Stalin’s Rule
The Totalitarian State
A totalitarian state is a dictatorship where the government controls every part of the people’s lives
No one has any individual rights
People are expected to obey without question
Entire population mobilized to achieve national goals
Methods of Mobilization
Through Persuasion
Control of media (propaganda - the spread of info to promote a cause)
Education
Rewards of party membership
Through Intimidation
Censorship
Terror (secret police, gulags)
“The Cult of Personality”
Leader is glorified as an almost superhuman hero
Stalin used the media (newspaper and radio) to create a positive image
Children were more loyal to Stalin than to their parents
Collectivization
All farmers were ordered to pool their land and animals into collective farms
Collective farms would increase food production by introducing more machines
It freed farmers for factory labor
Kulaks
The kulaks (wealthy farmers) did not want to lose their farms
Stalin had thousands of kulaks executed or sent to Siberia (very cold)
Resulted in a famine (1932-33) that killed 10 million Russians
Five Year Plan
The Soviet Union was at least 50 years behind the West
Soviet Union developed a planned, or command economy
Within 10 years, Soviet Union is the 3rd largest economy in the world
Problems:
Workers punished if they did not produce enough
Factory managers lied to avoid punishment
Russians used as slave labor (from the gulags)
The Great Purge
Began with the murder of a Soviet leader close to Stalin
Over four years, 8 million were arrested
Many went on trial and 800,000 were executed
Causes
Conflicting Ideologies
Democratic Capitalism of United States
Free market economics, political participation in citizens
Authoritarian Communism of the Soviet Union
Strict gov’t control of economy, redistribution of wealth equally
Both ideologies are universalizing, meaning those who hold them want everyone else to hold them
Mutual Mistrust
Began before WW2 had ended
European and Americans believed that Central and Eastern countries would be able to hold elections after the war
Stalin would keep those countries communist to act as a buffer zone (eastern bloc), in satellite states
America disliked this as it was a violation of self-determination
Origins of the Cold War
A cold war is a state of tension and hostility w/o armed conflict
Division of Germany
West Germany (controlled by Western Allies)
West Germany was “de-Nazified”
Allies promoted education and democracy
East Germany (controlled by Soviet Union)
Stalin took over East German factories
Resources used to help rebuild Soviet Union
Berlin Blockade (1948)
Soviets blocked all traffic into West Berlin (in East Germany)
Truman orders Berlin Airlift of over 2 million tons of supplies
1961 - Berlin Wall is constructed
The Iron Curtain
Soviet setup communist governments in Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Poland, Romania, and Bulgaria
These were “satellites” (nations controlled by the Soviets)
Stalin claimed need for “buffer zones” against future German attacks
Albania and Yugoslavia set up their own communist government
America’s Reaction
Containment
US wanted to contained/hold Soviet Union to its current size
US wanted apply pressure to Soviet Union (politically, economically, and military if it was needed)
Truman Doctrine (1947)
Truman promised to support free people who rejected communism
Sent money to Greece and Turkey to stop communist takeover
Marshall Plan (1948-1952)
George Marshall (US Secretary of State) feared spread of communism due to postwar poverty
US sent 13 billion to help rebuild West Europe
New Alliances
1949- North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO): U.S., Canada and 10 W. European nations agreed to defend each other if attacked.
1955- The Warsaw Pact: Soviet Union and 7 E. European nations agreed to a similar treaty
Implications
Effects would change most of the world
Intersected with decolonization
US and Soviet Union began to compete to influence each of the new states and win them to their respective side
Effects in China and Japan
China
1949- Communists win Chinese Civil War
Chinese Communists (Mao Zedong) defeats Nationalists (Chiang Kai-Shek)
Mao Zedong established the People’s Republic of China (PRC)
Chiang Kai-Shek and Nationalists flee to Taiwan (create Republic of China)
American Reaction
Pres. Truman criticized for being “soft” on communism
Truman blamed for “losing” China (but China was an independent nation)
U.S. (and UN) recognizes Taiwan as official government of China
US would only have diplomatic relations with Taiwan
Taiwan (and not the PRC) would be part of the United Nations
Soviet Reaction
Stalin forms alliance with PRC
Soviets boycott UN Security Council
Anger over recognition of Taiwan
Refused to attend council meetings
Soviet Union was a member with power to veto any decision
Stalin and Mao are rivals for leadership over world communism
China’s Reaction
Mao saw both U.S. and Soviets as western imperialists
After Stalin’s death, Mao believed he should lead the world’s communists
China was willing to go it alone (“the East wind triumphs over the west wind”)
Japan
1945-1951- U.S. Occupation of Japan
U.S. Army (led by Gen. Douglas MacArthur) controlled Japan after its defeat in World War II
1947- New Japanese constitution renounces war
Japan and U.S. form a defensive alliance
American Reaction
Japan was a key ally in Asia (China (1949) and North Korea (1948) had already turned communist)
Japan needed to recover quickly from World War Two
Soviet Reaction
Soviets were not happy to see American influence growing in Asia
With American forces in Japan, Soviets were powerless there
Japan’s Reaction
Japan would benefit with the protection of the U.S. (and economic assistance)
Japan could concentrate on rebuilding
Rapid development was Japan’s “economic miracle”
Effects in Korea and Vietnam
Korea
The Korean War (1950-1953)
During WWII, Russian troops occupied northern Korea while US troops occupied southern Korea.
June 1950 - N. Korean army with Soviet-made tanks invaded S. Korea and took nearly all the country.
Aug. 1950- UN forces (with 80% U.S. soldiers) begin amphibious assault, quickly take back nearly all of S. Korea.
Nov. 1950- 300,000 Chinese soldiers poured into North Korea- forced UN troops to retreat with heavy losses across 38th parallel.
1953- “Cease Fire” Line set at 38th parallel
American POV
Viewed China and N. Korea as threat
Containment of communism
S. Korea was America’s “proxy,” or substitute, in this conflict over communism
The U.S. also saw S. Korea as crucial to defend Taiwan and Japan
Soviet POV
Supported N. Korea’s decision to invade S. Korea
N. Korea was “proxy” of the Soviet Union
As the only major power “friendly” with China and N. Korea, it had to help
Korean POV
N. Korea received help from Soviets and China
S. Korea received help from the U.S.
Both nations knew that superpowers were “trapped” in Korea (neither side could afford to leave)
Human Cost
54,000 US soldiers killed
1.2 million South Koreans killed
1 million North Koreans killed
600,000 Chinese killed
Vietnam (1946-1975)
The Vietnam War
1946- Ho Chi Minh and Communists begin war with France
1954- Geneva Conference
Temporary division into North and South
National elections would be held in 1956
Independence for Laos and Cambodia
1963- Unpopular S. Vietnamese president Ngo Dinh Diem overthrown
1964- Gulf of Tonkin Incident
Two US warships attacked by N. Vietnam
Congress authorizes use of military to respond
500,000 U.S. soldiers in Vietnam by 1967
1973- Paris Peace Accords- US agrees to leave Vietnam
1975- N. Vietnam invades S. Vietnam, unites both sides
American POV
Feared the “domino effect” (that all of Asia would fall to communism)
Containment of communism
Felt obligated to help French allies
Soviet POV
Supported the spread of communism in Southeast Asia
Supported U.S. entanglement in Southeast Asia
Provided aid to Ho Chi Minh and North Vietnam
Vietnamese POV
Most Vietnamese viewed conflict as a decolonization movement
Both France and U.S. were imperialists
Ho Chi Minh was more nationalist than communist
Human Cost
58,000 Americans killed
1.5 million Vietnamese soldiers killed
2 million Vietnamese civilians killed
Effects in Cuba
Pre-Revolutionary Cuba
Spanish-American war (1898)
US defeats Spain, Cuba gained independence
1901 - US amends Cuban constitution
US claims right to intervene in Cuba
US leases Guantanamo Bay
1900-1960: US companies control sugar and mining
US supported anti-communist Fulgencia Batista (1952-1959)
The Cuban Revolution (1959)
Fiden Castro overthrows Batista
Castro announces land distribution in Cuba
Sugar in Cuba
Cuba nationalized US sugar industries (1960)
US refuses to buy sugar from Cuba
Soviets (Nikita Kruschev) offer aid to Cuba (buys entire sugar crop)
US imposes trade embargo on Cuba
Bay of Pigs invasion (1961)
CIA begins training of anti-Castro Cubans for invasion (1960)
Invasion of Cuba fails, embarrassing defeat of US
Castro declares himself as a communist
Cuban Missile Crisis (1962)
Soviets begin building nuclear launchpads in Cuba
President Kennedy orders/established naval blockade in Cuba
Soviet ships carrying missiles approach and stop at blockade zones
Soviets agree to remove missiles, US (later) removes missiles from Turkey, promises to never invade Cuba
Proxy Wars
Event | Superpower POV | How did it respond? | Likely POV of “Proxy” nation |
Guatemala (1954) | The U.S. feared that newly elected President Jacobo Arbenz was a communist. He had suggested that the United Fruit Company should pay taxes. | CIA plot (at the request of the United Fruit Company) overthrows elected president of Guatemala. | Guatemala resented U.S. interference in democratic process. |
Iran (1954) | A newly elected anti-colonial government, led by Mohammed Mossadeq tried to nationalize western oil interests. The U.S. feared he was a communist. | A CIA-sponsored coup d’état placed the Shah of Iran in power. He ruled until 1979. | Iranians angry over U.S. interference in Iran’s development. This anger would help inspire Iran’s revolution in 1979. |
Egypt (1956) | Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser threatened to take the canal from the British. The U.S. did not want to lose access to the Suez Canal. | Britain (with the assistance of France and Israel) attempted to retake the Suez Canal. Attempt failed. | Egypt became more friendly with the Soviets. |
Hungary (1956) | Prime Minister Imre Nagy announces that Hungary will drop out of the Warsaw Pact. The Soviets feared that independent actions in Hungary might encourage other satellites. | Soviet tanks and soldiers rolled into Hungary. Head of the government was executed and thousands were jailed. | Hungary was not happy with Soviet intervention, but was powerless after the revolution failed. |
Dominican Republic (1962-65) | Juan Bosch is elected as new president. U.S. fears that social reforms and land redistribution would lead to “another Cuba.” | Supported a military coup. When Bosch’s supporters attempted to return him to power, US Marines “restored order.” The US backed anti-communist President ruled for most of the next 30 years. Social reforms ended. | Anger over American interference in democratic reforms. |
Czechoslovakia (1968) | Czech leader Alexander Dubcek announced the policy of “socialism with a human face.” The Soviets feared this would lead to revolution. It does lead to “Prague Spring,” a youth protest movement. | Soviet Premier Leonid Brezhnev announced the “Brezhnev Doctrine”: the Soviet Union had the right to prevent its satellites from rejecting communism. Soviet armed forces invaded and removed Dubcek from power. | Czechoslovakia was unhappy with Soviet intervention, but was powerless. |
Afghanistan (1979-1989) | The Soviets invaded in 1979. The U.S. did not want Soviet power to expand in the region. | The United States begins to train Afghanis to overthrow the Communist government. The Soviet Union withdrew from Afghanistan in 1989. | Muslim population did not want interference from either superpower. |
Nicaragua (1981-90) | The U.S. feared that Sandinistas, led by Daniel Ortega, were communists. | Provided massive economic and military aid to the anti-government “Contra” organization. War and turmoil led to decline in support for Sandinistas. Lost election in 1990 to a pro-US political party. | Not as angry as some other countries were, since the U.S. has left Nicaragua alone since 1990. |
Communism in China
1953 - First 5 Year Plan: Collective Farms
Farmers shared land, tools, work to produce more food
Each received part of harvest, and rest was sent to the government
1958 - The Great Leap Forward (2nd 5 year plan)
China was divided into communes (large collective farms)
Included several villages and thousands of acres
As many as 20000 people livedo n a commune
Failure of the Great Leap Forward
Many destroyed crops to protest system
Communes could not keep up with their quotes, especially due to exaggeration of statistics
Lack of machines + poor harvest led to severe hunger
As many as 38 million people died from 1966-1967
The Cultural Revolution (1966-1976)
Mao wanted to revive revolutionary feeling in China
Aimed to destroy four olds (old customs, habits, culture, thought)
Red Guard were young communists who attacked those who did not support Mao and his beliefs
Mao had many arrested, tortured, and even killed (500k - 2 million)
“Lost Generation” - 17 million young people were deprived of education
Revolution ended when Red Guard turned against army, gov’t officials, and the party
Foreign Policy
Food as Foreign Aid
Mao exports food to USSR + other communist nations for military technology
By 1970s, foreign aid reached 7%GDP (US spends on 0.22%)
China and the US
Feb 1972 - Richard Nixon visits China
US officially recognizes PRC, China moves away from USSR
Both countries begin a profitable trade together, exchanging $5+ billion everyday today
China
Economic Developments
Led by Deng Xiaoping (197801997) introduced the four Modernizations (agriculture, industry, technology, military)
Rural Responsibility System
Farmers grew their own crops
Farmers sold part of their crops to the gov’t
Could sell rest at a greater price
Newer system encouraged greater food production
Deng moved from “heavy industry” (machinery, tanks, other weapons) to “light industry” (production of clothing and tools)
Deng began to encourage foreign investment to China and for Chinese students to study abroad
Created “Special Economic Zones” where western enterprise was allowed
Social Developments
“One-Child-Per-Family” Policy
With one child, family received more benefit
With 2+ children, family faced fines
Most urban families followed, but rural did not (could make money back with Rural Responsibility System)
Led to increase in female infanticide, abolished in 2016
Westernization of economy and culture
1981 - First Coca Cola bottling plant
1987 - First KFC
1990 - First McDonalds
1996 - First Walmart
Political Developments
1989 - Tiananmen Square Uprising
May - Thousands of students begin to protest, demanding freedom
June - Chinese gov’t puts down protest
Thousands wounded, killed, arrested
Nationalism
Gov’t used national pride to achieve goal
People supported gov’t efforts to avoid “humiliation” once more
2008 Beijing Olympics, 2013 - Chinese Lunar Mission
Emergence as creditor nation in global economic crisis in 2008-2009
Hong Kong
From 1997 - 2019, Hong Kong had been permitted some independence from China
2019 - 2020 - Chinese police crack down on pro-democracy riots in Hong Kong
Chinese gov’t eliminates almost all political freedom in Hong Kong
Uighurs
Muslim minority living mostly in western China
China accused of place Uighurs in “reeducation camps” and sterilizing the women which China denies
Fall of the Iron Curtain
Soviet Problems
Soviet command economy led to shortage of most items
Soviets could not keep up with military production of the US
Soviets suffered costly and humiliating defeat of Afghanistan (1989)
Soviet citizens lose faith after nuclear accident at Chernobyl (1986)
Mikhael Gorbachev (1985 - 1991)
Glasnost - policy of openness and honesty (less censorship, more election)
Perestroika - restructuring of Soviet economy (military production to consumer goods)
Poland
1981 - 1983: Soviets impose martial law
Solidarity ( Polish Worker Union ) - had 10m members by 1981
June 1989 - Communist gov’t permits free elections
Lech Walesa (Solidarity Party) elected president
Was allowed by Soviets under Khruschev
Revolts in the Satellites (1989)
October - Communist party of Hungary gives up power
November
Czechoslovakia - “Velvet Revolution” -> Playwright Vaclav Havel elected president
Communists give up power in Bulgaria
December - Romanian dictator Nicolae Ceauseu overthrown + killed
All Warsaw Pact nations (except Russia) eventually join NATO