• The late imperial period was characterized by increased maritime piracy due to factors such as a decline in bureaucratic governance under the Ming Dynasty and heightened state isolation policies which unwittingly fueled smuggling and piracy, pushing many into piracy due to deteriorating economic conditions.

Key Case Studies: Zheng Zhilong and Zheng Yi Sao

• Zheng Zhilong established a powerful pirate empire, first serving as a privateer for the Dutch before working for the Ming dynasty itself, illustrating the dual nature of pirate engagement with both imperial and colonial powers.

• Zheng Yi Sao led a significant pirate confederation, demonstrating a complex administrative structure that included systems for wealth distribution among her 70,000 pirates, solidifying her power base in a turbulent political landscape.

Theoretical Implications for Political Communities

• The article systematically details Scott's framework before offering a comprehensive sketch of maritime piracy's significance in late imperial China. Piracy is framed as not merely a criminal enterprise but as a distinct form of political community that challenges prevailing state structures.

• MacKay claims that pirates functioned as both criminals and political figures, creating systems of law and order within the chaos of state failure.

Comparisons to Modern State Dynamics

• MacKay contrasts historical pirate communities with modern state-making processes, implying that historical pirates represent the persistent struggle against state authority, a theme that continues in contemporary contexts where state authority is challenged by similar structures of resistance, manifesting globally as piracy in areas like Somalia.

Conclusion

• The evolution of maritime piracy in late imperial China showcases not only the resilience of these escape societies but also their capacity to influence state power and political legitimacy. While their operations were largely extractive, they filled crucial governance voids left by weakening imperial authorities, complicating the narrative of state versus non-state actors in historical political discourse.

• Overall, MacKay provides an insightful lens on the political significance of piracy as a challenge to state authority, providing a template for understanding similar dynamics in contemporary global contexts.