Jackson & Owens

Page 1: Introduction to International Society

Overview of Chapter

  • Title: The Evolution of International Society

  • Authors: Robert H. Jackson and Patricia Owens

  • Contents:

    • Origins and definitions

    • Ancient Greece and Renaissance Italy

    • European International Society

    • Globalization of International Society

    • Conclusion on global international society

Reader's Guide

  • The chapter focuses on the concept of 'international society' and its historical contexts.

  • Begins from the idea of human beings existing in politically separate communities and the conflicts and cooperations that arise from these existences.

  • Defined as a distinct institutional response to the coexistence of political communities (typically states).

  • Historical evolution shows different forms and common features, notably independence and interconnectedness of political groups.

Page 2: Origins and Definitions

Understanding International Society

  • Core Problem: Examining horizontal relationships and distinctions (e.g., 'we' versus 'they') in political contexts.

  • International Relations: Defined as relations among geographically based, distinct political communities exercising a degree of independence.

  • International society emerges as states function without a supreme authority.

Definition of State (according to Brownlie 1979)

  1. Permanent population

  2. Defined territory

  3. Central government

  4. Independence from similar authorities (related to state sovereignty).

Key Concepts

  • Coexistence: Doctrine between political communities.

  • State Sovereignty: Political independence of states.

  • Suzerain State: A dominant state that controls neighboring states without total annexation.

  • Hegemony: Dominance of one state over others.

  • Balance of Power: A system where one state’s power is counterbalanced by others.

Page 3: The Evolution of International Society

Fundamental Description

  • Hedley Bull’s Definition: International society involves states with common interests and values, bound by shared rules and institutions.

  • Core values include independence, self-determination, and the right of self-defense.

  • Diplomacy: Important arrangement among sovereign states to facilitate relations.

  • Historical Context: Different epochs of diplomacy from ancient Greece to modern times.

Characteristics of Sovereign States

  • Importance of acknowledgment and regulation in state relations.

  • Recognition of mutual independence among states.

  • Rise of international organizations shaping contemporary relations.

Page 4: Historical Record of 'International Society'

Ancient Records and Empire Dynamics

  • Historical Records: Agreements and alliances among ancient states from as early as 2400 BC.

  • Political relations characterized by empires dominating over city-states and regions.

Greek Political Structures

  • The ancient Greek international society included independent city-states sharing culture and religion.

  • Example: Political and cultural identity of Hellas, distinguishing themselves from 'barbarians'.

  • Major Powers: Cities like Athens and Sparta exemplified the inequalities within Greek city-states.

Page 5: Greek and Italian Contributions

Greek International Society

  • Described as the first international society in Western history, unified by shared culture and religion.

  • Lacked formal concepts of international laws and rights.

Renaissance Italy's Influence

  • Renaissance Italy's city-states established a pioneering form of political association.

  • Contributed to diplomacy concepts and practices, inspiring European political evolution.

Page 6: Post-Greek and Medieval Developments

Historical Transition to Empire

  • Shift from Greek interconnectedness to Roman imperial frameworks, which emphasized dominance.

  • Christian Theocracy: Emergence of political authority intertwined with religious structures during the medieval period.

  • Political Loyalty: Shift from feudal loyalties to state-centric frameworks as kings gained power.

Page 7: The Respublica Christiana

Political Transformations

  • The medieval period characterized by a universal religious authority that fragmented into independent states.

  • Role of the Pope in mediating disputes showcases early traces of international arbitration.

The Renaissance States

  • Break from medieval authority facilitated the emergence of independent city-states embedded in regional political dynamics.

Page 8: Statecraft and International Society

Italian Renaissance Diplomacy

  • Development of modern state concepts and diplomacy practices in Renaissance Italy.

  • Political realism emerged during this period, emphasizing state interests over universal ethics.

  • Machiavelli's Contributions: Introduced the idea of statecraft focused on practical politics.

Page 9: The Modern Society of States

Formation of Modern Europe

  • The European international society took shape through evolving sovereignty and diplomatic practices.

  • Significant historical events included the Protestant Reformation affecting the balance of power.

Page 10: The Treaty of Westphalia

Secular International Society

  • The Peace of Westphalia marked a crucial change in international relations, establishing principles of state sovereignty.

  • Three principles solidified a framework that would govern state interactions

  • Transition from a religious to a secular basis in international society regulations.

Page 11: Historical Balance of Power

The Balance of Power Doctrine

  • Aimed to prevent any one state from achieving dominance; laid foundational norms for European diplomacy.

  • Cooperation among states became essential for maintaining the international order.

Page 12: Globalization of International Society

Expansion Beyond Europe

  • Beginning in the fifteenth century, European imperialism intertwined with globalization of international society.

  • Non-European territories increasingly subject to European legal and diplomatic norms, despite not always being controlled by Western powers.

Page 13: Global Interactions and Non-Western Resistance

Indigenous Political Movements

  • Emergence of anti-colonial struggles based on Western principles of self-determination among formerly colonized nations.

Page 14: Post-Colonial Dynamics

Evolution Post-Cold War

  • Rise of new independent states alongside continuing challenges to international order.

  • The global landscape shaped by historical and contemporary dynamics of sovereignty and imperialism.

Page 15: Contemporary Challenges in Global Society

Examining Global Dynamics

  • Tensions between normative values of international society and systemic inequalities among states.

  • Examination of post-colonial legacy impacting current international relations.

Page 16: Future of International Society

Ongoing Evolution

  • Enhanced global interconnectivity raises questions about the traditional notions of state sovereignty.

  • Discussion regarding the changing roles and influence of power dynamics in contemporary global relations.

Page 17: Questions for Reflection

  • Examine the implications of international society on global political values.

  • Evaluate contributions of key historical concepts to modern international discourse.

Page 18: Further Reading

  • Recommendations for exploring scholarly works on the evolution of international society.