Poli phil 2-3-35

Discussion of Shared Perspectives

• Reflection on sharing experiences and commonalities.

• Recognition that participants are from different educational backgrounds with varying experiences during significant historical events like 2015.

• Conversations on related cultural topics such as gay marriage discussions during Barack Obama’s presidency.

Cultural Impact of Media

• Mention of television shows like The Fosters, a representation of LGBTQ+ families on screen which contributed to public conversations during the period.

• Discussion on Glee, highlighting that every show seemed to incorporate LGBTQ+ characters leading to broader acceptance.

• Acknowledgment that Will and Grace popularized stereotypes and was pivotal in the depiction of gay characters in media.

Community and Definition of Family

• Contemplation on the definition of family and its role within community strength.

• Assertion that community strength diminishes if there is no shared concept of family, leading to conflicts in moral perspectives.

• Quote: "Community means shared values or shared moral horizons."

Compromise and Disagreements

• Emphasis on the ease of compromising financial issues compared to moral or ethical debates like abortion and gay marriage.

• Reference to Federalist 10 by Madison, stressing that political issues often revolve around shared interests rather than passions or moral opinions.

Individual Freedom vs. Community Life

• Discussion on the tension between personal freedom and the virtue of community life.

• Example provided about young Puritan couples faced with severe repercussions for breaking community norms, illustrating the complexities of community standards vs. individual freedom.

• Mention of Breaking Amish series as a commentary on the challenges faced by those attempting to integrate into wider society.

Education and Inclusivity

• Outcomes of a strong community on individual freedoms; trade-offs explored between connection and personal ambitions.

• Discourse on education as a crucial factor for community integration and the impact of cultural isolation.

Aristotle’s View on Citizenship

• Exploration of the concept of citizenship as central to political science. Discussion includes variations by regime type, emphasizing democracy's inclusiveness.

• Reflection on the necessity of ethical foundations for communities; previous examples include initiation of laws and moral codes.

Historical Context of Law and Agreements

• Consideration of historical agreements, particularly concerning Indigenous land rights and their validity post-Revolution.

• Examination of how colonial agreements were dismissed following the establishment of American independence.

• Application of philosophical theories to real-life consequences faced by marginalized communities throughout history.

Changing Perspectives Over Time

• Personal reflections on lineage and societal changes, asking how connected individuals feel to historical Americans.

• Recognizing remarkable changes in moral values tied to issues like family structures and human rights.

Conclusion on Citizenship and Social Contracts

• Reiteration of the enduring question regarding the concept of citizenship across different regimes.

• Deliberation on the need for a shared understanding of values and ethics for a cohesive society, juxtaposed with individual rights.

• Reflection on differences between ancient and modern political views, particularly the emphasis on individualism versus community virtue.