Chapter_5-_Revised_2023__1_

Chapter 5: The Landlord's Obligation to Repair

Overview

• This chapter outlines the landlord's obligations regarding property maintenance and repairs. It focuses on ensuring that rental units are fit for habitation and meet health, safety, and maintenance standards.

Key Concepts

A Good State of Repair

• Definition: Landlords must keep the rental complex in a state of repair that a reasonable tenant would find satisfactory; however, this does not obligate landlords to enhance the property unnecessarily.

• Requirements: If repairs can restore conditions to an acceptable level without substantial upgrades, the landlord is fulfilling their obligation. All amenities, including services like swimming pools and elevators, must also be maintained within this obligation.

Criteria for Good State of Repair

1. Regular maintenance schedule.

2. Timely major repairs as necessary.

3. Prompt responses to routine maintenance requests from tenants.

4. Immediate response to emergency repair requests.

Fitness for Habitation

• Landlords must ensure that rental units are habitable in both physical and mental aspects.

• Obligations include:

  • Providing potable cold water and hot water suitable for washing.

  • Ensuring adequate water pressure and ventilation.

  • Maintaining secure windows and doors, serviceable plumbing, and sufficient light within the unit.

Safety Concerns

• If other tenants compromise the safety of the premises, landlords are required to take reasonable actions to mitigate these risks, including addressing illegal activities of other tenants.

Case Example: Kocura v. Bodula (1984)

• In this case, a tenant left after one night due to the uninhabitable condition of the apartment, which was deemed unfit due to a non-functioning furnace and a mouse infestation. The court ruled in favor of the tenant.

Regulatory Standards

• Under the Residential Tenancies Act (RTA), landlords must comply with municipal health and safety standards, which may include property standards mandated by local governmental health departments.

Repair Obligations During Tenant Turnover

• Landlords are required to inspect units before new tenants move in to ensure compliance with maintenance standards.

• If a unit has been vacant, landlords typically clean it before a new tenant arrives, but if moving out and in occur in close succession, condition may vary based on the previous tenant's cleanliness.

Inspection Responsibilities

• After a tenant has moved in, landlords are generally not obliged to inspect the premises unless a specific condition suggests that inspection is necessary (e.g., aging systems like plumbing or electrical).

• Landlords must respond to repair requests in a reasonable timeframe considering urgency, nature of the repair, and additional conditions (like when the request is made).

Landlord's Liability

• A landlord’s obligation arises when they know or should have known about issues needing repair.

• Landlords may avoid liability for rent abatement if they demonstrate a reasonable maintenance program.

• They are responsible for repairs related to normal wear and tear, and they may charge tenants for damage caused by the tenant’s actions.

Limits on Liability

1. Tenants must maintain cleanliness and repair damage they or their guests cause.

2. Landlords are not penalized for issues not reported to them.

3. Landlords must meet reasonable tenant expectations but are not required to meet unreasonably high standards.

4. Landlords are not insurers of tenants' personal property.

Successor Landlords

• If a new landlord acquires a property in disrepair, they inherit the responsibility for abatement claims from the date of purchase. Claims prior to purchase are not their responsibility.

Recommended Actions for Tenants

• If repair obligations are unmet, tenants should document requests in writing.

• If no action is taken, tenants can escalate complaints to the municipal property standards office or apply to the board for non-compliance within one year of the alleged issue.

Changes by Bill 184

• New regulations require tenants to notify landlords of maintenance issues before an eviction hearing related to non-payment of rent.

Necessity of Repair Regulations

• The law previously debated tenant rights concerning rent abatements during necessary repairs (e.g., repairs affecting common areas). New regulations outline that maintenance work must not substantially interfere with tenant enjoyment unless reasonable notification and efforts to minimize disruptions are made.

• Factors for board consideration in potential abatement cases include actions taken by both landlords and tenants regarding undue delay or interference.

Key Terms

• Abatement of Rent: A reduction in rent due to failure to maintain property standards or health conditions.

• Amenities: Additional facilities and services available to tenants, which need to be maintained under the landlord's obligations.